12 ms·
Is the Universe a Simulation?
- alasarmas 13y agoAnd, if so, can we run arbitrary programs on it?
- barkingcat 13y agoa good enough simulation is indistinguishable from the real thing. So that question doesn't actually parse for me.
- barkingcat 13y agoUnless the question is to ask whether the universe is a poorly written simulation with edge cases that differ from the real thing. In that case, the question is very interesting.
- hansjorg 13y agoHow would you know what the real thing was from inside the simulation?
- pjscott 13y agoOne approach: you look at what the physical laws appear to be, and then ask "What weird edge cases would we expect to see if and only if this were running in a particular type of simulation?" That's what the paper linked to does. It's not perfect, but it's something.
- angersock 13y agoSo...how do we detect we're running in Perl instead of Ruby?
- eCa 13y agoThe answer is obvious [0]. [0] http://xkcd.com/224/ http://xkcd.com/224/
- jblow 13y agoThe main objection is that the way edge cases would "differ from the real thing" depends on what their "computers" are like which may not be anything like our computers. In fact there is no reason to believe they are similar at all.
- solipsism 13y agoTo take that point further, not only may their computers be nothing like our computers, the whole point of the article is that our natural laws and the basis of our mathematics is part of the simulation. That implies that the host (to borrow virtualization jargon) world's computers may work according to rules nothing like our own. Certainly you can't make statements like quantum effects between particles would otherwise require an infinite amount of memory. You can't make any statements about the host world, any more than we can make statements about the nature of a god, if one existed.
- evanb 13y agoWhat is the real thing? Is there a grid at the bottom of the real universe or not? We can calculate what a world with no grid at the bottom would be like. Is our world like that world? See my top-level comment for more detail.
- lutusp 13y ago> Is there a grid at the bottom of the real universe or not? Wait -- we don't get to specify what criteria can be used to detect a simulation, from within the simulation. This is a classic case where Gödel's incompleteness theorems rule out any such determination. Very briefly, Gödel's incompleteness theorems say that, for any sufficiently complex system, there are true statements that cannot be proven from within that system, i.e. using the system's methods. This has obvious applicability to the question of a simulated universe and our ability to detect this fact from within the simulated universe. In short, this entire conversation is pointless except to say that it's pointless. Because of what Gödel proved, we cannot ever determine that we're in a simulation, from a perspective inside the simulation.
- tutufan 13y agoActually, an unspeakably crappy simulation may be indistinguishable from the real thing if it doesn't "fight fair". Just have the simulation delete any thoughts by the participant(s) that they have convincingly observed anything amiss. The simulation might not quite fit in 640KB, but we might be rather disturbed at just how trivial a sneaky simulation of our world would be.
- platz 13y agoThis seems like such faulty and backwards reasoning to me. The experiment of detecting anomalies at the subatomic level is very interesting and that work should continue. But, why must we say such anomalies lead to "we are living in a simulation"? This seems like a fallacy of logic from reasoning backwards from the effect to the cause, with absolutely no connection between the two. (Maybe people just want to hop on the "everything is a computer" bandwagon for marketing/publicity; it is tiring. At it's worst, it makes future tech assertions look kookish)
- jamesaguilar 13y ago> But, why must we say such anomalies lead to "we are living in a simulation"? That is not the main argument that we are living in a simulation. The main argument is the following disjunction (from wikipedia). Either: * human civilization is unlikely to reach a level of technological maturity capable of producing simulated realities, or * a comparable civilization reaching this technological status will likely not produce a many simulated realities for any of a number of reasons, such as, diversion of computational processing power for other tasks, ethical considerations of holding entities captive in simulated realities, etc., or * any entities with our general set of experiences are almost certainly living in a simulation. Personally I think the biggest prima facie weakness in this argument is that while we will probably reach a point where simulating a human mind is feasible, and we will probably do so when that time comes, it may take a lot of computational mass to simulate a person. Thus, any recursive simulations would get smaller and smaller in terms of the number of thinking entities in them.
- nikbackm 13y ago> it may take a lot of computational mass to simulate a person It might be sufficient to simulate one person. The rest of the universe (including all other humans) just serve as inputs in the simulation.
- mistercow 13y agoIf each simulated universe can only contain one actual person, then the simulation argument doesn't hold up, since the vast majority of people would still be living outside of simulations.
- 5362677_0010 13y agoThat article is so much fluff, and doesn't really say much in the way of hard science. What he's referring to are Quantum Chromodynamics simulations, which in very general terms were born out of a desire to simulate the sub-atomic interaction of the nucleus of various elements, mapping nuclear reactions for weapons like the hydrogen bomb, when live fire tests were banned by international treaties. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD Numerical lattice Quantum Chromodynamic (QCD) calculations using Monte Carlo methods can be extremely computationally intensive, requiring the use of the largest available supercomputers. It's nice to contemplate the philosophical implications of being able to simulate the stimulated emissions of high-energy gamma ray emissions with high reliability and resolution inside a computer, but where's the meat of the article? It's just eleven paragraphs of "what if?"
- evanb 13y agohttp://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847 http://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847 and see my top-level comment for more detail.
- 5362677_0010 13y agoIf I'm the sentient result of an elaborate computer simulation, then you are very obviously an apparatus of those who control the simulation. If that's true, then please cut the shit, and knock on my front door right now, and just come right out and tell me: 5362677_0010? You're a computer simulation.
- zw123456 13y agoMaybe we stuck in a strange loop?
- radley 13y agoOr just a natural one.
- hansjorg 13y ago> we assume that our universe is an early numerical simulation with unimproved Wilson fermion discretization and investigate potentially-observable consequences So the argument seems to be that, if we were living in a simulation, and it used physics we now know to be slightly inaccurate, we would be able to measure that. Maybe I'm missing something, but that's not very logical is it?
- guspe 13y agoThe article should have linked to the original Simulation Argument by Nick Bostrom, since the physics part is just one of many possible tests to verify the hypothesis. Here is Nick Bostron's argument: http://www.simulation-argument.com/ http://www.simulation-argument.com/
- hansjorg 13y agoWhat are the other tests? I've read Bostrom's argument, but wasn't aware that he was proposing any specific tests.
- kordless 13y agoDark matter matters?
- solipsism 13y agoI think the argument is more like, "If we are in a simulation, it can't have an infinite resolution because that would imply an infinite amount of memory and computational power. We should be able to detect the 'graininess' at the limit of resolution."
- huxley 13y agoWould a parent universe that didn't share mathematics as universal noumena be capable of creating a simulation of a universe like ours?
- lmg643 13y agoThis reminds me of an article I read a year back, same topic: http://falkenblog.blogspot.com/2013/07/my-big-toe.html http://falkenblog.blogspot.com/2013/07/my-big-toe.html "The bottom line is, if we are in a simulation, there needs to be compressive sampling because quantum effects between particles would otherwise require an infinite amount of memory, so the meaning of the wave function is that it's for data compression. [...] The fortuitous data compression implicit in wave functions is merely another reason to suspect we are in a simulation. "
- bencollier49 13y agoThe Falkenberg blog just prompted me to write on the subject, because it implies that if a creator exists, they are not omnipotent. http://www.bencollier.info/content/physics-and-demiurge-creator-not-omnipotent http://www.bencollier.info/content/physics-and-demiurge-crea...
- lostcolony 13y agoSeems like backward reasoning. It's fair to say "Hey, if the universe is a resource constrained simulation, that would explain why wave-particle duality!", but I don't see any logical requirement that "Because wave-particle duality, it must be a resource constrained simulation (if it's a simulation)".
- andrewflnr 13y agoQuite. The creator could just as easily choose such a physics for obscure aesthetic reasons, or reasons for which we have no concept at all. Furthermore, we have no way of knowing whether "resource constraints" are a meaningful concept outside our little physical universe, either.
- almosnow 13y ago"No one could be able to simukate our universe because we can't do it."
- 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- crystaln 13y agoWe are living in a universe with natural laws and intelligence. Whether it's a "simulation" is sort of a nonsensical question. Is an iPhone emulator a simulation or an actual iPhone? What distinguishes those two other than our definition of iPhone, which of course is subjective? The question is similar to "is there a god?" That is, is there an intelligence outside of our universe that consciously created this one. Do wave function anonomolies indicate that our universe is the product of intelligence, or do they just show us how little we understand about the nature of existence? Further, following the logic of the article, we most likely live in near infinite nested simulated universes, since the same reasoning applies to our gods, unless of course reason is an aspect of out universe in which case how can we expect to reason about what is outside it? These are interesting questions, but jumping to the conclusion that we are in a simulation seems both premature and nonsensical to me.
- hansjorg 13y agoIt's the same question, just dressed in scientific language. We could write a program that detects if it's running on a real or emulated iPhone, but that's because we know both those environments from the outside. I think Boström poses interesting questions, but I don't believe it's possible to make an experiment to test this from the inside.
- logicallee 13y ago>Is an iPhone emulator a simulation or an actual iPhone? That's a really good question, and I hope the next metaphysical conundrum I encounter can be despatched with as easily. The answer is that it is a simulation. Next!
- crystaln 13y agoYou're missing the point. What makes an iPhone more real than an emulator? Is it that we consider an iPhone to be real and an emulator to be a simulator, is it that one came first? An emulator is still real. One could emulate an emulator - which of those then is real? Is the "real" iPhone not a simulator? It's all a matter if semantics. Even if we live in a universe created by an intelligence, we are not in a simulator - we are in a universe created by an intelligence. If we are in a simulator, what are we simulating? The real universe which is like this one?
- drdeadringer 13y agoPart of me is becoming tired of "brain in a jar" lines of reasoning, because there can be no other side of the discussion by default. If there is, I'm a Citizen who would like to know more.
- solipsism 13y agoWhat sides are you talking about? Either the line of reasoning (whichever you're talking about) has flaws or it doesn't. If you're trying to say "it leads nowhere", I sort of agree. But it only "leads nowhere" once you get to the acceptance that truth is subjective. Getting that far is worth it and can change the way a person thinks about many other things.
- drdeadringer 13y agoYes, I'm trending toward "it leads nowhere". To me, it's like trying to prove a negative: "prove you aren't a brain in a jar, receiving electrical//chemical inputs instead of walking around in a body". Well, right down to it, I can't just as much as you can't. > So truth is subjective, knowing that is worth it, and getting that far is awesome. Agreed.
- dsr_ 13y agoThe minimum evidence that we are in fact in a simulation would be observing a violation of physics. Until then, all is speculation.
- thenmar 13y agothat doesn't really make any sense though
- solipsism 13y agoIt would be a leap of logic to assert that we're in a simulation after observing a violation of physics. The first possibility we'd have to consider is that our understanding of physics is flawed. After that consideration (or maybe as a part of that consideration, depending on how you look at it), we'd have to consider the possibility that the laws of physics are not constant. But why would we jump immediately to the universe being a simulation?
- lutusp 13y ago> The minimum evidence that we are in fact in a simulation would be observing a violation of physics. Not at all. A "violation of physics", by which I assume you mean a discrepancy between our picture of the universe and the real universe as revealed in experiment, only tells us that our model is wrong. There have been any number of "violations of physics" over the decades. We believed that a luminiferous ether served as a medium for light waves -- wrong. We believed that neutrinos didn't have mass -- wrong. We believed that all mass/energy was accounted for by the descriptions in the Standard Model -- very wrong (only 4% is so described, the rest is dark matter and dark energy, with no present explanation). The simplest explanation for these discrepancies, consistent with lex parsimoniae or "Occam's razor" is that our model isn't good enough and needs revision, not that the universe is a simulation. It's equally logical (and not very logical at all) to argue that a perfectly running universe, with no anomalies, would constitute evidence for a simulation, on the ground that any self-respecting superbeing able to craft an entire universe, would surely test his code before launching it.
- gfodor 13y agoWhen someone posts something like this, do they honestly believe everyone else having this debate, including serious physicists, are just stupid because they can't see the brilliant insight they have posted?
- modulus1 13y agoMathematics is like a fractal, given some axioms it explodes into an infinite set of true equations. No one has to observe math for it to exist. I think our universe(s) could be the same way, given some natural laws, or equations, everything we know is defined to take place. Why would there have to be anything 'running' the simulation.
- seba_dos1 13y agoI started to read that article on a browser without NoScript installed. It reminded me why I love it so much.
- evanb 13y agohttp://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847 http://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847 This comment is a response to a bunch of the comments in this thread, but it didn't make sense to scatter the information throughout the page. The way lattice QCD [0] works requires a few approximations in order to fit the problem into your computer. You (1) simulate a universe with finite volume (state-of-the-art calculations have boxes just a few times bigger than a nucleus in each direction), (2) discretize the space into a bunch of points some lattice spacing apart connected by links, and, (3) possibly simulate at values of the quark masses that are not their physical values (this helps make a a matrix you need to invert better-conditioned). Finally, you know what action[1] you want to simulate (that of QCD[2]) and you construct a discretized action that accounts for all of the above approximations that approaches the real action you want to simulate when you take the limits volume --> infinity, lattice spacing --> 0, masses --> physical values. There are many different ways to build such a discretized action (and they go by names like the Wilson action, the Domain Wall action, the Staggered action, and others), but no discretized action is "perfect" in the sense that anything you try to measure can have errors that depend on how different the volume you actually measured is from the infinite-volume limit, how much having a finite lattice spacing changes your answer, and how much unphysical masses matter. We have theory that controls how measured quantities depend on these parameters, and thus can understand, via extrapolation, how lattice artifacts change the quantities we measure from the true continuum limit. You can use this understanding to find out what the answer is in the limit of there being no discretization at all (lattice spacing = 0) and then compare measurements of our world to those predictions. If they match, then the world doesn't really have a grid of points at its bottom, but if they don't match you can find out how finely spaced the grid of spacetime is. Unfortunately, any simulation you do will have error bars, and so in practice all you can say is "the continuum world looks like this ± that", the practical consequence being that you can only put an upper bound on how different the lattice spacing of spacetime is from zero: "If the lattice spacing were bigger than X then we would have conflict between the experimental observations we made of the universe and the simulation. No such conflict is known, so the lattice spacing is smaller than X." Source: I am a postdoc doing lattice QCD, and I have met Martin and Zohreh. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_QCD [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_(physics) [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_chromodynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_chromodynamics
- pirateking 13y agoI sometimes picture the Universe as being some kind of a recursive knowledge generation simulation eating memory as it learns, with (Known Universe <-> Subatomic Particles) being the current limitations. The One Electron[0] acts as the program counter. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_electron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_electron
- slacka 13y agoIt is interesting how counterintuitive quantum mechanics seems and yet many aspects make perfect sense in the eyes of a programmer. * The foundation of Quantum Mechanics is the idea of quanta. The data or physical quantities of a computer and our Universe can change only by discrete amounts like the bits of a computer. Distances, energy, and possibility time are quantized in our universe. * The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle also implies Interactions don't 'count' unless they affect some other piece of the system. Is the Universe doing called 'lazy evaluation' here? * In computer simulations, the criteria to achieve von Neumann stabilitiy is that no effect can propagate at a speed faster than the size step divided by the time step. Interactions in our universe are also limited by the speed of light. * Holographic Principle does away with spatial locality, drastically reducing the number of possible states our Universe can have. None of this makes sense unless the Universe is trying to minimize resource usage. * E=mc2 : mass and energy are two forms of the same thing. It a computer it's all bytes at it's simplest form.
- simias 13y agoI don't quite understand how we propose to identify those anomalies when we have nothing to compare them to. Maybe the weird behaviours we observe in quantum physics for instance are the result of some optimisation/bug in the simulation, but how would we prove that? How would a video game character understand and then prove he's in a simulation if the simulation itself didn't program them to do that? It kind of reminds me of the people looking for life on other planets by searching for worlds similar to ours. It's of course a reasonable approach but in the end we have no idea if statistically speaking the presence of water or a certain temperature or atmosphere gives higher probabilities for life to emerge. We're just extrapolating from a sample of one.
- evanb 13y agoWe can simulate worlds with different parameters and compare them to our (experimentally observed) world. See my top-level comment for more detail.
- randomracker 13y agoIt's probably better to resist the temptation to ascribe meaning to models. The model is the meaning, nothing more or less. If we observe these artifacts, it means that's a property of our universe. Really, we're completely locked within that system and can't say that it means anything else. But, I'd argue that if we can be a simulation, we're ignoring the qualia of consciousness issue. So I'd say that if we can be a simulation, we can just be one of those mathematical entities in Platonic space. The universe seems to be written in math, perhaps all of this is just what it's like to be one of those Platonic ideals. There's not much use in speculating in that which cannot be falsified.
- h43z 13y agoIn my naivety i think it will be impossible to proof that we live in a simulation. Even if we could simulate an universe we cannot say we live in one. And if we find bugs in our current universe we cannot say if it is a bug or our model is just wrong.
- discostrings 13y agoI think Kant may have rendered this article's vector at the question pretty meaningless over 200 years ago. In the Critique of Pure Reason, he posits that space and time are the forms of our intuition, and he claims that anything that comes to us does so through these forms. That is to say, we do not know things as they are in themselves--we only know them insofar as they have properties that can be reflected in a form that can be processed by our intuition. We bring space and time with us, as part of our structure, and mathematics is an examination of that structure. So Kant would have it that mathematics is neither a Platonic form nor something we have created-it's an exploration of our capabilities of sensation. This seems to me like a much better explanation of why mathematics are "universal" than the article's approach. It also leaves open the question of whether we are "living in a computer simulation" without suggesting that it's a simple matter (or even necessarily possible) to see out from inside.
- evanb 13y agoI think the supposition that space and time are forms of our intuition is suspect, and is indeed undermined by relativity. The supposition that maybe spacetime are the forms of our intuition also doesn't necessarily withstand scrutiny, because there is at least one way of formulating quantum field theories with no reference to spacetime at all (see, for example, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6403285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6403285 ).
- discostrings 13y agoI don't think relativity or quantum field theory undermine the idea that space and time are our forms of intuition. On the contrary, I feel it may be the first framework that really created a sensible space for those phenomena. Kant's approach holds that our /intuition/ is limited by space and time and that "things in themselves" may in actuality be many different ways. We can only receive and understand things insofar as they exist or can be manifest in space/time. I think his theory very much leaves open that we can better grasp the properties of things by studying the way they appear in space/time and drawing inferences. His very point is that space and time do not exist in themselves as far as we perceive them--they are merely the forms through which we are capable of receiving anything. And thus I would say he created a groundwork of thought that made room for relativity and quantum observations well before they were conceived--in fact, I imagine Kant's groundwork was important in our path to them. [Edited for a slight bit more clarity] [HN meta comment: it's really annoying that any given story that has a lot of upvotes and that is seemingly appropriate for HN can be flagged from the front page. Why spend time writing an insightful comment when any given story could be sent from the top of the front page to the middle of page 3 by the capricious action of a flagger or moderator, meaning no one will ever see the comment? Such unpredictability really discourages quality participation and encourages quick responses--why expend a lot of effort when the chance of anyone reading your work could evaporate so quickly and arbitrarily?]
- fredgrott 13y agoOkay short version.. Our physical world is complicated that any math system is incomplete as far as modeling the real world.. Since we use math to understand the world..its simulation is somewhat a true statement from our in precise mathematical model of it...
- quarterwave 13y agoThe Universe is a simulation, so what programming language/galactic cloud does it run on? Haskell for typing and correctness, Erlang for 'just fail', Ruby for POLA (God's, that is)...
- FreeFull 13y agoHacked together perl and lisp
- burritofanatic 13y agoIt blows my mind that some very famous people submit comments here.
- DenisM 13y agoYes: http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2535 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=2535
- mindcrime 13y agoI don't know, but this whole discussion just prompted me to pop in The Matrix for another rewatch. The orders were for your protection Ha ha. I think we can handle one little girl I sent two units, they're bringin' her down now No, lieutenant, your men are already dead
- FryHigh 13y agoEven if it is a simulation, as in the words of Rene Descartes, I think therefore I am. My interpretation of it is, I might be in the matrix but I exist somewhere. I might be a butterfly in another dimension hooked up to the matrix like simulation to be in a human body and experience earth. Anyhow I exist.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ifPaheycad 13y agoUniverse in layman terms. Grandpa Tom, is playing "Mario" on his beautiful "iMac" presented by his grandson for Christmas. He is just a regular grandpa who is in his 70s and is really new to this computer world. After playing Mario for a while he starts wondering how does a key on keyboard is making Mario Move. He starts putting himself within Mario character and starts seeing things around him. What he see is a world where he just have to "Run from dangers, get powers, survive and save the queen". Mario is so much involved he doesn't even know that there is something called as keyboard and a monitor outside his system. Mario thinks he just have to move and perform certain actions to accomplish his goal. thats all. After playing so many hours of game, Suddenly mario starts thinking "am i doing things on my own or am i being controlled ? how the hell i am going to find out. the environment around me just extends in whichever direction i go. but not if i die. so what is this sorcery !" In this whole story, Mario is each one of us. The next obvious question is, how do you know ? Neither does Mario. Some of these Marios went beyond the simulated environment (non materialistically, because there is no matter which runs this system, just like above cpu, interaction....) and figured out all this. We can decide to "believe" or "find an answer ourselves". Now a programmer knows an answer. I wrote this goddam Mario program, i did not give him enough instructions (C/C++/whatever) to thik, so he will never know what the hell is going on. But, given intelligence to think on his own, he might be able to figure out things around his environment, but still he can't see the CPU<->Memory<->GPU<->Display<->Keyboard interactions. He can, only if .... ? . So, who are we , better than mario ? who can think on their own right... ? what more do you want ? Hope this helps.