5 ms·
90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking officials
- cwan 17y agoThe news is from 2006, but it's a reminder following a recent scandal and but it's also a reminder of the difficulties outsiders (both inside and outside of the country) face in trying to become successful in China.
- rbanffy 17y agoThis is the unavoidable consequence of China's political/economic system. It's not surprising at all. What makes me worry is that the Chinese government has a far larger influence on Chinese companies than most other countries and that makes economic reliance on China a very dangerous move. It also makes people used to totalitarian regimes to the point of making them tolerable. They shouldn't be. Chinese people deserve better.
- jbarciauskas 17y agoI don't think it's unavoidable, but centralization will tend to have these sorts of effects without other controls and institutional checks, yes. One could imagine a benevolant, meritocratic oligarchy, in which the hiring and promotion process had a strong process of only advancing those up the chain who had demonstrated a certain level of competence, e.g., many successful large engineering organizations.
- garply 17y ago'Chinese people deserve better.' Really, what business is this of yours? I feel like Westerners are always looking down their noses at the Chinese political situation but people don't seem to take into account China's historical context. China IS getting better (and rather rapidly). Less than 100 years ago, China still had an Emperor. With that in mind, how many centuries has Western democracy had to mature? My personal belief is that democracy develops very gradually, sometimes punctuated by sharp periods of rapid change (e.g., revolutions, foreign colonization).
- rbanffy 17y ago"Really, what business is this of yours?" Every human being deserves better, Chinese or not. We are all on the same boat after all. And yes. China is making some progress, but, still, it has a long way to go. Switching from an imperial totalitarian state to a communist one (also an unavoidable consequence of the past couple thousand years of Chinese history) makes for not that much of a change after all. At least not much when you consider the human condition. And it is my business as it shifts the "Overton window" towards a position more on the totalitarian end of the spectrum. While recognizing China made a lot of progress in the past century (making up for the couple thousand years before) it is still unacceptable. Mind you my children will have to live in a world where a totalitarian state ruled with iron fist by a political aristocracy is a major commercial partner of just about every other country. And this arrangement may start putting ideas into some minds that would be better if left empty. At least for me it's not acceptable.
- garply 17y agoKarma for introducing me to the term Overton window. And I do agree with you that we should encourage China to continue to liberalize. I just wanted to try to offset what I feel is a somewhat one-sided view of the Chinese situation. I'd also like to point out that, despite how the Western media often presents it, the CCP isn't monolithic. Power swings between two poles: Beijing and Shanghai (Beijing being the political and military hub, Shanghai being the economic hub). For example, Jiang Zemin represented the South and was what we would consider more economically liberal and now Hu is more friendly toward the military, more focused on 'political stability', and more representative of the North. I highly suspect the next president will be a conscious swing back to the 'liberal' side of the spectrum. And the power hubs tend to alternate every decade or so. I suspect when democracy does start to trickle down to the Chinese population, the party will split somewhere along this line. We just need to give it a few more decades.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoWe just need to give it a few more decades. Here's hoping that world events allow them time to do so. What is required is a way for one bunch of people to say "hell, the people running the government right now are idiots. Idiots I say! Let's completely do things differently!" and be able to assume power and change things without force of arms or violence. And do this on a regular basis. I know I'll feel better when that day comes. Because well, sometimes the folks running things are idiots. And they have all the guns.
- olihb 17y agoAs many things in life, often it's not what you know but who you know. And I guess that if you know the big cheese, it's easier to get all the permits, gov. contracts and financing.
- jacquesm 17y agoI don't see anything different in this respect in China than I do in many western societies. Having a leg up is definitely a pre, anywhere. It may differ in degree but certainly not in principle.
- rdouble 17y agoIn which western countries are 90% of the billionaires children of government officials?
- jacquesm 17y agoerrm... I said 'degree' didn't I ? I meant that in any society the number of people that will make it big that have connections will outnumber those that do not. It's very hard to 'make it on your own', in any society and China is (unsurprisingly) no exception. News would have been 90% of Chinese billionaires (or millionaires or some other metric) had no family or other connection to power. On another note, there are only 9 Chinese billionaires in all (10 if you count HK); see http://www.forbes.com/lists/2007/10/07billionaires_The-Worlds-Billionaires_CountryOfPrmRes_3.html http://www.forbes.com/lists/2007/10/07billionaires_The-World...
- rdouble 17y agoThe news was 90% of Chinese billionaires are actually kids of government officials. That would be like if the billionaires in the UK were children of parliamentary officials or if the billionaires in the USA were children of senators and representatives. It's wrong to equivocate the Chinese situation with simply having "connections." It's a fundamental structural difference between China and "western societies." Also, what you're implying in the weak sense is probably wrong. Billionaire lists are easily found on the internet and if you look at the bios of the people on such lists, I would assert the opposite - most of the billionaires in western countries started out with few significant connections at all.
- jacquesm 17y ago
- vaksel 17y agoThat's because its harder to bribe people in China compared to the USA. There you need to do a shady deal and pay a ton of money, so family gets the inside track. In the USA, all it takes is a 100K at election time, and its completely legal.
- garply 17y agoI can't imagine that it's harder to bribe people in China than in the USA. In fact, I think much, much more bribery per capita happens in China than in the US. The Chinese legal system is very weak.
- vaksel 17y agonot harder per se, but there its done as a backroom deal. In USA, we just call it lobbying and campaign contributions.
- varjag 17y agoStill, the U.S. political system allows for such an outlier as Obama[1] to get on the top. It would've been impossible if it was only the issue of getting the most lobbyist beef behind. [1] Not idealising him here, but his ascent was both extremely untypical and very American at the same time.
- newy 17y ago"Guanxi" is a huge factor in dealings involving the Chinese government, and even in day to day Chinese business. One difference between the Chinese and American system of connections and favors may be that Chinese put a heavy emphasis on family relations, which doesn't seem overly prevalent here. Well, save for certain notable exceptions. On another note, the problem of "guanxi" extends to the microlending arena. China's lending capital for microloans is small, and even then, the funds are generally directed to those with connections to the government. I'm working with a nonprofit called Wokai (http://www.wokai.org http://www.wokai.org), and we're working to raise loan capital from people around the world for microloans to Chinese farmers. We operate pretty similarly to Kiva, except that due to Chinese regulations we can't return money to lenders - therefore, we solicit contributions that turn into perpetual loan capital.
- baguasquirrel 17y agoI don't think outsiders grasp how much of an impact the emphasis on "guanxi" and family relations has on everyday life in China. On one hand, you can see this as 90% of Chinese billionaires are the kids of high ranking officials. Bot on the other hand, you can see this as 90% of Chinese kids of high ranking officials are expected to marry someone who is successful/will make them look good. Anyone who's dated an Chinese girl whose parents are relatively successful (especially if they are East Asian themselves) will probably tell you a thing or two about having to measure up to standards. In Chinese society, people use their relationships to leverage life (and by extension, business and politics) to the full. Thus, it's not acceptable to marry below you because if you do, you may be forced to hire the relatives of your lowly mate. It is shameful if your family is not doing well, and it is shameful if your close relatives don't have a job. This is the cost of sticking together, having strong friendship and family bonds-- you do not want any relationships that are too one-sided or unsustainable. While modernization has weakened this system nontrivially, it does feel that it is still the norm, and we have reason to believe it will continue (at least to a greater extent than here in the West). The reason is that China has too many people, too many mouths to feed. China produces many more engineering students than does the US. But most of them aren't hireable. There's a reason why we're still "better". Finding the right talent in China is even more formidable than it is here, and it always has been, thanks to the fact that China has 3x more people per acre of arable land than the average country (cited from Stratfor but I can't find the link). Now I'm not saying that the system is fair or even efficient compared to the Western system, but using the family to extend one's goals is a byproduct of Chinese society. I would argue there is some wisdom in what they do. Here in the West, our HR departments often prefer to hire people who are referrals. There's an implicit understanding that good workers like to hang out with other people who are good workers. In this light, the Chinese are merely extending that wisdom beyond the workplace.
- 0_o 17y agoThe link is blocked by GFW, I think, I can not open it here in China.
- garply 17y agoAll of blogspot is blocked by the firewall, and has been for some time.
- cwan 17y agoThis is what I use while I'm in China: http://www.witopia.net/welcome.php http://www.witopia.net/welcome.php - Highly recommended given how much China is blocking these days. On other US/European sites that aren't blocked, I often find it is faster on the VPN than it is direct as well. Because I'm generally in Canada I can now also access Hulu.
- sown 17y agoExecutive Summary: "Hi, I'm George. My dad works in the whitehouse. Let me show you around."
- pegobry 17y agoWhat's even more "interesting" is the exception to that rule, Huang Gyangyu, up until recently the richest man in China, its "Sam Walton", who was arrested and is still being held for "insider trading", when arresting someone in China for insider trading is sort of like a character on The Sopranos getting arrested for saying fuck. With no formal education or family ties to speak of, he started his business at 16. Of China's billionaires, Wang was the only one who was 1- a Christian and 2- not a member of the Communist Party. And now he's in prison.