6 ms·
Pandora Knows if You Are a Republican
- daveslash 13y agoThe people who hang out here on HN probably have more complexity to their personalities than your "average Joe/Jane". We're probably the outliers to the statistical model - and my guess is that we'd all be surprised how accurate Pandora's insights are for the general public.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoI think if you go to any web forum you'll get people saying similar things about themselves vs. "the general public."
- BlackDeath3 13y agoPeople do tend to think this way, but when applied to the topic that the forum is built around, this line of thinking is probably accurate. People on HN are probably more tech-savvy than the general population. People on DefensiveCarry are probably more CCW-savvy than the general population. People on /r/Seinfeld probably tend to be some of the show's/comedian's biggest fans. I understand and agree that the claim that we have more "complex personalities" is a little suspect, but a lot of these sorts of claims probably have something to them.
- protomyth 13y ago> The people who hang out here on HN probably have more complexity to their personalities than your "average Joe/Jane" I think that statement is a load of crap and elitist. You're not more complex than the rest, you just gloss over their complexity since it is not in your frame of reference.
- hnriot 13y agoso do I!! Wow, I would likely argue quite the opposite is true, hackers are generally deficient in many other areas. Complexity comes in many forms, and just having an affinity for highly deterministic systems (computers) is likely a feature vector of diminished complexity. But very likely that's also crap.
- Shivetya 13y agosomeone else said it nicer, but herd mentality describes many who think they are special. The user of sites similar to this become painfully predictable. There are those on the extreme to one side or another, but the rest are herd animals basically typing long winded "ME TOOS"
- rmason 13y agoI am willing to bet they don't know my voting preferences solely from the music I listen to on a regular basis. I think the story is wrong, they must be using other data if their predictions are accurate.
- valarauca1 13y agoPandora still hasn't correctly nailed down my musical taste despite nearly 2 years of continuous usage. How are they going to guess my political party affiliations correctly?
- RyanZAG 13y agoBlue or Red isn't really a difficult decision to make. If you flip a coin you're already 50% likely to be correct. Musical taste is much much harder.
- freehunter 13y agoFor me personally, I've completely quit using Pandora because every station I try to make ends up playing Top 40 pop music. At least Last.FM sticks to the genre I've put in, Pandora seems to try to steer me to listen to songs they want me to listen to. Really annoying when I start listening to Americana and classic country and end up with Drake several hours later.
- ycmike 13y agoAll roads lead to Drake and Ke$ha.
- valarauca1 13y agoTimber!
- ycmike 13y agoThat too!
- robbyking 13y agoWhat makes Last.FM so good is they recommend music based on similar users, not similar artists. An artist I frequently use to demonstrate this difference is Hank Williams III. People who are familiar with him knows he plays both neo-traditional country and "hellbilly," so it's difficult to find similar artists. To generate a Hank III radio station, Pandora analyzes his music, and -- based on similarities in composition and genre ("major key tonality," "traditional country influes") -- creates a station of top 40 pop country songs, which is pretty much the antithesis of Hank III's music. Last.FM, on the other hand, analyzes the listening habits of other Hank III fans, and correctly assumes someone listening to Hank III radio will not only be a fan of outlaw and traditional country music, but also of bands like the Misfits and Black Flag.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MSM 13y ago> " Mr. Krawczyk said he believes Pandora's predictions are between 75% and 80% accurate" This doesn't really seem noteworthy at all. I would be interested to know on a national level, percentage-wise what the average majority of each county votes. I don't know how to word that better unfortunately, so here's an example: If we have three counties with equal population and one votes 81% republican, another 71% republican and the third 88% democrat, I would be able to determine your voting preferences by county alone with ~80% correctness. I know some states are swing states, but I think that a lot of those counties are still strong in one direction. Anyone know where this data might exist just for kicks?
- jaredsohn 13y agoThis map shows the voting percentage from the last election for the House of Representatives for each county. http://s1131.photobucket.com/user/swolf318/media/Political%20Geography/UnitedStatesHouseofRepresentativesElection2012byCounty_zps37885a7f.png.html http://s1131.photobucket.com/user/swolf318/media/Political%2...
- MSM 13y agoThanks! Managed to find a raw data source, added a reply to myself.
- MSM 13y agoAlright, so I managed to dig up the raw data by county.[1] I think I crunched the numbers correctly, but I wouldn't bet money on it being 100%. I just took the winning % per county and took a weighted average across the nation. I believe that should give me the desired results. The result set I used was purely presidential votes between only Obama and Romney which gave me some weird stuff like Harris, TX having a majority vote of 49.4% (also the third highest voting county, which hurt the average). Anyway, it was a fun excercise and it appears that pandora is estimated to be 25-30% more accurate than guessing on county/zip alone. I ended up seeing 61.29% as the average "majority" in each county. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/nov/07/us-2012-election-county-results-download#data http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/nov/07/us-2012...
- nswanberg 13y agoThis is way more interesting than party affiliation (which I bet is largely based on cultural affiliation, not policy preferences): "He says that people within higher-income brackets have more eclectic musical tastes than others." I can see that possibly being true but has anyone seen studies on this? Is the correlation between income and diverse music tastes very strong?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoThere are probably a metric shitload of confounding variables in between.
- bendoernberg 13y agoYou may enjoy the 1996 paper "Changing Highbrow Tastes: From Snob to Omnivore" http://www-personal.umich.edu/~lundyj/New%20College%20Class/Readings/Peterson%20and%20Kern_From%20Snob%20to%20Omnivore.pdf http://www-personal.umich.edu/~lundyj/New%20College%20Class/...
- alecco 13y ago"The Cloud" is getting creepy.
- madcaptenor 13y agoThey don't know your voting preferences, so the headline is a bit misleading. But they don't need to know them for sure; they just need to be able to guess them better than other ad providers.
- unoti 13y agoSure. Pandora also thinks I'm Mexican, and has been playing ads to me in Spanish ever since the day I listened to a couple of awesome Flemenco guitar songs.
- walshemj 13y agoThat's nothing in the UK yahoo seems to think I come from India and keeps showing me Indian matrimonial arranged marriage sites.
- arielweisberg 13y agoChristmas music botched it for me. Polluted all my stations so I left.
- Osiris 13y agoHow does that happen? I had a couple of Christmas stations set up in Pandora and none of it 'leaked' over to any other radio station.
- Nicholas_C 13y agoSame here. They've also been giving me localized ads for the Austin area when I haven't lived there in years and have only visited occasionally since.
- ry0ohki 13y ago
- sliverstorm 13y agoJoke's on them, I listen to country and electronic... I wonder what they will make of that.
- wmeredith 13y agoI thought this was odd, because I'm not a Republican or a Democrat. The headline of this article is a nice outline of the obnoxious presumptuousness pervasive in the marketing industry that got me to leave it.
- aresant 13y agoI accidentally burned some cycles in the world of political marketing and it is incredibly rigid. The general approach is spend your money to get KNOWN party voters back to the polls. EG - make sure known republicans: (a) know you are the republican candidate (b) get to the polls And if you read the article Pandora is effectively leveraging a very boring, unoriginal approach to political marketing wrapped in great PR: "Pandora's inferences start with a user's ZIP Code, supplied at registration. So if 80% of citizens in a certain county voted for President Obama in 2012, Pandora assumes that 80% of people in the ZIP Codes in that county "lean Democrat." If the county voted twice for Obama, the algorithm pegs users in those ZIP Codes as likely to be "strong Democrats." Then there's some sprinkled in "algorithmic" work around user music preference. Which really I bet that buyers won't care that much about as they're too afraid of missing any known voters to want to take a risk on micro-targeting.
- scottu1 13y agoI think Pandora is just going to push a bunch of potential customers away if they start delivering political ads. Most people have lost trust in both parties and don't want to hear it. Well I just heard a Keystone pipeline ad that asked me to call a Congressman or the President or something. Guess it's already going on.
- al2o3cr 13y agoUp next from WSJ's crack "Shit We Should Have Already Known About" research team: "HOLY FUCKBALLS, Your Credit Card Company Knows STUFF About You!"
- trhway 13y agono surprise. Even adult video industry knows if you're a Republican and sells this data to the marketers in "normal" channels
- cesarbs 13y agoPandora thinks I'm single (I'm not).
- bitwize 13y agoNot news. The companies that run analytics for the cable companies and movie studios know your age, race, gender, education and income level, just from the shows you watch. D vs. R is trivial to figure out.