3 ms·
I don't understand this. Why would the manufactures not just directly send those cars over to china and sell them? Why is it illegal to export them other than
by sschueller 13y ago
I don't understand this.
Why would the manufactures not just directly send those cars over to china and sell them?
Why is it illegal to export them other than undercutting prices of a dealer in China (but that would be dealt with by restrictions on import)?
That Americans would be deprived of owning such cars because there was a shortage is a load of crap. Car manufactures are in the business to make money that's it.
Also why are we wasting tax payer money on this?
- josefresco 13y agoNothing to understand here legally as it's simply a money-grab by automakers who are quite obviously lobbying the feds to crack down on a business that is eating into their profits. And you're right, not a single person in the US is having a hard time finding or buying a Mercedes, Land Rover or any other luxury automobile. I can't believe there are government officials wasting time pursuing this so called crime. This is lobbying to protect business interests at it's purest. Edit: I just realized my comment was basically re-stating/agreeing with yours without adding too much to the conversation and for that I apologize. I think your observation was spot on.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- twoodfin 13y agoWhy would the manufactures not just directly send those cars over to China and sell them? Presumably because they make about the same amount of money either way: If they distributed more cars into the Chinese market, prices would drop in China as supply caught up with demand. Obviously that leaves room for a competitor to undercut you, but these luxury brands can, for now, demand premiums for their cachet. In the meantime, selling cars with competitive supply (and competitive price) in America plays some part in keeping that cachet alive. You want movie stars and pro athletes driving Mercedes. Not to mention it would be a huge mistake to abandon competition in the U.S. market just because China is huge right now. If China tails off, it's expensive to rebuild your brand image, dealer network, ...
- abcd_f 13y agoForget China, look at Canada. Virtually identical certification requirements, virtually identical cars (sans MP/H vs KM/H and F vs C), but high-end Audi like S6 used to cost 100% more than in the US. They enforced this by forbidding US dealerships to sell to Canadians, by voiding the warranty and forcing to go through expensive re-certification. There's nothing to understand. In theory, there's free trade, but "it's not here in particular".