4 ms·
"full of enriched this" Before vitamin D fortification which began around the 1st great depression (1930s not 2007), bone deformities due to lack of vitamin D
by VLM 13y ago
"full of enriched this"
Before vitamin D fortification which began around the 1st great depression (1930s not 2007), bone deformities due to lack of vitamin D were the norm. Pro-fortification propaganda claims 90%+, anti-fortification propaganda glosses over it only being about half, and relatively minor. So the truth is probably in between.
Its very much like salt. If you know how and where you look you can buy nearly pure NaCl in a store (look in the canning aisle...) but anti-caking Mg salts and iodine are added. After that, gross levels of iodine deficiency were rare.
Or the TLDR is unless you're taking the proper supplements, you're better off not drinking "untouched except by pasteurization" milk. In some states its illegal to sell raw milk or in some states illegal to sell unfortified milk so if you really want to, you have a long evening with google to research which nanny state vs free state to visit and shop.
This is aside from the obvious issue that unless you're a baby cow, perhaps you're an adult human, you really haven't evolved to drink cow milk as an adult human so you almost certainly should not do so, at least not on a regular basis. Human milk would be much healthier balance of nutrients for a human to drink for obvious reasons, although culturally would be considered creepy, and your innards are way too old to be drinking milk anyway if you're posting to HN. Maybe you could industrially adulterate cow milk to make it nutritionally similar to human milk, that would be much healthier and not as culturally creepy as the real stuff.
- db48x 13y agoThe difference is not that great. The biggest difference is in the antibodies; most of the cow antibodies aren't going to help you since you can't catch the disease they protect against anyway. The only adults who should specifically avoid milk are the ones without the lactase mutation, since they cannot digest the lactose in it. This applies to human milk as well.
- dec0dedab0de 13y agoI would say that all adults should not be drinking human milk.
- Dylan16807 13y agoWhich way do you mean that sentence? * The statement that 'all adults should' is false. * For any and every adult X, X should not.
- dec0dedab0de 13y agoI just meant the idea of an adult drinking a glass of human milk weirds me out a bit. I didn't think it was ambiguous.
- Dylan16807 13y agoWell there's a big gap between 'weird' and 'no one should ever do this'.
- buro9 13y agoBut the milk of a different species is OK? The thought might repulse, but human milk at least contains things a child human needs and that other humans can benefit from. Milk is strange... best not to think about it too much. Best also not to visualise it, which is kinda the problem with human milk.
- jordan0day 13y agoIf you're coming from a vegan perspective or something, I could see how cow milk could be "weird". If you eat meat or eggs, milk's just another animal product, though. Is it really any weirder than eating animal muscle? Also, there's this: it's freaking delicious. That's usually a pretty good reason to eat something.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe lactose in human milk would be just as problematic to all the adult humans that have problems with cows milk.
- phaemon 13y ago> Before vitamin D fortification which began around the 1st great depression (1930s not 2007), bone deformities due to lack of vitamin D were the norm. The UK doesn't fortify milk with vitamin D, yet they also saw a fall in the number of cases of rickets etc. That would seem to cast doubt on your causation.
- bhousel 13y agoTrue but plenty of other foods are Vitamin D fortified. Most cereals and other dairy items like butter or margarine or yogurt.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]