3 ms·
You said: > For example, in the wage gap discussion, I have never seen anybody ask an employer why they pay women less. Who knows, there might be some surprisi
by e12e 13y ago
You said:
> For example, in the wage gap discussion, I have never seen anybody ask an employer why they pay women less. Who knows, there might be some surprising answers.
I replied:
>> "That amounts to asking employers why they are breaking the law, which makes it a little tricky"
Because your question assumed some employers paid women less, and in eg:
the US, systematically paying women less for the same job that you pay
men more for, would be
illegal.
>> Maybe you haven't noticed, but you are already assuming that employers are guilty. That kind of thing is exactly what makes me speak out against feminist articles all the time, because there are so many unspoken assumptions.
I see were we might have mis-communicated here. If we assume at a given
employer, that women are paid less for the same type of jobs that men
do, to a statstically signficant degree -- you might argue that it just
so happens that women are paid less, that it has nothing to do with them
being women -- therefore the employer might not be discriminating.
Now, if you're right, you might get some answers with justifications
ranging from experience, to education etc. However if you're wrong, then
an employer would be incriminating themselves by answering. That's why
it's a tricky question to ask -- if you expect to get meaningful
responses.
Note that such research has still been done (see other comments in this
thread).
- belorn 13y ago(replying to this comment since I can't tell which is the furthest down on the comment tree) Wage differences are not as simple issue as potraited here. For example, if discrimination is the only factor, why is the discrimination only after the age of 40? Before that, wage difference is in many professions negligent. A study in Sweden noticed that by every 10 years from the age of 30, average wage differences between men and women increases by a factor of 2 (ie, 30 = 0-10%, 40 = 15-20%, 50 = ? - 40%).
- e12e 13y agoIndeed, outright discrimination isn't the only factor, I think that's reflected in the other comments in this thread. My response above was to the lack of qualitative studies as to why employers might pay women less -- in cases that they do. The example from Sweden you site might be an example of the "glass ceiling" at work -- lack of promotion and recognition for women compared to men (I can't tell by your example if the differences are in similar positions, of if lack of promotion might be an issue).
- belorn 13y ago> My response above was to the lack of qualitative studies as to why employers might pay women less I agree there 100%, which is what I said initially in this discussion way up in the beginning of this. the "years of feminist research" has so far only identified that there is a problem, and came up with many many theories around why. Its why I call feminist research poor at best, because we need qualitative studies to show which of the many theories are correct. The Swedish study was basically just an other summery of census data. It gave theories why, but are still at that stage. I would also guess that promotion and recognition for women compared to men is an issue, which could be a result of "glass ceiling". It could also be because men compete with other men to achieve recognition (which is not the same as accomplish the job task).