3 ms·
Microsoft is in the same place with Windows 8.x that it was with Windows 2.x: trying to migrate its userbase onto a new computing paradigm (GUI/mobile touch app
by bitwize 13y ago
Microsoft is in the same place with Windows 8.x that it was with Windows 2.x: trying to migrate its userbase onto a new computing paradigm (GUI/mobile touch apps) while still showing support for the old paradigm (DOS/traditional GUI). Yes, it's going to be a force fit. In part because the paradigms are so different, and in part because it's Microsoft and they don't know how to do anything with any grace, at least at first.
But eventually they'll get it kinda-sorta right. And when they do, they'll crush the competition. Especially when tablets and convertibles start to supplant traditional laptops as daily driver devices. Apple probably hasn't much to fear. The real loser here is Android. A light, cheap, powerful device that can run full Windows like the Dell Venue 8 Pro has insane added value above the equivalent Android device.
- netcan 13y agoI think you're right. But that doesn't translate (IMO) lead to MS crushing competition. They have a lot of assets. Important software. Decades of user experience. Several war chests. An institutional ability to grind out a success. etc. etc. But, "computers" has become a big industry. It seems strange to say something so obvious, but the number of "computers" in use, the importance of those computers and the amount of money businesses and individuals spend on them is still growing and growing. I don't think MS can keep ahold of "market share" when the market gets to that size. Market share has always been MS' biggest weapon. The difference between 95% and 80% is 3X as much competition, even if it is nothing in total sales. Imagine an incumbent (say Amazon, Samsung, Google or whatever) company launching a new product that runs something inspired by Chrome OS & iOS on $250 hardware that can replace windows laptops for 10%-20% home users. That sounds a lot more plausible today than it did 10 years ago. 6-7 years ago Vista came out. It had issues and didn't run well on the low end hardware retailers were selling. They probably lost a percent or two of market share to Apple/OSX. Apple never really went after the low margin low-middle end. 6-7 years from now that could be 10%-20% to an unexpected incumbent. The markets important to MS are still growing and expanding so I don't think they are in trouble. They could lose market share and still grow absolute sales. tablets and convertibles starting to supplant traditional laptops as daily driver devices is an opening for new players.
- leoedin 13y agoPerhaps the problem is that the new paradigm is not so clearly superior to the old one. GUIs have huge advantages over text based computers for productivity. Does touch actually have that many advantages over a mouse and keyboard for someone sitting at a desk? I'd probably choose a touchscreen over a laptop touchpad, but I'd definitely choose a mouse over a touchscreen for most of the actual work I do.
- wolfgke 13y ago> GUIs have huge advantages over text based computers for productivity. Then why prefer many programmers to work using the command line for many tasks? ;-)
- leoedin 13y agoI think if you're doing the same task a lot then a command line based workflow can be very productive. However, the big advantages GUIs have is that they allow the discovery of new functions. Reading the man page for a command line application is complex and often quite confusing, while a well designed GUI will often allow you to easily find the functionality you want with a tiny bit of trial and error.
- r00fus 13y agoYou're correct, but the new target isn't touch. It's the cloud. Take a look at who the CEO is now. The hub is the cloud. Apple and Google got it right, and Microsoft realizes this (I hope). If they have indeed learned this lesson, they will be competitive in the coming years, and perhaps come to dominate. Ignoring this lesson means Windows is going to be torn apart by Android, iOS and Steam. Touch, Desktop, Search and Console should all be spokes on the hub - different ways to consume the same services. It will be a challenge meeting this vision, but Microsoft can and will meet it. Question is, will it be in time to fight off Google/Apple?
- marcosdumay 13y agoWell, I don't really remember thigs that way. Microsoft didn't push people anywhere, people were already switching to GUI based systems (IBM OS, MAC OS, etc) when MS finally got there. When they finally moved, they crushed everybody, but you are claiming a kind of power that they simply didn't show. Anyway, this time it quite different. GUIs are quite compatible with CLIs, but you can't have a touch-based small-screen hight input throughput big-screen GUI desktop, even the name is a contradiction.