5 ms·
I was thinking about stuff like the research cited here: http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/pap
by e12e 13y ago
I was thinking about stuff like the research cited here:
http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html
(I can't find the actual project I was thinking off, but this seems to be a good enough example of what I don't consider to be "poor at best, non-existent at worse".)
- belorn 13y agoLet see what findings the cited studies in the paper has to say: "teachers give boys greater opportunity to expand ideas and be animated than they do girls and that they reinforce boys more for general responses than they do for girls." (1994) "teachers who are made aware of their gender-biased teaching behaviors and then provided with strategies and resources to combat bias are better able to promote gender equity in their classrooms." (2000) All good and all, but nothing about single-sex education. Nothing about gender inequality in programming. Their conclusions are also very low hanging fruits. Is it non-obvious that educating teachers about discriminating behavior will have an effect in how they teach? It is good that they tested it, but it was not a very controversial proposition. Single-sex education is.
- e12e 13y agoI only challenged the idea that there's no (good) feminist research, or that there aren't "years of" it. When this stuff started is was much more contriversal than it is today (in most circles anyway). Progress is good :) And in case you misunderstood my point of view: I'm not advocating reverting to single sex education across the board. I'm saying that when there is documented bias (on the side of the educators and/or the students) it can be beneficial to run some single sex groups. I know that it can be useful in sexual education to do both separate and common sessions, for example. As for the example in the article, having a class available to a single group of students only; I do agree that it can end up a negative(or strange) inpact on individuals. However the tale of a single privileged male child (obviously has awesome mother!) isn't conclusive evidence that it didn't do more good than bad overall. It might well have. Or it could have on balance been a good thing if we agree that equal oppurtunity is a worthy goal (yes, negative discrimination might be part of the price we should pay to get there).
- belorn 13y agoBefore arguing about the benefit/costs of single-sex education, understand that I base my opinion not on this article but about the well established controversy surrounding single-sex education. For example, http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6050/1706.full http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6050/1706.full show that single-sex education sacrifice social skill for improved test scores. Since sexism and gender inequality is a social problem, I am not convinced that sacrificing social skills for test scores is the way to fix that social problem. It seems counter-productive. ACLU for example argues that Sex-Segregated Schools causes increased sexism, and that it perpetuates antiquated gender stereotypes (https://www.aclu.org/womens-rights/sex-segregated-schools-separate-and-unequal https://www.aclu.org/womens-rights/sex-segregated-schools-se...). Again I have a hard time to see how more gender stereotypes helps in reducing sexism in programming. Having single-sex education as "the solution" to sexism, is like having single-race schools as the solution to racism. The notion of "black and white schools" is a big part of race segregation and discrimination of the early 1900. I would prefer that the notion of single-sex school do not become the symbol of sexism in the early 2000.
- e12e 13y agoI'm not advocating single-sex education as a general system of education. I'm saying that it can be beneficial to have some lessons or courses segregated in an otherwise co-ed environment, when that can help give all students a more equal base from which to participate. Granted, it shouldn't be the first or only tool used -- but it might be a useful tool. So, if there seems to be a barrier for girls join soccer games in breaks, it might help to give a small girl only intro class to soccer -- or vice-versa for basket for boys or what not (yes, this is a contrived example). But other things might help, or be enough: encouraging inclusive behaviour in general etc etc. I absolutely agree that this type of splitting of students shouldn't be done lightly, or even seen as a particularly good situation -- it must be seen in the context of what realities we observe, and what kind of reality we would like to achieve.
- facepalm 13y agoI think that kind of research is interesting, but feminists are prone to jumping to conclusions. All sorts of things could happen in the classroom. For example, maybe boys raise their finger more often to ask questions (no idea, just an example). That could be a reason for "teachers giving them more time and space". No theory of discrimination necessary. Or maybe boys are dumber and need more help than girls - another possible way to explain the measurements without calling for discrimination. But "feminist scientists" (deliberate ") WANT to see discrimination. As soon as they see any data that can be interpreted to support the presence of discrimination, the case is closed and no further inquiry is being made. For example, in the wage gap discussion, I have never seen anybody ask an employer why they pay women less. Who knows, there might be some surprising answers.
- e12e 13y ago> think that kind of research is interesting, but feminists are prone to jumping to conclusions. I'm afraid researchers in general are far to prone to jumping to conclusions. > As soon as they see any data that can be interpreted to support the presence of discrimination, the case is closed and no further inquiry is being made. That's not my experience with such research. On the contrary, there are usually a progression: first look at the statistical data to see if there appear to be differences, and if there are, then try and find out more about those differences, why they are there and if they can and/or should be mitigated. A lot of the work in classrooms, for instance, first started with documenting classroom settings on video, looking at the amount of time spent with various students and how often one or another group was picked to answer questions etc. This work revealed rather stark differences, much to the surprise of teachers who subjectively thought themselves to not do any sort of differentiation. Now, explaining those differences is indeed complex. And while I don't think there is any support for the idea that boys are dumber than girls (or vice versa) -- there are indeed studies suggesting that young boys have a harder time learning and concentrating in a quiet "at-the-desk" classroom setting. This then has implications for how one should organize class; in general you don't want noisy students to distract those that are more quiet/more mature -- nor might you want to segregate the classroom too much. > For example, in the wage gap discussion, I have never seen anybody ask an employer why they pay women less. Who knows, there might be some surprising answers. That amounts to asking employers why they are breaking the law, which makes it a little tricky. In general there are three important questions here: do women earn the same as men (no); are women paid the same amount for the same work as men (no, but the difference is smaller -- especially now than in the 60s); And: Why? The answer to why is also a two-part answer: partly women do more of the work that is considered free (or very low wage when people are hired to do it): housework and staying at home with children. Additionally, due to women being overrepresented in careers with lower wages, in a typical family, it makes more economic sense for the woman to stay home with young (and/or sick) children -- which again means the woman might progress slower in her career. To cut an already too long comment short, have a look at for example: http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-06-21/equal-pay-plaintiffs-burden-of-proof http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-06-21/equal-pay-pl... http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/04/09/1839281/on-equal-pay-day-why-women-are-paid-less-than-men/ http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/04/09/1839281/on-equal...