6 ms·
> I don't think the best way forward is to throw out years of feminist research. That sentence gave me a nice smile. feminist research is poor at best, non-exi
by belorn 13y ago
> I don't think the best way forward is to throw out years of feminist research.
That sentence gave me a nice smile. feminist research is poor at best, non-existent at worse.
Take affirmative action in education. Give me a single study that shows that it a) produce long-term professionals, b) is better than the base line, and c) if it has any of the negative and well documented long term effects inherent of single-sex education.
There are plenty of feminist research that shows there exist an gender imbalance in STEM, and most studies gives one or other kind of theory around the why. The theories are however rarely if ever tested. The "years of feminist research" has not gotten to that part yet, and won't until we demand more from researchers than summery of latest census data.
- e12e 13y agoI was thinking about stuff like the research cited here: http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/genderbias.html (I can't find the actual project I was thinking off, but this seems to be a good enough example of what I don't consider to be "poor at best, non-existent at worse".)
- belorn 13y agoLet see what findings the cited studies in the paper has to say: "teachers give boys greater opportunity to expand ideas and be animated than they do girls and that they reinforce boys more for general responses than they do for girls." (1994) "teachers who are made aware of their gender-biased teaching behaviors and then provided with strategies and resources to combat bias are better able to promote gender equity in their classrooms." (2000) All good and all, but nothing about single-sex education. Nothing about gender inequality in programming. Their conclusions are also very low hanging fruits. Is it non-obvious that educating teachers about discriminating behavior will have an effect in how they teach? It is good that they tested it, but it was not a very controversial proposition. Single-sex education is.
- e12e 13y agoI only challenged the idea that there's no (good) feminist research, or that there aren't "years of" it. When this stuff started is was much more contriversal than it is today (in most circles anyway). Progress is good :) And in case you misunderstood my point of view: I'm not advocating reverting to single sex education across the board. I'm saying that when there is documented bias (on the side of the educators and/or the students) it can be beneficial to run some single sex groups. I know that it can be useful in sexual education to do both separate and common sessions, for example. As for the example in the article, having a class available to a single group of students only; I do agree that it can end up a negative(or strange) inpact on individuals. However the tale of a single privileged male child (obviously has awesome mother!) isn't conclusive evidence that it didn't do more good than bad overall. It might well have. Or it could have on balance been a good thing if we agree that equal oppurtunity is a worthy goal (yes, negative discrimination might be part of the price we should pay to get there).
- belorn 13y agoBefore arguing about the benefit/costs of single-sex education, understand that I base my opinion not on this article but about the well established controversy surrounding single-sex education. For example, http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6050/1706.full http://www.sciencemag.org/content/333/6050/1706.full show that single-sex education sacrifice social skill for improved test scores. Since sexism and gender inequality is a social problem, I am not convinced that sacrificing social skills for test scores is the way to fix that social problem. It seems counter-productive. ACLU for example argues that Sex-Segregated Schools causes increased sexism, and that it perpetuates antiquated gender stereotypes (https://www.aclu.org/womens-rights/sex-segregated-schools-separate-and-unequal https://www.aclu.org/womens-rights/sex-segregated-schools-se...). Again I have a hard time to see how more gender stereotypes helps in reducing sexism in programming. Having single-sex education as "the solution" to sexism, is like having single-race schools as the solution to racism. The notion of "black and white schools" is a big part of race segregation and discrimination of the early 1900. I would prefer that the notion of single-sex school do not become the symbol of sexism in the early 2000.
- tedks 13y ago>There are plenty of feminist research that shows there exist an gender imbalance in STEM, and most studies gives one or other kind of theory around the why. The theories are however rarely if ever tested. The "years of feminist research" has not gotten to that part yet, and won't until we demand more from researchers than summery of latest census data. Could you give specific examples? Please limit yourself to peer-reviewed journals in psychology and sociology. There's a long tradition of feminist research in psychology relevant in this problem space; it's incorrect as a matter of simple fact to claim that it doesn't exist.
- phazmatis 13y agoCould you give specific examples? Please limit yourself to peer-reviewed journals in psychology and sociology.
- belorn 13y agoWhile I too would really like to see such peer-reviwed journals, I can go first so tedks can post afterward. http://journalistsresource.org/studies/society/gender-society/occupational-gender-segregation-pay-differences http://journalistsresource.org/studies/society/gender-societ... (2012 study published in Sociology) That study do reference a bunch of other study, some which did also polls rather than just census data. However, note the mass use of the words "could be", "potentially", "suggests" and so on. I choose to interpret those words as "further study is needed" each time they are used, limiting the article to only what has the word "finding" on it.
- tedks 13y agoI'm in my lab now, but if you insist I can transcribe the reference section of my favorite psychology of women textbook when I get home. I don't think it's unfair to call out people with obvious agendas (in this case, single-gender education) when they make broad claims about entirely uncontroversial topics within a field itself. Nobody on HN would brook that over an evolution debate; it's sexist, frankly, to allow that to happen here.