4 ms·
You're starting your rebuttal from the wrong point. No, you are :-) It's not a zero-sum game like a casino. There is value created by the allocation of resourc
by gaius 17y ago
You're starting your rebuttal from the wrong point.
No, you are :-) It's not a zero-sum game like a casino. There is value created by the allocation of resources. That's what Warren Buffett does. OK so it's not what LTCM did, but that's a flaw in the implementation, not the theory, of capitalist economics. The gambling metaphor simply doesn't fit.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoTouch/e. Capitalist economics is pretty useless as a theory, if it doesn't work in practise then it's no use. Define "work". The purpose of capitalism AFAICT is to make money for wealthy capitalists and it does a pretty good job at that. The social fixes added by governments to avoid the capitalists destroying the workforce (eg social security, min wages, health care) are the only reason it can continue. And now of course we have the bailouts, without which the capitalist economy would be dead already rather than groaning in death pains. I'm pretty /au fait/ with the concept of borrowing to leverage larger sums of money to optimise efficient growth - floatation works IMO only if those buying have altruistic reasons as well; everything is too open to abuse from the big investors. Efficient allocation of resources is not the net effect IMO. Another example, I can see how you want to mitigate against changes in currency destroying your profit on a large / long-term cross-border project by ForEx deals, but this isn't only how ForEx is used. I don't see how gambling doesn't encompass a naked-short-sell (say) unless you have opportunity to influence the market by some insider trading, which is both [normally] immoral and illegal, or predict the market by being privy to some deals before they are made (as in the recent expose of the NYSE network being sniffed).
- gaius 17y agoCapitalism has no "purpose" other than an optimal allocation of existing wealth with the objective of creating new wealth. It's an algorithm or a technology, not an ethical system. This is where many critics of capitalism stumble. The bailouts are emphatically not capitalism. Capitalism says let the banks go bankrupt, let the investors lose their shirts, they knew the risks, they knew the profits they were making were in return for taking those risks. The bailouts are entirely political (oh shit! we need those Detroit votes!).