5 ms·
Why a woman's attractiveness acts as a repellent, explained using probability.
- swolchok 17y agoA Beautiful Mind covers this issue from a slightly different angle. It's a decent flick. I'm marginally surprised neither it nor Nash was mentioned in the article.
- sofal 17y agoThe example of a Nash equilibrium in A Beautiful Mind was completely wrong. A real Nash equilibrium assumes that no player regrets their strategy given the knowledge of everyone else's move. In the case of the Carol Syndrome (or the "solution" from A Beautiful Mind), the players will have plenty of reasons to want to change their initial strategy.
- msie 17y agoThere's theory and then there's reality. There are many attractive women/men who are wondering why noone attractive is chatting them up.
- 4chan 17y agoSimple explanation. Unattractive people are more used to rejection, and also are more likely to approach when they're not as into someone, so they mind it less. Attractive people have less experience with rejection and approach others selectively, so it hurts more.
- 4711 17y agoSimple explanation. Unattractive people approach less selectively and have more experience with rejection, so they're less sensitive to it. Attractive people tend to be much more risk-averse.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mrshoe 17y agoFear of failure is the main reason one would not chat up an attractive girl. The point of this article is that men think they are going to fail, not because they are not attractive, but because attractive girls must have so many other options. Therefore, it is somewhat independent of the man's assessment of his own attractiveness. This model is probably oversimplified, however, as self-confidence must play a role in there somewhere.
- endtime 17y ago>Therefore, it is somewhat independent of the man's assessment of his own attractiveness. The article does mention Guy's evaluation of himself as a candidate. And, intuitively, if Guy considers himself to be extremely attractive, then he should consider p(a) to be accordingly higher.
- indiejade 17y agoKeep in mind that it works the other way, too: extreme attractiveness can also be a repellent for women. Especially if the guy has a big ego, is a player, etc. (not many nerds are, but some are). When it comes to relationships, most women I know of prefer loyalty over physical attractiveness, even if they say otherwise. Of course, there is also the issue of persistence, which cannot be entirely discounted.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- 1gor 17y agoCarol situation is a case of prisoner's dilemma, which may be presented in a bit shorter way than the article does. Let's use standard game theory terms for the possible actions of one male individual: 'Cooperate' (C) = to publicly approach an attractive girl 'Defect' (D) = to ignore the girl, read the paper instead So, imagine yourself walking into a cafe and seeing Carol at a table. She has been there for a while, and you have no way of knowing if some other guy has already approached her (or if Carol has a boyfriend). Let's assume for the sake of simplicity that the first man who dares to approach Carol always gets her telephone number (her nice way to reward him for being brave). That automatically means that the second guy will be rejected and feel bad. The outcomes are (in order of preference): CD = You dare to speak to Carol, you are the winner, the other guys didn't dare to approach her. DD = Every man in the room reads the paper, Carol sits alone. DC = You choose to ignore the girl, then some lucky bastard walks across the room and gets her number. Bad, but you have not lost your face. CC = The worst outcome. You have approached Carol, but she is already involved with someone else. You walk back to your table, feeling miserable. You notice that second and third outcome are somewhat identical, there is no gain, but also no real damage. A rational person may well prefer to do nothing and land in the 'neutral' area where 50% of total outcomes lay, rather than to approach Carol and to have 25% chance of success vs. 25% chance of a complete disaster. --- I think it is not the women's attractiveness that acts as a repellent, but uncertainty of her status (has or has not a partner already). The way for Carol so improve her situation is to develop some sort of signalling that says she doesn't mind to be approached (flirting used to do the trick in old times).
- Dilpil 17y agoWell if you know yourself to be attractive, the problem is even more acute. Why approach another attractive person when you will most likely be approached yourself?
- 321abc 17y agoBecause you know that attractive people are less likely to be approached.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- swolchok 17y agoWell, there is certainly a missing factor in the model -- what about the probability q that a date with Carol will be a worthwhile experience, for whatever definition of "worthwhile" Guy uses?
- fatdog789 17y agoBullshit. A repellant to a certain type of guys, maybe. But the hotter a chick is, the more dates she goes out on unless she chooses to be picky. From the article: 1. He talks to Carol and she responds in a friendly manner. He gets her phone number and a proper date next week. 2. He does not approach Carol. He can enjoy another rewarding task (like reading the last issue of Plus). 3. He talks to Carol and she proves uninterested. He will feel miserable for a week. No guy who is actually interested in a woman will pick option 2. In fact, it's a non-option. No guy who will "feel miserable for a week" over some random chick turning him down for a date. If he does feel miserable for a week, he's got serious emotional problems or instability issues. A few minutes, maybe. A hours, possibly. if he has a really sensitive ego. Finally, as to the anecdotal evidence at the bottom of the article which inspired the article, I call bullshit again. Uma Thurman and Jessica Simpson were both referring to boyfriends, not dates, and discussing how their careers and financial success was scaring off men who were intimidated by the spectre of being in a relationship with a more successful woman. (I watch Extra, so sue me.)
- spydez 17y ago"No guy who is actually interested in a woman will pick option 2. In fact, it's a non-option." I'm a guy. I'm interested in women. I pick option 2 all the time. Some of us happen to be shy and/or introverted...
- req2 17y agoYou don't pick option 2 so much as it picks you.
- sown 17y agooption 2 hasn't so much as picked me as had it's tendrils wrap around my aorta.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI guess that doesn't fit very well with my notion of what an option is :-)
- mkfort 17y agoI think this is useless without pics of Carol
- cduan 17y agoThe illustrations are pretty good though--I'd use him for that social network webapp I'm writing that's going to take over the world.
- TriinT 17y agoAnd without info on Carol's age. It's cruel, I know, but it's the reality...
- vaksel 17y agoJust picture any hot woman you'd never approach, because you are SURE she must have a boyfriend, and if she doesn't, then there must be something wrong with her.
- mahmud 17y agoIf you are in a committed loving relationship, you would have no trouble chatting up anyone you would normally be attracted to, because you don't have an agenda; all of the sudden, you're one hot cookie. So if you're single and looking, the easiest way to connect with people you're attracted to is to approach them with no agenda. Become as sexually detached as you can and treat them like a buddy.
- 321abc 17y agoActually, it's really quite simple. Just follow the step-by-step instructions here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_n2IVF9a2IA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_n2IVF9a2IA and here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCEYxs7kWmQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCEYxs7kWmQ
- jlees 17y agoOf course being buddies with someone you're attracted to can also lead to sticky situations, cf http://xkcd.com/513/ http://xkcd.com/513/
- donaldc 17y agoGuy considers the possible outcomes: (a) He talks to Carol and she responds in a friendly manner. He gets her phone number and a proper date next week. (b) He does not approach Carol. He can enjoy another rewarding task (like reading the last issue of Plus). (c) He talks to Carol and she proves uninterested. He will feel miserable for a week. A week? Guy needs to lighten up, and not take rejection so seriously. His attitude may have just cost him a date with an intelligent and attractive woman.
- ardit33 17y agoI don't know any good looking, smart, and single women that can't get dates. Actually I don't know any good looking/smart girl that is actually single. From anecdotal evidence: I got to know this cute and smart girl, but she was in a long term relationship at the time. At some point I learned through a common friend that she broke up a month and a half ago. I asked her out, and she told me she has been dating this other guy for a month. So, basically, she was single for two weeks. With my friends, we call "high quality" girls, girls that are good looking, smart and nice, have a job/passion in their lifes, or have something going on for them. They are very rare. Actually, extremely rare around here. You might meet good looking girls, but that have nothing else going on for them in their lives, you might meet smart girls, but that are just not attractive to you. The combination of smart + good looking is a real killer, and often is ruined by "bitchiness", but that is very subjective. It seems that women become "nicer" and easier to talk to as they get older. Especially in their 30s and so, when they clock is ticking. But in their '20s', it is tough to find a girl like this Carol. Maybe Carol needs to move to SF. She will have the pick of the litter.
- mynameishere 17y agoA woman of beauty and intellect can go anywhere and do anything. Read his biography: Napoleon himself was starved for such a woman. But you are asking for two 99 percentiles in categories which share a pretty dubious correlation.
- endtime 17y agoAttractiveness should be totally uncorrelated to intelligence - or, if anything, have a very slight positive correlation. Also, he didn't say anything about 99th percentile. A girl who is even the 80th percentile for both looks and intelligence would be pretty desirable.
- oliveoil 17y ago> Attractiveness should be totally uncorrelated to intelligence Why would you think so? Isn't it the case that smarter guys make more money (or are otherwise more successful), allowing them to chose among more potential partners, some of them being physically attractive and selected for that reason? The offspring would be both smart (after the daddy) and pretty (after the mummy).
- electromagnetic 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minor_Discworld_concepts#The_.27Jerk_Syndrome.27 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minor_Discworld_concepts#The_.2... "This is a condition that may be experienced by a woman who is so beautiful, so alluring, that any man with half a brain isn't even going to think about asking her out, because it's obvious she's too grand for the likes of him. This leads her to believe that the problem is at her end, and that there must be something wrong with her. This persists until she meets a man who does not have half a brain (i.e. is too stupid to realize she'll likely reject him, or is so used to rejection that it doesn't bother him, or has some other flaw that stems from an even more major flaw), and he does in fact ask her out, and she is so grateful that she says yes". A woman may be so attractive that a guy won't ask her out, because she's a 10 and he's a 1. However there'll always be people too stupid to count and can't tell the difference between 1 and 10 and will ask her out anyway.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoOr he may be the one smart guy who thinks, hey, she's such a stunning beauty, I bet no one has dared to ask her out, so I will. And maybe the smart guy doesn't need to be so super smart but simply an attentive observer. Also, chances are that Carol is smart (and courageous) enough to approach a guy herself once she becomes fed up with her own situation.
- tel 17y agoAny bundle in which both Guy and someone else approach Carol yields (c) and has reward value 0. Oh, so that's how it works? No wonder this situation seems out of balance. Instead, I would suggest that in the p_star case, N is only the number of other guys who (from Guy's perspective) are more interesting (attractive, well-spoken, outgoing) which helps to keep N down for any suitably attractive, confident Guy. That changes Carol's p_none too. Now she's getting the product across some distribution of p_stars from guys around her, each of which is related to the apparent value of the dating pool and individual confidence. I haven't worked the math, but it definitely seems like p_none < 1/2 only when none of the guys are very confident in their worth. I don't really think you needed to use game theory to get that result.
- SleepHitter86 17y agoAny time spent reading hacker news or that article is not used approaching attractive women. Just saying, its purely a function of our own MOTIVATION, not necessarily our self-image, which we can change.
- calcnerd256 17y agoAh, so there is a mechanism selecting against people who underestimate themselves. I would prescribe she be less shy if she's so attractive. Make the first move, Carol; chat a guy up.
- sown 17y agoShyness was conveniently part of the problem statement.
- mike463 17y agoI can explain it quite easily - "Nobody goes there anymore -- it's too crowded"
- joechung 17y agoIt never hurts to try. Oh wait, yes it does. A lot.
- timr 17y agoThe pain is completely in your head. And the more you do it, the less it hurts.
- josefresco 17y agoUnless of course your 'game' sucks and you get slapped/kneed-in-the-crotch or her gaggle of un-hot friends assaults you. I'll take physical pain over extreme social pain/embarrassment pretty much any day of the week.
- timr 17y agoEveryone's game sucks at first. You make it suck less by putting yourself out there and practicing.
- albemuth 17y agoI think everyone knows that, the barrier to entry is just too big
- browngeek 17y agoCarol should put her profile at an online dating site. Its easier for men to "chat her up" online (Option 1); and not feel too bad when Carol rejects their move (Option 3). Essentially, Option 2 becomes a non-option and Carol would have more men approaching her and to choose from. Anecdotal: I saw this girl online. I considered her "out of my league". But what the heck, I picked Option 1. Now we are engaged. If I had seen her in the real world, I would have picked Option 2.
- slig 17y agoYour anecdote inspired me to do something. Thanks, man!
- gtzi 17y agoIn practice, N=1 (just you), a>>b,c, so it is p->1 and you have to go for it :)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ilitirit 17y agoFinally I understand why women are repelled by me.
- kingkawn 17y agoI think this probably has to do with attractive people thinking that they should be approached. If you're beautiful, especially for women, you're asked to do less for attention and reward. So you get used to doing little, and expect others to come to you.
- biohacker42 17y agoBullshit. While I'm sure that super attractive people can intimidate a disproportionate share of the opposite (or same!) sex. The lack of romance requires that in addition to being super attractive they also refuse to be the one who breaks the ice. Proper headline should be attractiveness + refusal to take the first step leads to fewer dating opportunities.
- bkovitz 17y agoThere is a reason why mathematics students have the highest virginity rate of any major. http://www.forwardon.com/view.php?e=Id1200c8f6b7f5f813 http://www.forwardon.com/view.php?e=Id1200c8f6b7f5f813
- philwelch 17y agoThose statistics are from Wellesley, a women's college. It would be more fair to see statistics from a coeducational college.
- srn 17y agoSeriously, where's the study? This is a nice example of game theory but let's not call it truth without some backing research, and all the anecdotal evidence in the world sounds nice but we are not exactly a representative group are we?
- benatkin 17y agoThe illustrations are good. The article was intriguing at first, but the last part of it was disappointing. It's a shame. It could have been a really good article.
- chaostheory 17y agoThe problem I find with this article and game theory in general is that it assumes everyone acts rationally all the time, which is not the case. I remember a research paper finding that the only people who consistently acted rational in the game theory sense were economists and sociopaths.
- doki_pen 17y agoI think most men wait for a social cue from the woman before approaching her. Maybe this woman needs to throw out some signals to some men that she is attracted to. Most men only need the slightest encouragement to feel safe from bad rejection.
- adrianwaj 17y agoIt's called an Approach Invitation to some. There also a pre-AI, where you can signal to her, so that she can then signal back.
- dschoon 17y agoAs many people have already observed, ideal rationality and reality are very different. This is one of the reasons why assertiveness and risk-seeking behavior is rewarded in {dating,business}. The game theoretic calculus might not provide the optimal course of action, because its assumptions might not sufficiently model reality. I'd offer that we don't see many beautiful, single women because we irrational agents take the risk to chat her up anyway. And HEYYO, turns out that, empirically, maybe that's the right thing to do.