4 ms·
Stroustrup on The C++0x "Remove Concepts" Decision
- huhtenberg 17y agoWoa .. this will sure upset Mr. Stepanov. The lack of the support for concepts was one of his main concerns about the C++ even back in 1995. I'm sure his feelings didn't improve dramatically since then. What is an iterator? Not a class. Not a type. It is a concept. (Or, if we want to be more formal, it is what Bourbaki calls a structure type, what logicians call a theory, or what type theory people call a sort.) It is something which doesn't have a linguistic incarnation in C++. But it could. http://www.sgi.com/tech/stl/drdobbs-interview.html http://www.sgi.com/tech/stl/drdobbs-interview.html
- thras 17y agoI really like C++. I use python, I use ruby, but I don't enjoy either of them as much as C++. They feel "dumbed-down." And the speed has been nice many times. I feel that one of the things really holding C++ back is its development model. The benevolent dictator open source approach seems to have proven itself compared to C++'s problematic ISO-standard process. For one thing, mistakes are locked in stone. Non-standardized languages handle mistakes through versioning, which tends to be a much better bargain for all involved. At the same time, the ISO-standardization means that C++ has some much more computer-science orientated modules than you tend to see in other languages. The amount of thought and optimization that goes into everything is mind-boggling.
- neilc 17y agoGiven how enormously complicated C++98 is, let alone C++0x, I think the last thing C++ needs is to jettison the standardization process in pursuit of faster evolution. The evolution of C++ should be conservative: both because it is widely deployed on many different platforms and compilers for doing "serious" work, and because it already has far, far too much junk in it already.
- gchpaco 17y agoI don't expect this to make C++0x any less of a train wreck--it would take an act of God to do that at this point--but it's interesting to note that most standards committees see their role as codification of existing practice, whereas C++0x and the previous standard before it have had a marked tendency toward invention.
- thras 17y agoDo you really consider it a train wreck? There seem to be some useful new features. The tragedy, in my opinion, is that we don't have more to show from a decade's work by so many brilliant people. C++ is straitjacketed by ISO standardization.
- huhtenberg 17y agoDesign by committee is a tricky business, especially if Bijarne says they are always aiming for the consensus and not a simple majority vote. Even not considering C++, this approach is more likely to result in the acceptance of a feature that everyone feels equally "meh" about rather than something that "only" 80% really likes, but 20% opposes.
- GeneralMaximus 17y agoJust a fun fact: Haskell was designed by a committee. Just saying that it's not all bad :)
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoC++ has many compilers for loads of embedded platforms. It has to be standardized. It's not comparable to the languages with two or three implementations that all sit on top of Windows or UNIX. It is much harder to change C++ without hurting many compiler writers.
- biotech 17y agowe don't have more to show from a decade's work by so many brilliant people. Well said. I use C++ and Perl primarily, and both languages suffer from this.
- makecheck 17y agoIt's okay for them to be a little conservative. As we've seen with the likes of GNU extensions and Boost, it is certainly possible to move forward without perfect standardization. But part of me also wants to put C++ on life support, and simply devote all time to the improvement of D (akin to temporarily moving Python 2.x forward until Python 3 is more mature).
- chancho 17y agoCommercially, C++ is already on life support: it's no longer a general applications language but rather a niche language. Microsoft supports it in Visual Studio for the game industry and Intel supports it for the same as well as the HPC market. For all the rhetoric over C++ (it will either save or destroy C++ depending on who you talk to) its unlikely to make a big difference either way. I think D is pretty cool, but it has a lot farther to go with regards to standardization as well as implementation. There is a current reddit thread going over its shortcomings: http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/93jh5/ask_proggit_the_d_programming_language_looks/ http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/93jh5/ask_progg... Whether it wants to be or not, D is now in the same niche as C++, but without either the maturity or commercial support that a niche language needs to thrive. And that probably won't change now that the larger software world has moved on.
- kingkongrevenge 17y ago> no longer a general applications language but rather a niche language If by "niche" you mean "anywhere code has to run fast or in a small space." C++ is displacing C in embedded applications. The JIT compilers in Java and MS CLR are in C++. C++ is only growing for use in simulations, which remains a rapidly growing field. C++ remains a good choice for GUI development, which is hardly niche.
- scott_s 17y agoI think it's fair to call that a "niche." C++ is a systems programming language with rich support for data abstraction, object-oriented and generic programming. Most applications don't require the kind of control over resources and the level of abstractions that C++ has. This is progress - it used to be that the majority of programs had to consider processor and memory utilization as a primary concern. The examples you gave are excellent examples of where it makes sense to use C++, but that's not what the majority of programming is now.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]