8 ms·
Every time I see an article like this I just want to grab the readers and shout "Read a philosophy book!" to them[1]. Literally every point in every article on
by onion2k 13y ago
Every time I see an article like this I just want to grab the readers and shout "Read a philosophy book!" to them[1].
Literally every point in every article on how to live a happy life was being made by the likes of Seneca and Aristotle thousands of years ago, and there are good reasons why those writers are still the foundation for philosophy today - they were right.
[1] I would recommend something like "Philosophy For Life (And Other Dangerous Situations)" by Jules Evans or "Consolations of Philosophy" by Alain De Botton as a starting point.
- ozim 13y agoBasicaly those readers try not to waste time on reading old creazy guys from ancient past. It is easier to get pieces here and there on random internet sites. I would sum this article with such quote: "It is not that we have a short space of time, but that we waste much of it. Life is long enough, and it has been given in sufficiently generous measure to allow the accomplishment of the very greatest things if the whole of it is well invested. But when it is squandered in luxury and carelessness, when it is devoted to no good end, forced at last by the ultimate necessity we perceive that it has passed away before we were aware that it was passing." On the shortness of life - Seneca
- AutoCorrect 13y agotldr
- sz4kerto 13y agoAgreed, and I'd like to add that there's a reason why a few thousand years after Aristotle (and the rest) we still don't know a good recipe for a happy/whatever life.
- VLM 13y agoOn the contrary, we know so many recipes, and some have proven much better than others, while some have become obsolete. Its like asking for "the" (singular) recipe for cooking food. What the philosophers are good at, is helping the reader come up with a logical method for making value judgments about those recipes. Its (mostly) not "here's a great piece of source code" its mostly more like "and this is why OO design is better (or not)".
- robobro 13y agoI like the social contract, Marxism, Schopenhauer's writings, what we've learned in psychiatry, and so on...
- CmonDev 13y agoI would rather read a short article with pictures then read a 300+ page book. Both of them are subjective views anyway, it's not an exact science.
- Tloewald 13y agoSomething can be subjective and stupid.
- CmonDev 13y agoYes, but the contents of the article can be discussed here today. Because it's short.
- nazka 13y agoThere is the Philosophy in the Mathematics. It is a real branch like geometry or anything else. Socrate and others are simple to read.
- datphp 13y agoIt's actually as objective as you get, if there is such a thing as "rational". Rationality is the main principle of "exact" science too, and is a good tool to work within what we know. Unfortunately, it's also a limitation, and maybe what's preventing us from transcending our bonds[1]. [1] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0133093/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0133093/
- cLeEOGPw 13y agoI view it as a sanity check that's preventing us from transcending from reality into imagination, which might or might not have anything to do with how world works.
- chr1 13y agoThis article isn't interesting because of philosophy or because it says something important about life. Nice thing is the way it shows life and computer game in parallel. So it has nothing in common with reading philosophy book. (unless you mean after reading philosophy book one won't waste his time on stupid things like this)
- theorique 13y agoBut Seneca and Aristotle never wrote SEO-optimized 7 item listicles or produced YouTube linkbait. "This crazy Greek drank Hemlock. What happened next will blow your mind."
- girvo 13y agoOh crap. Imagine BuzzFeed but for ancient philosophers and classic literature. Awesome.
- onion2k 13y agoThere is a philosophical take on tabloid articles (based on The Daily Mail, a UK tabloid): http://www.philosophersmail.com/ http://www.philosophersmail.com/
- robobro 13y agoI would throw up.
- guizzy 13y agoYou won't BELIEVE what this vagrant philosopher said to the king of Macedon!
- coldtea 13y agoKing of Macedon: "What can I do for you, o wise hobo?" Philosopher: "Well, you could move over. You block my sun".
- chiph 13y ago"Philosophy Students Hate Him - One Weird Trick To A Lifetime Of Happiness"
- merrua 13y agoSeneca and Aristotle were building off information already passed on to them so its probably older than that.
- coldtea 13y agoAristotle (and Seneca but especially Aristotle) meticulously mentioned their sources. They had tons of original and unprecedented thoughts besides those anyway.
- f_salmon 13y agoAnd there's a major logical error in it: > At the start of the game, you had no control over who you were or your environment. By the end of the game that becomes true again. This implies that you have some sort of control between the start and the end - which is completely untrue, because: What genes you get from your parents and in what environment you are put will determine everything that will happen in your head. And everything that happens in your life, has its inception in your head (over which you could never have the slightest control). This is also the reason why whe should all have the same rights (and wealth), independently of the fact of how well we were (and therefor now are) "equipped": There is no such thing as a "free will". Everything in your life is nothing but a function of 2 variables: 1) Your inherited genes 2) Your inherited initial location It means we can never be judged by anyone. EDIT: The above is not based on any beliefs (as in "religious" beliefs), it's pure logic. (So, when I wrote "is completely untrue", I meant "is completely illogic".) EDIT II: Sorry, I can't recommend any literature for this. It's all based on my own thinking. But actually, you don't need any book, because I can't call this a "worldview", I can only call it: "100% pure logic". (Meaning: no cultural/religious/otherwise arbitrary beliefs allowed.) So, if you can think logically and are willing to do some mental work, you - and everybody else who does it - will automatically get there. That's kind of the beauty of logic - it's the only thing/law in the universe that seems to be an absolute/unquestionable truth, everything else being invented by somebody.
- baby 13y ago> This implies that you have some sort of control between the start and the end - which is completely untrue. You're just saying you believing in destiny. I believe the inverse. And we will never know the truth so please don't start with a "which is completely untrue" when it's just an opinion.
- datphp 13y agoCausality (in which most people believe, even though they never abstracted it far enough to realize the implications)
- 13y ago
- datphp 13y agoIn the end most of those books have a huge build-up, but if you truly understand them, you can sum them up in one sentence. "If you got hurt you will hurt others". "Everything you do is egoistical". "Everything is choice". "There is no choice". But then again, you don't need books for that. If you have the luxury (or curse) of being rational, you're 10 (5 maybe) and you're already having fatalist/whateverist thoughts. Then the next day you think about it, and realize it doesn't change anything in your life, and you move on. Then 10 years later you finally get to study the concept (or read it on a blog) and, well, it still doesn't solve or introduce any problem in your reality. People who think/act irrationally aren't sensitive and don't find revelation when they read or hear about those principles, only confirmation where they can. There are things that happen in life that can shake you up and change you, but from a piece of text you'll only assimilate what's aligned with your views, IMHO.
- rikkus 13y agoAristotle thought that women had fewer teeth than men.
- evacuationdrill 13y agoThat may be true. We'd need to find out how many teeth each gender has on average.
- siddboots 13y agoHere's a guess: Women, on the average, are older than men. So women, on the average, have fewer teeth.
- evacuationdrill 13y agoSounds logical. But, and I'm not sure if it's correlated with gender, my mother and her mother both have several baby teeth with permanent teeth above them still, so there are cases like that screwing with the data.
- vadman 13y agoOn a related note, Google Image search for "baby skull teeth" is quite interesting.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoFewer teeth in their mouths .. don't go there if you're squeamish.
- Jimmy 13y agoAnd Newton believed in alchemy. Doesn't mean we should disregard his entire body of work.
- hawkharris 13y agoOne of the philosophy scholars you mention, Alain De Botton, wrote an entertaining and insightful book called How Proust Will Change Your Life (or something along those lines). His goal was to make notoriously dense writings accessible to everyday people who are interested in literature. I think this piece about life as a video game has a similar goal. Just as I would rather learn about Proust through Alain De Botton, I would rather learn about philosophy through the contemporary vehicle of video games.
- Quetzalcatalyst 13y agoJust to add, Alain De Botton also has several documentaries exploring philosophical ideas at a layman's level.
- benihana 13y agoSigh. Hacker News top comment. It's not "wow this is great!" or "nice work, great illustrations, I'll show this to my students!" It's "I'm so irritated that I already knew what you just told me and I learned it from a better source that I want to assault you!! Why don't you read the same things I read!!?"
- hugogee 13y agoDont know bout you but im lapping up all the wonderful references to books & authors. -cheers There is biking aphorism that comes to mind, if you stare at that stump you WILL hit it.
- sorvalk 13y agoIt's true and not just in biking: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_fixation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Target_fixation
- avenger123 13y agoWilliam Irvine's book - http://www.amazon.com/Guide-Good-Life-Ancient-Stoic-ebook/dp/B0040JHNQG/ http://www.amazon.com/Guide-Good-Life-Ancient-Stoic-ebook/dp... is a great summary of Seneca and Aristotle's stoic perspectives. It's not a long book and gives a nice overview of the highlights of stoicism.
- dangerlibrary 13y agoSeneca's essays aren't terribly long, either. http://www.amazon.com/Stoic-Philosophy-Seneca-Essays-Letters/dp/0393004597 http://www.amazon.com/Stoic-Philosophy-Seneca-Essays-Letters...
- jh3 13y agoI immediately thought of just 'Finite and Infinite Games' just from the title of this post. “There are at least two kinds of games. One could be called finite; the other infinite.”