8 ms·
What's the difference between SOD tips and parallel construction?
by gwern 13y ago
What's the difference between SOD tips and parallel construction?
- dhimes 13y agoIt looks like one implies an outside source, the other originates with the officer at the scene. In the case of a traffic stop, the officer stops me 'because I am speeding' and searches me until he finds something. In another case, s/he stops me because of a 'tip.' The cover story of the officer differs. If they won't stop this they should at least keep stats on how many of these things pan out.
- joe_the_user 13y agoYou can be 100% sure these things "pan out" in the sense of resulting in convictions, because a lot of people are going to plea-bargain when confronted by the DEA, whether they are actually guilty or not. Essentially, once you have poisoned the actual trial process (and this shows just how poisoned it is), no statistics about "how effective this is" are going to mean anything. After all, I'm sure some DEA agents know they're convicting innocent people I'm sure others have blanket belief in the guilt of many innocent people. It's kind of a truism - once you abandon objective, unbiased inquiry, it's gone.
- tptacek 13y agoTo the best of my (limited) understanding, if you pull someone over because of a 'tip' and then search them, absent some other cause, the source of the tip needs to be documented to the court. You can't generally search people based on anonymous tips. (It's a little more complicated than that, of course: http://www.casebriefs.com/blog/law/criminal-procedure/criminal-procedure-keyed-to-israel/arrest-search-and-seizure/illinois-v-gates-2/ http://www.casebriefs.com/blog/law/criminal-procedure/crimin...)
- Spooky23 13y agoIs that true if the policeman happens to observe an actionable infraction, like failure to keep right?
- tptacek 13y agoYou can't search a car on a traffic stop without probable cause of an actual crime. However, if your traffic stop is for a moving offense that warrants arrest (DUI, for instance, or reckless driving), all bets are off, because the police can do intrusive searches incident to an arrest. Also, if you're stopped for a moving violation and either authorize a search, or have evidence of probable cause in plain view (for instance, a bag of weed in the passenger seat), all bets are again off.
- smsm42 13y agoDogs can authorize searches: http://reason.com/blog/2013/02/19/scotus-approves-search-warrants-issued-b http://reason.com/blog/2013/02/19/scotus-approves-search-war... And to get this power, all the dog has to do is to pass a training program. That's like giving anybody who has a "diploma" from a "prestigious Internet university" powers to arrest and imprison. Only in this case you can't even argue with them because how can you argue with a dog? A dog barked, thus search is authorized. Now let's think - can there be any ways to make the dog bark? If somebody does that in order to make foolproof instant probable-cause-on-demand, what would be his risks that the dog will grow a conscience and tell everybody he's been lying for years?
- tptacek 13y agoYes, I agree with you, strongly, about the ridiculousness of drug-sniffing dog PC.
- makomk 13y agoWorse, from what I recall there are actual scientific studies out there demonstrating that many of these dogs do indeed bark when their handler thinks there are drugs rather than when they actually smell them.
- nkurz 13y agoFor those interested in the details, here's a good description of the cases in which vehicle searches can legally be conducted without a warrant: http://www.fletc.gov/training/programs/legal-division/downloads-articles-and-faqs/downloads/other/VehicleSearchVisorCard.pdf http://www.fletc.gov/training/programs/legal-division/downlo...
- derefr 13y agoRight, and the reason SOD tips work is that they don't need to be anonymous--as with laundering money, there's a legitimate front that the information is passed to (e.g. some known minor criminal who can be leaned on), which can then be cited as its source.
- tptacek 13y agoAre there documented cases of that happening? It's one thing for an SOD tip to put a cop at the right place at the right time to observe a transaction or pull over a car driven by a guy with warrants out. It's another thing entirely for an SOD tip to be the totality of probable cause, and for the police to lie to prosecutors or prosecutors lie to a judge about it. The latter case sounds much less likely to me, given the effort these slide decks show of LEOs trying to stay within the confines of the law (I don't happen to agree with where those confines are, but the evidence we have shows the DOJ paying at least lip service to it).
- smsm42 13y agoWith the tactics being top-secret I doubt there would be a lot of documented cases of it happening that could prove it exists - that would kind of defat the whole purpose of it being secret. It would probably take another Snowden to get any evidence on it.
- pessimizer 13y ago>It would probably take another Snowden to get any evidence on it. And I think that the possibility of another Snowden for this requires that there be some functioning mechanism by which requests to do this are centrally cleared, or even recorded, which I don't think is a sure thing. I see it just as likely that different agencies and departments within them are operating under a lot of different standing blanket orders in the form of legal interpretations, and that once a parallel construction is created, the records of any alternate explanation are destroyed (or were never created.)
- 13y ago
- MichaelGG 13y agoIf the 'tip' is "it sounds like my neighbor is gonna kill his girlfriend or something", and police enter and see contraband, is that admissible? Are "drug dogs" keyed to a specific substance? Is the cause given by a drug dog alert enough to conduct a general search and everything found admitted as evidence?
- pessimizer 13y agoAs far as I can tell, in parallel construction they use illegitimate cause or illegal evidence and ensuing investigations to construct a hypothetical way that they could have legitimately found cause or evidence, and then they lie and say that they did it the legal way. With SOD tips, they are getting tips from illegal sources and using them for cause, and simply lying and saying that they got the tip from somewhere else, like an anonymous informant, because there is no legal way they could have known. It's just a step away from hiring actors as witnesses, which I'm thinking is not very far away.
- Crito 13y agoAssuming the people they claim are the informants actually exist, and are not complete fabrications, then really the only difference between these 'informants' operating in this capacity and actors are what guilds they do or do not belong to.
- fleitz 13y agoWhy hire witnesses when you can get them for free by offering to reduce ridiculous sentences?
- tptacek 13y agoThese sound like identical processes. In both cases, it helps to be clear about terminology. You can't simply introduce evidence and conceal its source from a judge; that evidence would be excluded from trial. You also can't introduce evidence that chains back to excludable evidence. But the products of NSA/FBI fusion (or "SOD", or whatever you want to call it) are never introduced as evidence, either directly or as cause to authorize a search. That's why the process is called "parallel construction": it is the legal opinion of the DOJ that you can use excludable evidence as intelligence so long as you then build a case from probable cause (either for a warrant or arrest) that doesn't stem from that intelligence. In other words, you can exploit the NSA to put a detective in the right place at the right time. But the detective will need to observe you doing something that gives them probable cause for a search: you'll need to, say, do an open-air drug transaction, or get stopped for running a red light and then have drugs plainly visible in your car (or have a dog authorize the search, which is plainly problematic). The way parallel construction works, the information coming from parallel construction is never brought to court. This bothers criminal defense attorneys and civil rights advocates. It has never been the case that prosecutors are required to furnish all the information they collect on a suspect (though they are required to furnish any potentially exculpatory information, per Brady v. Maryland). But people opposed to parallel construction see this process as a bridge too far; one way to look at it would be that the whole process of discovering probable cause is something that a criminal defense can challenge, and so that whole process is potentially exculpatory. It's also helpful to know that parallel construction isn't a new thing. It's similar to the process that works when the FBI/DEA has a highly-placed informant in a criminal organization. They want to make cases from that CI, but they don't want to expose the CI, not least because they'll have more cases to make down the road.
- guelo 13y agoIt's the same thing. The article even says "The training document reviewed by Reuters refers to this process as "parallel construction.""