11 ms·
Why? What good would a strong Microsoft provide us? What void would that fill? We've been there, done that and frankly, I don't care to go back. They abused the
by taylodl 13y ago
Why? What good would a strong Microsoft provide us? What void would that fill? We've been there, done that and frankly, I don't care to go back. They abused their power when they had it and I have no intent of giving it back to them to give them another crack at it.
No, I much prefer today's world of Google, Apple, Samsung and FOSS in all its myriad forms battling it out. There's more developer frameworks than ever available to us. More languages. More everything.
No. I don't want to go back.
- romanovcode 13y ago.NET, C# and Visual Studio
- CmonDev 13y agoYes, the only reasonable alternative is Scala but there is no IDE for it to match VS and there won't be.
- streblo 13y agoIntelliJ IDEA is a really fantastic IDE for Scala/Java. I haven't used VS in ~6 years (and back then not deeply) so I don't have a great basis of comparison. But IntelliJ does a fantastic job and it's steadily improved over the years.
- romanovcode 13y agoYea, It's pretty good. But believe me - it has nothing on VS2013.
- frowaway001 13y agoI'm always surprised when C# developers think VS is the best thing ever. Having used multiple languages and technologies, I'm not even slightly impressed by VS.
- CmonDev 13y agoEveryone on HN used multiple languages and technologies. Have you used VS with ReSharper?
- vetinari 13y agoReSharper is being made by the same company, that makes IntelliJ IDEA. They're trying to bring the goodies _from_ IDEA _to_ VS.
- zequel 13y agoThen I don't think you've used VS much. Intellisense with tooltip comments, templates and code snippets. Most VS users haven't scratched the surface of its power. IntelliJ borrows a lot of the ideas from VS btw, their Resharper addon is excellent. I've also used XCode and Eclipse, they're poor men's versions of VS.
- mhast 13y agoEhhhhh... I've use VisualStudio every day for the past years. And honestly there are a lot ideas they could borrow from other tools like Eclipse. Some examples that I personally feel are ways that C# in VS is lackluster compared to Java in Eclipse. No proper automatic build. While the stuff in Eclipse is a bit too aggressive sometimes it's really one of those really cool features to have. Errors, warnings, other tools like StyleCop don't show errors inline with the code. I mean, really? I have to scroll through the error list and click? It also doesn't really seem to understand the code it's processing. I'd expect that when I'm working on Silverlight with C# that the premiere tool from Microsoft should be able to handle things like refactoring properties in C# where it would update automatically in XAML. And this is not even mentioning the complete trainwreck that is MSDN. Perhaps you can understand it once you really get into it, but I find it extremely confusing the way it mixes different frameworks with similar but subtly different functionality. (Eg a lot of things in Windows Phone are similar, but not identical, to features in .Net and trying to find the "chain of classes" that are relevant to your code is not nearly easy enough.) Some of these things are probably things you can fix with extensions like Reshaper. But in the end you'll pay hundreds of dollars to compete with something that is free in Eclipse.
- shmerl 13y agoNeither is very useful if you need to support many platforms. Microsoft it too entrenched in their walled garden mentality. Cross platform development never will be their strong side and it's their downfall.
- romanovcode 13y agoAgree. That's why it would be good if they brought multi-platform support sooner or later. Still doesn't change the fact that these techs are one of the best ever made.
- _random_ 13y agoIncorrect, Xamarin is currently the best option for multi-platform development and it has a good Visual Studio integration.
- romanovcode 13y agoJust imagine how fast it would become popular if you could host MVC5/WebApi on Linux.
- _random_ 13y agoTrue :(
- voltagex_ 13y agohttp://www.mono-project.com/Compatibility http://www.mono-project.com/Compatibility MVC4 would be blocked by: > MVC4 - Partial, no async features supported. > ASP.NET 4.5 Async Pipeline - Needs an parallel processing pipeline with async support, not done.
- itsboring 13y agoI switched to ServiceStack from WebApi just so I didn't have to develop on windows.
- shmerl 13y agoNot really. C++ is way better in cross platform coverage.
- cygwin98 13y agoI would prefer a strong Microsoft that keeps improving Bing and its web/mobile advertisement branch, which can counter-balance GOOG on web/mobile sphere. A GOOG with almost infinite cash flow from Ads would be as bad as MSFT in 90s. It's already the case that nowadays GOOG has become increasingly more arrogant.
- mathattack 13y agoI think Bing is a lost battle. The real question is what can they do on Azure, and can they move people to a cloud-based Office suite. On arrogance - this comes with size. The larger a company gets, the more internal stakeholders they have. What was once a simple, "Of course we'll change that" turns into "Who else is impacted to this change?" to "Let's only change what we need to, and not get distracted by everything else." My inclination is the more competitors, the better. But we don't necessarily need more standards. Creating another service provider for cloud based computing is great. Creating another browser that everyone needs to optimize their websites for separately - not so great.
- cygwin98 13y agoI think Bing is a lost battle. The real question is what can they do on Azure, and can they move people to a cloud-based Office suite. Bing is actually doing surprisingly well, considering the team competes with probably the most successful department and the foundation of GOOG. IMHO it's likely one of very few successful strategic moves of MSFT in competitive markets. Without Bing, GOOG would pretty much print money and pour money on whatever futuristic projects they feel like. Oh, well, they're already doing these stunts, it would only get worse without Bing. Azure and Office-in-the-cloud alone cannot compete with freebies backed by big pockets. Creating another browser that everyone needs to optimize their websites for separately - not so great. I agree on the pains caused by browser fragmentation, but I do think it's still a good thing to have IE especially the new versions around. The recent move of GOOG pushing for Dart is a dangerous sign that GOOG is starting to flex its muscle and do whatever they want. Mozilla alone stands no chance in such a challenge, in a same sense they couldn't in a battle against MSFT about 2 decades ago.
- bduerst 13y agoMicrosoft has a track record of not giving the user what they want, the opposite of which is what Google and Apple built their market share off of. The last thing we need is more UX failures like Windows 8 cluttering the market.
- glhaynes 13y agoI never want to see a Microsoft monopoly over "desktop computing" (hah, what an aged term!) again, but I'd definitely like to see their talent get to assert itself further than it currently is able to. Microsoft started as a development tools company and they're still pretty damn good at it. I hope the next decade allows that group to flourish at the very least.
- shmerl 13y ago> Microsoft started as a development tools company and they're still pretty damn good at it. Why are they so behind in C++11 support in their tools then? I think they are falling behind in their tools advantages already. With emergence of OpenGL debugger from Valve that will only escalate (at least on the gaming scene).
- ConceptJunkie 13y agoThat's ironic considered that Microsoft was ahead of the curve on C++03. They were the first, IIUC, to fully implement the standard, and were way ahead of the competition during the whole process. It wouldn't be unfair to call me a Microsoft "hater", but I've always had respect for their development tools, and especially their compilers. I'm doing a little Windows development these days, but it's on an ancient version of Visual Studio (2003) that can't be upgraded at this time, so I'm not familiar with the latest and greatest. I'm surprised to hear they are behind the curve here, although I'm not surprised to hear that anyone is having trouble implementing the amazingly complex stuff that was introduced in C++11.
- shmerl 13y agoThey are behind competition (gcc and clang). I doubt they can excuse it with the lack of resources, so I'm not sure why it is so. I don't really use their compilers so it doesn't bother me, I'm just pointing out the fact.
- wfraser 13y agoI think they're too distracted with the WinRT and its accompanying C++/CX silliness to properly focus on C++11. It feels like the 1st party platform got the priority in manpower.
- UVB-76 13y ago> They abused their power when they had it and I have no intent of giving it back to them to give them another crack at it. You're tarring more than 100,000 people with that brush, many of whom were not at Microsoft back then.
- dragonwriter 13y agoNo, just one (legal) person, the corporation called "Microsoft". He's not saying anything about any of the natural persons involved acting outside their roles in Microsoft. Corporate "goodwill" exists in negative forms as well, and Microsoft has acquired quite a bit over the years.
- sbilstein 13y agoCompany culture matters. Good people can be really disappointing under poor leadership.
- ZoFreX 13y agoIt's not Microsoft that was/is bad, it's having any single entity have too much power. In my opinion, right now, that is Google, and that's why we need a stronger someone - anyone. And Microsoft fit the bill.
- melling 13y agoDoesn't Microsoft have 90% of the desktop? About the same dominance in "Office apps", along with their proprietary formats keeping people uncomfortable using "compatible" software. That dominance is almost 2 decades old and it's quite hard to fix. When most people get a job, they're going to be using Microsoft because that's what they will be given. I've never been somewhere where I'm told which search engine to use. Most places still don't offer an alternative to IE in the work place. That's why developers are still coding to IE7. It really is frustrating that people don't understand this. I wouldn't mind a better Microsoft, except for the fact that people have short memories and don't really understand how powerful Microsoft currently is. Google is the the same ballpark? Seriously!?!
- krautjakob 13y agoWho ares about the market share or the desktop? Microsoft does not make significant new revenue from their installation base. Google however does with their platforms (web and mobile), so does Apple (on mobile mainly). I think it's very interesting to see an internal MS manager with a background in Bing and Azure to become CEO, interesting times are sure ahead.
- pdpi 13y agoTheir influence on desktop is slowly eroding, though, and the new battlefield is the internet.
- sdegutis 13y agoYep. I honestly could see the desktop being relegated to only scientists, programmers, IT, and possibly gamers, with mobile and tablet devices replacing it for nearly everyone else. This kinda makes me sad, seeing as I'm in the programmers group, and our fun toys (desktops) are starting to go away, but ultimately it's probably the right direction for society.
- YZF 13y agoReally? The world of Google and Apple (Samsung and FOSS aren't even a player) is a world of closed computing platforms where people can't control their own devices and can't and don't code for them. More languages? I don't think so. How many languages can you use to write apps for your iPhone or Android device? Objective C and Java respectively and that's about it. With Google not only do you not control your apps/device even your data isn't under your control any more. Yes, Microsoft's business practices weren't so great, but I don't agree the new world is much better. As a developer it actually feels worse. The only exception is Linux and server side development which is in a sense a niche (plus that existed before Google and Apple rose to their dominance and could have co-existed with Microsoft perfectly happily).
- taylodl 13y agoThere's lots of languages you can use to create iOS applications: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3949995/what-programming-languages-can-one-use-to-develop-iphone-ipod-touch-and-ipad-i http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3949995/what-programming-... Android allows you to freely deploy your applications to their devices, while iOS requires a little more work. In neither case do you have to go through their respective stores (I'm thinking enterprise/personal apps here). For commercial sales it's increasingly a moot point: consumers are purchasing apps through app stores regardless of platform. As a developer, I've never felt more free, less beholden to a corporate entity and their hidden agenda, and have an awesome stable of tools and technologies from which I can use to build solutions. It's almost gotten to the point where I have too much choice! And that's awesome!
- Crito 13y ago> "There's lots of languages you can use to create iOS applications: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3949995/what-programming-.. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3949995/what-programming-.... " Compared to truly open devices, and moderately open systems (even Windows or OSX), that is an absolute joke.
- angryasian 13y ago
- JonFish85 13y ago> They abused their power when they had it and I have no intent of giving it back to them to give them another crack at it. I feel like in some ways they were victims of their own success (Microsoft was). Building the core of an OS around a browser? At the time, a fairly novel idea, but really forward-looking. And I believe that's part of what brought about the massive anti-trust lawsuit.
- klipt 13y agoAs I understand it, the first version of the Microsoft Network (MSN) didn't allow general internet access at all - it was a completely proprietary walled garden, like the original AOL. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSN#MSN_Classic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSN#MSN_Classic