8 ms·
This article clearly elaborates that the author doesn't understand either the philosophy or ethics of libertarian (or actual free market) economics. From what I
by adventured 13y ago
This article clearly elaborates that the author doesn't understand either the philosophy or ethics of libertarian (or actual free market) economics. From what I can tell, the author may have not have even read cursory basics on Wikipedia about such.
This header:
"Google, Apple and other tech firms likely colluded to keep their workers' wages down." then concludes: "So much for that libertarian worldview"
That assumes incorrectly that willful collusion is somehow anti-free market, or anti-libertarian. The free market has absolutely no position on collusion, except that force may not enter into economic transactions. If two parties choose to collude to set prices, the free market has no opinion on the matter as such; if they set prices incorrectly in the process of judging the market, they will lose. That is basic free market ideology.
A free market doesn't outlaw or in any way forbid collusion. Nor is it considered immoral in laissez-faire doctrine to agree to freeze or suppress wages across an industry. The use of force (eg to prevent workers from leaving their job for a better paying one) to control workers would be considered immoral and illegal. Otherwise, it's the responsibility of the worker to pursue a job that properly compensates their talent, not the responsibility of the business owner to overpay the worker (and if the owner isn't properly compensating the worker, and that worker leaves, the owner loses).
As a response to wage collusion by business owners, in a free market workers also have the right to collude to attempt to inflate wages; owners also have a right to fire every single one of them in response. Whichever group judges correctly about their value proposition, wins.
One can then move on to debating the merits of laissez-faire Capitalism versus other systems; or libertarian ideology; or 19th century free market economics. The author however is far off base in understanding even where the conversation would begin.
- valtih1978 13y agoWe have a first libertarian to manipulate here. He even does not bother to read adn understand the basic idea exposed by the article. He thinks that we are children and keeps selling us the fraud.
- adventured 13y agoI never said I was a libertarian. What I explained is rudimentary free market doctrine. My ability to explain Stalinism doesn't automatically make me a Communist, either.
- valtih1978 13y agoThe fact that you can explain a doctrine does not render the criticism of that doctrine incorrect. Indecent attack on critique means that you use all means to defend a flawed doctrine, which implies you is a proponent of that flawed doctrine. The author obviously knows the reality, which stands behind the marvelous "free-market" fiction. He attacks this fiction. He says that self-correcting free-market fails to optimize itself since it kills itself by converging to monopoly. In the ideal free-market theory, you do not need the anti-monopoly law. But you have to use it in reality to mantain the free-market from collapse. It is clear what author says. He attacks this childish free-market fundamentalism. He makes a right point. You attack him without the reason and defend the flawed ideology, support spreading the wrong beliefs. How can I believe that you is not a libertarian?
- mason240 13y agoAn ironically childish and vapid response.
- ChristianMarks 13y agoNonsense. The free market ideologue lets the market solve all problems through the mechanism of price signals, and nothing else. Side deals in which one group systematically wins asymmetric zero-sum games against another group are excluded.
- jpttsn 13y agoAgain with this custom vocabulary. Why is it so important that you appear value-neutral?
- ChristianMarks 13y agoThe "appearance" isn't at issue. The question of capturing some phenomena conventionally characterized as normative (usually by philosophers who want to maintain a strict fact-value dichotomy) is of empirical interest. The positive content of "theft", "fraud" and "economic injustice" can be captured within game theory in repeated games, specifically in repeated asymmetric zero-sum games. The vocabulary is standard in the literature, even if game theorists tend to ignore such questions. My motive is to suggest, pace economists and philosophers who insist that such notions ought to be excluded from positive economics altogether, that they do contain significant positive economic content and I intend to say what that is.
- RivieraKid 13y agoExactly, wage fixing is fine in a free market, that directly follows from the definition of an unregulated market, every market participator is free to do any market decision they want. This is a nice example why free markets are not optimal, zero regulation is not the best amount of regulation.
- icebraining 13y agoThis collusion happened in a regulated market, though.
- nicolasp 13y agoThe market being regulated doesn't necessarily prevent collusion from happening, but makes it illegal when it does happen.
- icebraining 13y agoThe point is that we can't take a market with N regulations, see what happens with (N-1) regulations being followed, and then say "see, that's what would happen without any regulations!" Kill the regulations helping the capitalists, not just the ones giving a hand to the worker, and then we can talk.
- adventured 13y agoThe 19th century in the US is probably the largest data set when it comes to extremely low regulation markets. Hong Kong is a more recent example. The point being, there is a lot of actual real world data on each side of the fence.
- icebraining 13y agoWell, it depends on what you consider regulation. If you take a broader view, like Benjamin Tucker did, you'll see they were in fact very regulated.
- toyg 13y agoThe hypocrisy, it burns! So it's ok to exploit one's personal situation (family and financial commitments stopping one from moving to a location where the cartel is not in force, for example), but hey, no physical violence please, psychological one will do! There is a main difference between the two actors: employers own original capital, employees don't. The penalty for employers (losing some profit if all workers quit or get fired) is virtually nonexistent: limited-liability companies are set up with the explicit aim of exonerating capital owners from responsibility beyond the invested capital. You lose the company, you lose a bit of capital; but in most cases, there is more where that came from. Workers don't own original capital (which is why they are workers, after all). The penalty for them is much higher, they could lose their house and/or livelihood. Refusing to consider the fundamental imbalance of labor relationships is disingenuous at best. It's sad that we're still debating this same stuff in 2014.
- adventured 13y agoWho's debating anything here? Literally the only thing I did is relay what the actual ideology is, compared to what the author claimed it is. You reacted viscerally without any further consideration. I actually was careful to put in the last section to specifically try to prevent your type of response.
- jpttsn 13y agoThis seems more like a matter of opinion. What's hypocritical? > Refusing to consider the fundamental imbalance of labor relationships is disingenuous at best What makes it disingenuous? Isn't grandparent just disagreeing with some of your assumptions?
- cbsmith 13y ago> The hypocrisy, it burns! Sorry. Would you like a cool compress? ;-) > So it's ok to exploit one's personal situation (family and financial commitments stopping one from moving to a location where the cartel is not in force, for example), but hey, no physical violence please, psychological one will do! I don't know how to describe the ludicrousness of describing not cold calling someone as "psychological violence". In general though, I'm no libertarian, but I'm pretty sure they'd be the first to admit that the libertarian model is without exploitation, immorality, or evil. They'd just argue that the use of force to exert controls would invariably be a greater exploitation/immorality/evil. > employers own original capital At least with startups in the valley, they most certainly don't. To clarify: investors by definition are risking original capital, so they always own original capital... of course with a typical investment model, once they invest that capital, they no longer own said capital and in fact may no longer own any original capital. Employers are generally the businesses themselves, and so don't necessarily have original capital and statistically at least are disproportionately likely to either be in debt or at least have negative cash flow, particularly with startups. Employees on the other hand, have almost no capital at risk tied to their involvement in a venture beyond equity/warrants in the company. It is entirely possible (and particularly in the case of the tech industry, and particularly in the case of senior employees like those targeted by these practices) that they'd have original capital, and in fact in I think every case of the named companies they have opportunities to contribute original capital into their employer at better than market rates, as well as having sweat equity translated in to options or straight out equity/grants in their employer. So they are more than encouraged to have either original capital or at least the equivalent thereof. In short, the power dynamic you are implying as universal to the employer-employee relationship isn't universal and most importantly is a particular ill fit to the context in question. > employees don't At last with startups in the valley, that is far from necessarily true. > The penalty for employers (losing some profit if all workers quit or get fired) is virtually nonexistent: limited-liability companies are set up with the explicit aim of exonerating capital owners from responsibility beyond the invested capital. Yeah... but that limited liability is very hard to escape and often significantly outweighs the relative penalty for employees of quitting or getting fired. Again, at startups... most employees don't recoil in horror about the economic (psychological is a different matter) consequences of quitting or getting fired. > Workers don't own original capital (which is why they are workers, after all). Again, at a startup up, it'd be a huge assumption to think they are working there because they don't own original capital. > The penalty for them is much higher, they could lose their house and/or livelihood. Assuming there is demand from other employers, the penalty is almost 0. Particularly as a logical consequence of the hiring practices alluded to in the article, an engineer who is laid off is going to get snatched off the market almost immediately. In fact, they are likely to not even miss a single paycheck and could very well end up with a raise out of the whole thing. > Refusing to consider the fundamental imbalance of labor relationships is disingenuous at best. Refusing to consider the full impact of distortions on labor relationships is disingenuous at best. Engaging in a debate about this same stuff in 2014 without considering the market & economic realities that motivate these practices in the first place is beyond sad.
- bjourne 13y agoPerhaps in a theoretical sense. In a practical sense, it is always the same people who are in favor of free markets that are also in favor of anti-strike laws and wants to undermine unions. You can't have it both ways. Either you are in favor of free markets and then you keep your mouth shut when a powerful union puts a blockade on employers who refuse to allow collective bargaining or you are not.
- nickik 13y agoI dont care if there are unions, the problem I have is that when unions start to not allow other peoples to work for the employer. That has happen very often in history. Also the should be allowed to strik, but the employer should also be allowed to fire people who dont show up to work.
- chilldream 13y agoHonest question, why is it bad if a union becomes powerful enough to convince an employer to sign a contract forbidding them to hire non-union employees or fire during a strike? I can think of some answers, but none that can't also be applied to, say, usury laws which makes the average internet libertarian's position on unions feel hypocritical to me.
- nickik 13y agoI have no problem with such a contract. I only have problem with state granted power of such a thing.
- judk 13y agoHonest answer: because in many states, the law is that a certain vote can force that contract into place, not merely deprivation of labor by the pro-union segment. The reason for this is simple: government has power because it can use violence. Even democracy works because the majority uses threat of violence to get minority submission to law. (Otherwise, all we have is anarchy/consensus). When a non-near-100% majority of the labor force wants to unionize, it only works if had the power to use force-- its own, or the local/state/federal government. Otherwise, scabs will quite often undermine the union's bargaining position. Nowhere have I said that anyone's use of force is wrong! In the union debates, people often forget to ask: WHY is the use of force legitimate for the federal govt, but not for the labor pool for a factory? The answer is not obvious, the claim might not be true! "Because George Washington and Thomas Jefferson" is not a valid answer!
- mrow84 13y ago> The free market has absolutely no position on collusion, except that force may not enter into economic transactions. If two parties choose to collude to set prices, the free market has no opinion on the matter as such; if they set prices incorrectly in the process of judging the market, they will lose. That is basic free market ideology. I was under the impression that, to be allocatively efficient, market participants have to be 'price takers' (along with a bunch of other assumptions) - anything other than this creates an inefficient market. I also think it is incorrect to assume (even in theory) that this kind of market failure will always resolve itself by the price makers, i.e. those engaging in collusion, being priced out of the market. The alternative, which seems to me to be more likely (otherwise why would people collude?), is that the price makers capture an inefficiently large proportion of the market's productive output. In short, market theory absolutely does have a position on collusion - it leads to market failure.
- nickik 13y ago> I was under the impression that, to be allocatively efficient, market participants have to be 'price takers' (along with a bunch of other assumptions) - anything other than this creates an inefficient market. You should update your economic belives. Look at the 2002 Nobel Price by V. Smith for this one. > In short, market theory absolutely does have a position on collusion - it leads to market failure. The existence of market failure is no position. Just for the fact that there is market failure does not have any implication on what to do about it. No (almsot no) free market economys belvies that there is no market failure (however you want to define it). That is simply something that is often assert because it makes for good propaganda (makes it possible to laught at the idiot free market people without really listening to them). The question is not if the market is perfect, it is clearly not. The question is (a) can we do something about it, do we know enougth (b) given the power to do something about it, will the goverment actually do it, or will it use that power to do the oppiste. Now I would assert (hince my free market views) that both (a) and (b) have to be answer with 'most likly no'. We often do things because we think we can and it turns out that it also has tons of other effects that we did not wish for (law of unintended consequenses). Next even assuming that understand everything about some action, given the power is it not more likly that something else will be done. A quick glance at history clearly shows this, how often is a given regulation used to help buissnesses instead of people workers. Why do you think you coke is made out of mais sirup instead of cain sugar.