12 ms·
After Tyrone Hayes said that a chemical was harmful, its maker pursued him
- mathgladiator 13y agoWhat I want to know is this. How do people go to work, find out they need to _work_ to discredit someone, then try to go on about it. Coming from the tech world, I'm not even sure how this exactly works, and I wonder if I have rose tinted glasses for most of the "real world". For instance, are there meetings about who and how to discredit people?
- velik_m 13y agoI suspect it goes something like this: if we don't do it we will lose money and possibly our jobs. It's us or them, and for most people that is then not a difficult choice.
- pgeorgi 13y agoI doubt meetings start with "who do we discredit this week?". After all, a company might be unlucky and hired someone with a conscience (or more profane: the slides end up in court through discovery at some point). Make it "who are the main detractors and what is their agenda?" and you're fighting for a noble cause.
- netcan 13y agoRemember that people also go to work & find out who they need to kill this week, a lot of people. I don't think that fundamentally unsavory jobs have a particularly hard time recruiting. Corporate lawyers playing zero sum games, abusing the law (their own chosen profession) and doing other mean nasty ugly looking things have people lining up for the job while more ethical lawyering jobs have shortages
- pixl97 13y ago> I wonder if I have rose tinted glasses for most of the "real world". This depends on how you are defining the 'real world'. If you think of society as an ecosystem it should not surprise you that prey and predation occurs, as occurs in natural systems. In a natural system, if something is both possible and successful it is very likely to occur. As for jobs that the whole purpose is to discredit people, have not paid attention U.S. politics? Mudslinging is a very popular method of securing political victory. Many of our intelligence agencies are built on collecting just this kind of information.
- refurb 13y agoWhat if you believed the work in question unfairly demonized your product? What would you do then? Note that the EPA reviewed all the data in question and still determined that the risk did not outweigh the benefit. The article implies that industry owns the EPA, which I find a little surprising due to the power they can (and do) wield. Anyone else shocked at the number of studies the EPA reviewed and found didn't fit their definition of quality work? Wow, kind makes you wonder!
- lhc- 13y agoIt makes me wonder if, as the article stated, its possible that the standards they are looking for are only really possible by very expensive studies funded by the industries they are supposed to study. Then again, given all the other nasty business conducted by the pesticide company in this article, regulatory capture is probably not something they would attempt...
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoWelcome to the grand world of revolving doors and regulatory capture. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#United_States_examples http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#United_State...
- protomyth 13y ago"What if you believed the work in question unfairly demonized your product? What would you do then?" Yep, Don't assume the 'other' side is just being corrupt or greedy. They could have some true believers that think you are the crackpot and being dishonest or have your own greedy / ambition motive. Look at political discussions and how few false first stories are corrected if wrong. It gets worse if one or both sides believe "the end justifies the means".
- qubitcoder 13y agoThis is very common. After graduating, I spent the last six years doing consulting for various Fortune 500 pharmaceutical companies, working in some 20 countries with routine interaction with C-level execs and board members. These activities usually fall under the banner of 'change management and corporate communications', for which an entire army of specialists are brought in to 'manage' perceptions and ensure 'alignment' both inside & outside the organization. Specifically within the pharmaceutical industry, it's not at all unusual for clinical trial data to be misrepresented. Even worse, in second and third world countries with lax regulations, drug testing is conducted on a massive scale - often sickening and sometimes killing the most vulnerable. Just Google 'third world drug testing'. So I'm often a little surprised at the anti-regulatory tone on this board. I agree that some regulations are detrimental to innovation (e.g. the resistance to Uber). But the real world is far less rosy and idealistic than our beloved startups. I couldn't in good conscience be associated with this type of unethical behavior. So I decided to leave that world behind. Ever since, I've been diligently diving into various programming languages, design patters, and frameworks. Best decision ever. I can't wait to get back into the software development world!
- TempleOSV2 13y agoGod is perfectly just. C:\TAD\Text\BIBLE.TXT ighteth to honour. 6:10 Then the king said to Haman, Make haste, and take the apparel and the horse, as thou hast said, and do even so to Mordecai the Jew, that sitteth at the king's gate: let nothing fail of all that thou hast spoken. 6:11 Then took Haman the apparel and the horse, and arrayed Mordecai, and brought him on horseback through the street of the city, and proclaimed before him, Thus shall it be done unto the man whom the king delighteth to honour. 6:12 And Mordecai came again to the king's ---- God says... hold estimation exiled fragment obeys kindle glance Whereas grass lines corruptly enacted Triers die- external arrange formed faultfinders sitting regarding bier lover text head hart hurrying avoided MADE tomorrow sorrowed conflict Dominions wherewith announced subordinate manhood lifter oftentimes donations inclined release dissolution 'knock Latins pearl spent deepness loathed vail Some call would defender correspondence YOU apparel -If fluently moderation journey wearing empty fluctuating notorious blew
- sdegutis 13y ago> wrote that the company could “prevent citing of TH data by revealing him as noncredible.” > looked for ways to “exploit Hayes’ faults/problems.” > “If TH involved in scandal, enviros will drop him,” Heh, I thought corporations being this unethical and immoral was only a movies thing, not something that actually happens. > She wrote, “What’s motivating Hayes?—basic question.” Wow. So, it's not malice, it's genuine curiosity? This company literally did not understand basic ethics?
- wisty 13y agoThere's been a study in which role players consistently voted to keep a drug that was killing people on the market, to prop up the company's bottom line: http://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1139&context=marketing_papers http://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1139... It's quite similar to the Milgram experiment, in a way.
- mikeash 13y agoCorporations aren't really immoral, just amoral. If a human bit the head off a live baby seal, we'd probably call that evil. But when a polar bear does it, it's just the nature of the polar bear. It operates on instinct. Most corporations only care about their bottom line. Even if the individuals within them are moral, the structure tends to cancel that out. They are built to seek profit. If they obey the law, it is only because obeying the law maximizes profit. If they are moral, it is only because morality maximizes profit. On the other hand, if breaking the law maximizes profit (e.g. because enforcement is lax or penalties are low) then that's what they'll do. Likewise, if immoral acts make the most money, that's what they'll do. What Hollywood gets wrong is that corporations aren't intentionally evil. There's no CEO sitting in his office laughing maniacally about how his new project is going to kill widows and orphans. Hollywood always wants a villain, but in this case there isn't one. Villainy falls out of the corporate structure and lots of employees just doing their jobs to keep bread on the table. This is far from an isolated example, of course. Discrediting or destroying whistleblowers is what just about any corporation will do and has done, as long as they think the positives outweigh the negatives on next quarter's earnings statement.
- siliconc0w 13y agoOne thing that I have been saying for years is that google is a dichotomy. Google claims that their intention is to organize and show the most objectively relevant content as possible and yet all their income is from advertising which is a completely different objective. It's offering up relevance to the highest bidder. This can work in certain circumstances (if I'm willing pay more for a search term than anyone else I likely have relevant content) but it is far from the promise of objectivity. To wit: The P.R. team suggested that the company “purchase ‘Tyrone Hayes’ as a search word on the internet, so that any time someone searches for Tyrone’s material, the first thing they see is our material.” The proposal was later expanded to include the phrases “amphibian hayes,” “atrazine frogs,” and “frog feminization.” (Searching online for “Tyrone Hayes” now brings up an advertisement that says, “Tyrone Hayes Not Credible.”) Is everyone really cool with the premier organizer of information being so easily bribed(through a fucking API) to essentially lie to it's users.
- md224 13y agoI've been pondering the ethics of AdWords for a while... I can maybe understand how tech people perceive ads as this "black box thing" that they can just tune out of their vision, and therefore assume that ads aren't a problem. But I do think there may be something inherently problematic about it. If we drop this "invincibility-to-advertising" assumption and look at the facts: the largest information search engine in the world displays a portion of results whose presence and salience on the page is determined, in part, by how much someone was willing to pay. That seems a little weird to me.
- siliconc0w 13y agoWorse, all their art and technology goes into knowing what the most relevant results are and yet they promote the sponsored result instead. It's one thing to point me to a potentially inferior washing machine but even when the search is about a potentially dangerous chemical in wide use throughout the US they point users to information they know to be less relevant. And they do it for money. How is this not clearly acting against the public good? This isn't "weird" - this is plain dishonesty and immoral by pretty much any standard. Just because it's a web application doing it shouldn't change anything. For now, we're in the technological twilight where it's somewhat foreseeable someone could challenge Google but when they increasingly control both the client and the server -the ability to ad block will go away and the 'sponsored' links will be more difficult to ignore (their business essentially depends on it). The technology (patents/software/hardware/expertise) required to parse the increasingly unwieldy stream of information that describes this world will be held by a single entity - one whose revenue is the open betrayal it's user's interests. Whats fucked up is it's probably more expensive to mislead me about the washing machine. I feel like there should at least be a fee of some sort. They could use geolocation to see if the user is in an affected area and apply a surcharge of charge, say 40%, for the privilege of manipulating evidence of dangerous chemicals in a user's environment.
- r0h1n 13y agoWow. If there was one article you had to read to understand how large corporations systematically and unethically try to vilify their critics to shift focus from their own dangerous behaviours, this is it! Just a few of the things Syngenta turned out to be doing: 1. paying for detailed sychological profiles of critics, including weaknesses (“grew up in world (S.C.) that wouldn’t accept him,” “needs adulation,” “doesn’t sleep,” was “scarred for life,” "investigate wife") 2. paying others to not just discredit Hayes' work, but to make him look "as foolish as possible" 3. putting together a team of over 100 people, including 25 professors, to act as "spokespeople on Hayes" 4. buying Google keywords for his name and variants to astroturf people searching for him. Searching Google for "Tyrone Hayes" brings up "Tyrone Hayes Not Credible" 5. getting paid scientists to write op-eds accusing Hayes of being a "junk scientist" 6. leaning on universities (Nicholas School of the Environment, at Duke) so they wouldn't hire Hayes 7. trying to get Hayes to bait himself (“set trap to entice him to sue,”) 8. sending sock puppets to Hayes' talks whose job was to only ask him the same embarrassing questions (“everywhere Tyrone went there was this guy asking questions that made a mockery of him. We called him the Axe Man.”) There's so much more in the article that this could become either (a) a primer for scientists and critics to understand how corporations target them, or (b) a ready reckoner for corporations on what tactics to use to smear opponents.
- cinskiy 13y agoSearching Duck Duck Go on the contrary, gives credible results as Wiki page and his own anti-atrazine website
- jval 13y agoThis is the reason why I feed DDG all my data, even if I'm going to use their !g function to do a Google search anyway. A monopoly on search is a monopoly on the truth.
- r0h1n 13y agoI'm curious when you say you feed DDG all your data. What does that include? Also, instead of allowing competitors access to your data, what would you lose by denying everyone access to it?
- stuaxo 13y agoNice article, could probably have been a bit shorter, but I guess that is the new yorker.
- throwwit 13y agoTry Text-to-speech... the best multitasking trick.
- matthewmcg 13y agoYes, the voicedream app + instapaper is great for listening to these articles while you walk around.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI tend to lean the other way, I hate the trend for shorter articles. Usually, there isn't enough room in a short article, unless it is about something really simple and minor, to actually look at something properly, so you just end up with a woolly impression of the subject, that has often been rendered totally inaccurate by the requirements of brevity.
- slowmotiony 13y agoWait, so the use of atrazine is still legal in the US?
- merrua 13y agoYep and its banned in the EU. http://www.toxipedia.org/display/toxipedia/Atrazine+Regulation+in+Europe+and+the+United+States http://www.toxipedia.org/display/toxipedia/Atrazine+Regulati...
- altero 13y agoI hate to be that guy. But this reminds me hysteria around DDT, now it is estimated that DDT ban is responsible for 20M deaths due to malaria. But how strong is link between that chemical and negative effects? This guy works on this for 15 years, other confirm his result. But there is no lawsuit or anything which requires strong evidence. Also the lethal dosage is 3 grams/kg for rats, that is far from poisoning. In EU it was banned not because of toxicity, but because it degrades slowly in ground waters.
- tinco 13y agoThat's a very important thing to say. In any such case a risks/returns analysis must be made. I think it's too simple to just blame the ban on DDT for 20 million malaria deaths, the reasons for dying of malaria are plenty, some within the control of the western world. But within the context of the article, directly banning azantine could have some negative effects as well, it's not clear why those farmers who use it don't use the Monsanto product instead. That also raises an interesting question. If Monsanto really does have a directly competing product, why didn't Monsanto come to the aid of Hayes? Not that I'm super liberal or something, but that would be proper capitalism wouldn't it?
- altero 13y agoOne of the links says that EU use Monsanto product instead, because it degrades much faster, but it is much less tested than azantine.
- marvin 13y agoThat's a moot point. Science isn't about banning dangerous chemicals. It is about providing politicians the facts they need to make an educated decision regarding whether a chemical should be banned or not. This is simply another another example of a long tradition of standing behind scientists when their findings agree with you, only to shun, ignore and discredit them when their findings are inconvenient. Tobacco, DDT, asbestos, deep sea diving, global warming. Science rarely cares about what to do. It's only about finding out what is true. If politicians read Haynes's research and concludes that this is an acceptable tradeoff, there's no problem. If they are unaware of Haynes's research and make a decision on incorrect assumptions, that is a problem.
- sizzle 13y agoWOW, I am subscribing to the New Yorker, this kind of journalism is refreshing.
- ansgri 13y agoHow could you know without extensive investigation on your own that it wasn't sponsored by some other biased group?) No, really, when you have believed any similar article, it seems unreasonable to expect truth of any journalism and science (which has now become a form of journalism since the only visible effect is articles being published).
- tim333 13y agoEven if it was sponsored by some biased group it provides a lot of information as to what was going on and then you can judge who you believe. Bit like the adversarial court system where both sides put their case. Without the New Yorker article there would not have been someone putting Hayes case as well. Syngenta can now reply and say why it's all rubbish if they are so inclined.
- dba7dba 13y ago> Syngenta can now reply and say why it's all rubbish if they are so inclined. I would love to see Syngenta's response. The facts were supposedly from INTERNAL memos of Syngenta. Will Syngenta sue New Yorker for lying and defamation?
- saturdaysaint 13y agoAnd I'd say this is just typical of the quality you'd find in an average New Yorker feature. Also, they have a reputation for having the most rigorous fact checking process in journalism.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoGoogling "Tyrone Hayes" now shows an ad titled, Atrazine and Hayes - Academics Question Tyrone Hayes' Work. The ad links to the "official sounding" http://academicsreview.org/ http://academicsreview.org/. That domain is privately registered by proxy and there is no information on the site itself regarding ownership. There are, however, clearly industry-supportive, but unattributed articles on a variety of topics, in addition to Mr. Hayes. Not sure if those were added for "credibility" or actually used in separate campaigns. This stuff is straight out ouf Hollywood, and it's the reason conspiracy theories thrive. Sometimes, and perhaps more often than we think, there really are people out to mislead us for their own gain.
- tveita 13y agoFor what it's worth, I see no ads in the search right now, and a Wikipedia blurb saying "Tyrone B. Hayes is an American biologist at University of California, Berkeley. He is known for his research demonstrating that the herbicide atrazine is a potent endocrine disruptor that demasculinizes and feminizes frogs." A slight aside: "People also search for" contains Steven Milloy. His name autocompletes to "steven milloy is an idiot".
- unclebucknasty 13y agoYeah, looks like the "Tyrone Hayes Not Credible" ad from the article is back in circulation for me. Maybe HNers exhausted the budget for the other one. This ad links to http://agsense.org/atrazine-alarmists/tyrone-hayes/ http://agsense.org/atrazine-alarmists/tyrone-hayes/ where the tagline is "Where farmers explain the real benefits of atrazine for healthy crops and healthy land". Awesome. Makes me want to drink an ice cold glass of it. Their page on Mr. Hayes leads off with an ad hominem attack: http://agsense.org/atrazine-alarmists/tyrone-hayes/ http://agsense.org/atrazine-alarmists/tyrone-hayes/
- raphman 13y agoThanks. The founders of this site [1] are not anonymous, however, but a professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and a lecturer at the University of Melbourne. Definitely a strange site containing quite crude ad hominem attacks on researchers [2]. The founders seem to be very outspoken about the benefits of genetically modified organisms, too, as Google searches indicate. [1] http://academicsreview.org/about-academic-review/founders/ http://academicsreview.org/about-academic-review/founders/ [2] http://academicsreview.org/reviewed-individuals/ http://academicsreview.org/reviewed-individuals/
- mschuster91 13y agoThis article should be manually pinned to the top of the first page.
- timje1 13y agoThe articles for which this statement is true often end up there for a day or two. The system works :)
- tehwalrus 13y agoThe privatisation of science (pesticides, medicine, etc) will always lead to these types of conflict of interest. If the objective is to find The Truth, then a profit motive can be very damaging. It is why pharmacology in its current form is very badly flawed, among other endeavors.
- seanhandley 13y agoWhy is the article dated February 10th 2014 ? Did this come from the future?
- alina24 13y agoIts a weekly magazine,this article being in the next week's print edition.
- askew 13y agoI'm getting a Michael Clayton-esque vibe from this whole story.
- lazyant 13y agoWhat I found most disturbing is how EPA works. They accept only research that passes a bar that was lobbied by the industry and that only industry can pay. Even if they accepted negative research about a product then they do a risk assessment to see how many deformed babies are affordable given the dollars the industry would lose.
- brohee 13y agoThe PR damage control team is pulling extra hours, I just got an atrazine advert reading another unrelated New Yorker article. And certainly nothing would indicate I would be interested in any agricultural product...
- mynewwork 13y agoIsn't that just very basic web-tracking and ad targeting? Somewhere an ad-server is keeping track of keywords your browser is associated with and now atrazine is in your list.
- jfc 13y agoWhile reading this, I wondered if there is a startup focused on crowdfunding research. A quick Google search brought up Microryza.com, an online crowdfunding platform for researchers. This type of funding might end up being really useful for scientists in the future, in light of corporate shenanigans and diminishing government funding.
- dba7dba 13y ago12 billion dollars a year. There's your answer.
- apw 13y agoWhat prevents some enterprising high school student from purchasing some Atrazine off Amazon.com, catching a few hundred tadpoles from their local pond, and doing their own study?
- raphman 13y agoThe internal Syngenta documents the article talks about can be found at http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Portal:Atrazine_Exposed http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Portal:Atrazine_Exposed Exhibit 19 is a scan of Sherry Ford's notes on Syngenta's FUD strategy.
- ott2 13y agoThe takeaway of the article seems to be: when fighting limited-liability companies, being irrational is a good tactic. It is sad if guerilla warfare is the only option left when fighting corporate actions one disagrees with.