16 ms·
Confessions of an ex-TSA agent
- rosser 13y ago“I’m not trying to tread upon your First Amendment rights,” she said. “All I’m saying is: Couldn’t you have run those First Amendment rights past the legal department first?” Welcome to modern America.
- MBCook 13y agoThat was the most Orwellian sentence I've read in years.
- mbreese 13y agoYou have a First Amendment right to speech. You don't have a right to a government job. It's hardly Orwellian. If you self-identify as a government employee, then it is reasonable to assume that someone might take what you say as government policy. Had he not said he was a TSA employee first, there would have been no issue at all.
- malandrew 13y agoBut if someone first says they are a government employee and then immediately follows that disclosure with "That being said, all of what I'm about to say represents my opinions and my observations and in no way should be interpreted as the official position or policy of the agency that I work for", it should all be kosher and protected under free speech, no?
- hueving 13y agoFree speech does not guarantee employment.
- pyre 13y agoIf free speech costs you your job, is it really "free?" /snark ;-)
- hueving 13y agoYes. The point is that you can do it as much as you want without restriction from anyone. Whether or not that restricts your employment is irrelevant to the first amendment.
- watwut 13y agoOf course not. Unless you live in economic boom or are rich. If government employee can not voice his opinions on politics without fear of being fired, his free speech rights are pure theory. Theoretically he has it, practically he does not dare to use them. It just give the government ability to yell "we guarantee freedom of speech" without really giving it.
- argumentum 13y ago> You have a First Amendment right to speech. You don't have a right to a government job. It's hardly Orwellian. It's not "Orwellian" (the term doesn't make sense here), however what would you say if the TSA fired someone because he was a muslim, for example. I doubt the following: ""You have a First Amendment right to follow any or no religion. You don't have a right to a government job"" > If you self-identify as a government employee, then it is reasonable to assume that someone might take what you say as government policy. No, that's ridiculous. If someone says, "I work at the TSA, and the official policy is X", then perhaps it's "reasonable". Also, had he not identified himself as a TSA employee, none of what he said would make any sense: he was describing his experiences as a TSA employee.
- jdminhbg 13y ago> "You have a First Amendment right to follow any or no religion. You don't have a right to a government job" Actually, that's built directly into the constitution, so the First Amendment doesn't enter into it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Religious_Test_Clause http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Religious_Test_Clause
- lsc 13y ago>If you self-identify as a government employee, then it is reasonable to assume that someone might take what you say as government policy I disagree. Especially when you are at the bottom of the chain of command. Would you expect a Starbucks barista, when speaking in an off-hours context, to speak for Starbucks? "I work at starbucks, but I don't think their coffee is particularly good, and my boss is an asshole." No. That's clearly the private opinion and gripes of a grunt. Now, if said barista said that on national TV, sure, they'd get fired. But nobody would be mislead into thinking that the Starbucks official message was "our coffee is bad and our supervisors are assholes" The expectation that a grunt will stay 'on message' on personal time is... pretty goddamn silly, if you ask me. I mean, sure, if a grunt goes counter-message at a company that demands slavish obedience, you are going to get fired. Hell, if you go off-message in a public enough way, and embarrass your bosses enough, especially if you reveal real weaknesses in the system you are a part of, as this person did, you are going to get fired about anywhere. I'm not making moral judgments about that; it's just the way it is. But, going "off message" on your personal time and embarrassing your bosses, while it might get you fired, is not in any way misleading to the public. Especially when you are just a grunt.
- mbreese 13y agoBut the main point is that the government didn't force him into silence. There was no First Amendment issue here. It was an employee/employer issue, not a citizen vs gov't issue.
- lsc 13y agoI don't disagree, as written... though the guy did seem to fear being put on lists and harassed. To the extent that you think that fear is justified, this would be a first amendment issue. But as written, it doesn't sound like there has been retaliation. I was just taking issue with this idea that a reasonable person would think that a grunt speaking off-hours was speaking for the corporation or government that employs them. (I also have pretty strong feelings that complaining about your boss to people who aren't your boss is a reasonable sort of thing to do... and maybe even a fundamental human need. But that's not really relevant to the discussion at hand.)
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>You have a First Amendment right to speech. You don't have a right to a government job. It's hardly Orwellian. That's not how it works. Freedom of speech means you can say whatever you want without fear of being prosecuted by the government. And if firing the employee is not prosecuting them, what is?
- voxic11 13y agoSo what do you think the solution should be. Can government employees pretend to represent the government when they haven't actually been authorized to?
- enraged_camel 13y agoNo one is "pretending to represent the government." He simply said he works for the TSA. As an employee at the lowest level, the last thing he is doing is representing the organization's policy or philosophy.
- sliverstorm 13y agoif firing the employee is not prosecuting them, what is? Well, how about something like: pros·e·cute (verb) law : to hold a trial against a person who is accused of a crime to see if that person is guilty -- Merriam-Webster
- enraged_camel 13y agoI was using the term "prosecute" figuratively. But thank you for your pedantry. Sometimes I forget I'm on HN and comments like yours remind me again.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIt's hardly pedantry when it comes to legal documents... The first amendment does not protect against figurative prosecution, at least to my knowledge, so your premise is off. I realize you probably feel the actual text of the first amendment is needless pedantry, but what it actually says is congress shall pass no law...
- Intermernet 13y agoSerious question, looking for actual precedents: If you become a government employee, do you sacrifice any constitutional rights? Can there be a clause or contract in any situation that removes your rights as a citizen, or do you cease to be a citizen when employed by the US government?
- alistairSH 13y agoMaybe. Members of the US military generally enjoy the same rights and protections as civilians, but there are limits on their speech and they are subject to different laws/regulations (UCMJ). Military officers in the US are barred from speaking contemptuous words against the President and VP. (article 88 UCMJ). There is a parallel article that applies to enlisted members. Calling the Pres a "fascist pig" is a no-no. Army regulation 600-20 limits members ability to campaign on behalf of candidates for public office and partisan political causes. I'm not aware of anything like this that applies to civilian government employees.
- maxcan 13y agoguess you don't read much
- ptbello 13y agoIt cites a "legal department", which is probably enough to make it pretty Kafkian as well
- MBCook 13y agoYou're right, kafkaesque may fit better.
- baddox 13y agoIt's hardly even a modern phenomenon.
- anigbrowl 13y agoAs usual, the issue is quite a bit more complex than presented here. In modern America, government employees' free-speech rights are broader than they used to be, not narrower. The underlying principle here is that when you identify yourself as a government employee, you are in some sense speaking on behalf of the government, and as your employer the government has an interest in regulating the speech of its officers, not least to ensure an accurate reflection of its legal position. The author would [edit: probably - I haven't checked] have been perfectly at liberty to express the same viewpoint without self-identifying as a TSA official. A century ago this would have been an open-and-shut case...in favor of the government. http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/publicemployees.htm http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/publice...
- sliverstorm 13y agoRight, this is in the same bucket as the disclaimers on TV, e.g. the following in no way represents the viewpoints of this station. You as a person have more free speech than you as a representative of your employer.
- rosser 13y agoBut he's not acting as a representative of the TSA. He's not speaking for them; he's speaking for himself — for all of us, really — as someone who has seen their practices, many of them controversial, from an insider's perspective. That's an invaluable (and otherwise largely unavailable, or at best, irredeemably subject to spin) contribution to the dialogue we, as a society, should be having about the TSA's form and function. Muzzling him a priori because he happens to have that perspective does disservice to everyone, including the TSA.
- anigbrowl 13y agoSure, but nobody's saying that he shouldn't critique the agency as an ex-employee. That's totally legit.
- ama729 13y ago
- jff 13y agoAs another poster pointed out, it's different when you work for the government. If you have a clearance, you need to be careful about reading the news at work lest you open one of Snowden's classified slides on an unclassified workstation.
- tn13 13y agoShe clearly has a point there. When a person identifies himself as TSA employee he is using TSA brand to say something that is his personal opinion. I dont think TSA can prevent him expressing his own opinion, they have all the right to prevent him from using the word TSA whenever he speaks.
- seanhandley 13y agoYou understand a person's message from all of the words they use, not just individual words. And if you think it's acceptable to prevent someone from using an individua word, you don't really understand why we have the concept of "free speech". It's clear and in context that his account is reflective of his experience and his values. Asking him not to say "TSA" would nullify the very reason for him wishing to speak out and give rise to either a toothless account or one which obviously implicated the TSA because nobody else handles airport security in the US.
- Silhouette 13y agoI dont think TSA can prevent him expressing his own opinion, they have all the right to prevent him from using the word TSA whenever he speaks. So he can speak, just as long as he doesn't provide any verifiable credentials that might actually make him credible? There is a difference between speaking for the TSA, or any other employer, and merely speaking personally as someone with personal experience of the TSA, or any other employer. It's reasonable to prohibit anyone from falsely claiming to represent someone else when expressing a personal view. As a general rule, I don't think it's reasonable to prevent them from making factually accurate claims about employment that support their own authenticity when speaking personally. There probably needs to be an exception to that if there really is a genuine reason to avoid identifying an individual as part of a certain organisation for security reasons. However, given the tendency of governments to exaggerate "national security" and similar arguments, it would have to be a pretty compelling case and I would suggest that employees should have to be notified of it in advance so it could be properly challenged. In any case, it's hard to see how any of this would apply to a typical front-line TSA employee.
- pdonis 13y ago
- benched 13y agoAnd how eager are those responding to this comment to use their analytic understanding of the world to apologize for and rationalize the position of government or other heavyweight institutions? Cookies all around for being so smart - while you give away your power to institutions that don't give one fuck about you. All I can imagine are a line of poindexters pushing their glasses up on their nose, saying, "Well, actually, an informed reading of the constitution reveals that you are a peon, which is actually as it should be..."
- smsm42 13y agoAt least in US they are still scared of the First Amendment. In UK, for example, they just say "You've had your debate. There's no need to write any more."
- ck2 13y agoIt's interesting how they mostly got a pass this past holiday travel season. Barely saw anything about them. So even the media is looking the other way now.
- jonknee 13y agoWhy would it be a big story? It has been a dozen years.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- silencio 13y agoI feel like TSA is relaxing some of the security measures, just a bit - perhaps so there is no major media outrage so people will still trust them. Here and there there have been times my fiancé has not been made to take everything off and get a patdown. Scanners feel like they're decreasing in number so you can at least try to pick the metal detector lines again. That might just be me with my TSA PreCheck and recent international non-US-destined flying talking though. Protip: fly business/first class or be part of PreCheck and revel in the pre-9/11 style of security. You know, the one where I wore all my jewelry, a sweater, and my boots through the metal detector, set it off, and the TSA agent just waved me through with a smile. Where I also didn't empty my water bottle or unpack anything at all - in fact, told not to even think about unpacking. Oh I feel so safe!
- jonhohle 13y agoMy typical airports have completely eliminated metal detector only lines except for Pre✓™. Pre✓™ seems like extortion - I have a passport, DHS has my fingerprints (for unrelated reasons). Why should I jump through additional hoops, and give them more money for something that they've already collected from me? If they really wanted to know if I was a flight risk, wouldn't they have already used all of the information they already know about me? If not, why!?
- jff 13y agoIt may just be profiling since I'm a middle-class white male, but I've been waved into the pre-check line several times despite flying coach and not signing up for anything special. Shoes on, drop your stuff on the conveyor belt and move along. It was great. That's how security should be all the time. It might not be solely profiling, because my girlfriend, who is clearly Indian, has also been sent into the precheck line when flying alone. Even in the regular lines, I can't think of the last time it took more than 15 minutes to get through security, and I usually opt out every time too.
- malandrew 13y agoI really wish more people in government had the gumption that this agent has to speak out about how public trust is being abused. On a different not, I'm certain that I'm not the only one who read the Selectee Passport List in the voice of Yakko, Wakko and Dot.
- rmchugh 13y agonew hero! and his book seems like it will be good: http://playbooknovel.com/ http://playbooknovel.com/
- gavinpc 13y agoA bad job is never wasted on a good writer.
- thorntonbf 13y agoThis quote has had me thinking all morning: "The thought nagged at me that I was enabling the same government-sanctioned bigotry my father had fought so hard to escape."
- nostromo 13y agoOn The Media has been running an initiative to get lawmakers to answer basic questions about TSA and DHS policy. The agency has been stonewalling reporters so they've asked that citizens call lawmakers directly and ask a series of questions. http://project.wnyc.org/otm-detain/ http://project.wnyc.org/otm-detain/
- tptacek 13y agoCool! Has anyone here done this?
- larrys 13y agoI'm normally not a fan of that type of thing. To me it's like a ddos attack on the phone system. Edit: ddos attack on the phone system of the legislators. Nothing wrong with calling. But enabling people to call en masse without even the friction of having to look up a phone number (which is easy for sure) for the purpose of helping the media do their job just doesn't work for me. Has nothing to do with whether the questions need to be answered or not. But potentially overloading a representatives phone system is not the way I think it should be done. (5 people calling a day is not overloading so of course I'm assuming that this would result in more activity). Now of course considering how much people don't like spam and junk mail (which are really way less intrusive en masse than the phone ringing) I'm curious why people are disagreeing with my basic point.
- rosser 13y agoTreat it instead as a DDoS attack on your congresscritters' bad ideas.
- magicalist 13y agoI'm not even sure what this means. Calling your elected representative is one of the most effective ways of getting issues confronted (as long as you're joined by hundreds of others calling). An actual calling human (as opposed to an email) is important here, as we're a lot easier to ignore when we're abstracted behind text (see: greater internet fuckwad theory, etc). People underestimate the humanness of elected officials. The mere perception that there's a groundswell of support for something is often enough to get someone moving on something, or at least thinking about it. "We need to head this off before it becomes a bigger deal" is your ally, as it's so hard to tell what will become a bigger deal, it makes that perception hard to ignore. That's why political "scandals"--often so inane and often stupidly inconsequential--can have such a big impact: that perception of pressure brought about by the media or interest groups or whatever, sustained long enough, can reify itself through the actions that people think they have to start making to save face, fix the situation, capture the press cycle, etc.
- jarrett 13y agoDo government employees enjoy full protection from the First Amendment? It's not a simple yes or no answer. Whether a given utterance is protected depends on a variety of factors, but probably the most important one for low-ranking TSA employees is that the speech must be of public concern to be protected. I suspect that a front-lines TSA officer who writes a letter to the editor about the TSA would be entitled to First Amendment protection, per Pickering v Board of Education. Here's a bit more info, with summaries of relevant cases: http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/publicemployees.htm http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/publice...
- anigbrowl 13y agoOh snap, I just posted that same link ;) I do urge participants to look into this, because the 'bill of rights > everything else' viewpoint frequently expressed on HN (and the US internet in general) is both fairly recent and misguided in that it implicitly assumes a two-tier constitution.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- EpicEng 13y agoWhy we don't take a page out of the Israeli's book is beyond me. They have been dealing with this for much longer, have made the mistakes we are currently making, and have learned from them. Their airports don't have long lines and pat downs by ill-trained employees (lines of course exist, but they are shorter and not what we in the US are used to). Instead they hire fewer, educated and skilled persons, many of whom are, behaviorists to determine potential threats. It works; the last successful airport attack in Israel was in 1986, and they have prevented many since. I remember reading about this in an interview with an ex Israeli defense minister years ago, but I couldn't find that article. This one sums it up though: http://www.cnn.com/2010/OPINION/01/11/yeffet.air.security.israel/ http://www.cnn.com/2010/OPINION/01/11/yeffet.air.security.is...
- refurb 13y agoThe profiling the Israelis do would never fly in the US. Plus, all it would take is a few media reports about people missing or not being allowed on a flight and the system would come crashing down. From what I've read, the Israeli system basically works like this:"if I'm not convinced I'm getting the entire truth, we're going to keep doing this until I do, plane leaving or not".
- EpicEng 13y agoWell, I'm not saying we just copy what they do blindly. The situations are different. That doesn't mean we couldn't employee some of their tactics. Particularly, I've always liked the idea of trained personal (behaviorists) who have a quick chat with every passenger while doing away with much of the security dog and pony show.
- refurb 13y agoI think the problem is that the most effective techniques used by the Israelis are the ones that wouldn't fly here in the US. However, I'm sure the TSA reached out them for information on other things.
- lisper 13y ago
- yogo 13y agoCode red alfalfa. Ok that was a little redundant :)
- RationPhantoms 13y agoCode red alfalfa hot papa. THAT was the as redundant as full body scanner pat down security check anal probe passport sweep.
- siculars 13y agoFrom the why-anonymity-is-important department. Truth will out.
- Intlrnt 13y agoI wasn't a bit surprised to read any of this. Even the candor with which the author shows himself to actively and tacitly promote and sustain the unprofessional and compromising conduct in which he and his colleagues engaged. I'm not sure if that transparency is due to his arrogance, or ignorance of how much he contributed to the problems we all deal with. No matter. Business as usual. Ballsy? Maybe. 'Hey everybody! I'm a self-identified slacker, unqualified to be entrusted with responsibility. Here's my name. Here's my picture.' Still, very disappointing.
- nowigetit 13y agoAnyone else think "Rapiscan" is a perfect name for those machines?
- geophile 13y agoPaging Dr. Funke.
- deadfall 13y agoI started questioning all the TSA security after I recently watched a demonstration on how you could make dangerous weapons with items you can purchase after you go through security. It is quite scary. The people that want to cause harm will always find a way. I have not been outside the US, I am curious on the security around the world. Namely, flights headed towards US airports. Do they have to go through body scanners?
- brightsize 13y agoI'm a US citizen and I don't believe that when I flew from Berlin (TXL) back to the States a year ago that I had to go through a body scanner. It was quite relaxed. Likewise, my prior arrival in Frankfurt was like getting off a domestic (US) flight. Go straight to baggage. Stop at customs IF you have anything to declare, then off you go. In contrast, re-entering the States in Seattle was an appalling bit of theater. Crotch-sniffing dogs, long lines waiting to be interrogated and to have my Papiere scrutinized, then re-scanning of checked luggage (I had a connecting flight). I'm traveling again to .de in March and it will be very interesting to see what, if anything, has changed.
- ojii 13y agoI fly to the US a few times a year. Until a year ago from Switzerland either direct or London, now from Tokyo. Never seen a full body scanner outside the US. There is a bit of security theater though, which might pale in comparison to the TSA, like a security officer at ZRH giving me a 'old school' (read: no private areas) pat down because, as he told me, "I was the 12th guy in a row". At NRT they check your ID or passport prior to entering the airport and may glance at your bag, due to the troubles when they opened the airport. HND doesn't have that IIRC. TL;DR, this seems mostly limited to the US from my experiences.
- eatmyshorts 13y agoI do believe the first deployment of these scanners was at Amsterdam's Schipol airport. They were deployed at the time of the infamous Underwear Bomber that supposedly led to the US deploying them. This is the same Schipol airport where the Underwear Bomber went through security before boarding his flight to the US.
- pstack 13y agoAll you need to know about those performing the TSA roles can be learned from one trip through a security line, where some fat obnoxious woman screams at paying customers and american citizens like they're children and berate and segregate (for further humiliation or harassment) anyone who dares question anything or do anything but be blindly and unwaveringly obedient.
- stretchwithme 13y agoIts all been lies all along. What a shock. Our government does so much propaganda in collusion with the media. Every time anything happens, we are treated to news stories about how security is being beefed up. The reality is that there reality isn't much they can do except show more security on TV and hope you'll conclude "ah, they are on top of things."
- dror 13y agoIn a funny way I find this reassuring. After all the worries, posting from various places, TOR, and in the end from home, no one went after him even though he clearly ridiculed the TSA. It's kind of sad that we even have to consider that, but in these days of NSA abuses it's nice to see democracy at work.
- lucb1e 13y agoThought this was a great website with great content, reading this interesting article without annoying pagination (though the option was there if I had wanted it) at a comfortable font size. Clicking through to the homepage, it turns out they also feature a call to censor Snowden: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/01/edward-snowden-nsa-snow-job-102740.html?ml=m_b7_1 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/01/edward-snowde... Never mind. This makes me doubt what I just read.
- avalaunch 13y agoOne of my favorite stories came from one of the linked articles that he wrote while still on the job. http://takingsenseaway.wordpress.com/2012/11/12/confession-x-the-things-they-ran-through-the-xray/ http://takingsenseaway.wordpress.com/2012/11/12/confession-x... I recall one time I did a bag check on a man from Detroit, once the auto-making capital of the world. Having been informed by the x-ray operator that there was a bottle of water in the bag, I pulled it out and quickly sensed that something was slightly off. Then, I realized what it was: there was an enormous dildo rubber-banded to it. I then had an epiphany, spreading over me like a sunrise, beautiful and exhilarating: he wanted me to have to deal with the dildo. He did it on purpose. In rubber-banding that dildo to the water bottle he knew we would target, he seemed to say: “Yes, I have a dildo, federal officer. Even after the horrors of 9/11, I am still alive; full of vitality, love, sex and, later tonight, that large dildo rubber-banded to the water you are about to confiscate from me. That bottle of water, bought with hard-earned American dollars to relinquish my bodily fluids, so as to make me strong and keep the wheels of commerce of this great nation turning. In taking my water, I want you, federal officer, to know that the terrorists have won, and that you are complicit. I want you to see my dildo. To hold it in your hand; to know that I, as well as my fellow passengers and countrymen, are strong and resilient. That we, the people of this great nation, can, and will, snap back, like that rubber band.”
- alistairSH 13y agoOn the way to my bachelor party, my friends snuck a foil-wrapped dildo into my luggage in the hopes of eliciting a TSA response. Thankfully, it didn't work.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoHow did it fail? Did the TSA not find it, or did it just not elicit a response?
- alistairSH 13y agoEither they didn't see it, or they did, but didn't care. Either way, we all got a good laugh about it when I unpacked at our destination.
- dmourati 13y agoThis reads as if the author considers himself in league with Edward Snowden.
- beloch 13y agoThe bit about racial profiling is spot on, but heavily understated. People who are clearly U.S. citizens are merely inconvenienced and embarrassed by the TSA's shenanigans. If you know somebody from either the middle-east or a country noted for supplying narcotics (e.g. Mexico) who has flown through the U.S., even just to transfer to a connecting flight, ask them what their experience was like. The TSA treats U.S. citizens like Hollywood celebrities by comparison! The stories I've heard frequently cross the line into what any reasonable person would define as outright abuse. Obviously, few victims stand up for themselves. The terrorists didn't win. The TSA became the terrorists.
- smsm42 13y agoI always opt out from the body scanners, and I have yet to see another person do it (which implies very small number do, otherwise by pure chance I'd see somebody do it by now). Looks like most of the Americans just don't care. BTW, never took me excessive time and I've never been harassed or inconvenienced in any unusual (as opposed to usual for TSA) ways for opting out. Also, from this article, next time TSA employee tries to feel my ass looking for a bomb, it would be interesting to think about him as an aspiring satire writer. I wonder if that would change the experience.
- hisabness 13y agoi went through the airport yesterday on my way to watch the Broncos win the super bowl. TSA had a new procedure which required travelers to touch a screen and give up their fingerprints then get their hands swabbed in order to collect DNA. later in the procedure travelers are asked to show their ids, which are then placed under 'infrared' scanners. given all the recent discussion about the pseudo anonymity of our interactions with various software services i found this to be more almost as intrusive as body scans. essentially, the tsa could be doing the following: 1. touch screen so we have a fingerprint 2. touch again if it didn't work the first time so we potentially have 2 fingerprints 3. swab finger for DNA sample that we'll link to step 1 and/or 2 4. place id under scanner which we'll link to steps 1-3 5. triangulate all these data points over many years until the TSA has a complete database with everyone's unique identifying info...
- btbuildem 13y agoReally, nobody's gonna say it? Okay, fine. YOU ARE THE PROBLEM. You, guy wearing the uniform, you the mindless meat puppet acting out nonsensical policy directives. Without you, there is no system, yet you choose to participate in it, you enable it, you make it real. I understand some people have no choice, family to support, made bad choices in the past that limit their opportunities now.. but you, good sir? You get no pass whatsoever. Young, male, educated -- one would expect you'd try harder than to settle into a TSA job.