5 ms·
What in rural Wyoming would ever justify spending half a million dollars for a single water well? I do not think an example like the massive urban conglomeratio
by gwern 13y ago
What in rural Wyoming would ever justify spending half a million dollars for a single water well? I do not think an example like the massive urban conglomeration of Mexico City (greater area: 21.2 million people) naturally analogizes to such areas.
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoThey redirect water from Northern to Southern California. Why not from rural Wyoming to, say, Colorado? We may have 5M people here, and are chronically short of water. The water from Colorado (via the Colorado River) also supplies Utah, Arizona, Southern California, Nevada, and Mexico with water. All of those areas need more water; even if Colorado stays at its current demand level, you could imagine one or more of those areas funding a well in Wyoming to divert water to Colorado to either send directly down the river or to take the place of water that would otherwise be removed from the river, so that their allocation could be correspondingly increased. (Pretty much every drop of the Colorado River is owned by someone. [1]) Water is life. :) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River
- cbr 13y agoPretty much every drop of the Colorado River is owned by someone. The river is actually overcommitted: When the Colorado River Compact was drafted in the 1920s, it was based on barely 30 years of streamflow records that suggested an average annual flow of 17.5 million acre feet past Lee's Ferry. Modern studies of tree rings revealed that those three decades were probably the wettest in the past 500 to 1,200 years – and that the natural long-term annual flow past Lee's Ferry is probably closer to 13.5 million acre feet, as compared to the natural flow at the mouth of 16.3 million acre feet. This has resulted in more water being allocated to river users than actually flows through the Colorado.
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoI had heard that, but I didn't find the reference quickly, and I had to post. Didn't want to make unsubstantiated claims. Thanks for the follow-up. :) As a result we've been in violation with a treaty with Mexico over the lack of promised water volume over most of that time as well. Again, too busy to find the link.
- dllthomas 13y ago"Why not from rural Wyoming to, say, Colorado?" Or also to Southern California? So what if there's a few mountain ranges in the way?
- gwern 13y ago> Why not from rural Wyoming to, say, Colorado? I think pretty much any other solution will work better than digging a well in rural Wyoming and building a pipeline somewhere. For example, getting water from all the other places around Colorado. Why is this one particular spot in Wyoming so important?
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoAll of these aquifers are finite. There may come a time when every one in Colorado is drained -- if there are any at all.
- gwern 13y agoSo then one doesn't have to live there, if there's truly no source of water whatsoever. There is no divine mandate that people have to live there, and given the constant urbanization of the world, it's not clear people even want to live in rural areas.
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoUmm....I think Denver would resent being referred to as a "rural area." And Boulder. And Colorado Springs. Ignoring the "rural" aspect of what you're saying, the same can be said of Vegas. And most of Arizona. Not to mention, ahem, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. You suggesting that the 20M+ people in SoCal should pick up and leave because there isn't enough water? Because there isn't, except if you count the water imported from COLORADO. Colorado actually has PLENTY of water; it's just that legally we're bound to give it to others. Aside from which point, infrastructure costs money. "Pick up and move elsewhere" isn't reasonable if "elsewhere" doesn't have the infrastructure for millions of people. Did you actually read the comment thread before replying?
- grecy 13y ago> What in rural Wyoming would ever justify spending half a million dollars for a single water well? You need to think further into the future. What happens in 50-100-200 years when all the surface and near-surface water is spoken for, and there is literally not enough water for the population to even drink? (If you think I've being doomsdayish, this actually happens in Australia - a buddy of mine with a newborn in a city of 30,000 people had to rely on bottled flown-in water just to be able to drink)
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoI mean, on those time scales we could (more expensively) desalinate water using fusion power.
- angersock 13y agoOr even more cheaply, reduce the number of people!
- Dylan16807 13y agoDesalination for personal use is cheap. Cheaper than killing, even.
- grecy 13y agoJust because we might have the ability to repair some of the damage we've done to the planet in the future, that doesn't mean we shouldn't be trying to reduce that damage now.
- unclebucknasty 13y ago>What...would ever... Those words sound like the tell-tale signs of the short-sightedness that drives some of these decisions. I believe the next sentence, which may not be uttered until years later, is "Doh!", while face-palming. And half a million dollars is really nothing, meaning the eventual face palm is even more likely. Not to mention it could become even less costly to access it in the future.
- gwern 13y ago> Those words sound like the tell-tale signs of the short-sightedness that drives some of these decisions. Not really. The West has been colonized for centuries. We have a pretty good idea of what is valuable out there and what isn't, and for the most part, extractive is what is valuable out there. > Not to mention it could become even less costly to access it in the future. Talk about one-sided reasoning - and there could be even less reason to ever want to access it in the future too. Rural areas in the plains have been depopulating for decades.
- unclebucknasty 13y ago>We have a pretty good idea of what is valuable out there and what isn't So far. In relative terms. >extractive is what is valuable out there. In some places, water is an extractive. >Talk about one-sided reasoning - and there could be even less reason to ever want to access it in the future too. Possibly, but then, I wasn't the one making definitive statements like "what would ever justify...". See the difference? I'm showing you another side, not declaring it inevitable. That's why I used the word could instead of will. In general, you made a one-sided statement that also ignored the fact that your assumptions could change. I pointed that out, along with possible alternatives. Then, you reply that I am being one-sided? You're talking in circles. Contortions aside, your posture makes no sense to me. You're saying there is no need now and may never be, so let's destroy it. I'm saying there may be a need, so let's think about that. If we don't know, then why burn the bridge? One approach gives us a way back, whereas the other doesn't. And, that's the entire point of the article. The Mexicans are now having to dig deeper than they thought would be necessary or viable. At some point, they were saying "what would ever justify...".