3 ms·
What is he benefit or point in Facebook or Google doing interop with other IM systems? Interop seems like a desperate last-chance measure when you realise you'r
by MichaelGG 13y ago
What is he benefit or point in Facebook or Google doing interop with other IM systems? Interop seems like a desperate last-chance measure when you realise you're losing users.
I don't think there's anything technical involved. Unless spam is considered a technical problem, but denying federation seems to solve that problem considerably,
- Jtsummers 13y agoGoodwill? I don't think it's really a "desperate last-chance measure", so much as a tool. FB and Google both offer a lot of other services beyond just chat. FB offers photo sharing, the newsfeed, potential for correct address books (at least with people that share that info with their friends), event organizing, games. I'm not that into it, but I know a lot of people that are. Then Google offers Google Mail, Docs, Hangouts, Calendar, Drive. I think they have their own image sharing system (I don't take many photos, so those features are nearly useless to me). Their chat protocols are more of a side-effect of having something already associated with your identity. Opening them up to federation likely won't cost them many users (and those users it does cost them will likely be as inactive on all their other services as I am), but has the potential to gain goodwill and endorsement from other circles (particularly those people that others -- family, friends -- go to for tech advice).
- leobelle 13y agoI don't think you should be downvoted. You raised a valid point and people are downvoting you because they are disagreeing with you. I think pg should clean up downvote abilities for people who do this often via moderation. Like moderators should see a list of people who downvoted what and just one click nuke their downvote privileges.
- Jtsummers 13y agoMeta-moderation on /. was like this. Moderate the moderation, if it was deemed fair/appropriate then you were more likely to get to moderate again later. If it was deemed unfair/inappropriate you were less likely to receive mod privileges.
- MichaelGG 13y agoObviously I don't think I should be downvoted either since it's an accurate comment. :) But I am quite fine with moderation working the way it does - it'd be better than arbitrary moderation "nuking" privileges. A model where certain threads are curated and used to measure how valuable someone's voting is might be helpful in weighting votes. But that sounds like a lot of work for probably little reward.
- leobelle 13y agoI'm OK with less downvote privileges in general, the community would benefit if there were less downvotes all around.
- e12e 13y agoWhat's the benefit of gmail interop with other email systems?
- MichaelGG 13y agoEmail has too much momentum to ignore? See Facebook's messaging - they're happy to ignore and cut off email. If they get away with it, it's a huge win. If it looks like they're not gonna get away with it, then they reverse decision and talk about opening up or whatnot. I don't believe that it's clear at all that Google, FB, or Skype would win by opening up their systems. The best we're likely to see is alliances, like FB+Skype. Unless a service is in a losing position (like BBM), what do they gain?
- Argorak 13y agoThis is a purely business perspective, completely dropping the interests of the user. All older communication companies (providing e.g. phone calls, fax, SMS) have working, interoperable systems that work on a global scale for _any customer of one company to any customer of another company_. By using a globally unique number. It is, quite frankly, a disgrace that we now run around and find excuses for companies to re-introduce closed networks on a medium that provides working low-level routing on a global scale for almost all connected parties already. We're talking short messages here. I went back to SMS because of all this bull. Not even iMessage. It works. With everyone. Everywhere. Without installing something. From a users perspective, the current situation is horrible and a huge step back. I couldn't care less about what the benefit for Google or Facebook is.
- MichaelGG 13y ago>This is a purely business perspective Yep, pretty much. Do you expect multi-billion dollar companies to do something just because it sounded nice? Acting like that only works if they can get enough users onboard to commoditize the service. IM is far from that point (see the rise of new messenger apps/networks, decades after the first ones). These companies want their users inside their apps as much as possible. Not to mention, allowing federation doesn't help the vast majority of their users, who are on other closed networks. So for it to be relevant, two networks need to interconnect. Without any solid reason or threat, why would they do that? SMS BTW is a rather crappy example; I don't think I've ever used any other service that was so unreliable, slow, and expensive. And the only reason you have competition in many companies is due to the government coming in and breaking things up or allowing competition. Even today on phones, various companies are still doing their best to create lock-in or jam users, by, say, charging ridiculously high prices to call into their networks.
- Argorak 13y agoIf SMS is crappy for you, just take phone calls. There is still jam-in, yes, but you can mostly find a cheap phone connection from any place in the world to any other. I regularly call cross-continent and with some googling, you get a decent rate. The point being: the system is there and there is competition that drives the prices down. Also, I don't believe that for a "vast majority of users", federation doesn't matter. Everyone I know uses multiple messenger apps on their phone _or just use SMS_. SMS is the base line. This is a failure of a model. Sure, Google has no interest of federating with Facebook. What this leads to is the aforementioned silos of peoples communications. "How do I contact this person? WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter DM, Jabber, Google Talk, jadajadajada? The only thing that comes close is email. No, I don't expect multi-billion dollar companies to do something that sounds nice. Which still makes the model as a whole a failure. Obviously, multi-billion dollar companies cannot be trusted with providing reliable and easy reach-ability on a global scale.