3 ms·
Seems to me that it's mistitled. It's only an expensive bug if they lost the contract, and the article doesn't say that. No doubt the parties involved fixed w
by ajross 17y ago
Seems to me that it's mistitled. It's only an expensive bug if they lost the contract, and the article doesn't say that. No doubt the parties involved fixed whatever layout glitch or misconception led to the platform test and moved on. Contracts that big are expensive for both sides to cancel.
- crux 17y agoExcept it wasn't a contract, it was a sample server sent as a sales pitch. If somebody is trying to get your business and sends you a machine that purposefully checks for your flagship product, so that that machine can treat it like a second-class citizen, you probably aren't going to decide to give them your business.
- mbreese 17y ago"cost them millions of NOK in lost sales" So, yeah, I'd call that a big loss. According to the article, this was in an evaluation period with several different vendors. This one little piece of Javascript seems to have been enough to remove that company from the running. I don't know if Opera would have liked that company's offerings otherwise, but that would probably be enough to remove them from consideration. I guess if you're trying to sell something to a browser maker, you might want to make sure that your admin interface works with their browser.
- slig 17y ago> This one little piece of Javascript Not just that. The little piece just acknowledge the fact that the browser isn't supported, so removing it doesn't magically makes things work.
- mahmud 17y ago"Enterprise Software" deliberately insists on IE or another pet browser just because it can. Half the time they're not even doing anything browser specific. Millions in lost sales should teach them to take standards seriously.
- gaius 17y agoNot true. When a customer calls with a problem, if they're using some hoky browser (no offence to the Opera folks, but even they have to admit they're a tiny niche), then that's one more factor to eliminate before the problem can be understood. I would be very surprised if the profit on that one sale would cover certifying the product and supporting it going forwards.
- tokenadult 17y agoI would be very surprised if the profit on that one sale would cover certifying the product and supporting it going forwards. What technical reason would a server company have for NOT supporting a largely standards-compliant browser like Opera? Isn't the whole point of serving up content to the World Wide Web to be able to communicate with multiple devices all over the world?
- gaius 17y agoWell, for a start, it would mean rolling out Opera to every developer, tester and support rep's desktop, and it being someone's job to make sure it worked on every PC they had, to keep it up to date and apply any patches. It also means doing any manual QA cycles again with Opera, and/or rewriting automated tests to use it too. All of those things have cash costs associated with them.
- tokenadult 17y agoWell, for a start, it would mean rolling out Opera to every developer, tester and support rep's desktop, and it being someone's job to make sure it worked on every PC they had, to keep it up to date and apply any patches. Is it impossible to write a Web application that simply doesn't test the limits of most browser implementations? Again, I'm asking an informational question to follow up on your interesting response. What actually happens in the typical case of a server vendor's application that is supposed to run on an arbitrary browser if a browser the vendor hasn't considered is used? Does the whole application crash? Or does it just look a little bit less pretty?
- eds 17y agoSo as little as $300,000? Unless the amount was much greater, I'm betting there've been far more expensive Javascript mistakes.
- lucumo 17y ago> Seems to me that it's mistitled. It's only an expensive bug if they lost the contract, and the article doesn't say that. It does. FTA: > This single statement, apparently written by some sub-contractor they had outsourced admin interface programming to, cost them millions of NOK in lost sales.
- joezydeco 17y agoIt's also not a bug. The article never titled it a bug.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- noodle 17y agothey did lose the contract, and it was a big one. there wasn't any glitch or misconception, it was a hard-coded redirect specifically designed to kill opera usage. and, just in case you didn't pick it up from the article, this is opera trying to make the purchase. also, opera is a web browser. :)