6 ms·
Genetic Weapon Against Insects Raises Hope and Fear in Farming
- adrianN 13y agoWouldn't a highly specific pesticide also be susceptible to quick resistance?
- leobelle 13y agoYes, and that was brought up, a previous modification is facing resistance: "Corn growers need a new tool. For a decade they have been combating the rootworm by planting so-called BT crops, which are genetically engineered to produce a toxin that kills the insects when they eat the crop. Or at least the toxin is supposed to kill them. But rootworms are now evolving resistance to at least one BT toxin."
- wehadfun 13y agoGenetic pesticide No. Some sort of contraption built by Google Boston Dynamics with "Weed OCR" software that yanked weeds and smashed bug called the Weedernater. Yes.
- AJ007 13y agoEnding monoculture would be another option.
- cracell 13y agoYes! Is there anyone in the industrial farming industry that's actually pursuing industrial scale polyculture technology? Monoculture is not nature and is not just not how plants evolved to grow. We can continue to force it as we have been but that obviously isn't working all that well.
- kvb 13y agoDefine "isn't working that well". Are we not exceeding historical standards for agricultural productivity?
- mikeyouse 13y agoNot OP, but you're completely correct. Here's the wheat yield per hectare: http://www.earth-policy.org/images/uploads/graphs_tables/update92_yields.PNG http://www.earth-policy.org/images/uploads/graphs_tables/upd... And corn bushels per acre: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-lvcQDaR56xg/Trfc71LwF3I/AAAAAAAAQKs/KKi6Ng03gVU/s1600/corn.jpg http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-lvcQDaR56xg/Trfc71LwF3I/AAAAAAAAQK... Genetic engineering, as well as more traditional agriculture knowledge, has hugely improved productivity.
- araes 13y agoActually, the Chinese, who naturally have serious concerns about feeding a billion+ people, have been looking at this for a while. They actually had some fairly promising results for test farms and plots. However, its still pretty small scale by industrial standards. Official paper: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v406/n6797/abs/406718a0.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v406/n6797/abs/406718a0... Full text alt: http://www.mindfully.org/GE/Rice-Diversity-Yield.htm http://www.mindfully.org/GE/Rice-Diversity-Yield.htm Polyculture ag. production's not a bad idea, and it obviously can improve yields under the right conditions, but to be widely adopted it either needs top down advocacy from a larger body (Gov) or be so compelling economically that individuals / companies push for and adopt it at the personal level. Yields are one thing, but there is also the additional logistical difficulty, and cost, that comes from planting many different crops. Particularly tough when you're talking about some midwest, intensive crop farming, where machinery, layouts, and storage have been designed and optimized for monoculture operations over literally millions of acres. Adapting those operations while maintaining economies of scale is one of the greatest hurdles. Also, while folks sometimes decry our farming, America isn't as bad as we often make it out to be, and many areas do significantly mix crops. Example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Crops_Kansas_AST_20010624.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Crops_Kansas_AST_20010624.... Shows fields of wheat, sorghum, corn, and sections left fallow that are fairly well mixed in Kansas.
- mikeyouse 13y agoHow about the "Hortibot" instead: http://www.technologyreview.com/news/408225/robotic-farmer/ http://www.technologyreview.com/news/408225/robotic-farmer/
- amalag 13y agoThe next glyphosate? Thats nice, we have glyphosate resistant Superweeds, now we need insecticide resistant Superbugs.
- lublublub 13y agoI get the rather cynical impression that Monsanto may need to rethink the nature of the problem. Unless I'm mistaken this strategy is still going toe-to-toe with evolutionary biology and ends up causing individuals who are not succeptible to this target to flourish. I also don't like the idea of spraying stuff around that is built to silence genes--I'd like to have some mention on how specific the targeting is i.e. are you knocking out specific codons, frame rewrite or transposons, and if it's that general how is it contained/delivered? It's the vast crop monoculture that is the problem, not the "pest" who evolves and then takes advantage of it.
- mjt0229 13y agoI presume the RNAi described here targets regions of DNA of about ~20 nucleotides. Off-target effects are par for the course, but if you pick your 20 nucleotides carefully, you can get pretty precise. Common off-target effects also come from an orthogonal RNAi pathway that would would affect particular endogenous RNAs sharing the first ~7 nucleotides in that sequence. Your argument about "toe-to-toe with evolutionary biology" is a little misguided. Everything about agriculture and pest control is going toe-to-toe with evolutionary biology. You either let evolution run all over you, or you try to keep up. Monoculture is a problem, but crop diversity wouldn't eliminate the evolutionary challenge - it's just another mitigating strategy.
- mjt0229 13y agoFar be it from me to defend Monsanto, though. They're a horrible, horrible corporation.
- lublublub 13y agoI'm sure there are some people in Monsanto who mean well, however, I'll agree.
- lublublub 13y agoInformative! thanks! Though I never ment to suggest that the evolutionary challenge would be eliminated--it just changes the approach to the problem, rather than looking at specific pests and targeting them individually, (which is actually an endless fight--but may provide continued revenue for Monsanto) look at the systemic relationships and the patterns they create as they persist. If you eliminate one pest, you still have broad homogenous crop, which is a natural draw for all sorts of similar 'pest' problems. In any case I see it as being symptomatic of our highly optimized food system--which has problems in all sorts of places (input/output and stderr), as I think we are optimizing for the wrong thing in the long term. Slightly circular, and OT--sorry.
- b0rsuk 13y agoUltimately, it's not for us to decide. Things like these are always decided by economic viability and lobbying. It's really hard to create an outrage strong enough that people will just stop buying it, and go to a competitor. But this is the only message big corporations understand.
- leterter 13y agoEvolutionary incompatible approach like this will lead to defeat in the end. Co-existence is the only way that is compatible with evolution.
- rsync 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal
- exit 13y agoif anyone feels like indulging the fears this provokes, i recommend reading the windup girl by paolo bacigalupi > The Windup Girl is set in 23rd century Thailand. Global warming has raised the levels of world's oceans, carbon fuel sources have become depleted, and manually wound springs are used as energy storage devices. Biotechnology is dominant and mega corporations like AgriGen, PurCal and RedStar (called calorie companies) control food production through 'genehacked' seeds, and use bioterrorism, private armies and economic hitmen to create markets for their products. Frequent catastrophes, such as deadly and widespread plagues and illness, caused by genetically modified crops and mutant pests, ravage entire populations. The natural genetic seed stock of the world's plants has been almost completely supplanted by those that are genetically engineered to be sterile. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Windup_Girl http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Windup_Girl
- throwwit 13y agoThe advancements in genetic technologies are dangerous because they deal in creating inherently extreme solutions. A lot of evolutionary stability is dependent on a statistical distribution of genotypic/phenotypic traits that have roots in a complex reservoir of genetic material. Personally I feel one cannot simply hinge an entire 'solution' on one inserted gene. The process can probably be considered analogous to 'monkey-patching' the genome IMO.