6 ms·
Oh my god, it's a girl (2010)
- zobzu 13y agoI think it's more about the character of the person than the gender.
- mratzloff 13y agoAs a guy, I get pretty sick of it. I've noticed the "kiddie gloves" effect for a long time on HN and so I tend to just stay out of those threads altogether. I've found that if I disagree or critique a woman a thousand misguided defenders swoop in, presumably in some attempt to be chivalrous. Guys, give it a rest and treat women the same as you would men. They don't want or need special treatment.
- vonklaus 13y agoNo one else has said this yet. Probably most relevant thing ITT.
- skybrian 13y agoHaven't seen this. Could you give some examples?
- res0nat0r 13y agoThis is probably being brought up due to the Bropages post from yesterday which resulted in hundreds of comments stating that a rubygem with the simple name of 'bro' is somehow going to totally devastate the fragile psyche of all women in IT. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7121268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7121268
- lstamour 13y agoUgh, as a guy, that whole thread was silly. I got the joke, saw they were erring on the side of "dude" rather than "immature jerk" and stopped reading. What stopped me from contributing was that I couldn't find an easy way to cut examples out of a man page. Although it does occur to me belatedly that a grep for "<command> -" would probably do it for many commands. Or maybe there's another standard syntax that could be used. It also reminded me of that tool that could explain a command by annotating a given example. Hmm, maybe the sexist name debate stopped me from contributing more than I'd thought. That said, it was because the debate didn't interest me -- it wasn't relevant enough to the original subject matter, I felt.
- belorn 13y agoRelated, one can now not use the Swedish name for "bridge" in projects. Bridge being a common technical term is the same exact 3 letter "bro", and will likely call down the storm if used. My dream of bridging man pages and info manuals crushed.
- pstack 13y agoIf anything, I would find myself more concerned about all the overly sensitive fellow males swarming me for something they perceive to take offense to on behalf of someone or a group entirely unrelated to them than I am potentially upsetting anyone on whose actual behalf the offense is feigned.
- __pThrow 13y agoWe must read a different HN and participate in different industries. > They don't want or need special treatment. Many women these days are certainly expressing that they want special treatment. The question is if they need it, and if they are representative of women in IT as a whole.
- fallinghawks 13y agoI suspect the women who unhappy are writing posts about it, and the ones who don't want special treatment aren't saying anything because they're doing just fine. IMO it's a noisy minority, but given the recent story about the woman who got felt up at a Bitcoin meetup, perhaps more sexist behavior is going on than I see. I'm a female programmer. I don't want to be hit on or looked at like I'm from another planet; I want to be judged by the quality of my work. It's going to my satisfaction, so I don't feel the need to complain.
- benburleson 13y agoI can't remember the last time I actually noticed a username, or assumed a user was one gender or another.
- vonklaus 13y agoYep. Other than 1 or 2 people who often post extremely relevant and thoughtful comments and articles; I never "follow" anyone on HN.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoI notice some usernames but as the parent says you don't know what chromosomes they have ... perhaps they're not even humans ...
- hnriot 13y agoyes - exactly - most of us use gender agnostic language, rather than he/she usage, it is preferred to use they. this takes away any gender identity, except where specifically called out for gender specific topics. this whole thing about how women are treated is utterly dumb. am I male or female? Who can tell, does it matter, does it change anything about this comment? Of course not. gender agnostic language begets gender nondiscrimination.
- eli 13y agoI'm sure many people don't notice. I'm sure some people do notice but don't talk down to female users. But not everyone is like that. When people complain about sexism in the tech industry, they aren't saying that everyone in the industry is sexist. I'm sure that at least some of the time people would treat you differently online if your username was stephanieburleson.
- rdl 13y agoIt feels slightly horrible to admit it, but I'd probably try to be more encouraging/nicer to someone who posted something I disagree with if I thought that person was very young, new to the topic, female, or other underrepresented group. The "female" part is probably specific to tech; if it were a forum with equal gender distribution (biotech, or say fans of a tv show or something), I wouldn't. OTOH, I'd also be similarly polite to a respected person, particularly from outside the field, who posted something wrong. e.g. if a regulator or most VCs said something fundamentally incorrect, I'd politely try to counter it, but I'd back off rapidly unless the disagreement were really core. All of this is without specific information about the person; there are specific counterexamples. e.g. if pmarca were the VC who said something "wrong", I don't think "back off to be polite" would be useful or necessary; however, he's probably also less often wrong about things.
- nataliehacks 13y agoI'm going to use this username for a while and see what it's like.
- vonklaus 13y agoI once needed help on a project I was working on (building a lithium iron battery pack out of 18560 cells) and posted as DIYGirl. Got a ton of responses in a relatively less-traversed tech-heavy sub-reddit. If you explicitly state you are female people will treat you different.
- nataliehacks 13y agoHa, I've heard similar stories before. Let's see what happens when I post my next side-project under this account.
- rdl 13y agoIt's also a great trick for buying domain names.
- pavanred 13y agoWell, not necessarily the only factor. When I was living in Bangalore (a few years ago), I remember that if I post a question on StackOverFlow at night (Indian Standard Time), I had a higher chance of getting more responses than if I did it during the day. I presumed it must be because that translates into about morning in Americas and mid day in Europe and probably these places had the bulk of the active users.
- spudlyo 13y agoHeh, a buddy of mine always picks a female username when on freenode IRC looking for help with a technical problem. He says sometimes dudes fight over who has the better solution. Don't fight over me boys!
- Crito 13y ago
- vonklaus 13y agoThis thread brings up 2 obvious points: Often minorities are treated differently [and] because of the relatively anonymous nature of the internet, it is difficult to get true demographic information or user statistics.
- pstack 13y agoIsn't the whole benefit of the internet that you don't know anything about the other people and can thereby consider them on the merits of their words and actions? I'm not pre-judged by being white or male or fat (and therefore inherently "dumb and lazy") or anything else.
- inmygarage 13y agoAs an early HN user I secured the username "amanda" before promptly ditching it after 2 weeks. While I don't hide that I am female in my bio, I have also found that the style of interactions changed significantly when I changed my username. Figuring out how to leave the kid-gloves off in real life has been a bigger challenge.
- usaphp 13y agoWeird, I wonder what percent of HN users are actually looking at a user name when posting a reply, I personally don't even read a username of a person who I reply to, never mind looking for any male/female meanings in it. But because you posted this sort of comment I actually read your username for the first time :)
- rhizome 13y agoOf what possible use would a percentage of that be?
- jaredsohn 13y agoIt is relevant to the subject of the post. (If nobody looks at usernames, then the issue cited in the post doesn't matter.) Personally, I at least look at who I am responding to (especially when I disagree with them; sometimes the person you're responding to has readily-apparent expertise that you'd feel foolish disagreeing with.)
- lstamour 13y agoTrue. I also tend to look at usernames when a commenter annoys me, just to see if it's a troll who is camping out on a thread waiting to say the same things again. But... By then I've made up my mind what I'm going to say, and whether the troll's name is Jack or Jane isn't going to change that.
- YokoZar 13y agoIt would put some useful bounds on the behavior. If only 1% of people look at usernames when posting replies, she could conclude it's a very small subset of people generating this nonsense. If everyone does, we don't learn much at all.
- hnriot 13y agohow is one supposed to read that blog!
- MysticFear 13y agoI came here to type that. Transparency with white text. Not good.
- stock_toaster 13y agoI had to bring up the devtools and disable the css background on the body.
- Mz 13y agoWhat is your specific issue?
- zobzu 13y agotranslucent + background.
- Zimahl 13y agoDid you just change it? I personally liked the look with the transparent black with white text. Didn't look all that bad to me.
- Mz 13y agoYes, I did just change it. But I am logging off now. So no more fiddling. (I did not expect this to make the front page. It is a repost. I figured it would be completely ignored, or I would not have done it late in the day before logging off.) Later.
- leobelle 13y agoThe author has a really high opinion of commenters on hacker news. I don't really think it's that high quality. There are all kinds of weird conspiracy theorists, uncritical guffaws and just plain obnoxious toxic commentary. I think it was pretty high quality about one thousand days ago[1], but it isn't anymore. And yes this is a new account, but I'm not new. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079
- benched 13y agoI agree. Perhaps the author is remembering the way Hacker News was 3 to 4 years ago.
- Mz 13y agoAt the bottom of the page it says: (Originally posted elsewhere on 2010/12/25.) I am moving a few things from an old personal blog to a new one. This was previously posted on HN under the old url. I did not expect it to be upvoted this much or get any traction. I just thought a few people might be interested in knowing where it got moved.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoIt's true that the discussion quality isn't at some zenith, but it's still far beyond the vast majority of the web. There's plenty of expert commentary and educated comments to be found, despite the general drop. I haven't really seen that much "weird conspiracy theorists", though.
- vonskippy 13y agoOMG not this again. This has to be the most overinflated topic in tech. Just do your thing, if you're good, nobody cares what sex you are, if you're bad, don't use your sex as an excuse.
- zobzu 13y ago^this
- char 13y ago"if you're good, nobody cares what sex you are..." Part of the reason this is such a hot topic right now is because the above statement is not at all true. It is certainly applicable for some, but not enough to claim true equality in the system.
- jamesgeck0 13y agoThere are established behaviors people exhibit towards males who are good or bad. The author is noting that people tend to treat women differently, period.
- eli 13y agoIt keeps coming up because it's a real problem.
- controversial 13y agoYES. Women in tech would probably be treated more equally if they talked about ANYTHING other than being a woman. These types of posts do a serious disservice to women. Show me a woman who has actually accomplished something of merit who also writes about gender inequality. Complaining about inequality is just an excuse for not producing anything of value. Do you think I star repos on Github based on the sex of the author? NO! I star them based on their utility, elegance, etc. This issue is a non-issue.
- awhitty 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_feminists http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_feminists I would say all of these women have accomplished something of merit while talking about gender inequality.
- benched 13y ago1. Hacker News usernames became a blur of random characters quite some time ago. I don't know how I'd begin to tell what gender you all are, and it never enters my mind. 2. I really don't think there are that many people who care whether you're carrying the batter or the oven. 3. I don't know how to say this nicely, but you - not your gender, but you the individual - are sort of known to be a little sensitive to this, in a way that comes off a bit attention seeking. If you feel this is your message to bring, then great. More power to you, really. Just saying, this seems like one of your things.
- sergers 13y agoi got the same sense from reading the comments/blog. majority of people dont read into usernames, nor care of your gender. the only time i see kid gloves being used based on gender is that the lack of that gender in this field may raise some questions about the skillset. applies either way to gender. i have never seen kid gloves used on here for several years i think blogposts like this, no i dont think someone is being nice for a date on here because you are female, leads to gender discrimination. attention seekers using gender for cover of seeking attention.
- Crito 13y agoEh, while on most sites I completely ignore usernames, I actually do read usernames habitually on HN. The community is small enough and there are enough frequent users that I find recognizing usernames to be helpful in understanding where somebody is coming from.
- __pThrow 13y agoMaybe HN should have an intentional name obfuscator. You sign up, you're assigned a random handle. It's consistent and has no meaning other than as a pointer.
- hacknat 13y agoI don't even look at peoples' handles when I reply to them. I suspect a lot us are similar to me in that regard. Also, are men just attracted to women in general, site unseen?
- awhitty 13y ago> At which point, most men will metaphorically go back to affectionately punching you in the arm like you are one of the guys... I found this a little troubling. I wish women didn't have to feel like they're "one of the guys" in an online community.
- j2d3 13y agoOne of the wonderful things about the internet is that no one knows you're a...(something you're not)... unless you tell them.
- GhotiFish 13y agoThoughts on the reasons stated: 1) Attraction: Oh my god, it's a girl and she has a brain and is interested in some of the same things I am interested in. Maybe I can get a date! I wouldn't put it past the majority of my gender. 2) Misguided attempts to encourage women to post more: Oh my god, it's a girl and we need more girls posting here. Let's be nice and friendly and make her feel all welcome and stuff so she will post more (thereby sucking all the intellectual content out of their posts and killing any reason you have to post there). I wouldn't put it past HN. 3) It's not really kid gloves, it's really walking on egg shells: Oh my god, it's a girl and what if she breaks down and cries because I argued with her (like my girlfriend routinely does) Now that I just can not see. 3b) or what if I make a joke and she takes it all wrong and everyone will think I am some horrible sexist pig! People have lost their jobs to that one. Even I'm doing that. You would be crazy not to do that 4) Shyness: A lot of the very intelligent men you find hanging out in certain types of online forums (like Hacker News) are very introverted and just awkward around women and some of them have gotten a lot of rejection, so they get nervous once they find out it's a girl. iffy.
- thwest 13y agoIt's for your job prospects that you avoid off color jokes? Not the comedic banality or actual disgust with sexism?
- GhotiFish 13y agoWell. Already I'm in dangerous territory now arn't I? but let me be candid: >it's for your job prospects that you avoid off color jokes? yes. >Not the comedic banality no. >or actual disgust with sexism? no. I'm not a crusader, nor am I a paragon of morality. I would suggest to you, that such personally held traits are dangerous.
- __pThrow 13y agoWhat do off color jokes have to do with sexism? As an example, the dongle joke had nothing to do with sexism. I am not trying to shame you but have you ever been around groups of women as they work or play? Off color jokes are typical of the species homo sapiens in 2014.
- controversial 13y agoNoone ever seems to bring up the fact that sex and gender are NOT the same thing. sex - either of the two main categories (male and female) into which humans and many other living things are divided on the basis of their reproductive functions. gender - the state of being male or female (typically used with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones).
- anaphor 13y agothank you for the sociology 101 lecture
- ElliotH 13y agoHuh, I read lots of comment threads, but I can't say I've noticed anyone using kid gloves to each other around here. Any stories that had enough instances of this occurring that linking to it wouldn't be unfair?
- herbig 13y agoFrom the most recent post: "I basically think "dating" -- ie men spending money on women in hopes of getting laid -- is a form of socially sanctioned prostitution." Why are we wasting time discussing this author?
- pygy_ 13y agoWe're not discussing the author but her post. She may have unusual opinions on dating, but that's not the topic of this discussion.
- herbig 13y agoOpinions on dating are opinions on gender, and they're not unusual, they're ridiculous. I'm male. I consider myself a feminist. It's just as possible to offend me with ignorant statements as it is to offend anyone else, female or otherwise.
- 001sky 13y agoOpinions on dating are opinions on gender Right, and frankly they're not professional. An in that sense, why are you hung-up on them? Its a bit of a stretch to assume everything that is <not> professional is "un" professional.
- stefan_kendall 13y agoThe most recent post explained, without comment: https://www.blogger.com/profile/04569990405409070244 https://www.blogger.com/profile/04569990405409070244
- mmastrac 13y agoHeads up: mobile stylesheet makes the text black on black. Can't read this easily in Chrome mobile
- usaphp 13y ago> A lot of the very intelligent men you find hanging out in certain types of online forums (like Hacker News) are very introverted and just awkward around women and some of them have gotten a lot of rejection, so they get nervous once they find out it's a girl Imagine if man posted a similar statement about some female community, he would be called sexist right away...
- filoeleven 13y agoMaybe. You have to keep in mind though that the two situations are not equivalent. Men have been the "in group" for a long time, and as members of the in group there are a lot of social dynamics that we don't tend to have a deep understanding of. See the parable of the old fish asking the young, "How's the water?" Conversely, as "outsiders" who are greatly affected by the dynamics of the in group, women have had more of a reason to pay attention to the group dynamics of men for a long time. They are more likely to have a sense of these things, conscious or not. The same dynamic happens any time there is a minority. Black people tend to be more astute observers of white people's behavior than the reverse because a white person is more likely to live their life without having to understand how to get what they want from the black folks who have the power, while the reverse is less often true.
- jmspring 13y agoI find that I try and avoid certain topics on HN, they tend to be clustered around: 1) discussions of gender 2) discussions of gentrification in the bay area 3) financial or political ideology (anything especially randian, for instance) Interactions / discussion tend to not be as factual or informative as other discussions. The poster makes great points on how to engage, sometimes, however, good posts are lost within a bunch of noise.
- sergers 13y agofirst thing to learn on the internet: a guy is a guy. a woman is a guy. a kid is a fbi undercover agent. type wiseley
- belorn 13y agoWe recently had almost a thousand comments long discussion regarding which 3 letters can form a appropriate program name for female users. Ask yourself how anyone would feel about that kind of attention.
- Tehnix 13y agoMany mention they can't think of cases where gender would come up in discussions. While it doesn't often come up, there are some discussions where personal anecdotes leads to the inference of the gender of the author. Personally, in my AFK life and online, I treat women with the same respect (and critique) as I do men. I also don't know many people who would treat people differently based on their gender. Well, obviously disregarding the case for romance/relations.. I do understand the interest in women in fields like tech and gaming. It certainly is something that can pique ones interest when a person of the opposite gender shares the same interests as you, but that doesn't mean you need to treat them differently unless otherwise hinted. The only people I can think of that do (treat women the way the OP describes), are also people that are generally awkward in social settings, so it's not gender focused per se, just a bit more apparent there, maybe.
- pstack 13y agoGender discussions seem to arise on here (and almost every other geek/tech/whatever related group) between about one and three times per day. I'm pretty sure we have shared very similar discussions to the topic of this thread at least six other times around here in the last seven days.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- greatdox 13y agoEris makes some good points on her blog: http://blastar.in/crawfraud/?p=455 http://blastar.in/crawfraud/?p=455
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Crito 13y ago> (Originally posted elsewhere on 2010/12/25.) That seems like a reasonable title edit. The author presumably still thinks that the article is relevant today, but it was written in 2010.