7 ms·
Dear Google Recruiting...
- freeasinfree 13y agoThis is beyond a First World problem
- drdeadringer 13y agoZero World Problem? Almost sounds like a comic book series. OP could be the superhero -- the ability to be contacted by Google, no matter what [bad economy, career goals, whatever].
- carbocation 13y agoHow about a "First Percent Problem"? While I agree with the sentiment, I also agree that if Colin is repeatedly asking the company not to recruit him, they should respect that (and should have the first time, too). Perhaps if he puts a time limit on it, that will make things more clear (e.g., "Do not contact me for 100 years").
- pjmorris 13y agoI claim 'Rock star problem' as the term for problems that most first worlders might wish they had, except for the ones that have them.
- smtddr 13y agoI like to call these "First World Annoyances". http://i.imgur.com/UQu7dey.jpg http://i.imgur.com/UQu7dey.jpg
- magicalist 13y agoI understand being annoyed that they ignored your request, but would it really lessen your recruiter spam by an appreciable amount? I get such random requests, eliminating a single company wouldn't make much of a dent. I've just gotten good at hitting shift-3 or e (depending on my mood) in gmail the second I sniff recruiter in an email.
- cperciva 13y agoIt's not the emails which bother me; it's the fact that they're ignoring explicit instructions.
- Oculus 13y agoImagine a world in which Google recruiters have a profile of you on their desk of likes, dislikes, likely life goals, and potential avenues to woo you into joining them. I imagine Facebook has a dataset that could be applied to make such a thing and soon (if not already) so will Google.
- adnam 13y agoDear Colin, You're extremely lucky to have talents that are highly sought-after and well paid. I know many talented architects and designers with experience who just scrape by. Just ignore Google's recruitment advances and move on :)
- cperciva 13y agoJust ignore Google's recruitment advances and move on If I thought I was the only person being annoyed by them, I would probably do this. But I've spoken to lots of other developers who get similarly annoyed by Google recruiters despite their attempts to tell Google Recruiting to stop contacting them -- so I figured it was worth writing a "ha ha only serious" public piece in the interest of getting Google's attention and maybe saving a lot of developers that same occasional irritation.
- huckyaus 13y ago> I've spoken to lots of other developers who get similarly annoyed by Google recruiters despite their attempts to tell Google Recruiting to stop contacting them It might have been worth mentioning this in your post. As it stands, the faux-formal structure, slightly melodramatic tone and repeated references to your cushy career situation make it read like a classic humblebrag.
- frostmatthew 13y ago> it read like a classic humblebrag What about this did you feel was humble?
- chris_wot 13y agoThat's the whole point of a humblebrag.
- tptacek 13y agoHe doesn't need to be humble. Google would be extremely lucky to have him. Let's stop wasting time pretending that he's lucky to be contacted by them, or that he needs to be careful about how he presents this. He's at the top of his field. Get over it.
- rl12345 13y agoDear OP Yes you have the right to not be contacted by Google if you don't want so. But may I advise you to not get pissed by the fact that your labour force and intellect is being greatly demanded. Disturbance apart, you should be thankful.
- cperciva 13y agoI don't mind recruiters contacting me. I mind recruiters contacting me when the file in front of them tells them that I've specifically asked them to not contact me.
- mooreds 13y agoIs Google unique in this? Or is this a generic tech company/recruiter problem?
- cperciva 13y agoGoogle is the only company I've found which seems to be unable to take no for an answer. I get lots of recruiter spam from hedge funds, but I don't think any of them have ever re-contacted me after I've told them not to.
- Bahamut 13y agoThey seem to cast a wide net as far as their recruiting efforts goes. I kinda wish they put more effort into identifying unexperienced hires as well, as I remember expending quite some effort to try to get hired by Google after I left graduate school, but to no avail. Now I have shown my quick ability to learn (which was already proven by my education) in the world of development and now I get contacted...and I don't know whether I want to work for Google anymore. I deeply question their talent identifying apparatus. Even worse for them, if they did a correct analysis, they probably would have saved a lot of $. It would probably take over 2x what I am making now to woo me over, and that's not necessarily guaranteed.
- magicalist 13y agoWhy didn't you just apply? I imagine that a recommendation from a current employee would boost your chances, but I don't think a recruiter contacting you changes anything over just a resume submission, at least not at most companies.
- Bahamut 13y agoI did before - multiple times.
- slyall 13y agoI like being contacted by Google. I'm not really interested in interviewing with them ( long process, doubt I'd pass, would have to move ) but it makes me feel good that the top tech company (YMMV) in the world is interested in hiring me.
- mgkimsal 13y agoThis isn't a knock on you - I was contacted last summer. Had a long chat, but didn't pursue it, as I'd have to move. That wasn't the only reason, but a primary one. To me, I had about 5 minutes of feeling valued, then the cynic in me started thinking that they must be scraping the barrel to contact me. I don't mean it in a self-loathing "i suck" sort of way, but... they must be tapping out 'locals' already to be reaching out across the country. They really can't find anyone else within driving distance who's at least as qualified as me?
- arkem 13y agoDisclaimer: I used to work at Google and have some incidental knowledge of Google's recruitment practices but am not an expert. Many of Google's recruiters (especially the sourcers who are looking for candidates) are temporary contractors. These contractors generally have a tenure measured in weeks and they are vying for one of very few full time positions. This high turnover, low institutional knowledge, and desire to distinguish themselves would be my best guess at explaining why the "Do Not Contact" note is not being respected.
- thkim 13y agoThis is what I figure as well. Sourcing and incentive structure Google has in place for recruiting naturally gives "do not hire" note won't be respected. It's a problem that needs a systematic solution, but probably not worth the cost to fix it.
- err4nt 13y agoGet an agent, if you're that in demand you can hire somebody else to handle your recruiting and opporunitites for you?
- brucehart 13y agoI don't understand why it bothers people so much to be contacted by recruiters. I just send a quick reply that says "I appreciate the interest, but I'm not looking for new position right now.". It takes me about 10 seconds to type that sentence and hit send. It takes me such little time that I probably would not remember if they contacted me again a year later. I'm always grateful to have skills that are in demand. I have friends in other fields that are not so lucky. No need to be the girl that tries to tell everyone how attractive she is by complaining about the attention she receives from guys.
- rickyc091 13y agoI just hit the archive button :(, but now that I think about it, I should really just draft a canned message.
- georgemcbay 13y agoWhen I'm absolutely not looking for a job or not interested, I just ignore cold-call recruitment emails. I don't see this as being a negative at all, and I've actually worked with a recruiter after ignoring her for years and it didn't seem to be an issue -- I think they expect it, and because they almost certainly are shotgunning their email out to many people at a time, they aren't crying about you not personally responding. That aside I've never been contacted directly by Google :( Amazon spams me all the time though. I've never interviewed at either one.
- bronbron 13y agoEh, it just gets grating after awhile. Inboxes are cluttered enough already without getting 10+ emails a day from recruiters, you know? It's also annoying to try and hit "unsubscribe" from a mailing list only to find out "unsubscribe" does nothing.
- rogerbinns 13y ago> I don't understand why it bothers people so much to be contacted by recruiters. It likely depends on how big your online footprint is. I've been on the Internet publicly since 1989 and hence you can find me all over. That also means recruiters do. I have no problems with the ones who are good at their jobs, but about half are below average, working on commission, and their tactics are the same as spammers (spread yourself indiscriminately far and wide). Many are downright scammers such as taking resumes off the net and then pretending to represent those people, or scraping job postings off websites and then pretending to represent those companies. At the top of my resume I put a "note to recruiters" that makes it clear what I am good for. It is very clear then which recruiters have made even that miniscule effort, versus just started spamming right away. I'd say I see about one good recruiter for every 20 spammers. And that is what is bothering. Even worse the lack of response or saying no doesn't deter the spammers so you have to do something about it. I made a blocklist in the end. http://rogerbinns.com/recruiters.html http://rogerbinns.com/recruiters.html
- krapp 13y agoDear Google... ignore these dilettantes. I'll bend over as far as you want. Holla.
- doug1001 13y agoon the bright side: enduring the unimaginable suffering which this horrific indignity has obviously caused you, will strengthen your character.
- dsjoerg 13y agoIf only Steve Jobs were around, he would put the industry cabal back in place and fix this problem for you pronto.
- pbriggs 13y ago#Humblebrag
- pyduan 13y agoGiven Google's emphasis on quantifying every aspect of recruitment, I wouldn't be surprised if the reason is because their numbers show that contacting people who previously rejected offers was more likely to result in a hire than contacting people who never interviewed, and that they decided that ignoring "do not contact" instructions was worth it after some time. Basically, kind of an retargeting strategy but applied to hiring. I understand why this may be annoying to you, but your case is probably rare enough that they decided to go along with it -- I would think that most people do not care enough about being contacted by companies they do not want to work for to complain. I do not condone this but the assumption that you may not feel as adamant about not working at Google as you did two years ago (during which a lot can happen) seems perfectly understable to me. With that said, your post does come across as really obnoxious. Asking to have an "ON PAIN OF DEATH" mention added on their file? Really? I dislike having my instructions disobeyed as much as the next guy, but if I counted properly this is 6 emails over more than 7 years. Surely one could live with receiving one unwanted email every year or so? It's not like it's that hard or time consuming to just ignore a message or to decline politely -- after all, a lot of people do it multiple times on a daily basis, and I'm sure you do too. This is too bad, because the tone of your post distracts from the perfectly valid (but IMHO, minor) point that this policy does imply things about Google they view themselves.
- mrpickles 13y agoEvery considered working for Google? I hear the perks are great!
- arikrak 13y agoso google contacts you every couple years. must really clog up your inbox...
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoI wish I had problems that resembled this. :(
- krishna2 13y agoNow you can ask them to add a link to this post. "DO NOT CONTACT but if you still think you should, please check this link".
- the1 13y agoas a girl on okcupid, I fully understand this.
- 510 13y agoI can't see a good reason for posting the names of the recruiters in this post, and can't see why this is that "special" of a case. Maybe if they called that many times, it would be legitimately annoying. But a few spam emails? I don't know many people who would emotionally react like this.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mgkimsal 13y agoWhen google asked for my resume (which... oddly enough, they already had because that's how they said they got my contact info), I told them to bing for it. Haven't heard from them since. Perhaps that'll get them off your back in future.
- benihana 13y agoI think about my friends from high school and college who are struggling to find meaningful work when I read things like this. I try to imagine what it be like from their point and it comes off like an entitled prima donna is complaining about being recruited by what one of the coolest companies on earth. Honestly I think as an industry we should try to keep some perspective here.
- d23 13y agoTo me it comes across as the reverse of sour grapes: "Oh woe is me, I'm being solicited by diamond salesmen to add extravagant adornments to my golden palace. Can't they just understand that my platinum plated safe contains more diamonds than they could ever offer? Why is life so hard?"
- rmrfrmrf 13y agosee also: #humblebrag, #whitegirlproblems
- nknighthb 13y agoThe odds of a job coming out of contact by a Google recruiter are nearly indistinguishable from 0. They constantly carpet-bomb everybody.
- jcdavis 13y agoThat doesn't change the fact that tech folk are unique in being so lucky in the current economic climate to be complaining about getting asked about job opporunities. I know plenty of people in other skilled fields who would be happy to hear back from any of the many companies they ask about jobs at
- nknighthb 13y agoI don't think you fully understood my comment. Contact by a Google recruiter does not constitute a job opportunity. It constitutes a waste of time on a massive scale. Replace them with automated spambots and the effect is the same.
- d0m 13y agoWhat a jerk. I thought once of using Tarsnap.. now I know there's no way I'll ever use or recommend this product. Ask a support question about Tarsnap? Bam, blog post about you annoying the shit out of him with your question. If you are not interested in an e-mail, it takes about a third of a second to press "!" in gmail.. that's a free way pass to the spam folder. But the person sending the email, the recruiter, won't know it. So a quick: "No thank you. I'm more than busy right now and not interested in new job opportunities" would do wonder. And FYI, the last time a google recruiter tried to recruit me, we had a very nice chat about my own startup (Hacking Health) where we pair technical talents with health professionals to find innovate solution in healthcare. These guys are very well connected and can introduce you to so many people.. So, if you think it's okay to be jerk to them, then realize that you're closing the doors to great opportunities by doing so.
- tptacek 13y agoAnd now we know how much your recommendations about secure backup software are worth. Thanks for sharing.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- d0m 13y ago>> secure backup software The software isn't the problem - it's probably great - it's the service that I wouldn't recommend.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't even understand what you're trying to communicate anymore. "The software's great! But don't ever use it!"
- chris_wot 13y agoWell that was aggressive.
- cperciva 13y ago
- hohohmm 13y agoWhy's this post even up? He just needs to get a bigger inbox and learn to use the archive button.
- shawndumas 13y agoas a front-end engineer I have just been abducted to work in a hiring war room at my company (30 FTEs in 30 days is the mandate) seeing and having to do what sourcers do for the last week has been eye-opening. identification, assessment, and engagement of skilled candidates is super hard and very time consuming. I have nothing but sympathy for these people now...
- benologist 13y agoIsn't this spam you can report because it's illegal? If not what's the difference?
- tptacek 13y agoDear Every Recruiter That Has Called Me In Last Couple Years, I know you think you can help me find awesome Rails programmers in the Chicago area or whatever kind of developer it is you think you're great at sourcing, but all I can think of when you call us to pitch your services is that my company's name is going to end up in a blog post like this. Go to hell, Thomas.
- almin 13y agoso obnoxious
- frostmatthew 13y agoI doubt the time it took you to write this is less than the amount of time it would take to simply ignore their emails.
- tptacek 13y agoSaid every spammer ever.
- 10098 13y agoThis guy is so full of himself
- chris_wot 13y agoIt's very rare I say this, but he has every right to be.
- paulrademacher 13y agoYou could have just solved the problem by taking a job at Apple, Adobe, Intuit, Lucasfilm, or Pixar!
- krstck 13y agoIt's just insulting when recruiters don't do basic research on the people that they contact. Yeah, it's not the worst problem to have in the world, but I get the feeling that a lot of these people are just spamming anyone they can find in a particular keyword and then expecting those people to do the recruiter's job for them.
- ggreer 13y agoI also turned Google down after interviewing [1]. They contacted me every six months to see how I was doing. Eventually, I asked them not to contact me again, and they haven't. Other recruiters haven't been so nice, but it's important to remember that recruiters are people too. Their jobs can be very stressful, since much of their compensation comes from successful hires. I ended up writing a rather conciliatory post, and I link to it whenever a recruiter contacts me: http://geoff.greer.fm/2013/10/23/dear-recruiter-please-do-not-contact-me/ http://geoff.greer.fm/2013/10/23/dear-recruiter-please-do-no... It has been quite successful. Replies from recruiters have been understanding and pleasant. 1. One cool thing about Google: They asked me to do a post-mortem to talk about out why I turned them down. I met a manager at a coffee shop and discussed my reasons. He also wanted to make sure that the interview process had been enjoyable for me, and asked for feedback on what they could do better. I was impressed by their thoroughness.
- cperciva 13y agoThey asked me to do a post-mortem to talk about out why I turned them down. I had the same experience, although for me it was a web survey rather than a face-to-face interview (probably because I wasn't local). Whether they actually paid attention to what I told them, I'm not sure; 99% of the problems in the interview process were due to my recruiter screwing things up, but she got promoted a few months later.
- ameister14 13y agoI totally understand why this is annoying and can sympathize. However, it was probably a mistake to write a blog post about it and put it around. Not because of any backlash against your future prospects or because you're now missing out on some opportunity, because that's not your problem. I just think that by writing this in the way that you have, you've tarnished your personal reputation. If you're fine with that, then no big deal. But from this article and reading up on you, I know objectively that you are very intelligent and extremely accomplished in your chosen field, have a skill-set that is in constant demand, and are somewhat foolish. If I were to complain about a problem almost no-one in the world shares, I would do it privately. This public complaint is particularly worthless since your complaint is likely not going to have an impact on whether or not some temp recruiter at Google will try to hire you in 3 years. So, it doesn't accomplish much for you, and it convinces a whole bunch of people that you don't appreciate what you have.
- pgeorgi 13y agoThe problem isn't _that_ uncommon. Google recruiters truly carpet bomb the market (as defined by LinkedIn, it seems) with introductions. I only got them off my back after stating (twice) that I have a life and as such won't move ~10 timezones for a job.
- founder4fun 13y agoWoW you are publicly complaining about Google trying to recruit you? Have you read how people treated this guy http://valleywag.gawker.com/startup-stud-hates-homeless-people-ugly-girls-and-pub-1150802451 http://valleywag.gawker.com/startup-stud-hates-homeless-peop... or this guy http://valleywag.gawker.com/happy-holidays-startup-ceo-complains-sf-is-full-of-hum-1481067192 http://valleywag.gawker.com/happy-holidays-startup-ceo-compl.... IS your goal to be label yet another arrogant/ignorant tech douchebag? That just might now happen!
- eksith 13y agoPeople seem to be missing the crucial point here. It isn't that they keep ignoring the "DO NOT CONTACT", it's why Google wants his services so badly in the first place. What does Tarsnap do? Think about it. Google wants to be bullet proof. Probably internally at first, but then maybe roll out the benefits to other services.
- cperciva 13y agoI highly doubt any of the recruiters who have contacted me know what Tarsnap is.
- JeremyMorgan 13y agoEh, I've been contacted by them too. Probably a large portion of the HN audience has. It's called throwing out a big net, it's not like they're personally begging you.
- victorhooi 13y agoHmm, I've had variable experiences with Google Recruiting. I had one experience which was very good, with a Google Engineering team - I didn't end up passing through - but they made the experience fun (good questions), and they were very gracious hosts. I had another with a Google Sales team in Australia - where they made me do some four-page online assessment, answer more questions - then booked me in for a phone interview at 09:00 - then emailed me at 17:00 the day before to cancel. Their reason - oh yeah, the years of experience we required has changed...
- gejjaxxita 13y agoI was contacted by a Google recruiter recently and have a phone interview set up now after a phone screen. Until I read this I was feeling pretty pleased with myself :(