5 ms·
From what I've read the problem is patents: Blackboard owns a huge number of them and threatens to sue any potential competitor out of existence.
by pcwalton 13y ago
From what I've read the problem is patents: Blackboard owns a huge number of them and threatens to sue any potential competitor out of existence.
- onedev 13y agoWhat possible patents can a shitty web app like that own?
- nathan_f77 13y agohttp://www.google.com/patents/US6988138 http://www.google.com/patents/US6988138
- onedev 13y agoWow. Incredible. Just wow....
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoOn a quick glance claim 1 appears to be anticipated by any networked file sharing system that includes user permissions you'd possibly need to have 3 users with differing credentials for a novelty citation but there certainly doesn't appear to be an inventive step beyond mere citation of, say, a unix box with files with read/write flags and user:group credentials. Claims 2-7 are just messages sent to a particular group. Claim 8 refers to a "dropbox" file which, certainly in the UK, as a trademark wouldn't be allowed as it's inherently unclear. Many of the claims are distinct only in non-technical details, eg the name attached to a specific role or the textual contents of a file. Such claims don't define the invention. This strikes me as a very poor quality set of claims. The clumsy wording of claim 39 "An method for providing online education method for a community of users in a network based system comprising the steps of:" suggests that no one at the USPTO read it. As a B1 this is supposedly the patent "as granted".
- ivanca 13y agoYeah; all the patent says is "anything the school and its student does over any network, that includes Internet".
- WildUtah 13y agoThat is in every quality typical of the patents granted and enforced in court every day in the USA. Pointing out that the claims were anticipated and are incoherent doesn't help much in front of a jury of laypeople.
- Edmond 13y agoI think it has more to do with the structure (procurement) and culture (ivory tower thinking doesn't believe in efficiency) of academia than fear of patents.
- rch 13y agoI would love to know what the more important patents are, if anyone has been looking around and happens to have a list.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nate_meurer 13y agoAs far as I know there was one main patent -- 6,988,138 -- which was utter garbage and was invalidated in 2009. It was this patent which BlackBoard used to try to shut down a competitor named Desire2Learn in 2006. The invalidation forced Blackboard to retreat, and they've since been much quieter on the legal front.
- rch 13y agoInteresting - Thanks. It's downright annoying to read a patent like that, and I'm happy to hear it was invalidated.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ajayjain 13y ago"against the development, use or distribution of Open Source Software or Home-Grown Systems to the extent that such Open Source Software and Home-Grown Systems are not Bundled with proprietary software" Competitors are not protected by this pledge.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]