6 ms·
Ethereum “Dagger” proof-of-work function is flawed
- aaron-lebo 13y agoThere was this response by one of the devs: http://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/1vh94e/dagger_updates/ http://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/1vh94e/dagger_upda... They seem to be moving away from Dagger: "We will switch our PoW from Dagger to a hybrid PoW/PoS system to be developed via a bountied competition conducted by our university partners and open to the general community for participation." https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428589.0;all https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428589.0;all Whether this instills confidence that they are agile and not ideologues or shows inexperience is your call.
- judk 13y ago> Although we have great talent as far as theoretical computer science is concerned, we have not yet acquired any experts in computer hardware on our team Note to readers: the exact wrong time to use an appeal to authority is this, the moment after your authority been disproven by facts.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- joosters 13y agoI suspect these attempts to design a computation that cannot efficiently be performed by 'hardware' (ASICs, or even graphics cards or whatever) are doomed to fail. Furthermore, they're essentially pointless. Even if you end up with a scheme that can only run efficiently on a general purpose computer, it will probably be through making the computation utilise all the features of the computer. Which means that the computer won't be very good at doing anything else while it is mining. End result: people will have to dedicate machines to mining. What end benefit does this give to the users or to the currency? People either spend money on dedicated computers or dedicated ASIC miners. (I guess, at least if/when the currency crashes and burns, those machines could then be reused for other things... but it's still 'wasted' on the owner, who wouldn't have otherwise bought the computer)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bhouston 13y agojoosters wrote: "I suspect these attempts to design a computation that cannot efficiently be performed by 'hardware' (ASICs, or even graphics cards or whatever) are doomed to fail." For sure. Each time someone figures out something that can not be done on current ASICs/GPUs, a bunch of smart people throw themselves at figuring out a way to modify the GPUs/ASICs in order to enable it. It is an arms race scenario, where these inefficiencies for 'hardware' are just temporarily.
- iSnow 13y ago> Each time someone figures out something that can not be done on current ASICs/GPUs, a bunch of smart people throw themselves at figuring out a way to modify the GPUs/ASICs in order to enable it. Well, yes and no. Litecoin was invented in 2011 and still no one has successfully built ASICs for LTC mining.
- wmf 13y agoThis was just released: http://www.gridseed.com/main.php http://www.gridseed.com/main.php
- dexen 13y agoIt's time to bring back the good old polymorphic code. If there is one thing that ASICs can't do faster than generic CPUs, it's executing code that constantly undergoes changes.
- wmf 13y agoMany people could mine on their desktop PCs (if they have one) while they sleep or are at work with little impact on their normal usage. The Bitcoin ASIC market has so many problems that the more mature PC supply chain would be a huge improvement.
- sp332 13y ago
- barkingcat 13y agoi think it's better to approach this from the other side - there are already many distributed computing projects like folding@home, etc that are trying to solve "problems that are cpu and memory hard" - and will realistically have no ending (unless one day there is no disease, or we attain world peace, find aliens, etc). How about we assign value and proof of work to something tangible? Like if your computer folds a correct protein that solves a problem re cancer or aids, you get 1 "humanity coin" ?
- aaron-lebo 13y agoThat is ideal but not especially easy. Hashing as they are doing it requires several factors: what you need to compute is not handed out by a central authority, it is hard to compute, and is easily provable once computed. folding@home and others do not usually fit 1 and 3. However, there have been some attempts, see Curecoin and Primecoin to a lesser extent.
- bmm6o 13y agoWhile protein folding calculations are useful, they can't be used as a foundation of PoW systems because there is no easy way to verify a solution.
- barkingcat 13y agoYes there is. It's the most easy way to verify - see if the protein matches with the problem receptor. It's pretty much black or white if something binds to a receptor. I think the perspective just needs to change. Maybe a little handheld "protein receptor match" kit that you plug your numbers into, and it will "make" your particle to try to match in a small lab kit that is portable.
- possibilistic 13y agoFirst you have to verify that the conformation of the protein is correct. What use is an improperly or incompletely folded protein with regard to ligand binding?
- 13y ago
- nly 13y agoWhy is Scrypt not a suitable solution?
- TheLoneWolfling 13y agoScrypt requires as much memory to verify a POW as to create one.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe author doesn't seem to think that's a problem.
- foxhill 13y agothe problem of finding proof of work is inherently parallel - embarrassingly parallel, in fact - and cannot possibly be anything else. so calling dagger flawed for being parallelizable is.. well, ridiculous.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- quantumcash 13y agoProof of Work and proof of stake hybrid. Mining to create useful computations as much as possible. Make produced resources available using the currency only. Proof of computing resources provided.