3 ms·
This has turned out to be overblown, as usual. More info here: http://www.informationweek.com/news/personal_tech/drm/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=218501227 http
by potatolicious 17y ago
This has turned out to be overblown, as usual. More info here:
http://www.informationweek.com/news/personal_tech/drm/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=218501227 http://www.informationweek.com/news/personal_tech/drm/showAr...
Somebody (third-party) decided to sell 1984 and Animal Farm on the Kindle Store without owning the copyright to it. Amazon is of course forced to take down said illegal posting. The only questionable part here is whether or not they should be allowed to delete purchased copies (with refund).
- olefoo 17y agoThanks for finding that, it sounds like that story came out somewhat after the story had already blown up. The detail that it was due to a self-service publisher who did not own the copyright is crucial. It sounds like Amazon could save itself a lot of the PR grief that comes with this sort of thing by posting takedowns and C&Ds on chillingeffects.org like Google does.
- habibur 17y agoIllegal or not, the purchasers bought the books from Amazon's web site, not from some Hackerz site. Amazon later discovered that the books that Amazon was itself selling were somehow illegal, which the buyers need not have to be concerned about in the first place. Then instead of informing the buyers of it's mistake, Amazon decided to delete the copies outright, without any notice and of course without any talk of refund to the buyers. That's what I understand of this situation.
- potatolicious 17y agoThen you misunderstand the situation. Amazon issued notice of the deletion (though did not clarify that the books were illegal), and automatically refunded money without the customers having to ask. I think they handled it as well as anyone can handle this particular situation.
- tdonia 17y agoto not clarify that the books were illegal when rescinded is nearly as grave a mistake as to allow them to be sold in the first place. rather than being in front of this and stopping these books from being sold - which was something they had every right to bar & would have been a pr conflict for exactly no one- amazon instead designed a system that allowed bad content to be sold with a kill switch in place so 'in the event of a mistake, it could be rescinded' - they deserve this pr storm because they've earned it. they've broken trust with their consumers on not one but 2 fronts here - foremost, they offered an ILLEGAL product for sale on their website. secondly, rather than explain the fact that this was illegal, they immediately attempted to go back in time and undo it - something that directly conflicts with a value proposition offered on the premise that books create memorable value and that their consumers might notice if a book suddenly goes missing. Amazon deserves what it's getting and we can only hope this will be loud enough to set the precedents & standards that define a better eventuality next time a similar situation arises.
- uptown 17y ago"He who controls the past controls the future. He who controls the present controls the past."
- throw_away 17y agoA better result from a CS standpoint would have been to purchase licenses for the legit copy, eat the difference in price and improve the vetting process so that books don't enter into the marketplace until their copyrights are validated. This way there aren't blog posts in nyt about this and your customers don't suspect you of doing something dirty. The book is 1984 for f sake. Does it have to be 451 before someone at amazon realizes this would be a PR nightmare? There were better ways to handle this issue, but they can still fix it, as they must have a record of which books from which customers they revoked & refunded.
- j_baker 17y agoWhether or not amazon is really at fault, this still shows a serious flaw in our Copyright law. The fact that: 1. Someone still has a copyright on this book. 2. That person can demand that everyone that bought a copy of it have their copy deleted. ...should prove that without question.
- potatolicious 17y agoI disagree with #2. #1 is a problem, but this scenario doesn't exemplify in a way that other more prominent cases already have (Mickey anyone?). As a copyright holder of course you have the right to go after people who have illegally copied your work. I see nothing wrong here. What I see wrong is the ability to preemptively delete this material without notifying the user first.
- joe_the_user 17y agoHow can you disagree with #2?? Someone had the copyright and they were clearly able to have the works deleted. QED. Maybe they weren't in their immediate legal rights merely by virtue of their copyright but their possession of the copyrights gave them enough other leverage to force Amazon to take the actions that they did. So by having the copyright, they were able to get the books erased.
- onreact-com 17y agoThat's why I prefer real paper based books. No book seller will break in my home at night and burn my copy even in case it was "illegal". ("Illegal books" reminds of me of the Nazis)
- kragen 17y agoSuppose China decides that it is illegal to read 1984. Should Amazon delete any copies of 1984 found on Chinese Kindles?
- potatolicious 17y agoI think China has become the new Godwin's Law - you're inventing a straw man instead of addressing this specific scenario. The illegality of the book here has nothing to do with political pressure or information control. It is a simple matter of someone who didn't own something trying to sell what he didn't own.
- kragen 17y agoTechnical censorship mechanisms are agnostic as to why they are being used; the technical aspects of suppressing an illegal text are the same regardless of why that text is illegal. If we choose to create a world with very efficient technical mechanisms for censorship, we are providing governments with greater control over what information their people have access to. Some governments will use that control wisely; others will abuse it. You have to consider both sides when you are considering a technical measure like this.