3 ms·
To counter that: what difference does it make? Are users going to abandon this service because the Android app does not conform to UI norms? T-Mobile are going
by untog 13y ago
To counter that: what difference does it make? Are users going to abandon this service because the Android app does not conform to UI norms? T-Mobile are going to start caring about this when they have an incentive to spend the time and money on it. So far that doesn't seem to be the case.
I'm the last person to defend Apple but their App Store review process will often reject an app like the one you describe. Google won't. So people develop better apps for iOS because they have to.
- tadfisher 13y agoMy objections come from supporting the platform as a whole, not T-Mobile's bottom line. As more popular apps abandon official design guidelines in favor of custom UI that doesn't work, it makes using the platform an inconsistent and jarring experience, and that hurts the platform as a whole. Really, I'm surprised that T-Mobile doesn't get this, as their business relies in part on selling this platform to customers. Google could do more, yes, but doing so would erode the relative openness of Play Store app submissions. They provide the tools and the guidelines, and that should be good enough. I can't think of any other platform where a straight port of another platform's UI is a standard or acceptable practice.
- MBCook 13y ago> My objections come from supporting the platform as a whole T-Mobile doesn't care. The same thing is common in the Apple world. I use an app all the time that faked their own drop-downs to the point that the 'labels' are actually editable text fields. They don't care. Been there for months and a few updates.