5 ms·
If I where a Googler working in SF id have to start seriously thinking about getting a PPW license. PPW is short hand for the Uk licence to carry a gun for per
by walshemj 13y ago
If I where a Googler working in SF id have to start seriously thinking about getting a PPW license.
PPW is short hand for the Uk licence to carry a gun for personal protection - and yes there are tech companies that do have staff that do that.
- hgsigala 13y agoDo you honestly think that carrying a weapon in the san francisco bay area is a good idea?
- BryanB55 13y agoYes. But clearly you have an opposing view on the right to defend yourself with a firearm. No need to make this into a gun debate.
- ThomPete 13y agoAnd yet you do exactly that.
- aaronem 13y agoAs far as I can tell, it's a necessary consequence of any mention of firearms on HN, in any context. There seems little point in blaming any one participant, in any one instance, for the perennial argument over what is perhaps the most immediately, or at least the most reliably, polarizing issue ever raised on HN.
- DanBC 13y agoFireamrs is only one hot-button topic for HN. Others include Isreal / Palestine; sexism; RMS; etc. it is trivially easy to troll HN. HN does not do well at ignoring trolls or not responding to overly-enthusiastic posters. (There are some exceptions to this where a person will carefully talk through differences in opinion to try to understand or communicate a point of view but these are exceptions).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 13y agoIf I am getting threatened by random loonies yes - just as if I had worked for one of my previous employers in NI I would have been very careful about who I talked to and which places I went. one of my mates is married to a DA in the USA and has had to "cheek his guns just in case some one tried to make the threat good. Don't assume that all us Brits are fluffy little things who will have a fit of palpitations when fire arms are mentioned
- danielweber 13y agoI can come up with lots of reasons for why carrying a concealed weapon is more likely to be harmful than beneficial in these circumstances. But why is it a bad idea to carry a weapon in SF? Are people stopped and frisked? Are there metal detectors everywhere? Are there pickpockets all over the place that will steal your weapon and use it against you?
- stefan_kendall 13y agoIt is extremely difficult to legally buy and conceal a handgun that conforms to California law. You also can't pickpocket a gun to anyone carrying it appropriately. Try to take a gun from a cop and see what happens.
- kasey_junk 13y agoWeapon retention is an extremely stressed training point for most law enforcement agencies (even over effective shooting in many places). That's because many LEO shootings involve their service weapons that have been taken (I've seen estimates in the 8-12% range). This is in a population that is trained in weapon retention. I've rarely met non-LEO folks who spend adequate time on the skill.
- BryanB55 13y agoGood luck. I'd encourage this even if you are not a Google employee. You'll probably want to move out of California if you want the right to defend yourself and family though. Getting a concealed carry license there is next to impossible.
- pavel_lishin 13y ago> Good luck. I'd encourage this even if you are not a Google employee. How come?
- BryanB55 13y agoWell you asked so I'll answer but I understand that a lot of people on HackerNews may not share my same views on self defense. Also to be clear, I don't think a non-violent blockade necessitates the use of a firearm. However, I think the topic came up because protests can and do lead to a handful of rogue protestors going too far, getting too angry and attacking people. So to answer your question in a general statement: I'm a firm believer that is my responsibility to protect my life and my family and no one else's. I also think it is naive to believe that I could never be the victim of a crime or brutal attack by someone equipped with a more effective weapon than my hands. I'd much rather have a firearm in my hand then a cell phone waiting for 911 when someone is clearly trying to inflict severe harm or death.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoFair enough; I respect your desire and right to do so. I don't think it's for everyone, though, so I asked why you wanted to encourage everyone to do it. Thanks for answering my question. I, personally, believe that I'm statistically likely to make a situation worse or possibly hurt myself if I own a handgun. So I choose not to have one. I might choose differently at a later date, depending on where I live.
- wl 13y agoSan Francisco almost never issues such licenses. If memory serves, only two people currently have CCW licenses issued by the City and County of San Francisco. Those two people who have them have serious political connections.
- refurb 13y agoLast I heard it was down to a single person. However, CCWs in California are state-wide licenses and many of the more rural counties are pretty liberal with giving them out. Even Sacramento is close to a "shall-issue" county. I've heard San Diego is pretty decent too. In other words, if you live in a county where you can get a CCW, you can carry it legally in the entire state.
- abritishguy 13y agoThe only place that a member of the public can get a PPW in the UK is Northern Ireland.
- walshemj 13y agoyes and there was a huge fuss when they put the BT logo on the car park passes.
- walshemj 13y agoTwo who ever voted me down around 20% of my ex coworkers I know in BT from NI had close family members killed by terrorists in the troubles.
- aaronem 13y ago"In theory, there's no difference between theory and practice. In practice, there is." The trouble with the eternal firearms argument is that anti-firearms types tend to be theorists (many of whom, in my experience, have never even laid hands on a firearm, to say nothing of firing one), and pro-firearms types to be practitioners. It's sort of like expecting a random Haskell programmer and a random PHP programmer to see eye-to-eye on anything, or indeed to be able to have a productive conversation with one another. In theory, this can occur. In practice...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ericcumbee 13y agoWhy is it that you think because someone has a gun they are incapable of acting rationally? If I were in the above situation I would not draw my gun with out feeling that there was a real threat to my life or property. And in that case I would rather have a gun than not have a gun.
- DanBC 13y agoRecommending gun ownership in response to non-violent protest seems sub-optimal. Perhaps a gun is a useful tool in that kind of situation, but surely there's a bunch of other conflict de-escalation stuff that can be learnt first.
- ericcumbee 13y agoyou assume that the gun is the first option, when in fact its a last resort.
- DanBC 13y agoBut I see recommendations for guns all the time. I don't see recommendations for de-escalation techniques. Perhaps this is something that gun companies could do to promote their responsible gun carry image? They could provide training programmes on conflict managemen and de-escalalation along with safe gun use?
- aaronem 13y agoOf course, and ericcumbee's point is well made; people who've never put any actual thought into what it's like to go armed are generally very quick to assume that those who do go armed see putting holes in things as a handy means of resolving any situation, from an argument in traffic to a panhandler begging change. (Far be it from me, of course, to speculate on any personal qualities, or lack thereof, which might be inadvertently revealed, by those who make this unwarranted assumption, in the process of doing same.) That said, if I am effectively trapped in my home by a currently non-violent protest which has as its manifesto the sort of manifest lunacy on display in the linked article, I am going to want to be able to defend family and self with force majeure, should matters proceed beyond noisy and foolish hot-headedness into an outright attack.
- mortov 13y agoPPW in the UK ? Really ? Post Dunblane, all handguns are illegal in mainland UK. The only exceptions are for law enforcement/armed forces. [We'll ignore diplomatic missions using immunity/convention exceptions.] Northern Ireland does have PPW (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_politics_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_politics_in_the_United_Kin... and, handily for this topic, an FOI response on PSNI website http://www.psni.police.uk/firearms_applications_ppw.pdf http://www.psni.police.uk/firearms_applications_ppw.pdf). Without getting into all the republican politics, Northern Ireland is distinct in terms of the legal system and status compared to the mainland (of Scotland, England and Wales). You cannot use an example from NI to extend to the rest of the UK. I'll leave other commentors to discuss how sensible it is to talk about bringing guns into what seems to be a pretty hot debate on the street. One comment I read recently which has stuck with me goes along the lines of "there is no situation which resorting to violence will not make worse".
- imroot 13y agoI have my CCW (Carrying of Concealed Weapon) license. In Kentucky, you must go through an instructional class before getting your weapon -- and you learn that pulling your weapon out should only happen when you're prepared to use it in a lethal manner -- otherwise the aggressor could fight you for your weapon. You don't get a handgun as a show of force -- you get one to protect yourself from imminent harm...and some asshat blocking a bus isn't putting you in imminent harm: you're in the bus, and hopefully the bus driver has already called 911 to get the person/people who are blocking the road out of your way.
- jedmeyers 13y agoYou will never get it. The only reasonable sheriff to issue a CCW in the vicinity is in San Mateo county.