19 ms·
Network Solutions Auto-Enroll: $1,850
- eigenvector 13y agoUsing your stored CC info to auto-bill you for an unrelated product that you never consented to be billed for is quite likely in violation of their merchant agreement with the CC processor.
- eurleif 13y agoIsn't it straight-up fraud and/or theft?
- meritt 13y agoIn the event a customer is actually charged for said service, it absolutely is. I have a feeling the attention they're about to garner will correct that prior to ever occurring.
- cookingrobot 13y agoEven if they don't succeed, it seems like an attempted theft.
- AJ007 13y agoGiving the amount of money charged, they move in to grand larceny territory. The fact that they had to force an enrollment means this "product" they are selling may either be non existent or not match up anywhere near what they claim it is doing.
- ceejayoz 13y agoIf it isn't, the chargeback rate they're about to have should do the trick.
- notahacker 13y agoI hope they lose more than their merchant account for this, (better: their status as a registrar, with their executives winding up in a US court) Who approved this and were they insane? The most ludicrous thing about it is that being Network Solutions is basically a license to print money (with industry-leading margins) because of a large legacy customer base who aren't aware or simply don't care that they've been the most expensive, rather than the only game in town for years. So you provoke them into caring? It's like being a casino that steals from your customers. At gunpoint.
- mey 13y agohttp://www.federalreserve.gov/bankinforeg/regecg.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/bankinforeg/regecg.htm They would be in violation of this above Regulation for banking. Chargeback through your bank would be the quickest way to both get your funds back and penalize them. If you want to make it a federal case that is also an option.
- Crito 13y agoIs there any chance that they can weasel their way out of this by having their lawyers point to fine print?
- mey 13y agoIn theory their ToS may cover something like this, but charging a customer for a recurring payment they did not agree too should be pretty clear cut. Additionally they did send a notification prior to the charge, but there is no prior authorization from the customer so that's shaky ground. IANAL etc, legal counsel could tell you if there is a case worth pressing. I only deal with this fun at work as a developer :) Edit: This is pretty clearly not an "error" in the system, so their legal team (if there is one) must consider the billing valid in some way. Full legal text http://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/rules/6500-1350.html http://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/rules/6500-1350.html Edit 2: A compliant either though your local attorney general or the FTC may be appropriate. http://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0341-file-complaint-ftc http://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0341-file-complaint-ftc
- _red 13y agoIANAL, however my whole family is. I doubt they could do that. People are often afraid of such fine print gotcha's but would almost always would not stand up in court. Contracts are assumed to be "In good faith, and neither for nor against any particular side". Meaning having a clause like 'oh yeah, in addition to your yearly fee of $10, we can also charge you any unlimited amount and you agree to pay' This would be easily deemed as not in good faith and completely in favor of them (as no sane person would agree to that). Hence judge would throw it out - which may or may not invalidate the entire contract depending on how shady the judge thought they were being.
- inglor 13y agoI actually think what he did (making a big mess out of it so it ends in HN) is likely the right thing to do, it'll likely solve the issue faster and punish them more severely.
- larrys 13y agoCompetitor of Network Solutions here. Impossible for me to believe they are actually doing this. And auto charging the credit card. Something doesn't add up with this.
- ceejayoz 13y agoThe official (verified by Twitter) Network Solutions @netsolcares account says it's a real e-mail.
- larholm 13y agoIt is also most definitely illegal here in Denmark, and probably a whole host of other countries.
- beat 13y agoNetwork Solutions has always had appalling business practices that verged on the criminal. Some years ago, they poached a domain my wife had registered with another vendor, by sending her a misleading renewal letter. That particular event ultimately wound up with them at the receiving end of a class action suit. I absolutely refuse to ever register another domain with them. Their business practices are about as evil as I've ever seen from such a mainstream company.
- Caligula 13y agoI prefer their other method of registering domains that you checked for whether or not they were available. They would then charge a premium to get that domain.
- dlubarov 13y agoFMI - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_name_front_running http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_name_front_running
- audiodude 13y agoAny information more recent than 2008?
- eli 13y agoI don't think it happens any more. ICANN added a nonrefundable registration fee and "domain tasting" stopped being such a pervasive problem. This either solved what Net Sol was trying to protect users from, or removed the justification they were using (depending on how cynical you are). Not sure I would ever recommend testing domain names on NetSol's WHOIS server though.
- JacobAldridge 13y agoAnyone else remember "Network Solutions Sucks Balls"? (http://networksolutionssucksballs.com http://networksolutionssucksballs.com ended up being registered by Network Solutions under this method.) Sadly, no longer the case. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=96408 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=96408
- delinka 13y agoIs Network Solutions trying to lose customers? How could auto-opt-in to a program costing that much be a good idea? Does anyone have a reasonable explanation from Network Solutions about this?
- zedpm 13y ago$1850/year for the privilege of having extra hoops to jump through and extra lag introduced into the process of updating DNS? Where do I sign up? Seriously, there is potential value in having extra security steps surrounding DNS changes, since that is a known attack vector. It's not clear that this is a particularly good way to provide said service, and the cost is prohibitively high for most customers.
- xer0x 13y agoNetwork Solutions has been doing other unethical things for years. This is a pretty huge one, but I'm surprised you haven't run elsewhere years ago!
- ceejayoz 13y agoI find it fascinating that the first year is more expensive. You'd think they'd want to do the whole "first year is cheap!" trick to catch people on the renewal.
- brandon272 13y agoI have an account with Network Solutions that they will not let me cancel without calling their sales team. I do not have an active credit card on file with them nor do I have any domains or hosting services. They send me e-mails every month trying to bill me for something that I haven't signed up for with language indicating that I'm about to "lose" my services (that don't exist) if I don't pay. They're terrible. It fascinates me because I wonder who the leadership team is and what the company culture is like. Do they decide to be terrible by sitting around in meetings brainstorming ways to screw their customers?
- wil421 13y agoTheir leadership team must be grasping at anyway possible to gain revenue.
- rhizome 13y agoHere they are: http://www.web.com/aboutus/leadership.aspx http://www.web.com/aboutus/leadership.aspx They have a Chief People Officer.
- primitivesuave 13y agoAfter quickly glancing over their credentials, it seems like the underlying problem is that the key leadership is entirely business people while the people with actual training in CS or engineering handle smaller responsibilities like "Online Marketing". In today's world of developer-friendly SaaS, they're doomed.
- smsm42 13y agoYou don't need CS degree to understand that charging somebody automatically $1850 for something they didn't even ask is not the best idea. I won't be surprised if eventually NetSol will find itself on a receiving end of a very expensive class action suit. OTOH, by that time those C-types would have probably moved on to the next opportunity.
- Andrenid 13y agoThis seems too ludicrous to be true. Is this something they expect ALL customers to pay? Even my dad who has 1 domain with them since the late 90s? I'll be transferring all my domains (only a couple, most are with Namecheap these days) + any domains my family/friends have with NS out today.
- roozbeh18 13y agoNetwork Solutions has been doing other unethical things for years. I used to search for available domains using Network Solutions to only find that the domain instantly had become inaccessible to purchase. I later found out they were buying the domain people were searching for , for a period of 5 days so that you wont be able to purchase it from anyone else. very shady
- rhizome 13y agoIt was called front-running, and they still do it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_Solutions#Controversy_over_domain_name_front_running http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_Solutions#Controversy_o...
- pixl97 13y agoI remember when this... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_tasting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_tasting got so bad in the mid-2000's that it was best just to buy the domain if you even thought you wanted it.
- YokoZar 13y agoSo why doesn't someone just programatically search for a bunch of garbage domains from them?
- prawn 13y agoAs a registrar, someone's suggested they can put domains on hold at no cost. Not sure if domain tasting is still a thing too.
- 10feet 13y agoThey don't even buy it. As a registrar, they can put a hold on it for free.
- bigiain 13y agoIs that still true? I though ICANN now charge some nominal fee (12c? 20c?) for domains even if you don't keep the registration past the 4 or 5 day "grace period"? (Not that it'd stop a truly evil registrar - if you can occasionally sell ~$10 worth of front-run domains for $39 or $69, you'd still be making money on 2% "conversion rates"…)
- philsnow 13y agoThey are giving out 9-digit unique PINs required for making changes to accounts, rather than using (H|T)OTP ? What, exactly, is that $1350 / year supposed to pay for ?
- cheeseprocedure 13y agoMy guess is the same legal team that OK'ed this.
- michaelhoffman 13y agoHow many domains are we talking about? It's one thing if it's $1,850 for one, another if it's 100 domains at $18.50 each. Not that I'm defending Network Solutions' horrible business practices here.
- llamataboot 13y agoFirst sentence of the article: I got an email from Network Solutions — where I still have two domains, originally registered in the ’90s
- michaelhoffman 13y agoWow. That's insane.
- hamburglar 13y agoThat someone has been a Network Solutions customer for 14 years (minimum)? Yes, that is insane. :)
- Vivtek 13y agoMy hand's up. In 1996 there was of course no choice, and after that I just never had real cause to switch. Eventually I probably will. All new domains, of course, go through Joker. I like their hapless Deuglish.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoAccording to the article, grand total amount of 2.
- jonknee 13y agoIsn't it their job to not illegitimately allow changes to your domains in the first place?
- toast0 13y agoYeah, but they're not very good at it, so they want to charge $1,350/year plus an extra $500 per year for the first year for the privilege of getting them to do their job. (see this for an example of them not being good at their job: http://www.pcworld.com/article/2053380/network-solutions-investigating-dns-hijack.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2053380/network-solutions-inv... )
- crusso 13y agoI love easydns.com. Not a big player AFAIK, but professional and very responsive. I wouldn't consider registering a domain with NetSol and wouldn't hesitate to remove any domains they house from them.
- llamataboot 13y agoHas to be other HN readers who have gotten similar emails if this is true (I know their twitter support person confirmed it is real, but the price seems completely outrageous to be true). Looking forward to the first person with 200 domains registered there to write here that they got auto-enrolled for a cool 100k a year?
- bjitty 13y agoI'm glad to see he's transferring to hover.com. I moved my domains there a little over a year ago and couldn't be happier. I didn't have issues with NS but had a lot of issues with Register.com doing shady things like this. Hover.com is about first domain registrar I've used that didn't feel shady as far as milking every last dollar they could out of me. Trying to up sell, etc.
- llamataboot 13y agonamecheap is also great IMHO
- k3oni 13y agoWould as well recommend Namecheap.com, really professional.
- arn 13y agoI liked Namecheap, but have had major issues with their DNS service. you can't switch off of them without downtime. So don't use their dns, otherwise you are locked in. which is kinda shitty.
- ceejayoz 13y ago> I liked Namecheap, but have had major issues with their DNS service. you can't switch off of them without downtime. That doesn't make any sense. As long as you set up the proper records in your new DNS provider prior to switching nameservers, there'll be no interruption. It sounds like you switched nameservers first, assuming the records would just transfer over?
- arn 13y agoNamecheap controls both the domain name settings and the dns (if you use theirs). The moment you switch the nameservers for the domain, they immediately purge the records from their DNS. So, when you point to new nameservers, anyone pointing to namecheap's dns during propagation will get SERVFAIL. It sounds absurd... but I've gone back and forth with support about it, with no solution.
- chewxy 13y agoI'm so glad I cancelled my Network Solutions account 2 months ago. I discovered they were still charging me for a domain I no longer was interested in. Unlike most other domain name registrars, they actually auto opt-in for automatic renewal. Pissed me off to no end. To cancel, I had to : 1) Find out that you cannot delete your domains or let them lapse. Gotta call them. 2) Call them. They will tell you to send an email instead 3) Email them at deletions@networksolutions.com. 4) Get a confirmation email, which you have to call in to verify. I ended up cancelling my account after 4 phone calls.
- sifarat 13y agois't it the registrar we are talking about, who would register a domain name himself, if you search it using their website. Only to find, you would have no choice for 5 days except to register it with them or wait for 5 days to register with someone else. 'douchebag' is seemingly an innocent word for this kind of business. >Back in December, the domain registration and hosting company tested a new system that would automatically register any domains searched for by users of its site. That system went live last weekend, meaning users doing a search found the domain they wanted became unavailable and held by Network Solutions shortly afterwards. link: http://www.geek.com/news/controversy-surrounds-network-solutions-automatic-domain-registration-572245/ http://www.geek.com/news/controversy-surrounds-network-solut...
- brianzelip 13y agoI've begun taking over volunteer webmaster duties for a non-profit beekeeping association (made up of non-technical >= middle-aged folks) with domain reg and hosting through network solutions. I spent an hour on the phone with NS getting to the bottom of some things and got pretty appalled fairly quick. If the org hadn't renewed their setup with NS a month prior to my stepping in, I would have canceled everything on the spot. In addition to a couple other points, they charge double what godaddy charges for a .us domain. (~$40 vs. ~$20).
- gcb0 13y agolol. They are the new AOL. scaring old people with threats into paying recurring premiums for absolutely nothing besides their own corporate incompetence. Also, kids, this is why you change your credit card info every year, at least.
- gphilip 13y agoOP says he will be transferring his domains elsewhere. Seems like he is in for more suffering before that happens [1]: A Phone Call is REQUIRED for Domain Transfers from Network Solution to Other Registrars .. Transferring a Domain from Network Solutions to another provider requires the Primary Account Contact to make a phone call to Network Solutions technical support (average time 10 to 30 minutes). .. Use of the Network Solutions website procedure to obtain a Transfer Code, by the Account Primary Contact, requires a minimum 3 days wait. (EDIT: Formatting) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_Solutions#Network_Solutions_Standard_Customer_Service_Policies_and_Practices_Confirmed_as_of_October_1.2C_2013 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_Solutions#Network_Solut...
- wysguy 13y agoThis was not the case for me. I recently transferred a domain from Network Solutions to Hover for reasons similar to the OP. These instructions worked for me: https://help.hover.com/entries/21240798-How-to-Transfer-a-domain-from-Network-Solutions https://help.hover.com/entries/21240798-How-to-Transfer-a-do... This requires patience; it took 2 days to receive my transfer code from Network Solutions but I did not need to make any phone calls.
- mgkimsal 13y agoA client of mine transferred away several dozen domains last year - it did not require a phone call. OTOH, I had a single domain a few years ago there and I had to call in to transfer. I still have 2 domains there and I suspect I'll need to call to transfer.
- jakejake 13y agoI finally got rid of my last domain on network solutions. There's a form for requesting the authorization code, but despite submitting it out multiple times on various occasions I never received anything. The support docs indicated buttons that didn't exist. I finally called support and they gave me the code right away - at which point the transfer button mentioned in the support docs magically appeared for my domain. I found it annoying but the guy I spoke with was pretty cool on the phone and didn't hassle me at all about the domain or selling me other products.
- oliversong 13y agoI just moved away from Network Solutions. Their scumbag business practices just keep getting worse. "Auto renewing" your domains and forcing you to call in to turn off auto-renew was bad enough.
- deepsun 13y agoHere I collected prices for domains (only what I'm interested in). If you did that too, I'd be glad to see your spreadsheet. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Amel5Zz4w7aLdFl1cWtvRjRtb1V3NjdBWUdRdFRhdUE https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Amel5Zz4w7aLdFl...
- 10feet 13y agoLook at http://www.crazydomains.co.uk/ http://www.crazydomains.co.uk/, they only charge £2.67 per domain name, the cheapest I have seen.
- adders 13y agohave you used them? looks suspect.
- 10feet 13y agoUsed them for years. They are great!
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoHow many years - the domain appears to have only been developed in 2012? FWIW they also appear to be breaking European law by not displaying their trading/registered offices address on their website. Crazydomains.co.uk seems to be a non-registered trading name (ie it's not lodged with Companies House) for DreamScape Networks FZ-LLC. That company is apparently based in UAE? http://www.auda.org.au/news/breach-of-registrar-agreement-by-crazy-domains/ http://www.auda.org.au/news/breach-of-registrar-agreement-by... : >"auDA has found that accredited registrar Crazy Domains Pty Ltd has breached its obligations under the Registrar Agreement to comply with the .au Domain Name Suppliers’ Code of Practice and all applicable laws." UK branch may be no better ... http://www.ripoffreport.com/r/Crazy-Domains/internet/Crazy-Domains-Took-money-for-a-domain-didnt-authroise-domain-and-did-not-refund-money-o-1069929 http://www.ripoffreport.com/r/Crazy-Domains/internet/Crazy-D... Caveat emptor.
- 13y ago
- tapmap 13y agocheeky fuckers
- beedogs 13y agoI left NetSol almost a decade ago. Their ludicrous pricing was bad enough, but this is basically a scam they're running now.
- busterarm 13y agoClearly from this thread I'm not the only one who deliberately chose to forget this company's existence over ten years ago. Talk about blast from the past. I remember having conversations about how awful NetSol was on /. in 1998-99.
- latj 13y agoI was thinking this exact thing. I didnt even realize they were still in business. Although they sound more like a Jesse Willms scam now than a real business.
- Tepix 13y agoSame here. If you are still one of their customers in 2014 and you are not a gullible noob, you are doing something wrong.
- poopsintub 13y agoSomething similar happened to me at one of the domain registrar sites. I can't remember, but I believe it was register.com or namecheap? I unlock a domain at the last minute to request a transfer. Of course they offered a lower price to renew it with them. The next time I logged in, I couldn't unlock the other two domains without talking to support.
- CodeWriter23 13y agoNetsol recently caused me a bit of a problem, they auto-renewed my domains for me. THREE MONTHS before they were set to expire. I decided to move my domains after that. If you look at their site "Network Solutions is now a web.com company". Seems like the new owners are digging deep into Netsol's bowels to get that extra golden egg.
- mmgutz 13y agoI've never had any issues with GoDaddy for domains. There are always coupons for renewals. I've never paid more than $7/yr for each of the twenty or so domains I have. Just make sure you don't have domains autorenewing.
- dangrossman 13y agoGoDaddy's the only registar I know of with a history of transferring domains to authorities merely by their request, without a court order requiring them to do so. On top of trying to sell out the web as a whole (helping to draft SOPA and having themselves written in as the recipient of seized domains), GoDaddy's not a company I would recommend doing business with.
- dlubarov 13y agoBut it's a pain to have to dig for the latest coupon codes every time you want to renew a domain for a reasonable price.
- dclara 13y agoThey will send you coupon on the renew notifications. Last year was 30% off, this year is 20% off, mostly on new products.
- smsm42 13y agoI had the worst time trying to move my domains out of Godaddy. I emailed them, called them, got codes, configured options, and it still did not work, and nobody could explain me coherently what's wrong and how to fix it. Fortunately, it was not a very popular domain, so I just let it expire on Godaddy and then re-purchased it on another registrar. But since then I'm never touching anything with Godaddy name on it. It may be cheap, but there are other cheap options and this one isn't worth it.
- 10feet 13y agoI really do not trust hosting or domain register companies, which is why I use paypal to pay them. But recently, they have been able to setup an automatic recurring payment when I do this (9web). There is no option when I entered paypal, but to paypal's credit they did send me an email, and it was easy to log back into paypal and stop this.
- goatse 13y agoUse your credit card directly, my experience is that disputing with paypal for non-physical goods or services is almost impossible for the buyer. Despite paypal's marketing, they offer virtually no protection for purchase of virtual items or services eg software.
- andr3w321 13y agoThere are plenty of domain name registrars that accept bitcoin now which is currently impossible to setup automatic recurring payments for. https://www.namecheap.com/support/payment/bitcoin.aspx https://www.namecheap.com/support/payment/bitcoin.aspx
- MichaelTieso 13y agoI HATE that they require you to call to transfer your domain. Every client I ever come across that still has Network Solutions I immediately transfer them out.
- dpcan 13y agoIs anyone else afraid to check their ancient Network Solutions account to see if they have outstanding bills for thousands of dollars worth of crap they never purchased or agreed to purchase?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mark212 13y agoThis is a violation of federal law, specifically the Restore Online Shoppers Confidence Act. Opt-out or negative option charges to credit cards are illegal as of January 1, 2011. So is using a credit card number on file for one reason (e.g., auto-renewal of annual registration) for a second product or service. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/8401 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/8401 Note that the law doesn't prohibit 30 day free trials, which is how a lot of SaaS products are sold, so long as that's conspicuously displayed at the time of the original sign-up.
- tjmc 13y agoOnly since 2011? This stunt's been illegal in Australia for as long as I can remember.
- jypepin 13y agoIf it's only for domain name, I would definitely recommend iwantmyname.com. It's a small team and their service is really great. Just my 2cents!
- verytrivial 13y agoAnd this gem from the foot of the email: "Please note that unsubscribing from our marketing emails will not affect important transactional correspondence such as administrative and renewal notices related to your account." i.e. Anyone whom DIDN'T get this email because they have previously unsubscribed are still going to be stealth-charged? Are Network Solutions TRYING to put themselves out of business?
- sokoloff 13y agoFar from defending NetSol here, but that's not what that means. It means that if you unsub from marketing emails, they are still able to send you transactional emails (emails relating to order confirms, existing business, technical support. Etc). It's actually what you WANT as a consumer because otherwise it would be too risky to unsub from a vendor. It's also part of CAN-SPAM (not defending that either).
- georgemcbay 13y agoTo customers of Network Solutions who are considering moving their domains off the service: When they (inevitably) recant on this policy, please continue your plans to transfer out of their service, even though the phone calls required will make it painful to do so. This goes way beyond a situation in which the company (Network Solutions) needs to learn a lesson about customer management and into the area where the industry as a whole needs to learn a lesson about what happens to companies that go this far off the deep end and the best way for that to happen is the rapid death of Network Solutions.
- rrich 13y agoWow! Definitely time to get out of there.
- aquadrop 13y agoI had only troubles with network solutions. I curse the day I decided to use them. I don't understand how they still got reputation of a solid registrar.
- tehwebguy 13y agoThis is almost as bad as ResellerRatings.com We signed up for something like $15 per month, a year later they upped it to $50 a month and we didn't notice. Still later upped it to $1500 per month and charged several grand before we noticed. As soon as we realize the prices gone up we reached out, The rep on the phone instructed us to email the CEO to see if he could do anything. He replied with a straight face claiming that we had been notified (as this notifying us is enough, we should have to confirm). Turns out the price increase had been buried three pages deep in a five-page mailer. We got a partial refund but not before threatening to chargeback. The best strategy here is to publicize it and then issue a chargeback anyway, the only reason that we pushed was that some of the charges were too old to actually charge back.
- shravvmehtaa 13y agoThe same thing happened to me. I keep getting charged $15 for customer support I am not ordering, and I can't get it cancelled. After spending over 10 hours on the phone with customer service none of them have the ability to refund orders... Never use them.
- rotten 13y agoHave you tried complaining to your credit card company? I would think if enough people complain, the credit card company might cut them off.
- gr2020 13y agoYa know what else is funny about these guys...go to their home page (https://www.networksolutions.com/index-v2.jsp https://www.networksolutions.com/index-v2.jsp) and tell us how much a .com domain registration costs, without creating an account or signing in.
- spartas 13y agoEasy, add a domain to your cart. When prompted to create an account or sign in, click on the little "Cart" icon at the top right. $34.99 / 1yr … $999.00 / 100yr edit: If NetSol still does domain name front running, they may now be the proud owners of correct-horse-battery-staple.com
- jrs235 13y ago100 years? I thought the max ICANN allowed was like 10 or 12. If you sign up for 100 years its going to be 100 years strictly through NetSol auto renewing. Ugh. Stuck with NetSol! Then after they pull the crap they did to OP and you decide you want to transfer you'd lose all those "years" you bought.
- elwell 13y agoI was really pleased with the instantaneous load of this blog.
- kiallmacinnes 13y agoThis has got to be a hack? or something. No company could possibly this charging this sort of money "opt out" is even remotely acceptable.
- mariusz79 13y agoDisclaimer - I hate NetSol with passion. Correct me if I'm wrong but don't the following excerpts imply that you need to opt-in first? "In addition WebLock enrolled customers will have access to a 24/7 NOC and rapid response team in the event of any security issues." "We strongly encourage you to take advantage of this security program and register Certified Users before the program launch date. Thank you for helping us protect you better." "To establish Certified Users and pre-register authorized phone numbers and email addresses please call 1-888-642-0265 Monday to Friday between 8:00AM and 5:00PM EST." "Replying to this email will not secure your services. Please click here to unsubscribe. Please note that unsubscribing from our marketing emails will not affect important transactional correspondence such as administrative and renewal notices related to your account" Key words here are - "established", "enrolled", "encourage","marketing email","not secure your service". To me it just looks like this is just a sales letter that makes you think like you have no choice... Edit: added even more proof that most people have trouble understanding what they are reading.
- Lazare 13y agoI'm pretty sure it's you that's misunderstanding the letter, actually. "Starting 9:00 AM EST on 2/4/2014 all of your domains will be protected via our WebLock Program. In order to make changes to your Domain Name's configuration settings you must be pre-registered as a Certified User. [...] To establish Certified Users and pre-register authorized phone numbers and email addresses please call 1-888-642-0265 Monday to Friday between 8:00AM and 5:00PM EST. Please make sure to establish Certified Users with authorized phone numbers and email addresses before launch date. To establish Certified Users and pre-register authorized phone numbers and email addresses please call 1-888-642-0265 Monday to Friday between 8:00AM and 5:00PM EST. Please make sure to establish Certified Users with authorized phone numbers and email addresses before launch date. [...] To help recapture the costs of maintaining this extra level of security for your account, your credit card will be billed $1,850 for the first year of service on the date your program goes live. After that you will be billed $1,350 on every subsequent year from that date. If you wish to opt out of this program you may do so by calling us at 1-888-642-0265." That makes it very clear. As of 2/4/2014 his domains WILL be protected, any changes will require him to be registed as a Certified User, that will require a call, and he better make sure to register as a Certified User before the launch date (which is given; 2/4/2014). And after this launch date he will be billed $1,850, and he has to call in order to opt out of the program. There is no ambiguity in any of this. He WILL be protected, he WILL need to be a certified user, they WILL charge his card, and he WILL need to opt out if he chooses. The only ambiguous phrase is this, right at the end: "We strongly encourage you to take advantage of this security program and register Certified Users before the program launch date. " Now, you could interpret that to mean "if you don't register Certified Users you will not be protected". But you could also interpret that to mean "if you don't register Certified Users you'll be fucked, because your domain will be protected anyhow but you can't make changes". So it's ambigious. But the proceeding paragraphs explicitly state that you will be protected anyhow but can't make changes, so I think that, in contet, it clearly means that the program is opt-out, not opt-in. More charitably, it's possible NetSol managed to copy-paste a few paragraphs from the "thanks for opting in, your protections start {{ date }}" email into their "have you considered opting in, it's awesome" email; the general rambling and incoherent nature of the email would certainly support this. But while we can guess as to what insanity led them to send the email, and if they actually meant it, I maintain that the plain meaning of the email is jut what it said: That protection WILL start on 2/4/2014, unless he calls to stop it.
- sytelus 13y agoSimple Question: Can't you just call your credit card company and ask them to void all of these charges? My assumption is that credit card companies are obligated to take off any charge you deem is unfair. It is their responsibility to find a proof that charge was with your explicit agreement. This is why they get to keep 1-4% of each transaction in first place. Doing this also had side advantage that merchant ruins reputation and loose their ability to charge like this in future. Wouldn't this be the least hassle way? Just 5 minutes on call and charges are poof! gone.
- spullara 13y agoThis finally convinced me to move the last 5 domains I had hosted there out.
- Pitarou 13y ago357 words before they get round to saying "your credit card will be billed $1,850". Unacceptable. This would be more honest: --- Dear valued customer, blah, blah, blah, blah, have you fallen asleep yet? We're going to charge you $1,850. You will not notice this charge on your credit bill. You will not request a chargeback. You will wake up when I snap my fingers in 3 ... 2 ... 1 ... and you're awake. kthxbye
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- benmorris 13y agoWorking with a new client this year and I've been coordinating with the old developer migrating their hosting to my hardware. Long story short the client wanted to move registrars also. Moving from Network Solutions required a phone call from the client to Network Solutions. They proceeded to confuse my client by explaining they really didn't need to transfer the name out, just request the new name servers from me. They also tried to up sell a garbage SEO package. I've never used Network Solutions, but the way they operate is ridiculous.
- blantonl 13y agoI think I have over 150 domains with Network Solutions and I stay with them only out of convenience. But each time I register a new domain name, I swear I am about to sign up for a bunch of crap that I don't need - their registration workflow is fraught with pitfalls and if you simply want to reserve a domain you must navigate a minefield to complete the transaction. Is there a domain registrar out there that simply focuses on domain registration? If so, I'd love to hear about alternatives...
- timmclean 13y agoI've been quite happy with iwantmyname -- and I've noticed their co-founder frequents HN.
- redial 13y agoTry hover.com
- platypii 13y agoI like gandi.net. Very clean UI, their motto is "no bullshit" and they live up to it in my experience.
- Tepix 13y agoI've been using INWX (https://www.inwx.de/en https://www.inwx.de/en ) for several years now. They don't get on my nerves at all and they are still helpful and knowledgeable. And most of their prices are pretty good.
- jaebrown 13y agoI saw this and had to read. I feel obligated to post after reading some of the comments. I've never dealt with Network Solutions until I arrived at my current employer, fall of last year. I've to say, that they're by far the worst in the industry. I've dealt with many registrars and I use to think GoDaddy was the worst until I came across these guys. They nickel and dime you for everything. It cost just to redirect a domain via their c-panel. Transferring domains is a pain, along with just about everything else. You'll definitely be talking to a sales guy when you call support and he'll escalate the issue because he has no idea what he's doing. The real support guy will also try to sell you. I work for a company that owns a lot of domains (in the 100s) and have found my experience with Network Solutions to be horrible. Lucky for me, we only have 30 something domains with them and I've been waiting until this year got here (new budget begins) before I paid the fee to transfer them all over to the registrar that manages majority of our domains.
- jasey 13y agoI can confirm that network solutions engages in this type of disgusting behaviour with my own experience. I have one domain with them which I bought through a private buyer. They had it with NS so I just stayed with them instead of transferring to another domain registrar. Yesterday I got a email about renewal which was nice and genuine. However throughout the whole renewal checkout process they added up-sell services by default. Also they defaulted to 5 years renewable. Finally their domains are $40 / year which is about 4x more expensive than other providers. By the end of the process I had been through like 4-6 "upsell" screens and had to opt out of about 2-3 things I didn't want like private registration and brand protect (registers all the useless tld's for your brand). By the end of it I vowed never to do business with them again. Im already being robbed at $40 / year
- johnjlocke 13y agoIsn't Network Solutions the company that got caught buying up domains that users would search for, if they didn't buy them immediately? Thereby forcing users to backorder domains at an increased cost? This post does not surprise me. GoDaddy isn't close to this bad.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoI thought it was GoDaddy that was caught doing that.
- blueskin_ 13y agoI thought they both were, maybe at different times. GoDaddy certainly purchase their customers' domains when they expire though, then sell them back at a huge markup.
- cranklin 13y agoPeople still use network solutions? lol j/k
- NoPiece 13y agoThis is my nightmare story with Network Solutions. We were running our business on a domain with Register.com back in ~2002. Network Solutions sent a "bill" for renewal, which our office manager paid without telling anyone. That triggered a transfer from register.com to Network Solutions, blasting all our DNS entries along the way. I was at E3 in Los Angeles and got the call that the site was down, and no email was coming in. I remember sitting on the floor of the convention center trying to troubleshoot over the phone what happened... I'm still angry at Network Solutions for engaging in something awfully close to a phishing scam.
- oakaz 13y agoCan't you sue them ?
- dangrossman 13y agoFor what happened in 2002? The statute of limitations on that's probably expired. Fortunately, they were sued by the FTC back in 2003, which put a stop to that practice. http://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2003/09/network-solutions-settles-ftc-charges http://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2003/09/networ...
- firebones 13y agoMy first thought: why this whole notion of having to call in to cancel reeks of AOL in the bad old days. So I Google "aol 'network solutions' executives" and find: http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Network+Solutions+and+America+Online+Announce+Multi-year,...-a061929194 http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Network+Solutions+and+America+... Relevant part: >>Network Solutions, Inc. (NASDAQ: NSOL), the world's leading registrar of domain names with more than 10 million registrations, and America Online, Inc. (NYSE: AOL), the world's leading interactive services company, today announced a multi-year, multi-million dollar strategic marketing alliance to offer Network Solutions' (NSI) domain name registration and value-added services globally across America Online, Inc. brands, making it easier and more convenient than ever for businesses and consumers to create an online presence. Interestingly, I ran across what I thought was a great anecdote about Jim Rutt, CEO of Network Solutions in a Barron's article this week: http://online.barrons.com/article/SB50001424053111904681004579326532181934464.html?mod=googlenews_barrons http://online.barrons.com/article/SB500014240531119046810045... >>The second inspiration for this memo came from a report entitled Alpha and the Paradox of Skill by Michael Mauboussin of Credit Suisse. In it he talks about Jim Rutt, the CEO of Network Solutions. As a young man, Rutt wanted to become a better poker player, and to that end he worked hard to learn the odds regarding each hand and how to detect "tells" in other players that give away their position. Here's the part that attracted my attention: At that point, an uncle pulled him aside and doled out some advice. "Jim, I wouldn't spend my time getting better," he advised, "I'd spend my time finding weak games." Seems like he found a weak game with auto-rebilling.
- drdeadringer 13y agoI'm glad that the worst hosting company I got in bed with was Yahoo. Maybe I'm lucky, but sometimes a little research with a little experience does a stress-level good.
- Suncho 13y agoUgh. Network Solutions is terrible. In 2003, I registered my domain for 100 years at $9.99 per year for a total of $999. Then ten years later (2013), I received a notice that they were having a problem charging my credit card for the domain name renewal? Apparently, it went into their system as a ten year registration. I've been on the phone with them periodically for about a year now trying to resolve this, and in the mean-time I've paid for two additional one-year registrations. It was basically a miracle that I was able to track down the credit card number I used back in 2003. I had to fax them various documents as evidence and now they're supposedly doing an investigation, but I haven't heard from them in a while. I really should follow up again. I hope I can get a refund for the remaining 90 years and switch registrars. In the end, I might just let Network Solutions keep my $900+ and switch away from them for the peace of mind.
- duskwuff 13y agoDomain registrations have always been limited to 10 years. If NetSol ever claimed to be offering a 100-year registration, they were either wrong or being misleading.
- toast0 13y agoI remember seeing advertising for this. I believe they promised that they would keep it registered 10 years out until your time ran out. Of course, even in 2003, the only thing Network Solutions had going for them was high prices.
- Suncho 13y agoThey said they'd automatically renew it on their end. It was marketed to me as a service that I'd only have to pay for once and never have to worry about for the rest of my life. Obviously, the opposite has been true. =/
- dschiptsov 13y agoSeems like famous "Darklord of the Internet " article got wide adoption. Being "successful" scammer is now considered a vertue.
- bebop 13y agoA different situation, but I was just charged almost $40 dollars for a renewal that I never authorized. Network Solutions is about to loose my business. As small a sum as that may be.
- georgemcbay 13y agoDidn't see this tweet earlier, seems to be Netsol's primary public response: https://twitter.com/netsolcares/status/425751251369095168 https://twitter.com/netsolcares/status/425751251369095168 "We are working to get you opted out." Holy shit, what a crazy response. "Working" to get him opted out? Like they are doing him some kind of a favor and putting in effort above and beyond just not defrauding him in the first place?
- brandon272 13y agoThis echoes the response I've received from them when trying to just cancel my account in general. I e-mailed them months ago asking to have my account cancelled. I was told: > Please be advised that your account through Network Solutions will not be cancelled or deleted for historical purposes. However, if the system determines the inactivity of the account, your Network Solutions account will be deleted automatically. Long story short, my account was never cancelled. I called them by phone yesterday to attempt to cancel again. The rep told me that he would have to "escalate" the issue to someone else, but then told me my account had been cancelled. However, I am still able to log into the account today so I'm guessing it hasn't been cancelled at all.
- protez 13y agoUnbelievably sustainable business practice. It's amazing that they've been doing that decades after decades.
- llamataboot 13y agoHere is the first update I've seen from the company (rather than just tweets from a CS person). Looks like the program is not targeting all users, but the top 1% of their traffic. http://domainnamewire.com/2014/01/21/network-solutions-auto-enrolls-customer-into-1850-weblock-service/ http://domainnamewire.com/2014/01/21/network-solutions-auto-...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoHelpful tip - your CC provider probably lets you generate single-use credit card numbers. BankAm calls this service ShopSafe, but it is very likely your bank provides something similar. Use it. For example, say I want to buy something for $10. I create a new CC number with a spending limit of $11 that expires in 2 months. Auto-renew, overcharge, try whatever you want. You got hacked and my CC # got stolen? Hacker can spend at most $1. You can also create CC #s with monthly spending limits (e.g., $cost_of_service+$1). Canceling these single-use CC #s is easy (no phone call - it's one click online) and because they are single use, you only affect a single merchant.
- pseingatl 13y agoRemember that in order to get a chargeback you have to tell your credit card company that you specifically want a chargeback. Do not tell them that you are disputing the charge. If you do not use the term "chargeback" they will merely contact the vendor who will then advise that the charge is valid. Under Visa/MC rules, if you ask for a chargeback using that language they have to give it to you.
- Cowicide 13y agoI've always considered Network Solutions to be the worst of the worst in many ways. Just trying to get a lot of their pricing off their website is a run down the rabbit hole. Even crapster Godaddy is more upfront about pricing than they are.
- bane 13y agoThis is so egregious and outrageous, why isn't this story a top result when one searches for "network solutions" in google or google news? Let's not let this die here in HN.
- PhantomGremlin 13y agoTo add to the chorus of "use this other registrar" posts, I'd like to add one thing: read the terms and conditions you are agreeing to. I did that quite a number of years ago and wound up choosing to use Melbourne IT, aka inww.com for my domains. They were one of the few that didn't have Ts&Cs which they reserved the right to unilaterally change at will. Of course, I've been too lazy to read their current Ts&Cs so maybe their current terms are even worse than NetSol (but that doesn't seem possible, does it?).
- blueskin_ 13y agoWhy does anyone still use Network Solutions? I think that by now, I've probably heard as many horror stories about them as GoDaddy, if not slightly more.
- arbuge 13y agoOn a smaller scale, I just noted that my 1&1 shared hosting account bill went from $8.99 monthly one year ago to $17.99, after a bunch of questionable security features were tacked on. Only way to opt out was by phone.
- robflynn 13y agoI have had nothing but trouble with 1&1, as well. (I don't use them personally, but I have some clients that used them previously.) What a pain trying to get anything done.
- rosslazer 13y agoHopefully other people that get this email will google it and see this post. I'm sure many non-technical people fall for this sort of thing.
- emacdona 13y agoIt's been almost a day since this was posted, but I still haven't heard of any other customers having had the same experience. Is there anyone else out there to whom this has happened? I'm having a hard time finding a colleague that is a NetSol customer -- so I have no one to ask. Can someone confirm that this isn't the only case of this happening? I'm no fan of NetSol, but this seems ridiculous beyond belief. I just want to know if there is more to the story.
- thrush 13y agoI think it would excellent if there existed a blacklist of companies that do this. This is clearly not an isolated incident (think freecreditreport.com). All we would need are the following columns: offender || evidence || amount || date
- bhartzer 13y agoDomain Name Wire found out about this program, directly from Web.com. Essentially, if your domains are within the top 1% of traffic at Web.com, the company is going to opt you into WebLock.
- watershawl 13y agoYeah, that's what I don't think people are realizing here. This isn't an issue of Network Solutions culture, but a result of Web.com purchasing them recently. It's Web.com culture.
- andrew2984 13y agoNetwork Solutions now says they will not automatically enroll anyone into the program. It will be opt-in only: http://domainnamewire.com/2014/01/22/web-com-weblock-program-will-be-opt-in-not-opt-out/ http://domainnamewire.com/2014/01/22/web-com-weblock-program...
- larrys 13y agoHacker news discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7105830 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7105830
- Nitramp 13y agoHere's something I just don't understand about this: How could anybody ever just "opt out" charge you money for anything? Charging somebody requires a contract between the two parties. That doesn't need to be written or signed, but there must be an agreement between the two parties of some sorts, verbal or whatever. If not, I could just spam the world saying "I herewith unlock you for Foo Service at $5000 per month, opt out by travelling to the North Pole and doing a waltz around it". Surely, that must be illegal in US law, too? How do these people not end up in jail? Or at least sued to death by some consumer organization?
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoOh them, I searched for PolyFocus.com and another domain using Network Solutions and they registered both the next day and auctioned them off to the highest bidder. They are nasty. I've heard some registrars do that. They check the search logs for anything good and grab domains up.
- thupten 13y agoI think I don't have an account with them. But after reading this news, I wanted to make sure I don't have any inactive account with network solutions. So I went to their website and did a forgot userid/password and entered my email address. It appears my email is on their system because it says they have sent an email with my user id. Its been about 15 minutes and I have not received any email from them. I have checked inbox, spam box..not its not here. I hope they did not activate an inactive account I may have with them or worse I hope they did not create an account I never had in the first place.
- puppetmaster3 13y agoHow hard is it for anyone to file a small claims? Not hard I think.