4 ms·
> The drives that just don’t work in our environment are Western Digital Green 3TB drives and Seagate LP (low power) 2TB drives. Both of these drives start accu
by justin66 13y ago
> The drives that just don’t work in our environment are Western Digital Green 3TB drives and Seagate LP (low power) 2TB drives. Both of these drives start accumulating errors as soon as they are put into production. We think this is related to vibration. The drives do somewhat better in the new low-vibration Backblaze Storage Pod, but still not well enough.
Another reason to avoid the WD Green 3TB: these drives aggressively put themselves to sleep to save power. It's literally a matter of streaming a video from disk and if the OS caches enough of the file, the drive will see there haven't been any accesses in a few seconds and stop spinning.
The video will of course glitch when the cached data runs out and the drive needs to spin up. Great design.
- B-Con 13y agoDon't use the Green line for anything performance related, even if it's watching videos. The Green line is simply not intended for that. I think it's designed to be an occasionally-accessed backup drive, or something like that. The Black line is the performance-conscious line, look at the corresponding equivalents in that line. IIRC the Blacks are 10-15% more expensive, but they actually respond.
- IgorPartola 13y agoI recently bought two Green drives for my NAS not knowing the difference. Do your research :). Having said that, the NAS is working out pretty well so far with ZFS running on top of them.
- frenchman_in_ny 13y agoI bought 3 Green 2.5TB drives for a Synology NAS that's lightly used -- and all 3 have had SMART failures in the ~18 months that I've owned them. WD just sent me a refurb'ed Green 3TB drive, let's see if it holds out better. I wish I had had access to this data before buying the Greens...
- dpe82 13y agoI've had 4 Green 3TB drives in a raidZ for less than a year. First few months were great, then I had to replace two of them a couple months ago due to data errors and another just started failing so today (literally as I write this) I'm replacing the other two. Don't use Greens for anything that's on and could be active 24/7. The aggressive load cycling kills them.
- erkkie 13y agoLike others have mentioned, please make sure you're using wdidle to regulate head parking. Also might wanna read this http://forums.freenas.org/threads/western-digital-red-with-tler-vs-green-with-wdidle-set-to-disabled-drives.11280/ http://forums.freenas.org/threads/western-digital-red-with-t... . Greens are dangerous in a NAS context so make sure you have backups.
- IgorPartola 13y agoOdd. The link you posted directly contradicts your point. It says that Reds are at that time unproven and that the Greens are the way to go for ZFS. Basically it is saying that ZFS does not require TLER so that part is not an issue. On top of that it is saying that the Green drives are both common and well tested.
- erkkie 13y agoI think I read it slightly differently then, the gist was that if wdidle is properly used, the drives "should" be equivalent (since they supposedly share the same hardware, just different firmware). Reds are made for a NAS context, greens are not. You may or may not make the difference go away by using wdidle. This does make greens inherently dangerous (when compared to reds).
- levesque 13y agoThere should be disclaimers about that when you buy such HDDs. I wouldn't consider watching videos a performance related activity. I say this is WD's failure at properly marketing their product lines.
- baddox 13y agoIt's true that Green drives aren't intended for performance-related tasks, but it's wildly incorrect to imply that streaming video to a single user qualifies as a performance-related task in this context. Blu-ray video maxes out at what, 50 megabits per sec? WD Green drives from 2010 have no problem attaining sequential read speeds of 100 megabytes per second. They'll manage 50 megabytes per second even with random reads. Also, I have streamed a lot raw Blu-ray files from my WD Green drives over a gigabit network with absolutely zero issues.
- justin66 13y agoB-con is confused. The behavior in question - the drive powering down right away - would actually occur less frequently if I were trying to do something "high performance." It's the fact that a single user playing mp3 or video sequentially is pretty laid back that means the drive gets a chance to shut off. Of course, you wouldn't want to use these in a server, either. Or for anything, really. edit: in response to your comment below, the reason you haven't seen glitching with your high-bitrate video is probably that it's high-enough quality video (lots of data) that the OS never caches enough of it to let the drive stop working and go to sleep. Or else maybe WD have altered the stock settings of these drives. They certainly should have. edit again: if you've had them for "many years" then we aren't talking about the same hardware
- baddox 13y agoI've had several of them in my home server for many years. It gets heavy use from 1 or 2 users (which as far as the server and drives are concerned is not "heavy use"), and has never had any issues streaming any content, from MP3s all the way up to raw Blu-ray files.
- lelandbatey 13y agoI am with you; i have a 1.5TB WD green as my main non-ssd storage medium, and it performs great. I put everything on there, movies, music, photos, Virtual Machines, etc, and I've never had any kind of (overly) noticeable performance problems.
- caycep 13y agois this the "head parking" thing? The Reds are supposedly the same drive, but don't have the head parking algorithm, with tweak able TLER to make them more RAID friendly, and their rates are pretty acceptable.
- deelowe 13y agoThat and spin down. Actually, the spin down might be worse.
- baddox 13y agoI have streamed hundreds of hours of high bitrate video (raw Blu-rays) from WD Green 3TB drives over my home gigabit network, and have never encountered this behavior. I couldn't be more pleased with the drives.
- fuckpig 13y agoI've never had good luck with WD drives, from the 1990s through the present. At first, I had no luck with Seagates, then they seemed to do pretty well up until recently, where now I'm seeing some radically bad results. I wish IBM would get back in the HD business.
- zonk 13y agoIBM sold their drive business to Hitachi -- which lead in these published reliablity statistics by a large margin.
- gmac 13y agoWell, IBM's HD division was bought by Hitachi, and they're the ones coming out of this smelling of roses, so (subject to what WD do with Hitachi's drive division) your wish is sort-of granted.
- fuckpig 13y agoThanks to both you and zonk for pointing this out. I feel my warez will soon be safer on a Hitachi drive.
- networked 13y agoYou can disable the aggressive parking behavior ("Intellipark") with WD's own wdidle3.exe [1] or idle3-tools [2]. Disabling Intellipark was literally the first thing I did with each of the three WD Green drives I've owned since 2011 (got two but one failed early on and was replaced), so I can't really compare their performance with this setting on and off; however, I can say that I haven't noticed the drives being parked more aggressively than similar Samsung or Seagate drives. I used the official wdidle3.exe under FreeDOS for each drive. [1] http://support.wdc.com/product/download.asp?groupid=609&sid=113 http://support.wdc.com/product/download.asp?groupid=609&sid=... [2] http://idle3-tools.sourceforge.net/ http://idle3-tools.sourceforge.net/ Edit: changed "aggressive spin-down behavior" to "aggressive parking behavior". It actually isn't quite clear how disabling Intellipark affects disk spin-down behavior. Edit 2: There's also wdantiparkd (http://www.sagaforce.com/sound/wdantiparkd/ http://www.sagaforce.com/sound/wdantiparkd/). I have not used it but it might help you if tuning the drive itself doesn't work.
- justin66 13y agoI looked into WDC's tool for this a while back and it totally didn't work. That second one looks worth a try, thank you for that.
- lutorm 13y agoThis has not been my experience. We run a bunch of GP drives, 1TB, 2TB, and 4TB, and I have not experienced them spinning down ever unless explicitly commanded to. They park heads for sure, but don't spin down. (These are normal GP, not AV-GP, never tried one of those.)