10 ms·
Snowden-haters are on the wrong side of history
- c7b0rg 13y agoGreat read, thanks
- pedrocr 13y ago>An actual spy would have quietly disappeared with the damaging intel, and no-one in America would ever have known anything about it. And chances are one probably did. It's one of the risks of amassing that much private information in a single place. You become a juicy target.
- tomp 13y agoI'm pretty sure CIA is protecting him very carefully, preventing him from having conversation with any non-US intelligence agencies, and preventing him from getting killed (which might trigger some "insurance" mechanism that would release the documents).
- vinceguidry 13y ago> preventing him from having conversation with any non-US intelligence agencies, How would they do this?
- tomp 13y agoI guess by being near him. If my theory is correct, Snowden want's them near him, protecting him against non-US spies, who would like to kill him (and thus cause the release of the remainder of the documents).
- vinceguidry 13y agoCan the CIA operate overtly in Russia like this? The Russians don't mind?
- pedrocr 13y agoI wasn't referring to Snowden. I was saying that for every Snowden there is one or more greedy analysts that will just sell info quietly and we'll never know. That's also why the idea that Snowden has caused a huge amount of damage because he alerted enemies to the US's methods is comical. The public releases have been heavily edited and the NSA knows exactly what data has been shared with the general public. If someone else has grabbed the same info as Snowden but just sold it quietly the adversaries got much more info and the NSA doesn't know it so they can't mitigate the impact.
- itchitawa 13y agoI don't think this is a valid argument. It seems to be "I'm right because I believe people in the future will agree with me". Maybe so but the author can't know that until the future comes.
- nmc 13y ago> "the author can't know that until the future comes" Yes, Capt. Obvious, we cannot know the future. However, we can think about it, and try to forecast. Maybe you believe the author is wrong — I personally find the text overly optimistic. But please do not blame them for trying to forecast the future.
- simias 13y agoIt's a circular argument though. Of course if you think you're right you think history will side with you. It's a silly argument I keep hearing more and more. Pro-life people are on the wrong side of history, pro-choice people are on the wrong side of history, anti-gay marriage are on the wrong side of history...
- Karunamon 13y agoTraditionally we as a society have moved towards more inclusive policies. There's a clear pattern. Women got basic rights, slavery was abolished, women got the right to vote, blacks got basic rights including voting, homosexuality officially no longer a mental illness, slowly the rights of LGBTs are being recognized. (My history sucks, so I probably got some of those out of order, but anyways.) Opposing equal rights does put you on the wrong side of history, meaning you oppose this socially progressive pattern. It takes time, but the pattern is still there.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoCan you give an example of a Whistleblower who exposed corruption who wasn't hailed as a hero after being vilified by those he exposed? Just curious if you have an example to the contrary of the clear pattern so far in history.
- Shivetya 13y agoSnowden is in no way equivalent to King. Never in a long run. King stood up to his foes, Snowden ran.
- dasil003 13y agoKing's foes were not the US intelligence service.
- timje1 13y agoThink of all of the interviews and articles that he's written since the release of the first batch of materials. If he had been captured.. then been kept naked in solitary confinement for all this time (Manning), certainly not allowed within a mile of a pen or microphone, how much more of the story would the US government have been able to keep quiet?
- Karunamon 13y ago
- 7952 13y agoIt is really a question of which group is most naive. Is the threat from terrorism larger than the threat of un-patched vulnerabilities in vital software. At the moment the response to these "issues" is mutually exclusive. Only time will tell.
- emiliobumachar 13y agoDo not forget the threat of high-level corruption in an all-seeing, secretive agency. Even if they are basically honest today, they may not remain so.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoAh the "terrorism" card. Remember that its been shown found a number of times (including by the president's own 'show' committee) that the operations in question were not important facets in discovering or preventing any terrorist plots. It also stands to reason that most of the 'terrorists' (People the FBI setup not withstanding) were aware of the faceless wiretapping and ability of the govt to get data from google/yahoo/att/etc in the first place. Given that there were stories about such things (to a limited extent) since around 2006.
- tomp 13y agoThat's a doubly false dichotomy. Terrorism is a threat, yes, but the NSA spying isn't preventing terrorism and making us safer. On the other hand, most people (AFAIK) are not concerned by NSA or somebody else exploiting un-patched vulnerabilities, but by NSA and the US government monitoring and controlling free speech and the resulting chilling effect this has.
- tptacek 13y agoThe NSA doesn't create vulnerabilities in software. (If you think they do, you can argue equally persuasively for the NSA's role in hiding aliens at Area 51). The strongest argument you can make about NSA's malign role in software security is that, by buying vulnerabilities from people who would otherwise sell them to vendors, NSA is retarding third-party security research and slowing the mean time to discovery for new vulnerabilities. I'm disquieted by that notion too (it's been a little while since I found the kind of vulnerability that sells for real money --- those are very particular kinds of flaws, contrary to popular opinion --- but I've had a "no selling vulnerabilities" rule for a long time). But I'm not naive. Most of the people who would sell vulnerabilities to NSA probably weren't in a hurry to share them with vendors anyways. And part of the reason for that is, vendors feel entitled to security research about their products, even though they refuse to pay for it. They were outbid even before NSA came along.
- throwwit 13y agoWhat's all the fuss about? I for one welcome our skynet overlords. Privacy is obsolete. All knowing omniscient corporations are the future!
- rwmj 13y agoSo I'll put forward a controversial, but hopefully true point: If you believe in the Rule of Law, then Snowden should be tried, and probably will be found guilty, for a fairly clear breach of the law. The US President is bound by the constitution to use every means available to go after him. Presidential pardons, although they are part of the US consitution and therefore strictly speaking part of the Rule of Law, are very capricious tools and not really in the spirit of it. Of course this is why we shouldn't have secret laws or secret parts of government, and national parliaments weren't doing their job to get us into this situation in the first place. And we weren't doing our job either, by not holding politicians to account and being apathetic about voting.
- KaoruAoiShiho 13y agoHistorically presidential pardons have been constrained enough so that it is in the spirit of the rule of law. The law uses it as an out in the cases of laws needing correction, same as the constitutional amendment system.
- Karunamon 13y agoI believe in the "Rule of Law" as a general concept necessary to a functioning society. I do not believe in it as a dogmatic application of The Law Über Alles, where the text of a law takes thoughtless precedence over the moral principle it was meant to establish. You imply such a thing as prosecutorial discretion does not exist. It does and always has. When one breaks a law to bring light to greater wrongdoings, the only just thing to do is pardon the original transgression.
- aaronem 13y agoSo what you're saying is, you'd pardon someone who broke a law against torture and saved lives by so doing. After all, the torturer "[broke] a law to bring light to greater wrongdoings", and "the only just thing to do is pardon the original transgression." (If you reply at all, you will of course weasel out of this with "torture never works and you're a horrible person besides", but I find it amusing enough, to point out that your argument easily justifies torture, that I'll do so despite the near certainty you'll dodge the point instead of considering it.)
- seanhandley 13y agoBest part of this article, the phrase "For the hard of thinking"
- sTevo-In-VA 13y agoHe should be buried with honors.
- alan_cx 13y agoWhat I think needs to exist is a similar protection government has, national interest. I think there should be, in all democracies, a defence of national interest. The law should never be allowed to obstruct the truth.
- jackgavigan 13y agoWhere's the national interest in revealing how the US and its allies' intelligence services target adversaries like China and Russia, international drug cartels and terrorist networks?
- cwp 13y agoI think maybe he means "public interest."
- talmand 13y agoFrom what I've seen a great deal of the materials released so far show how the US spies on everyone but the examples you cite, including these allies you speak of. Have there been examples in the Snowden materials of how the US spies on "adversaries" such as Russia and China? I didn't even realize that those were adversaries in the traditional sense that justifies such intrusions in everyone's lives.
- jackgavigan 13y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/15/us/nsa-effort-pries-open-computers-not-connected-to-internet.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/15/us/nsa-effort-pries-open-c... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/exclusive-uks-secret-mideast-internet-surveillance-base-is-revealed-in-edward-snowden-leaks-8781082.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/exclusive-uks-...
- talmand 13y agoI can't read the first article as it is behind a paywall. It starts with the NSA installing software in nearly 100,000 computers worldwide to conduct surveillance. I suppose it explains somewhere after the paywall of how they use that to spy on adversaries such as China and Russia? The second one seems to be more about the British spying on the Middle East of which they share information with the NSA. I admit I skimmed it but does it accuse the NSA of spying on adversaries such as China and Russia? So far, they just seem to spy on everyone.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't understand this article. Unless its author can predict the future, or knows a lot of things that nobody else in the public knows, they can't possibly draw conclusions about exactly what Snowden did. Snowden himself has made it clear that he took documents from NSA en masse, far more documents than have ever been disclosed in the media. How many of those documents have been released to the press? We don't know. But what we do know is, of the documents he gave to the press, only a subset have been released. In Greenwald's case, that's because it was decided that a titrating drip of stories would keep the narrative alive in the media and, not coincidentally, better serve the interests of the publications releasing the stories. In other cases it's because journalists have resisted full disclosure out of concern for its propriety. What's been done with the zero to a billion documents that haven't been provided to the press? Who knows? Have they been encrypted and stuck on the Internet as an insurance policy? Have they been provided to Russian intelligence? Were they stolen from Snowden in an embassy in China? Are they vouchsafed with his acquaintances? Does Wikileaks have them? Nobody knows. Including the author of this blog post. There are places those documents can go that will alter history's judgement on Snowden. For instance, if he offered wholesale access to US intelligence secrets to Russia, a country which painstakingly and overtly spies on its own citizens and routinely kills journalists (Barton Gellman is not in hiding in the US, for what it's worth), there aren't going to be any adoring spreads about him my grandkid's history book. You can tell by the questions that jump to my mind what I generally think of Snowden. But nobody who (a) is skeptical of Snowden and (b) posts on Internet message boards could possibly be unaware of how out-on-a-limb that impression must be, because Snowden skepticism invariably whips up a frothy swell of criticism. Unfortunately, the author of this blog post doesn't seem to have the benefit of a critical readership; it's clear that he hasn't actually thought through what's happened.
- Nrsolis 13y agoWhere I have a hard time with the "Snowden as hero" storyline is my nagging suspicion that he make very clear and deliberate attempts to place himself in a position to have access to these materials for the express purpose of stealing them. He was essentially fired from the employ of the CIA only to find another position at NSA. Apparently the CIA got wise to his attempts and shut him off. The NSA wasn't so lucky. None of this detracts from the disclosures of NSA overreach. But we would be foolish to discount the possibility that all of this is a huge smokescreen for a concerted and consistent attempt to weaken or expose US intelligence operations. The fact that an impingement of our sources and methods helps our adversaries cannot be understated.
- puppetmaster3 13y agoI am surprised if I see people trained in critical thinking not supporting the humanity hero Snowden. Just think of the immediate economic impact of US tech and US tech services not able to export. He is trying to fix that. And long term, if people don't have free will they won't work as hard. And worst, the information will be used for political reasons, not state reasons. The political party in power stays in power. (that is why THEY like it, the 10% approval ratting corrupt congress)
- futurist 13y agoThe only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. ~Edmund Burke As someone who wholeheartedly agrees with Snowden being one day vindicated as a hero, it's tempting to nod my head silently and move on to the next article. The problem is the critics. They will be vocal. They will openly condemn Snowden. Many have never done anything courageous in their life or stood up on moral grounds. Morality is just an antiquated concept to them. Just another word to dilute and distort. So I'll speak up and say that Snowden is a hero, and I'll take one hero over a pack of cowards any day.
- molbioguy 13y agoCommenting on the comments, not the original post. Seems to me there's some confusing of issues going on. MLK vs Snowden is not a reasonable comparison -- one was a lifelong activist and the other is a first-time whistleblower. Their roles and goals dictate different actions, including whether to stay put or run, among other things. Secondly, the issue of the legality of NSA actions versus their constitutionality is quite different. Laws can be found unconstitutional. So while the NSA was ostensibly following the law, Snowden claims they were violating the constitution. One does not invalidate the other.
- gms7777 13y agoRegardless of my own beliefs about the matter, which I'll leave out of here, I couldn't get past the massive logical fallacy that this article seems to rest on: The goverment doesn't like Snowden. The government didn't like MLK and MLK was a good guy, therefore Snowden must be a good guy as well.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe wrong side of a progressive history, maybe. If Martin Luther King is the benchmark for someone on the right side of history, I'd advise finding an online article about him, published on a major newspaper site, and reading the comments. He is still universally despised by the children of John Birch.