3 ms·
The problem with this, I think, is that people will quickly forget about the bad conditions that created the need for the stipend and only see the people using
by vinceguidry 13y ago
The problem with this, I think, is that people will quickly forget about the bad conditions that created the need for the stipend and only see the people using it for drugs. Politically, this works out to 'unfeasible'.
After all, isn't this almost exactly what food stamps are? Technically not a stipend, but they're pretty readily converted to cash on the secondary market.
- 1stop 13y agoAustralia has the equivalent of a "stipend" for poor, unemployed, students, single parents, etc. Plus free healthcare for everyone. It is a hugely successful program with a very low percentage of exploitation (i.e using the money for drugs, or contributing to unemployment rate). It has been constantly tweaked for the last 20 years. You don't need to look at obscure tribal examples within America, you can just look at Australia (a very similar society to the U.S) to see this is a good policy with extremely positive outcomes for society.* * I'll caveat this with, if you can afford it. Australia is in a super good position with regards to it's GDP/Capita and has been for the last 20-30 years, so it's difficult to say whether this is sustainable in the (even) longer term, or in countries without the same advantages.
- dllthomas 13y ago"You don't need to look at obscure tribal examples within America, you can just look at Australia" You need to look at all the data you can reasonably get. There are a lot of similarities between the US and Australia, but there are certainly differences. The more unrelated tests of the idea we get, the more confident we can be that our conclusions generalize.
- 1stop 13y agoSure, agreed. I guess I meant: Australia would be a more useful comparison.
- vectorsys 13y agoThe healthcare isn't free no matter how many times you people say that. But you're also wrong about Australia being "a very similar society to the US". Maybe at one time, but Australia has some very authoritarian laws these days - from gun control to internet filters, etc..
- 1stop 13y agoHealthcare is free in that anyone anywhere can go to a hospital with anything and be treated for it without paying anything. (And everyone who earns enough money pays taxes). You really want to argue that healthcare isn't 'free'? Gun control isn't 'authoritarian' it's sensible. Only with a screwed up U.S agg-prop point of view could you construe it as 'authoritarian', there is no mention of guns as a "right" in any of Australia's (or almost every other country in the worlds) constitution or case law... So could you justify how you came to your point of view? There are no active internet filters in australia... Though there is talk of them, and some ISPs filter stuff... Do I need to remind you about Wikileaks getting it's Amazon servers shutdown... Even if there was a filter in Australia, it would be 'closer' to the US not further in similarities.
- Kroem3r 13y agoDid you mean "agitprop"? It's been a while since I've seen that. Thanks for the belly-laugh.
- vectorsys 13y agoAustralia is very authoritarian. They actually confiscated the guns. not just made them illegal. They threatened law abiding citizens with prison time for not turning them in. Here http://rense.com/general81/ligun.htm http://rense.com/general81/ligun.htm when other authoritarian regimes have confiscated guns. Not only that, but crime went up in Australia. Obviously the criminals didn't turn in their guns. Australia also makes it mandatory to vote. Any kind of forced action like that is very authoritarian.
- 1stop 13y ago
- protomyth 13y ago"You don't need to look at obscure tribal examples within America, you can just look at Australia" Since the tribe is paying a dividend from a successful business to the owners of the business and Australia is transferring money from tax payers to "poor, unemployed, students, single parents, etc.", I do not see how they are equivalent in the first place. The tribal members are being paid for something they own.
- tjmc 13y agoAs Australians I think we should acknowledge that life is still pretty grim in many remote aboriginal communities here. Massive rates of preventable disease, low life expectancy, illiteracy, high domestic violence, drug and alcohol abuse etc etc. Lots of reasons for this of course and I don't know how services could ever be made as accessible to remote communities as they are in our cities. But I think it shows that the availability of a "stipend" clearly isn't enough.