7 ms·
The sum of all the positive integers is not -1/12
- funemployed 13y agoFor the love of math, this!
- ColinWright 13y agoOh for the love of - does this really need to be said? Really? I mean, of course it's false! It's an instructive example of how apparently reasonable things go wrong, and why you sometimes really, really need to pay attention to the details. Do we really need to be told that the sum of all the positive integers is a negative fraction? Of course we don't. I despair sometimes, I really do. I need to go away and spend some time in my happy place.
- lisper 13y agoI think it needs to be said because the people promulgating the falsehood are legitimate mathematicians. And most of the time their blog has quality stuff. But they dropped the ball on this one.
- ColinWright 13y agoForgive me, but I really don't understand your point. Do you think they believe it? This is proper geek fun with serious points underneath and a good smattering of why it's actually valid to consider these things. This isn't established people with proper reputations setting out to con the unsuspecting public. There is solid math going on here. See Terry Tao's recent blog post[0] about why we can and should play with these things. And now it's late here and I'm going off-line for a while. As I said elsewhere, I need to detach for a bit. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7078744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7078744 Added in edit: Just checking before signing off for the night and I see that the submission of Terry Tao's blog entry on this topic has been killed. By mods, flags, whatever, I don't know. here's the link[1] if you're interested, and this is me, signing off. [1] http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin-formula-bernoulli-numbers-the-zeta-function-and-real-variable-analytic-continuation/ http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin...
- lisper 13y ago> Do you think they believe it? Depends on what you mean by "they" and "it". The numberphile folks undoubtedly know that they are playing fast and loose with the rules. The readers of Slate almost certainly don't know it. > There is solid math going on here. No, there isn't. There is solid math going on in complex analysis where you have concepts like analytic extensions that produce unintuitive but useful and (more importantly) consistent results. But that is NOT what this video is about. This video is about using high school math to "prove" a result that is simply not true under the rules of high school math. The only thing separating this from outright crackpottery is that the result they derive happens to look like one that can be legitimately derived under the rules of complex analysis and analytic extensions. But that's a mighty thin reed. It doesn't change the fact that they present the result as if it were true under the rules of high school math, and under those rules it isn't true. EDIT: Terry Tao's article is excellent, and I am appalled (but, sadly, not surprised) that your submission was killed. Hm, my own submission seems to have fallen off the front page awfully quickly. EDIT2: I have been corresponding with an HN mod who informed me that my submission triggered the voting ring detector. (It was a false positive, which ought to worry someone at YC.) Also, the original Terry Tao submission has now been unkilled. I encourage you to upvote it.
- gus_massa 13y agoI hope that a good question makes you happy. I don’t know the details of the Ramanujan summation and don’t want to dig too deep in the subject now. What is the Ramanujan summation of S_3 = 1+1+1+ ... ? (With a liberal interpretation of the Wikipedia article, I think it’s 0.) Where is the fault in 0 = S_3-S_3 = S_3-shift(S_3)=1+0+0+0+...=1 ? Is the shift a legal operation? When?
- lisper 13y agoX - X = 0 only if X is finite. If X is infinite, X - X can be anything.
- gus_massa 13y agoThat’s what I secretly wished. If it where infinite then everything is explained. But the Wikipedia article “said” that it is 0 (because 1^0+2^0+3^0+...=1+1+1, and 0 is even). But the [dead?!] article submitted by ColinWright from Tao’s blog says it’s -1/2. (I prefer not to disagree with Tao, just fixed Wikipedia.) The problem is more deep. I should read the complete version of Tao’s article.
- lisper 13y ago> The problem is more deep. You want to focus on the idea of analytic continuation. That's where the magic happens.
- dnautics 13y agothe claim in the operations is that these sums have finite values.
- lisper 13y agoYes, but you cannot assume that the values are finite in the "proof" that they are finite. You have to prove that they are finite before you are allowed to manipulate them as finite quantities.
- 3pt14159 13y agoPeople believe witchcraft math because they don't understand things like e^pi*i - 1 = 0, so they have no faith in their own reasoning.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoWell... I don't understand the mindset of "of course it's false!" The first question that comes to my mind is "can I use normal-seeming algebra to make 1 + 2 + 3 + ... sum to a number other than -1/12"? If it's trivial to make it come out to anything at all, we can chalk it up to apparently reasonable things going wrong; if it seems to be mysteriously easier to add it all up to -1/12, it's worth investigating why that might be. I mean, we can apply the good old formula for the geometric series, 1 + x + x^2 + x^3 + ... = 1/(1-x) to x=2, and we learn that 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + 16 + ... = -1 And before rejecting that as obviously absurd, maybe we should take a minute to reflect on how the computers we're using right now represent the quantity -1?
- jonsen 13y agoHa, what a coincidence. It won't work for decimal 10s complement numbers: For x=10 we get 1 + 10 + 100 + 1000 + 10000 + ... = -1/9 And -1 in a decimal computer is 9 + 90 + 900 + 9000 + 90000 + … so … OMG! 9*(1 + 10 + 100 + 1000 + 10000 + ...) = 9*(-1/9) = -1
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> Ha, what a coincidence. > It won't work for decimal 10s complement numbers: I don't get why you say this -- you go on to demonstrate the opposite? This is just the other-side-of-the-decimal-point inverse of the well known 0.9999999... = 1 equality. One of my favorite proofs for 0.9999... being equal to 1 goes like so: imagine subtracting it from 1. You'll get a number which has a 0 at every decimal place: 0.0000000.... Obviously, the number with a 0 in every decimal place is 0 itself. Similarly, if you have your integer represented decimally as a bunch of coefficients (0 <= c < 10) of powers of 10, and all of the coefficients are 9, it's fairly straightforward to see that adding 1 will get you a new number for which all of the coefficients are 0. Since adding 1 to the original number gave us 0, we can treat the original number as -1.
- jonsen 13y agoI don't get why you say this Just a narrative of my own experience thinking this through :-) I thought "OMG" would tell you that, sorry.
- atmosx 13y agoG. Hardy had a hard time understanding it, and Ramanujan apparently knew it[1]. I'm not a mathematician, but if Hardy had a hard time understanding this at first glance, I don't think anyone should be ashamed for not knowing that the same of all numbers is -(1/12) [1] http://books.google.cz/books?id=Of5G0r6DQiEC&pg=PA53&dq=gratified&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=gratified&f=false http://books.google.cz/books?id=Of5G0r6DQiEC&pg=PA53&dq=grat...
- russelluresti 13y agoUgh. First, the title of this article is wrong because in the article itself the author says it IS -1/12, just not the way the video proved it. And, yes, I know in math that HOW you get the answer is somehow seen as being more important than the answer itself, but really? You consider this attention damaging? This is like the people who complain about Mythbusters because it's not "real science". Look, anything that gets people more interested in math is great, especially when it's a video as harmless as this one (it's not as if this video could actually impact someone's life or well-being). So drop this "I was the cool form of uncool before uncool became a thing" attitude and just be happy that people are interested in math for a change.
- jedi_stannis 13y agoNo, the title is right. The sum is not -1/12, there is no sum because it diverges. The Ramanujan summation is not the real summation, its a way to assign a sum to divergent series which can be useful in some cases.
- lisper 13y ago> just be happy that people are interested in math for a change Sorry, can't do it. Mythbusters actually is real science, and anyone who thinks it isn't doesn't understand science. But this video is not real math, notwithstanding that the result it derives looks the same as one that can be derived using real math.
- aortega 13y agoYou are wrong and the title is correct. As proof, I present you my hypothesis: "You cannot obtain a negative number by adding positive numbers." Try and disprove me, I dare you.
- Almaviva 13y ago> Step 1: Let S1 = 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ... Because it's not so clearly stated in the article, step 1 is already flawed. > the algebraic rules that apply to regular numbers do not apply to non-converging infinite sums I'm sure the author knows this but they don't even apply to all converging infinite sums. (Only absolutely converging ones.) E.g. 1 - 1/2 + 1/3 - 1/4 ... converges to a value, but you can also re-arrange the terms to get any value you want.
- lisper 13y agoActually, I didn't know that. And it surprises me, actually. Intuitively I would have guessed that converging infinite sums would be well-behaved under normal algebraic manipulations. But you learn something new every day :-) Can you point me to a reference?
- ufo 13y agoI guess any introduction to real analysis should cover that. http://www.amazon.com/Calculus-Vol-One-Variable-Introduction-Algebra/dp/0471000051 http://www.amazon.com/Calculus-Vol-One-Variable-Introduction... Unfortunately, I don't know any online references out of the top of my mind.
- gus_massa 13y agoThe problem is that 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ... is not convergent. The sum is not infinite, but it’s neither a finite number, simply “not exist”. The correct method is to calculate the partial sum of the first N term: S_N=sum_{n=1}_N (-1)^n. When N is even the amount of 1 and -1 are equal and the partial sum is 0. When N is odd then there is an additional 1 and the partial sum is 1. So the partial sum has no limit and then 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ... is not convergent. Conditionally convergent series like 1-1/2+1/3-1/4+1/5-1/6+ ... =ln(2) are much better. (The problem is that 1+1/2+1/3+1/4+1/5+1/6+ ... = infinity.) You can operate with them almost freely, but you can’t rearrange the order of an infinite number of term. The unconditionally convergent series like 1+1/4+1/9+1/16+...=pi^2/6 are almost like finite summations. You can do whatever sensible operation you want and the result will be correct.
- dmunoz 13y agoAhhhh.... this is one of my biggest pet peeves. We're using the same words to mean wildly different things, and then arguing past each other about meaning. Every discussion thread I have seen on the matter has quickly brought up the relevant actual semantics, but people still want to argue. It's a shame that ColinWright's post, linked by him below, got nuked by the moderators because it contains the most relevant information on the matter directly from an accredited mathematics professor, Terry Tao [0]. This is what should gratifies one's intellectual curiosity, not a series of posts that argue about the boring parts. [0] http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin-formula-bernoulli-numbers-the-zeta-function-and-real-variable-analytic-continuation/ http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin...
- gus_massa 13y agoTwo additional details: * Terence Tao got the Fields Medal in 2006 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terence_Tao http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terence_Tao * ColinWright's post is now undead.
- twotwotwo 13y agoThe really interesting point, or at least what struck me when I first heard about this, is that there are alternative, useful, counterintuitive notions of ideas things that folks might think they have some intuitive grasp of. There's more to math (and not only the parts you _know_ you don't know about) than is dreamt of in one's philosophy.
- Iv 13y agoMath is mostly about exploring the consequences of alternative definitions for notions we take for granted. In this case, it is the equality notion that is used in a different fashion
- rtpg 13y agoThis is a non-proof based only off of notational styles. Let s be a series , with s_n = sum (1 to n, 1) = n if S3 exists (i.e. lim n->infinity s_n exists), then the series (s-s) (where (s-s)_n = s_n - s_n) converges , and it converges towards S3 - S3 (=0). > = (1 + 1 + 1 + 1 ...) - (0 + 1 + 1 + 1 ...) the series whose sum he's describing here is not (s-s), but another one entirely : u where u_1 = s_1, u_n+1= s_n+1-s_n These are different series, so it is entirely reasonable for them to converge at different values, 1 doesn't equal 0. The "real" reason this result isn't what we think it is(apart from "infinite sums are different" argument, which is a non-answer): >Step 1: Let S = 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 ... What you're doing here firstly, is saying that "I assume that this sum converges, let S be the value it converges to". So you end up proving (if the other steps weren't also flawed) that S = -1/12, all you're saying is that if the sum exists, then it is -1/12. The issue here depends on what sort of thing you're working on. The "classic" definition of a limit (convergence of a series) does not work here, because you can prove that for all n, the sum of n numbers will always be at least -1/12 away from -1/12 (on account of it being positive), so it can't converge to -1/12 (hence S not existing). However, there are techniques for assigning limits to divergent sums. these summability methods will give the same result as the classic analysis for convergent series, but will also give values for some divergent series. It is similar to analytic continuation( f(x) doesn't exist, but a limit exists in x both from the left and to the right (named y), so we sometimes say that f(x)=y ), in that it allows us to extend the resolution domain slightly. But the classic definition no longer works. The one used here is zeta function regularization, which consists in the following: you have a series a , and a function Za(s) = (1/a1^s)+(1/a2^s)+(1/a3^s)+(1/a4^s)+..... Za is only defined for certain values of s depending on the series. But for a serie representing a convergent sum, we know that Za(-1)= a1+a2+a3+... exists. So this method will give the same limit for convergent sums as the classical method. For a series with a diverging sum (a_n)=n, Za(-1) doesn't exist, but the limit in -1 exists from both ends (by analytic continuation), so we extend the domain of Za to -1 by the value of this "limit" : -1/12 The article mentions Ramanujan summation, but Zeta regularization is actually a much more useful tool. In
- werner34 13y agoI didn't watch the numberphile video and just read this. Can someone explain to me why I am allowed to add a padding zero at the start without taking it out at the end? By adding it, I am giving the sum an offset, and I can kind of understand why adding zero is not a big deal, but they reasoned: Then S1 + S1 = (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) + (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) + (0 + 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (1 + 0) + (1 - 1) + (1 - 1) .... = 1 + 0 + 0 ... = 1 But I might as well leave the leading Zero out and argue that: Then S1 + S1 = (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) + (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) + (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (1 + 1) + ( -1 - 1) + (1 + 1) .... = (2 - 2) + (2 - 2) + (2 - 2)... = 0
- 14113 13y agoThat's the point! Using the algebra from the article: (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = 0 + (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) and therefore: (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (0 + 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) And as they're mathematically the same (again, in the article's algebra), why not replace one with the other? The problem is that when you do, and you sum the two infinite series using the "zipping" method (as in the numberphile video) the two equations equate to different results.
- werner34 13y agoAlright, got it. Thanks!
- lisper 13y ago> Can someone explain to me why I am allowed to add a padding zero at the start without taking it out at the end? Because there is no "end". These are infinite series. > But I might as well leave the leading Zero out and argue that: Yes, exactly, that's the whole point. You cannot manipulate non-convergent series in this way if you want consistent results.
- werner34 13y agoCheers, thanks!
- coldcode 13y agoThe answer is clearly 42. Monkeying with infinity allows you to derive any answer you like and I like 42.
- csomar 13y ago= (1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) + (0 + 1 - 1 + 1 - 1 ...) = (1 + 0) + (1 - 1) + (1 - 1) .... I can't get this part.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- paradoja 13y agoJust add 0 in front of the second sum. 0 + x = x, so it is the same.
- lisper 13y agoYou're just adding the elements of the two series pair-wise (which "works" because addition is commutative and associative). Here are a few additional intermediate steps: = (1 + -1 + 1 + -1 ...) + (0 + 1 + -1 + 1 ...) = (1 + 0) + (-1 + 1) + (1 + -1) + (-1 + 1) ...
- bren2013 13y agoI didn't feel like signing up for a Blogger account, but I still wanted to drop this here: > My friend, Ray Sidney, with a PhD in mathematics from MIT explained away this nonsense rather succinctly. > infinity + 7 = infinity > If you minus infinity from both sides, you can tell the world 7 = 0! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_sphere#Arithmetic_operations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_sphere#Arithmetic_opera... infinity - infinity (along with a few others) is very often left undefined for this very reason--not to mention it lets you divide by zero without breaking math.