4 ms·
Someone should try a similar experiment: "Unemployed Homebuilder poses as Software Engineer on Jobs Site, OMFG too many recruiters". Or "Poor Indian wears Fair
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Someone should try a similar experiment: "Unemployed Homebuilder poses as Software Engineer on Jobs Site, OMFG too many recruiters".
Or "Poor Indian wears Fair&Handsome and poses as Rich Western Tourist, barely lasts two hours before getting annoyed by beggars".
Related thoughts from the often interesting Scott Alexander: http://squid314.livejournal.com/327849.html http://squid314.livejournal.com/327849.html http://squid314.livejournal.com/327957.html http://squid314.livejournal.com/327957.html
(Yes, I'm one of those big jerks who has as much sympathy for the sexually deprived as the monetarily deprived, which is not a huge amount. Feel free to make status-lowering comments in response.)
- timje1 13y agoNo need to comment if we simply disagree. That's what downvoting was made for!
- chippy 13y agomany hacker news members are unable to downvote. There is some kind of threshold limit based on account age. My account was created about 1000 days ago, and my karma is 182. I am unable to downvote at this time, because I lurked for long part of that 1000 days.
- taspeotis 13y agoLast time I checked it was karma-based [1] and you needed 1,000 internet points before you could downvote. [1] http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- chippy 13y agoYeah that FAQ doesn't quite answer that, but the unofficial one does: http://jacquesmattheij.com/The+Unofficial+HN+FAQ http://jacquesmattheij.com/The+Unofficial+HN+FAQ Edits: Yes, that doesn't have anything about some kind of ratio though... just that there is a threshold. Thank you :)
- skrebbel 13y agoNo it wasn't. Downvotes are for comments that are below HN standards. Comments are for disagreeing.
- gruseom 13y agoNo, timje1 had it right. PG has repeatedly stated that downvotes are ok for disagreeing. Comments are for when you have something substantive to say.
- rjknight 13y agoI don't get it. Let's take your software engineer example. Software engineers often do complain about spam from recruiters, in cases where the recruiters: a) Plainly have not taken your skills or location or pay grade into consideration b) Refuse to take "no" for an answer c) Turn hostile or somehow imply that you owe them your time or should be grateful for their attention And we generally assume that the engineers are correct in their complaints. I can't say I've ever seen recruiters being abusive, but I have heard voicemail messages that start with "I know you said not to call you again, but...", and there's really no question about who is in the wrong there. Whether it's actually important is a different question. I get a fair few pointless enquiries via LinkedIn, and I ignore them. I can't say that it troubles me much. But if the people sending those messages were insulting me, making sexually explicit statements or generally being persistent beyond all efforts to make them stop, I would probably feel much more strongly about it. What puzzles me is that the behaviour of the recruiters does make at least some sense in a way that the dating site behaviour doesn't. Sure, getting a job spec for a senior Java developer and then mailing everyone with "senior [something] developer" in their past job titles on LinkedIn is going to fail quite often, as you'll hit Senior Python Developers and Senior C++ Developers and so on, but sooner or later the recruiter has to get lucky. But who the hell responds positively to the kinds of comments that the OP received? Are the people sending the messages doing so because they believe that sooner or later it's going to work? Even worse, does it actually work sometimes? I can't easily believe that it does, but it's hard to understand the behaviour otherwise.
- cm2012 13y agoMy wife has a friend who is forty and has never had "luck with men" for long term relationships. I can easily see why now. My wife and her worked together and made a thoughtful post on Craigslist for an invitation to a thanksgiving dinner date, with a picture and lots of personality description. It actually worked - we got 40 applicants and half were decent guys, and 10 were attractive to her in looks and had thoughtful messages. She ended up only contacting one back who aaid, "Hey baby you hot whats up?" or something like that. I've seen this many times now and have no sympathy anymore when they turn out to be assholes.
- 13y ago