7 ms·
Let me tell you how things work in the real world. When the people with money say "we want this", you don't argue. It doesn't matter if it's technically infeas
by bitwize 13y ago
Let me tell you how things work in the real world.
When the people with money say "we want this", you don't argue. It doesn't matter if it's technically infeasible. It doesn't matter if it won't have the intended effect. When the people with money want something, YOU GIVE IT TO THEM. And let them deal with the consequences. Otherwise, you won't get the business, and life can otherwise be made very, very difficult for you.
The people who run Hollywood have lots of money to play with. The people who run the Web companies want a piece of that action. Hollywood says "no can do unless we have reasonable assurance that due diligence has been done to prevent piracy -- that means DRM." DRM isn't really about being effective -- it's about providing a nominal barrier to piracy that will dissuade casual pirates outright, and in the case of serious pirates, provides something that can be "broken" so the studios can go after the person who broke it with civil and criminal copyright infringement claims. Now you know why the DMCA anticircumvention provisions exist: so the copyright industry can do with the law what DRM alone couldn't do.
So the Web either gets DRM, or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it.
Money shapes reality in this world.
- duncan_bayne 13y ago> or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it. What's wrong with that scenario, exactly?
- espadrine 13y ago>> or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it. > What's wrong with that scenario, exactly? Nothing. It's the current scenario. It can bother users, but overall it bothers big media, because piracy is active and well on those proprietary platforms. That's the complaint we hear from them. There's a large part of W3C that want change so that people with disabilities (such as poor vision) can enjoy big media products. Of course, that assumes that big media cares about implementing the ARIA stuff. I personally believe that their not caring in the past, on proprietary platforms, is an indication of what they'll do in the future, on the Web.
- onli 13y agoLet me tell you something about the state of the real world: The content Hollywood produces is already fully available on the Web. They try to fight that, but they lose. So the w3c is in no position where it is necessary to accommodate them to get their content. Besides, for the w3c, where is the business incentive, where is the money involved?
- flavor8 13y ago> The content Hollywood produces is already fully available on the Web. For people willing to pirate, it, yes. However, it's far less convenient to pirate movies and get them to your big screen TV than it was to use napster and listen to songs on your mp3 player. On the flip side, Netflix (i.e. content with DRM) accounts for roughly 1/3 of nightly internet traffic in the US. DRM facilitates consumer access to restricted content. > Besides, for the w3c, where is the business incentive, where is the money involved? The w3c is primarily an industry group. The players pushing DRM in HTML5 are Google, Netflix and Microsoft, all of whom have a business interest in being able to stream content via browsers.
- esteb_li 13y agoI don't think it's the DRM that facilitate anything. DRM is a tradeoff between pirated stuff and going to the theater. Netflix is a legal Napster while Hollywood are content with DRM as good enough protection.
- smsm42 13y agoThe problem here it does not dissuade anybody. All TV content is available on torrents within hours of the release. All movies appear on torrents sometimes before, sometimes within days of theatrical release. Technical knowledge that is needed to obtain this content is pretty much downloading one piece of software and clicking one link. >>> or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it. Let them. They will spend tons of money on it and all those money will go down the drain once somebody wakes up and understands that treating customers as customers is better than treating them as enemies.
- Nursie 13y ago>> When the people with money say "we want this", you don't argue. It doesn't matter if it's technically infeasible. It doesn't matter if it won't have the intended effect. When the people with money want something, YOU GIVE IT TO THEM. Strange how the general public don't get DRM-free movies from hollywood... Either way, my point was exactly about 'Hollywood', if you want to call them that, it's them that are delusional about their ability to protect content with DRM. >> Money shapes reality in this world. In this case it sems to propagate delusions.
- talmand 13y agoThe general public doesn't have an issue with DRM, they happily purchase the content as-is today. They may grumble when they have to purchase a movie for the second or third time but they continue to do so. Therefore the public, being people with money, have stated overwhelmingly that they want content without stipulating anything about DRM, free or otherwise. You are attempting to apply your viewpoint on the general public, which clearly does not agree with you. As for your statement that Hollywood is being delusional about DRM being able to prevent piracy. They are not delusional about it at all. They know exactly what's going on. They want DRM that prevents casual copying so that Uncle Bob doesn't give a copy of the latest movie to his entire family which is not an attempt at monetary gain. That way they only have to spend money going after serious piracy efforts that exist for the purpose of making money. Your statement assumes that Hollywood is being run by stupid people and that's a serious mistake to make in this type of debate.
- Nursie 13y ago>> The general public doesn't have an issue with DRM, they happily purchase the content as-is today. Do they? >> They may grumble when they have to purchase a movie for the second or third time. So not happily then. And not what they actually want. >> but they continue to do so Because the choice is that or piracy, and many choose piracy. 'Not participating in popular culture' is a choice, but it's never going to be a big one. >> You are attempting to apply your viewpoint on the general public, which clearly does not agree with you. The general public are dolts, but even you have admitted they grumble and don't get what they want. >> They want DRM that prevents casual copying so that Uncle Bob doesn't give a copy of the latest movie to his entire family which is not an attempt at monetary gain. Then they have failed, because cousin bill, Bob's kid, has that figured out on them innernets. >> That way they only have to spend money going after serious piracy efforts that exist for the purpose of making money. Serious piracy efforts like usenet, torrents, IRC etc? Nobody makes much money there. There are for profit piracy-streaming services that advertise I guess. Never seem to have much legal trouble. >> Your statement assumes that Hollywood is being run by stupid people and that's a serious mistake to make in this type of debate. It is. Powerful, litigious stupid people with a lot of vested, anti-consumer interests.
- vidarh 13y agoIn reality, most of the pirate activity in this house is my 4 year old son watching full length pirated movies on YouTube. There is no real barrier to piracy. There's a minimal barrier for the hottest Hollywood properties - meaning you have to go through the hassle of a torrent instead of just going to YouTube - but if you want the content for free bad enough, you'll get it. Usually before it is available through legal channels.
- talmand 13y agoActually, that wouldn't necessarily be considered piracy. Unless the laws have changed the last time I read up on it, this is legal on your part but illegal for the source of the stream. Where your kid might be the factor in the piracy bit is in file-sharing, which makes you an uploader and not just a downloader.
- makomk 13y agoExcept that the Web's getting DRM exactly so that Hollywood can restrict content to proprietary platforms that allow DRM. Right now, the main use for HTML5's DRM support is DRM on Chromebooks - hardware that's only available from a handful of approved suppliers and is locked down from the hardware up to stop the user running any non-manufacturer-approved code on it. If you enable the ability to run your own code, the DRM module refuses to decrypt anything, and so far as I know no-one has found a way to bypass this.
- al2o3cr 13y ago"When the people with money want something, YOU GIVE IT TO THEM." Apparently this applies to everybody except consumers.
- bgruber 13y ago> So the Web either gets DRM, or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it. so, let's turn the web into another proprietary platform?
- talmand 13y agoOr maybe make a small part of the web, which already has proprietary elements to it, have a new proprietary element that you can freely decide to not participate in.
- fafner 13y ago> So the Web either gets DRM, or Hollywood makes content available on proprietary platforms that provide it. DRM in the Web will be a proprietary platform! The EME proposal is a proposal to make the former open Web depend on proprietary platforms. The actual DRM is not specified (how could it be?) and it only proposes an API the browser should provide for the proprietary binary blob DRM. This is a really horrible step and an attack on the open Web! I'd much rather have Netflix and Hollywood use a completely proprietary DRM platform for their streaming services than them ruining the Web.