9 ms·
China cloning on an 'industrial scale'
- anigbrowl 13y agoExecrable writing, but interesting to see that they're industrializing this already.
- richardjordan 13y agoAs a long time fan of the BBC (well all my life really) their web written content often disappoints. When it's on a topic I know it's too often wrong or misleading. They need to bring their written web content up to the level of the rest of their media product.
- car 13y ago"BGI offers a glimpse of what industrial scale could bring to the future of biology." "If it tastes good you should sequence it," he tells me. "You should know what's in the genes of that species." "A third category is if it looks cute - anything that looks cute: panda, polar bear, penguin, you should really sequence it - it's like digitalising all the wonderful species," he explains.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoMan. This disturbs me on a visceral level, even though I know it's inevitable.
- gcb0 13y agothat sounds a lot more like silly PR shenanigans for the evening news audience than real motivations of even the most absurd enterprise. cmon.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoKind of surprised he didn't take the name Moreau :-) It will be interesting and potentially shocking to see what comes out of these efforts. Both good and bad scenarios come to mind.
- awakeasleep 13y agoThe part about halting pig's aging at one year stopped me in my tracks. The whole article was incredible, but that has been my lifelong dream (for pets) Imagine a dog that stayed one year old forever. Or a giraffe. Edit: Guys. I get this isn't an immortal dog. I just want it to stop growing at one year, like the article says. I also understand this isn't a perfect commercialized technology.
- quesera 13y agoThe article says the pigs stop growing at one year. They presumably still die on time, or perhaps even earlier, that doesn't seem to be a consideration. sorry. :(
- geuis 13y agoThat's not what happens. They don't just stay piglets forever. Mammals aren't that simple. They stop growing but they still age. They'll die younger than normal pigs as a result
- mhb 13y agoIt didn't say that aging stops. It said that it stops growing. Big difference.
- ckoepp 13y agoIt is, but still it quite open what happens if you'd deny a normal growth. Animals are no machines where you simply disable a gene and it works like you expect it to work. We're not even sure what a huge amount of the DNA really does (and what it doesn't). So playing around with such stuff is trial-and-error as you see on virtually any such experiments (Orange trees, potatoes, cloned sheeps, etc.).
- bane 13y agoImagine having a baby elephant! A 120kg (260lb) 85cm (33 in) baby elephant. Actually there'd be a tremendous market for perpetual puppies and kittens. Even if their life span is a little on the short side.
- raghuHack 13y agoWould have liked some more info on how they counteract the risks of cloning. Firstly, a success rate of 70-80% is unheard of wrt cloning. Survival rate of clones is very less compared to the natural borns (I know that the pigs probably get killed for food, but a low survival rate could be indicative of unhealthiness too). Lastly, cloning is prone to complications during growth. (more on that here - http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/cloning/cloningrisks/ http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/cloning/cloningrisks/) I wouldn't want to eat a cloned pig. Would you?
- 1stop 13y agoUnless there was evidence to show that a particular clone was bad for you (to eat) why wouldn't you eat it? You trust 'natural selection' more than 'attempted perfect clone'... why?
- raghuHack 13y agoIt's one of those things, where you prefer things as they are. The same reason why people prefer organic food over BT or processed food. Agreed that both probably have an equal chance of harming you, but the reason is more psychological than rational.
- pyre 13y agoYour premise seems to be that if the natural born animal is ok to eat, then the clone of it is ok to eat. On the other hand, if the survival rate of clones is less than natural born, doesn't that imply that the two aren't exactly equal?
- Blahah 13y agoThe survival rate is different because of the way they blastocysts have to be implanted. We have no reason to presuppose that cloned animals will present more risk to eat than bred animals.
- Symmetry 13y agoOften the only way to get better at something is to do it a lot. I don't think much of the actual product of this factory, but I'm hopeful about the contributions they might make to biotechnology.
- logn 13y agoWe should be cautious of making even more of our food supply dependent on cloning. Then one virus/etc can take out most of the supply. Look at what happened with cloned orange trees.
- gcb0 13y agoor bananas. but unless you go back in time and change nature, we will continue to only have cloned bananas... unless I'm ignorant of some sexual species (no pun intended) what they are doing is not becoming dependent of cloning (i hope) but experimenting. so what that we sequenced dna? what does pair 3531 do? they change it to know values (how that part is done intrigues me) and observe the result. ah ok, now we know that pair controls growth hormone. see, science. it is very similar to what that monk did with flies, which is the reason today that medicine knows if you will have some genetic disease based on family history.
- sampo 13y agoEach apple variety also comes from a single clone. "Every McIntosh is a graft of the original tree that John McIntosh discovered on his Ontario farm in 1811, or a graft of a graft. Every Granny Smith stems from the chance seedling spotted by Maria Ann Smith in her Australian compost pile in the mid-1800s." http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/04/heritage-apples-john-bunker-maine?slide=0 http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/04/heritage-appl...
- rmc 13y agoWe've been relying on modern industrial food production for about 100 years now. 150 years ago a potatoe famine broke the back of Ireland. It was all the same cloned crop. We've crossed that rubicon. The only way to go back is for there to be considerably less people.
- Gupie 13y ago"produces an astonishing 500 cloned pigs a year" - but why? Is there a market for cloned Pigs!? Is this a research project?
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoI invite you on a journey into the world of bacon.
- malanj 13y agoYes - there is a market. Having duplicates of the same animal is seriously useful if you're developing medicines or doing other kinds of R&D
- narrator 13y agoIs there any good source for China science news in English?
- bsaul 13y agoDamn, this sentence shows just how deep in the sh*t we in the west really have become standing.
- culturestate 13y agoI'm not sure I follow — how would it have been any different if he were looking for translations of, say, German news?
- bsaul 13y agoi include Germany in "the west". Seing someone on hacker news trying to find scientific news in english from China is a big hint that china is now where scientific breakthrough will occur. And since China still remains a pretty "special" political regime, i don't feel very reassured.
- Blahah 13y agoFor a long time exciting science has been coming from China. Why is that a problem? It's not a competition :) it's all good for the world.
- bsaul 13y agoHmm, not sure today's china government is aiming at making "the world" a better place. They seem pretty focused on China only interest at the moment (and not everyone in China i would add)...
- Blahah 13y agoIt doesn't matter what their aim is, BGI are advancing science that benefits us all. They publish their research, we read it, everyone wins. Except the pigs.
- Fuxy 13y agoPeople are going to freak out on this. I just hope all the negative press wont stop them from continuing. I have nothing against cloning it's a natural step in biology if we don't do it we won't be able to discover new things.
- tluyben2 13y agoCloning is fine; putting these animals in these small spaces is not unless they manage to breed them without any memory/brain (verifiable) at all; just meat machines then it's fine.
- jcfrei 13y agoI'm sure they (BGI) will make lot's of mistakes along the way, but they got the right attitude.
- galaktor 13y agoI found this amusing: "This is a BGI innovation: replacing expensive machines with people." Probably because it seems contrary to the common (western?) opinion that workers might eventually be replaced by "cheaper" machines. (fwiw I'm aware that it's not that simple, but from my experience many people think machines are always cheaper than human workers)
- jeremywenisch 13y agoChina may also be more accustomed to seeing people as a cheaper resource.
- w_t_payne 13y agoI wonder how quickly we will be able to apply the technology to human clones, breeding them for loyalty and obedience.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoDifficult. We have a troubling capacity for meta-behavior, where we notice how we're thinking and try to change it. More likely, breed for non-violence and contentment. These are endocrine (?) systems that are immediately available to genetic engineers for tinkering.
- w_t_payne 13y agoEven if you could not explicitly breed for loyalty and obedience, simply reducing the variance in the expressed phenotype would make managing and controlling the general population much more straightforward. If everybody responded to stress and fear in a similar way, it would make it much easier to use these tools as instruments of control.
- w_t_payne 13y agoOf course, you are still left with the problem of how to "retire" obsolescent models. Perhaps the new models could be engineered with the ability to eat foods that are toxic to the old models. In this way, simply turning over increasing quantities of agricultural land to production of the new foods would quickly push "old" food prices beyond the reach of (most of) the old-model human. Without need for overt action, the whole "retirement" process could proceed in an entirely covert and deniable manner.
- w_t_payne 13y agoI wonder what Orwell would have made of the use of bureaucratic English in this thread?
- ck2 13y agoWhen China finishes its industrial age, it is going to be one terrifying economic force to reckon with. It is going to be completely self-sustaining, why will it need to answer to anyone. We've become completely reliant on it and we keep feeding it all our cash.
- jalayir 13y agoNow you know how they felt about the Europeans in the 1700s. ;-)
- casualobs 13y agoChina is as dependent on the US as we are on it, and if you look at the data, we are actually more dependent on other economies than China. There are a lot of people who are very bearish on China's immediate prospects and you should read their ideas to balance out the sensationalism of the media
- waterlesscloud 13y agoChina imports massive amounts of raw materials, so they aren't really self-sustaining, no more than any other nation is.
- JamesArgo 13y agoWhat I find even more Gibsonesque is the prospect of China investing in eugenic technology like iterated embryo selection. They've already invested in researching the large patchwork of genes that are correlated with high IQ. Combine this with the fact that most Chinese citizens have far more positive attitudes to designer babies and we are looking at a future where the average Chinese citizen has an IQ more than a standard deviation above the average American. This would magnify their economic dominance considerably.
- junto 13y agoChina is the the world as Google is to the internet. I've said this before, but we should not forget that for 2000 years China was way ahead of other cultures both economically and scientifically. They had a 100 year blip and now they are back with their human ppulation almost completely under their control. Nothing will stand in the way of progress. Human life is cheap. They have a billion of them and counting. Be afraid, be very afraid.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- campbellmorgan 13y agofor anybody with a new yorker subscription this article on BGI is also fascinating http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2014/01/06/140106fa_fact_specter http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2014/01/06/140106fa_fact_...
- jheriko 13y agolets hope their less constrained ethics result in some good for the poor and needy. the idea of cute mini pets with their growth hormones gimped is all well and good and i'm sure will be fantastically popular... but its not exactly a noble use of the technology. I'm thinking more like golden rice v2 - except without being crippled by the infantile kind of controversy that it sparked in the west :)
- walshemj 13y ago500 pigs a year is not industrial scale it's small scale batch production if that.
- est 13y agoLike a Chinese once said, a single spark can start a prairie fire
- Nanzikambe 13y agoSo where, exactly, in China is The Island?
- tokenadult 13y agoThe helpful link here to the New Yorker article about other BGI projects helped establish some context for this article. The BBC and the New Yorker are both professionally managed news organizations, but I think people don't appreciate how practiced BGI is at playing two weaknesses of most news organizations: (1) the gee-whiz factor of China as a still mysterious country where most reporters can't speak the local language(s) and the government still controls the press and (2) the gee-whiz factor of genetics research as a developing science that seemingly explains everything. I have a lot of in-person and online acquaintance with genetics researchers, and so far it looks like BGI is overhyping and underdelivering in the usual manner of the science news cycle.[1] Particularly if we are talking about new developments in animal husbandry, an important industry all over the world where people eat meat or use leather, what is economical to do in one country may not be economical to do in another country, and national barriers to free trade in animal products on dubious scientific grounds are still very much a factor in international trade (and thus domestic prices) for animal products. So maybe this is a big deal for hog producers in other countries, or maybe not. The comment already posted here that the scale described in the article kindly submitted here counts as small-scale rather than "industrial scale" in the United States is correct--some of my cousins are hog producers, and they keep track of all the latest technology in the industry. Here on Hacker News, we have had several discussions of gee-whiz stories about predicted future developments in China that end up never happening. (How many of you remember the many stories about the prefab skyscraper that was to be built in a matter of days?) Predicting the future in China is easy these days: just predict something amazing and seemingly impossible anywhere else, and watch the journalists lap it up. But sometimes the future never comes to China. Anyone who raises hogs for a living will follow this news closely, but whether this news will change any practices in the worldwide industry as a whole remains to be seen. [1] http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1174 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1174 AFTER EDIT: From another comment in a different subthread here, They've already invested in researching the large patchwork of genes that are correlated with high IQ. And that is why I think BGI is more hype than substance. So far BGI has not produced any publishable results from that research. When it has publishable results, I venture to predict, the results will show that any one gene, and any assemblages of genes that they find, will have limited effect on phenotype for IQ. The research on this subject consistently shows this, and some of the best human genetics researchers on the planet already have publications on this issue.[2][3][4] [2] Deary, Johnson, and Penke (2010). "The neuroscience of human intelligence differences" http://www.larspenke.eu/pdfs/Deary_Penke_Johnson_2010_-_Neuroscience_of_intelligence_review.pdf http://www.larspenke.eu/pdfs/Deary_Penke_Johnson_2010_-_Neur... "At this point, it seems unlikely that single genetic loci have major effects on normal-range intelligence. For example, a modestly sized genome-wide study of the general intelligence factor derived from ten separate test scores in the cAnTAB cognitive test battery did not find any important genome-wide single nucleotide polymorphisms or copy number variants, and did not replicate genetic variants that had previously been associated with cognitive ability." [3] Johnson, W. (2010). Understanding the Genetics of Intelligence: Can Height Help? Can Corn Oil?. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 19(3), 177-182 http://apsychoserver.psych.arizona.edu/JJBAReprints/PSYC621/Johnson%20Current%20Directions%20Psych%20Science%202010%20(G%20and%20E%20in%20IQ).pdf http://apsychoserver.psych.arizona.edu/JJBAReprints/PSYC621/... looks at some famous genetic experiments to show how little is explained by gene frequencies even in thoroughly studied populations defined by artificial selection. "Together, however, the developmental natures of GCA [general cognitive ability] and height, the likely influences of gene-environment correlations and interactions on their developmental processes, and the potential for genetic background and environmental circumstances to release previously unexpressed genetic variation suggest that very different combinations of genes may produce identical IQs or heights or levels of any other psychological trait. And the same genes may produce very different IQs and heights against different genetic backgrounds and in different environmental circumstances." [4] Chabris, C. F., Hebert, B. M., Benjamin, D. J., Beauchamp, J., Cesarini, D., van der Loos, M., ... & Laibson, D. (2012). Most reported genetic associations with general intelligence are probably false positives. Psychological science, 23(11), 1314-1323. DOI: 10.1177/0956797611435528 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3498585/ http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/9938142/Most_Reported_Genetic.pdf?sequence=1 http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/9938142/Most_Repo... "At the time most of the results we attempted to replicate were obtained, candidate-gene studies of complex traits were commonplace in medical genetics research. Such studies are now rarely published in leading journals. Our results add IQ to the list of phenotypes that must be approached with great caution when considering published molecular genetic associations. In our view, excitement over the value of behavioral and molecular genetic studies in the social sciences should be tempered—as it has been in the medical sciences—by an appreciation that, for complex phenotypes, individual common genetic variants of the sort assayed by SNP microarrays are likely to have very small effects."