5 ms·
I upvoted you because I like seeing people who go against the grain here, who hold combative viewpoints and are willing to be blunt about faults, regardless of
by asveikau 13y ago
I upvoted you because I like seeing people who go against the grain here, who hold combative viewpoints and are willing to be blunt about faults, regardless of whether or not I agree.
However, after seeing this:
> ... because they are entrenched, and they literally own quite a large portion of their userbase.
> Unfortunately no matter how many people invent software that does the same thing as Hacker News but works much better and offer it up for free, nothing will be done.
... I have to say, if you are disappointed, have you thought about testing this theory? This website has not been around forever. It isn't the first of its kind either. I'm probably not the only one here who came to this site after having frequented a bunch of others that were essentially the same thing. So I don't expect it to be the last one, either. If someone has the interest and the skill set, I say, please do make this. Worst case you waste a few weekends or something.
- ilaksh 13y agoThere are a number of Hacker News clones, i.e. people got fed up and even went ahead and figured out how to mirror the Hacker News content. Far as I know very few if any gained any popularity, but its not because they weren't better.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sehr 13y agoI quite enjoy lobste.rs. Despite the lack of discussion, the majority of the topics posted are interesting and turn over pretty fast (in comparison to some of the other replacements).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kyro 13y ago>people who go against the grain here, who hold combative viewpoints and are willing to be blunt ie assholes
- sehr 13y agoas opposed to yes men, it's somewhat of an improvement.
- kyro 13y agoThere's also this whole middle-ground of tact and civility and stuff.
- asveikau 13y agoThere's a place for those things. I also think it's important that you don't get overly consumed by some frivolous notion of those concepts, prioritizing it above honesty, authenticity, and everything else. To that end I often feel it's refreshing when people say something that is not a majority opinion on this site, and don't hold back.
- asveikau 13y agoIf that's the name for what I described then please call me that. Not only in the fan club but also a member.
- mercurial 13y agoGoing against the grain ( eg, the prevalent PG / Musk worship) is fine. Feelings of entitlement, less so.
- grrowl 13y agoI even suspect Hacker News isn't that fussed if most of its community moves elsewhere. The core community (that it was built for) will stay, and the postings will become more focussed on what the core community finds, reads, and is interested in.