4 ms·
I'm always fascinated by the implications of the very common approach of people to anthropomorphize cats when discussing them and to put down human intelligence
by adventured 13y ago
I'm always fascinated by the implications of the very common approach of people to anthropomorphize cats when discussing them and to put down human intelligence in relation to the cat in the process. I don't see it done nearly as commonly when dogs are discussed. It seems nearly universal in the discussion of cats anywhere online.
"Given that he believes cats are semi-feral and that they think we are cats too, we must surely consider that cats aren't all that stupid -- because they must realize that we are, in fact, quite that stupid."
- KingMob 13y agoA hundred times this. Humans find it incredibly difficult to avoid anthropomorphizing things. While it's bound up with Theory of Mind (predicting others' mental states), one of our biggest talents, it goes a bit awry when applied to non-human species. Just because we know what a human's intentions would be if it did what a cat did, does not mean we ascribed the same quality or depth of intention to a cat.
- jkestner 13y ago> Humans find it incredibly difficult to avoid anthropomorphizing things. But this one takes the cake - they've even assigned similar (aeluromorphous) intent on the part of cats. Which is extra cute. Dogs' motivations are well understood, while cats are less scrutable, and so we pretend they're complex, and therefore like ourselves.
- headlights 13y agoWhat is an alternative model of the cat?
- guspe 13y agoWe can't avoid applying human paradigms to animal behaviour. Cats strike us as introverted and cynical so they serve well the purpose of criticizing humanity; by playing the role of a cat, people can disclose about the pointlessness of life without sounding too bitter or too philosophical (much like dogs facilitate talking about how humans can be loyal, friendly and honorable). Nonetheless, opinions about dogs and cats really are homogeneous. Maybe this means our ideas about those animals have been constructed over time. We wouldn't be so eager to call an eagle "loyal" or "smart". Our relationship with dogs and cats is so long that we've had enough time to carefully craft their images.
- bitwize 13y agoCats strike us as introverted and cynical A lot of that has to do with a cat's expression, which we assign human significance to. If a human looks at you through half-closed eyes, it can be a sign of suspicion; whereas if a cat looks at you through half-closed eyes, it usually means the cat likes you and trusts you, and feels comfortable around you.
- headlights 13y agoIn some places they are also food.
- headlights 13y agoColours are assigned emotions. This occurs more frequently. I think this will bring you much enjoyment in days following. http://www.amazon.com/The-Coloring-Book-Dover-Nature/dp/0486240118 http://www.amazon.com/The-Coloring-Book-Dover-Nature/dp/0486... Enjoy the happiness happening onto you right now.