3 ms·
"why you can't replace programmers" Oh I'd disagree with that... If you'd like an example, note how "Excel" is the industry wide corporate standard database ma
by VLM 13y ago
"why you can't replace programmers"
Oh I'd disagree with that... If you'd like an example, note how "Excel" is the industry wide corporate standard database management system. Its buzzword compliant, being NoSQL, and scales to tens of thousands of records, which despite claims to the contrary is almost always enough for most real world problems. The world of the future is not having a DBA and CRUD developer cooperate to write your shopping list, its one untrained dude with a spreadsheet.
Look at how many graphics artists using paper and pencil have been replaced by one marketing guy with photoshop. Its already happened. Its not bravado but observation.
Rows and rows of desks of junior accountants replaced by one accountant with quickbooks. Another observation, not bravado.
And what, exactly, are pharmacists doing 99% of the time beyond being a very high item value / high risk vending machine? Realizing my mom worked as a pharm-tech part time when I was a kid, so you're not going to fool me... Very highly priced customer service and team lead and thats about it.
The mechanical steam shovel never quite eliminated the use or sales of hand shovels. Its just that "digging ditches" isn't a viable career path anymore for almost anyone, anymore. Or "manual metal lathe operator" or any number of other tasks. I'm not saying there will never be another accountant hired or dr. or lawyer. Just a whole heck of a lot less of them. At least one, two, maybe three orders of magnitude fewer.
Much like the first industrial revolution... there's people right now, out there, being paid to use a hand shovel... the story is, its now probably hundreds of people right at this moment, not 5% of the population or whatever like in 1850.
- ams6110 13y agoThe examples you cite are all enabled by A, cheap, powerful hardware; and B, software which is feasible because of A. But the actual process of building software, a developer sitting at a keyboard, writing code line-by-line, has not really advanced since we moved away from plugboards, or at least since the advent of high level languages. The tools have gotten incrementally better, and are more accessible to more people, but this is all because cheaper, faster hardware made it possible, not because of any exponential leaps in the process of building software. We haven't gotten rid of hand shovels in this case, we've just made them much cheaper and much more efficient, supporting a larger, not a smaller number of hand-shovel workers. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plugboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plugboard
- marcosdumay 13y ago> but this is all because cheaper, faster hardware made it possible, not because of any exponential leaps in the process of building software. The exponential curve has no leaps. This looks like pedantry, but it's important to keep in mind. Exponentials are completely smooth and boring all the way up.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoFor certain areas, you can replace or drastically lower the entry barrier to programming, sure. Replace it totally? Doubtful. There's still inherent limits to computation that we have not resolved, and if our current hunches are correct, likely won't. COBOL was meant to make programming a negligible and easily doable task with its rigid English-like syntax, but how did that turn out? Sloppy code generators have been around for decades that can pop out some generic half-useful spaghetti abomination, but if you want anything just above total crap, you have to do it yourself. Things like databases? Sure. CRUD apps? Absolutely. Even if you don't have a GUI to generate them, there will likely be some extremely abstracted library where it's a matter of pasting in a few procedures. Yet a lot of things are still too vast and niche. That, and reaching the bug-free equilibrium. Removing state and side effects will deal with a wide class of bugs, but it obviously does not rid of them entirely. There will still be some just barely competent (or wizardlike by the hypothetical far-future standards) people who will be in charge of maintenance, and those will be our programmers. While programmers are certainly a peculiarity in that doing your job well means furthering your own extinction, I don't think it will be anywhere near as drastic as it's made out to be. An ever-breaking technological dystopia sounds much more likely than some clockwork ubiquitous computing society.
- grey-area 13y ago"Excel" is the industry wide corporate standard database management system Excel is not a database (I don't mean that as a trivial correction, it's quite distinct); many of the jobs done with it could conceivably have been done with databases but were not, so in a way it's opened up a whole market to store and manipulate more data than ever before on a small scale in businesses, and I suppose you could conceivably replace dbs with it in some cases. However I don't see it replacing databases in the businesses I work with — in my experience at least I see more data moving from excel over to databases and apps (with internal dbs) as it becomes complex or people want to share it than I see it moving the other way. For example imagine a CRM built in excel, scaling up to 1000s of customers and several users — eventually there comes a point where it is far easier to use a db and front-end than to try to manage that sort of data in excel by hand and share amongst several people. Data manipulation is an excellent example of the complex changes wrought by technical progress — there is an argument for saying that as technology progresses, we discover more work we can do with it, and data and analysis become more complex, not less — more jobs are created which simply didn't exist before. Automation doesn't always lead to jobs becoming simpler or humans becoming redundant, quite the reverse in our recent experience. Look at how many graphics artists using paper and pencil have been replaced by one marketing guy with photoshop. Answer, zero. Graphic artists have become quicker, can do more work, and can produce work of higher quality in terms of resolution, type etc than before, but it's still quite a distinct job from marketing. One related example of a profession which has gone is typesetter though — they've been entirely supplanted by technology. Just to be clear I'm not saying technology never supplants anyone, but that the professions you listed are the farthest away from being supplanted and are not even on the horizon in most cases. Customer service is still really important in many jobs, interfacing with humans is extremely hard, and expert systems are not an adequate replacement for most humans yet, esp. in creative or customer facing roles — that will require a qualitative change in the nature of our software. Perhaps that will happen eventually (in some ways I hope it will), but we simply haven't made that leap yet.
- VLM 13y ago"Excel is not a database" It most certainly is used as one in the corporate world. That doesn't mean its a very good one, in the sense that a hammer isn't a very good substitute for a screwdriver. None the less, where a businessman would have called IT to store a couple hundred records in 1970, now the businessman uses a spreadsheet as a database. I agree I LOL when I see people my hand doing the equivalent of an SQL JOIN. To some extent, the older I get, the more I see people using computers as a somewhat different form of manual labor, rather than a replacement for manual labor. Rather than typing this form by hand on the manual typewriter, you use Word and call it progress.