7 ms·
I watch American tv shows and movies and am well aware of restraining orders but thought it was something very rare and almost never happens; now I read this. I
by tluyben2 13y ago
I watch American tv shows and movies and am well aware of restraining orders but thought it was something very rare and almost never happens; now I read this. Is it that normal to get one 'after a breakup'? I have never heard anything like that in my country except for hardcore, life threatening criminal situations. Is it that easy to get one there and you actually get rounded up and hauled to a cell for violating while you are just 'contacting'?
- rjknight 13y agoIf it sounds unlikely, then there's probably more to the story. We don't know what happened between them that caused a judge to believe the order to be necessary, but I presume that such orders are not given lightly.
- dredmorbius 13y agoYou presume incorrectly in the case of a temporary restraining order. These can be and are granted without a hearing from the restrained party: http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Temporary+Restraining+Order http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Temporary+Rest... http://www.walnut-creek.org/citygov/depts/police/faqs/violence.asp http://www.walnut-creek.org/citygov/depts/police/faqs/violen...
- tluyben2 13y agoWell I presume that as well; I hope someone here has experience with that and can tell how hard it is? Because I just had that 'wow!' experience ; it feels like they hand them out at the police station to anyone asking :) I know they are not, but some 'actual', non media enlarged information would be great!
- ZoFreX 13y agoI'm confused as to why you are under the impression that restraining orders are 'normal', or that they hand them out to anyone asking, based on a single data point of one person getting one restraining order?
- peterjancelis 13y agoHe probably thinks so because of other comments above.
- chillingeffect 13y agoThere are 2 to 3 million of them handed out each year [1]. If not "normal," that's certainly _common_. There is no proof or evidence required to issue one. The judge only reads a description of events. It is not required for the restrained party to be there to defend or present counter-evidence. It's simply a 5-10 minute meeting between a judge and a person who alleges "fear" or "emotional harm." Exact laws vary from state to state. They are free to file and cost 5-10 thousand dollars to appeal. [1] http://www.dailyfinance.com/2010/03/30/the-high-price-of-restraining-orders/ http://www.dailyfinance.com/2010/03/30/the-high-price-of-res...
- einhverfr 13y agoRight you are talking about a temporary restraining orders, right? For a full fledged restraining order there is at least supposed to be a showing of evidence and an opportunity to rebut the evidence on the part of the other party, right? The article you link to seems to lump these together with no real discussion of the process. The idea behind a lax standard for TRO's is that if there is danger, the court should temporarily try to mitigate it, pending further process.
- hyperpape 13y agoThe 2-3 million figure is based on an _estimate_ by http://www.mediaradar.org/ http://www.mediaradar.org/ and http://www.acfc.org/ http://www.acfc.org/, which are not neutral sources (though this does not mean that they are wrong). The one clear piece of evidence cited is ~38,000 orders for Pennsylvania, which comprises 4% of the US population. Edit: My initial comment understated the issue. Media Radar states that women are twice as likely to engage in unidirectional (unreciprocated) violence towards their partners are men. While domestic violence against men is real and subject to a lot of shame and silence, this estimate seems insane: I have previously seen figures like 10% of domestic violence stemming from women.
- 13y ago
- einhverfr 13y agoIIRC the process is something like this (disclaimer, this is secondhand from listening to lawyers and I have no experience with the process): 1. Alleged victim goes to judge, gets temporary restraining order on essentially no evidence. This is supposed to be a stop-gap while further process is going on. 2. Alleged perpetrator is notified and a court date set to discuss whether the restraining order is appropriate. Temporary restraining orders really require nothing more than an allegation to get. The idea is that if the situation is life-threatening, you don't want to wait for evidence, but they are also supposed to be temporary. Longer-term restraining orders are supposed to require evidence and an actual adversarial process. The article does not say what sort of restraining order was at issue.
- cdash 13y agoIf the situation is life-threatening, how would a restraining order prevent it?
- king_jester 13y agoIn some places, restraining orders can be a barrier to things like purchasing a gun. But generally speaking, restraining orders alone aren't enough to prevent life-threatening situations.
- einhverfr 13y agoAre there any jurisdictions where it is a barrier to, say, purchasing a knife? I doubt it. Again, if I thought my life was in danger, a restraining order would not be sought.
- sophacles 13y agoGenerally (yes there are cases of abuse-of-the-system) these temporary restraining orders are the result of domestic violence situations. The abuser is given a restraining order, and in conjunction the police provide some extra level of protection if it is a case of "(s)he may come back". It is a legal way of allowing the police to diffuse a situation before it gets worse - because there would otherwise be no good way to stop an offender from doing it again until an assault is in progress. It's a relatively effective way of the legal system saying "look, you got us involved, now we are requiring you to take a few days to calm down, and we'll deal with it after cooler heads are present". A full restraining order is different.
- a3n 13y agoProbably varies from state to state. I once had a temporary restraining order served on someone based on nothing but my say so. I went to a judge with my lawyer, and the other party wasn't there and knew nothing about it until they were served. To an outside observer it probably looked pretty mundane, but inside the little circle of conflict there were real dangers and the judge went with caution.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThey are given lightly. For example, a woman in Santa Fe got a restraining order after a "breakup" with David Letterman. He was ordered to stop communicating with her via code words on his show. Kelsey Grammar was also involved somehow. http://www.volokh.com/files/lettermanapp.pdf http://www.volokh.com/files/lettermanapp.pdf http://www.volokh.com/files/lettermantro.pdf http://www.volokh.com/files/lettermantro.pdf (It was later overturned on the grounds that the Santa Fe court didn't have jurisdiction over mind control transmitted from NY.)
- GFischer 13y agoWow. Thanks for sharing those links. How bizarre.
- atmosx 13y agoThese kind of things enhance faith in the judicial system... Seriously? Through code words ????
- aestra 13y agoThey are also not given when they should be. http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/alissa-blanton-stalker-kills-florida-newlywed-hooters-waitress/story?id=9801964 http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/alissa-blanton-stalker-kills-flori... EDIT: She was actually looking for an order of protection, my mistake
- patio11 13y agoAssume that a restraining order represents someone's strongly held desire to get a restraining order. That's the limiting factor. It's much closer to "X was sued" (Y filed some paperwork) than "X was found guilty of a criminal offense."
- pervycreeper 13y ago(IANAL) Restraining orders are usually granted without requiring any evidence, aside from the testimony of the person requesting it. I believe it is a common strategy for (especially) women to exploit this in order to gain some sort of advantage over their partners following a breakup.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThere's a distinction in many jurisdictions between a temporary order (granted as a matter of course on prima facie statement of the requester) and a permanent order, which generally requires a hearing and evidence from both parties (though if only one shows, the order is generally granted base on preponderance of evidence). ROs suffer from a number of deficiencies: if someone's really bent on doing harm, they can be grossly ineffective. And in some cases (particularly child custody, though also other divorce proceedings, as well as immigration situations due to provisions of VAWA), ROs can be grossly misused to attempt to gain benefits not otherwise available. Typically a TRO should have a hearing within a few weeks, however this isn't always the case (particularly in more complicated situations), so "temporary" may be an extended period of time. Orders are rarely granted reciprocally, that is, as mutual stay-away orders, though these are granted in some cases. A unilateral order turns what are otherwise lawful actions into criminal ones (usually misdemeanors, but not always). The requesting party may use the order to trap the restrained party, particularly as forms of indirect contact (as described in this story) may be construed as violations of the order.
- einhverfr 13y ago> if someone's really bent on doing harm, they can be grossly ineffective. Indeed. Among other things you have to tell the target where to stay away from (namely where you live, work, etc). if someone really wants to hurt you, the restraining order contains all the information they need to carry out an attack.
- rmc 13y agoif someone's really bent on doing harm, they can be grossly ineffective The flip side of that statment is that in some situtations they are effective at stopping harm, and that they act as a deterrent.
- rmc 13y agoWell if the person is threatening your life, then it makes sense that you might break up with them...
- einhverfr 13y agoBut if the person is threatening your life, it makes no sense to get a restraining order. "Yes, I know you want to kill me, so don't contact me, don't come near my home at such and such address, or my work at such and such address, or you will be guilty of a minor misdemeanor!" Right.... that's a good idea...
- hyperpape 13y agoIt's true that it isn't nearly as effective as you'd hope but it does help enhance your ability to get the police quickly involved, establish a paper trail, etc.
- einhverfr 13y agoNone of that matters if you are dead. If someone is out to kill you, go hide with relatives, some ways not too close. Don't serve them with a restraining order.
- hyperpape 13y agoFair enough for that literal description, meaning that the parent poster was sloppy. But at some point between an unfriendly breakup and literal threats of murder, the restraining order is the right response. I think that's the key point.
- einhverfr 13y agoOh sure. I would even say a "credible threat of murder."
- aestra 13y ago>If someone is out to kill you, go hide with relatives, some ways not too close. Define not too close. My closest relatives are over 200 miles away. Am I expected to quit my job? Take my children (If I had them) out of school? For how long? This person may know exactly who all your relatives are and where they live, thus know exactly where to find you anyways.
- skrebbel 13y agoMy thoughts exactly! I don't even know what "restraining order" is in my language.
- tluyben2 13y agoWe share that language; I didn't know the word, but it seems to be omgangs/contact verbod. And no, I rarely hear them being used; there was one for some Amsterdam gangster and the partner who betrayed him, but that makes sense.
- parennoob 13y agoIt is kind of telling that people seem to have become inured enough to the extremely anti-male nature of such laws in the US that they are seriously discussing whether or not sending a man to jail over sending a Google+ invite to a woman is okay or not, saying "it depends upon the circumstances" and whatnot. Are you kidding me? Seriously, seeing "You got a Google+ invite from X" can cause you so much mental harm that you have to send another human being to jail? In a sane world, this would invite investigation for possible human rights violations. As it goes in the USA today, apparently people are shrugging their shoulders and saying "Well, you know, he did send her a Google+ invite..."
- DanBC 13y agoThe behaviour he was put in prison for was not "sending a G+ in invite" but "violating a court order".
- parennoob 13y agoAgain, in several regimes, "court orders" have been served that are accepted as being human rights violations today. You don't accept a ruling as being correct just because it is a court order (not going any further to avoid invoking Godwin's Law.)
- DanBC 13y agoYou either obey the court order while you appeal it and fight the injustice. Or you disobey the court order and go to jail and appeal the court order and fight the injustice. But while the order stands it will be enforced by the apperatus of the law.
- rmc 13y agoThe courts told him "no contact". This wasn't some frivilous law suit of "emotional harm", this was a judge saying "If you do this, you'll go to jail", and the person did the thing.
- 13y ago