3 ms·
Or (it suggests) that father's are frequently the primary breadwinner and typically have less to do with child rearing?
by Mz 13y ago
Or (it suggests) that father's are frequently the primary breadwinner and typically have less to do with child rearing?
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoFrom the OP [Bauer and Larkina, the authors http://www.psychology.emory.edu/cognition/bauer/lab/people.html http://www.psychology.emory.edu/cognition/bauer/lab/people.h... incidentally] >Another important finding was that the style mothers used when chatting with their 3-year-olds was associated with the level of remembering by those children later on. Specifically, mothers who used more "deflections", such as "Tell me more" and "What happened?" tended to have children who subsequently recalled more details of their earlier memories. // It only mentions mothers. Suggesting either fathers were scientifically accounted for - the only way would appear to be by using subjects without contact with their father [or similar figure]. Or, that children chatting with fathers doesn't elicit the same response in recall and this was measured as insignificant and hence discounted. The assumption that [all] children only chat over memories with mothers would be a rather massive flaw in a scientific analysis. [Yes there are of course other influences, primarily siblings I imagine, that are also unaccounted for]. Even if we assume that father's are absent during the events that are later recalled then interactions with father's could be more important. In that assumed environment mothers [or other carers] being present don't have to have details recalled to them; but I'm heading off-piste there. The specification of it being "mothers" not "parents" or "primary care-givers" - assuming scientific rigour - must be important. A quick search [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%28Bauer+PJ[Author]%29+AND+%28mother+OR+maternal%29 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%28Bauer+PJ[Author]...] against Bauer PJ shows 10 papers on childhood memory which in abstract appear to all refer solely to maternal influence; though without reading the papers (I don't have access) or discussing them with the authors one can't really draw further conclusions. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%28Bauer+PJ[Author]%29+AND+%28father+OR+paternal%29 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=%28Bauer+PJ[Author]... returns no results. [Interesting, this relates http://www.psychology.emory.edu/cognition/fivush/lab/FivushLabWebsite/GenderAM.html http://www.psychology.emory.edu/cognition/fivush/lab/FivushL...]
- Mz 13y agoThe specification of it being "mothers" not "parents" or "primary care-givers" - assuming scientific rigour - must be important. I am disinclined to assume such scientific rigor as the explanation for that wording. I am much more inclined to assume unquestioned bias on the part of the people who wrote and administered the study. We have peer reviewed journals et al to help account for the fact that humans are pretty darn bad about being human, no matter their job title. But, ultimately, it is essentially impossible to weed out bias entirely. I hope you are right and I am not but I see no reason at this time to think so.