7 ms·
A Short Talk about Richard Feynman (2005)
- thearn4 13y ago> You know, I remember a time—it must have been the summer of 1985—when I'd just discovered a thing called rule 30. That's probably my own all-time favorite scientific discovery. And that's what launched a lot of the whole new kind of science that I've spent 20 years building. [See A New Kind of Science, page 27.] Oh, Wolfram... Some self-promotional aspects aside, this was a pretty interesting write-up about the personal side of Feynman. One quote of his from this article stands out: "peace of mind is the most important prerequisite for creative work." I'd be very interested to know what he would have thought about the current state of academia and scientific research.
- tlow 13y agoFeynman's views during his time on academia are well known and popularly published in his books. See Cargo Cult Science [1] and his work on a science textbook advisory committee [2] which gave a blank book a 7/10. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult_science [2] http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm
- asveikau 13y agoA few months ago I read the compilation of Feynman's letters that was published in 2005 that this is referring to (title: Perfectly reasonable deviations from the beaten track). I believe I even read it after someone mentioned it on HN. If you are interested in that personal side it's pretty interesting. A little raw at times but the content speaks for itself.
- Fede_V 13y agoThere is a similar statement by Higgs (the guy who won the Nobel prize for physics for the discovery of the boson named after him) about how the insane pressure to constantly publish and produce papers comes at the expense of being able to think really hard about difficult problems. It's a difficult problem. Universities have limited funding, and want to attract professors that get lots of grants to self finance their own research. To get lots of grants, you need to publish lots of high impact papers. To publish lots of papers quickly, you need a lot of PhD students to supervise, and you need to work in a hot and rapidly moving field. This leads to professors acting as glorified managers who spend all their time churning out grants, and spend an incredibly tiny fraction of their time working on their own science.
- chii 13y agothe classic problem of "you get 'promoted' to your level of incompetence".
- danso 13y agoKind of sad to see this, or at least what Wolfram perceived of the situation: > It did have some limits, though. I think he never really believed it applied to human affairs, for example. Like when we were both consulting for Thinking Machines in Boston, I would always be jumping up and down about how if the management of the company didn't do this or that, they would fail. He would just say: "Why don't you let these people run their company; we can't figure out this kind of stuff." Sadly, the company did in the end fail. But that's another story. I don't believe that tech/computers/science is the end all of improving human existence. But sometimes, the systems we construct are machines, in the worst way. I wonder if what Feynman meant that they could "figure it out", but it was either beneath them, or, Feynman was wise/cynical enough to know that that their kind of individual intellect had no real power in that realm of political and collective human affairs. In a way, it's nice that a genius is introspective enough to know that intellect and cleverness, especially by individuals alone, can't be efficiently applied to the business concerns that frustrated Wolfram. On the other hand, many of us below Feynman's knack and energy for problem-solving would say the same thing about the physics that he did get around to working out.
- georgemcbay 13y agoDecent read but I vastly prefer W. Daniel Hillis' "Richard Feynman and The Connection Machine" as it is actually more about Feynman (in his later years, around the same time period as Wolfram's piece) rather than using him as a jumping off point to remind everyone of how smart the guy writing the essay is. http://longnow.org/essays/richard-feynman-connection-machine/ http://longnow.org/essays/richard-feynman-connection-machine...
- sillysaurus2 13y agoThe guy who wrote the essay is smart.
- georgemcbay 13y agoThe guys who wrote both essays are smart. But one of them never misses an opportunity to obnoxiously shove this fact in his reader's face at least three times per page of text using A New Kind of Bragging.
- baddox 13y agoDid you read the article, or did you just say what you think people are supposed to say about anything Wolfram writes?
- georgemcbay 13y agoI actually read the article but wasn't too surprised when he continually inserted what I would consider too much of himself into it. It doesn't directly bother me that Wolfram is an egotist, I don't have to deal with him on a personal level, so why should I care? But he fancies himself a writer (among other things) and I do think his constant need to insert himself and his past accomplishments continually (even when his subject is ostensibly something else) detracts a great deal from his writing and thus it is fair game to call him out for it.
- eruditely 13y agoI don't think we read the same article, obviously you are forcing what you have decided his identity is and are trying to fit it into the article. Just like how people see giraffes in clouds when they are just clouds.
- acidburnNSA 13y agoThe Wikipedia journey I just took thanks to this was amazing: Rule 30 -> cellular automata -> Conway's Game of Life -> Golly_(program). This lead to the package manager and then an hour of fascinating entertainment going through the samples. Wow.
- GuiA 13y agoThe bit about how Feynman organized his life is particularly interesting. He was quite the character, and became extremely successful because he was able to thrive in his academic environment. I wonder if a personality like Feynman would flourish today?
- Scienz 13y agoThe part of "Surely You're Joking" where he cracks the safe at Los Alamos makes me wonder more if he would have gone the way of Aaron Swartz, in today's world.
- sytelus 13y agoI just don't know if I'm feeling sad or amused after reading this. I've read 3 full books about just Feynman (one of them twice) and still today I keep coming across new factoids and quotes about him every now and than I hadn't known before. If aliens came down tomorrow and asked me to pick the finest sample of humanity across space and time, I would pick Feynman. Without a doubt. And here is Wolfram, a burned out prodigy busy managing a commercial company and doing classic Cargo Cult science part time with little respect from peers and with a seminal work called New "Kind" Of Science. He should be thankful that he actually met living and breathing Feynman and even had opportunity to work with him (although Feynman never seem to have mentioned Wolfram anywhere). Instead he goes on to put quotes likes these whose only purpose seems to show how limited Feynman was and how Wolfram didn't had those limitations: What mattered to him was the process of finding it. And he was often quite competitive about it. Really Wolfram? Where is your Nobel prize? Oh, I know you are waiting for the one on new "kind" of science. Some scientists (myself probably included) are driven by the ambition to build grand intellectual edifices. I think Feynman—at least in the years I knew him—was much more driven by the pure pleasure of actually doing the science. No Mr. Wolfram. You are driven by egoistic desire to leave your name everywhere and people worshiping you for your intellect on their knees. And he was a great calculator. All around perhaps the best human calculator there's ever been. Yeah, he calculated some of the greatest mysteries in known physics. The ego of Wolfram dribbles all over: And one day he calls me and says: "OK, Wolfram, I can't crack it. I think you're onto something." Which was very encouraging. And it was nice of him to write such nice things about me.
- stiff 13y agoNone of those quotes are derogatory toward Feynman, and I don't see how Wolfram being pleased by Feynman liking his idea says anything about Wolframs ego. In fact, this was very modest for Wolfram standards, and a much more interesting and cultured homage to a friend, than the ones by Susskind or Gell-Mann: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpjwotips7E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpjwotips7E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnMsgxIIQEE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnMsgxIIQEE I must say I in general don't understand the hate a lot of people have for Wolfram, he clearly is a bit narcissistic, but what he writes and says is always otherwise genuinely interesting, even if not as earth shattering as he would like. Certainly his work is not cargo cult science, he did genuinely advance the research in cellular automata, and he even did some lasting minor contribution to physics in his early days: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Wolfram#Particle_physics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Wolfram#Particle_physic...
- visakanv 13y agoThis was the quote that really resonated with me: "You know, it's funny. For all Feynman's independence, he was surprisingly diligent. I remember once he was preparing some fairly minor conference talk. He was quite concerned about it. I said, "You're a great speaker; what are you worrying about?" He said, "Yes, everyone thinks I'm a great speaker. So that means they expect more from me." It reminds me of Daniel Chambliss' findings in "The Mundanity of Excellence": "Swimmers like Lundquist, who train at competition-level intensity, therefore have an advantage: arriving at a meet, they are already accustomed to doing turns correctly, taking legal starts, doing a proper warmup, and being aggressive from the outset of the competition. If each day of the season is approached with a seriousness of purpose, then the big meet will not come as a shock. Feynman's diligence was not at all surprising. We cultivate this idea of eccentric geniuses. But it's precisely the diligence- to little details, over years and decades- that makes all the difference. - http://www.visakanv.com/blog/2014/01/the-mundanity-of-excellence-by-daniel-chambliss/ http://www.visakanv.com/blog/2014/01/the-mundanity-of-excell...
- vonnik 13y agocan wolfram write anything that doesn't compliment wolfram?