5 ms·
> On his website, he's urging Americans to join the lawsuit, in his words, "to stop Barack Obama's NSA from snooping on the American people." So this is mere p
by a3n 13y ago
> On his website, he's urging Americans to join the lawsuit, in his words, "to stop Barack Obama's NSA from snooping on the American people."
So this is mere political opportunism. Because it's not Obama's NSA, he just happened to touch down in part of the NSA's timeline. The NSA has been, would be and will be doing this regardless of administration or party.
- twoodfin 13y agoThe NSA works for the President. He can order them to stop any and all of these programs immediately, and if they don't, start firing people until they do. He won't (and I don't think he should) because he thinks it would be a bad idea from both a national security and a political standpoint.
- a3n 13y agoAnd Rand Paul works for Rand Paul, and with the Republicans that he has chosen to throw in with. The NSA would be in the exact same state of capability and behavior today if a Republican were in the Whitehouse, and Paul would not be suing. This is about Rand Paul, using any available brick to throw at Obama, the idea being that as Obama's fortunes fall Paul's rise.
- smokeyj 13y agoWhy does Paul's motivation matter? I'm just happy to see something being done.
- pcloadletter 13y agoIt does, because motivation decides what that "something" in "something being done" is. Rand Paul's party is by far the biggest supporter of NSA, TSA, and other TLAs. If he really wanted to change things, he could start by convincing his own party to stop fellating the NSA.
- 1457389 13y agoI think injunctive relief against the NSA is a goal, a "something" that most civil liberties advocates and Rand Paul can agree on. Let it not be said that liberals took yet another opportunity to miss an opportunity at bipartisan reform of our executive branch's powers.
- a3n 13y agoMotivation matters because you serve the goal, not the tactics. If Paul's motivation is not actually restricting the NSA, then at some point he's likely to pivot.
- adventured 13y agoWhere in Rand Paul's heavily libertarian-leaning history do you see evidence that he's in favor of a police state (or policies that make such possible), such that a massive issue like this is one on which he's likely to pivot away from his fundamental beliefs?
- a3n 13y agoI know nothing of Rand Paul's history. When I see someone talking about an issue (the NSA) and using it to paint an opponent ("Obama's NSA"), then I think it's safe to say that the point is as much that opponent as the mere paint.
- larrys 13y ago"Rand Paul, using any available brick to throw at Obama" In short a version of grandstanding. Schumer of NY uses any opportunity he can in the same way for certain issues. While all politicians do this some are more likely than others to seize the moment. In other words something is in the news and then all the sudden Senator "x" is writing a letter or demanding some action which gets him publicity. It would be interesting to see how many times a press release is issued by these types that is not about some issue that has bubbled up first in the media. (My point being that I'd like to see if I am correct...or not.) I do know that politicians are quick to write letters about anything and everything. But certain issues that have more PR potential seem to be more equal than others. My observation.
- jbooth 13y agoI would be seriously fascinated to hear Obama's honest reasoning on this topic. He's got a history all the way back to law school of public statements that are diametrically opposed to what he's authorizing the NSA to do. Yet when he's president, he lets it continue? I mean, maybe he stopped them from doing some even worse stuff, but you'd think he'd be opposed to the currently disclosed programs, from his history.
- dllthomas 13y agoBased on his history, I assumed he came into office, went to the NSA, and said, "Well, I know you want to do way more creepy spying. I want you to do less creepy spying. So how about we meet in the middle with a little more creepy spying?" And then they talked him up a little from there.
- jbooth 13y agoHa, fair enough.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> The NSA works for the President. While I'm not that well versed in American politics, I find that hard to believe. The President doesn't seem to be some sort of all-controlling, micromanaging dictator, I'd find it more believable that he doesn't directly control the majority of US institutions, especially since most of them operate regardless of the political party in charge. I mean, the NSA has been operating for 60 years, so obviously there is some continuity, and their activities go beyond the whims of each individual president...
- protomyth 13y agoThe NSA is part of the executive branch and must obey directives from the President that do not violate the law. Otherwise, the President couldn't execute his/her duty as defined in the US Constitution. "the buck stops here"
- adventured 13y agoThe NSA falls under the Department of Defense, they are a military tool. It is directly under the command of the Commander-in-chief, ie the US President, at all times, period. They do what he commands. If that's not the case, then the United States is under siege, and the government has suffered a coup.
- dllthomas 13y ago"If that's not the case, then the United States is under siege, and the government has suffered a coup." Not every instance of dereliction of duty is a coup... but at the extreme, yeah.
- res0nat0r 13y agoThe President isn't a dictator. The NSA is under the DoD. So he needs to start by firing Chuck Hagel, then his Deputy, then General Alexander, et al. That is going to do more damage than it helps. The NSA isn't black and white no matter how much people on HN have recently decided it to be so. Law changes and reforms within the NSA are the only sane way to fix issues you don't like without doing more harm than good, and the President just doesn't unilaterally get to pass new laws on his whim.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIndeed, the NSA is one of the four branches of our government, and there is little control the executive branch has over its operations or conduct.
- refurb 13y agoIt is true that Obama is limited in what he can do, but apparently he isn't even willing to do that. The Obama administration has decided to preserve a controversial arrangement under which a single military official is permitted to direct both the National Security Agency and the military’s cyberwarfare command despite an external review panel’s recommendation against doing so, according to U.S. officials. http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/white-house-to-preserve-controversial-policy-on-nsa-cyber-command-leadership/2013/12/13/4bb56a48-6403-11e3-a373-0f9f2d1c2b61_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/white-...
- adventured 13y agoIf Obama wanted to fundamentally alter this problem forever, he'd go on national TV and tell the American public exactly the situation - that the NSA is so powerful he can no longer control it. Then he'd convene with Congress, and order the NSA to be dismantled immediately (and rebuilt under a different, much more restrained spec). If the NSA tried to stop the process and acted against the orders of the Commander-in-chief, Obama should then recall the US Military and destroy the NSA with brute force, treating it as a hostile domestic militia that is attempting a coup. Game over. Sound far fetched? No, it's just a standard issue government revolution, no different than what has gone on throughout history all across the map.
- mixmastamyk 13y agoI think those that have been paying attention know this. If it is bad from one party it is bad from another. However, perhaps this is a calculated attempt to rally TV conservatives around the cause. It may not be completely accurate, but it might work.
- natmaster 13y agoDon't let your political idealism blind you. Obama has control over the NSA, and Paul is calling out the man who can change its policies.
- corin_ 13y agoSure you're right, but if Obama lost his last election do you think they'd be any difference to the NSA today? Maybe Rand Paul cares more about the morals than the politics, maybe he doesn't. I don't like the guy, but whatever his motive I'm happy he's doing this. At the end of the day, both sides would be happy to claim morality when really just playing politics, so even if that is what he's doing, I don't see it as making him any worse than his colleagues or rivals.
- natmaster 13y agoSo I assume you knew Obama was going to kill innocent children with an drone strike campaign larger than anything before, spy on the world, etc, and because of this you did not vote for him?
- corin_ 13y agoWell I didn't vote for anybody because I'm English. But I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, anyway. I'm not arguing that Obama is good or shouldn't be blamed for NSA, I'm just saying that I believe had he not become president, it wouldn't have changed the NSA situation. Maybe I'm wrong. Who knows, maybe a republican president right now would abolish the NSA, or maybe they would drop nukes all over Europe, I (and you) can't know exactly what would have happened. But if you disagree with my assumption that Obama losing wouldn't have lead to any different reaction to the NSA, then feel free to make that point. But apart from that, whether Obama is murdering kids with his bare hands or making the world an incredible place with his love, is irrelevant. As to my own views, had I had US voting rights I would have voted for Obama, and by now would be (and am despite not voting) extremely upset by his actions in office. But I'm not sure my politics are relevant. My point was that I think that were the roles reversed, it would be a democrat wanting to fight the NSA, and a republican president keeping the status quo. And my point was that politicians on both sides consider both moral and political points before deciding to do something like this. I'd make that point whether I loved Rand Paul or hated him, whether I love the NSA or hate them.