8 ms·
Sen. Rand Paul says he's suing over NSA policies
- tokenadult 13y agoIt looks like this submission with the correct spelling of the Senator's name in the submission headline will get more traction for discussion of the substantive issues in the story. I'll begin, and I look forward to comments by other Hacker News participants. United States Senator Ron Wyden from Oregon[1] and United States Senator Rand Paul from Kentucky[2] run for election with the endorsement of different political parties, and have plenty of other differences on issues of public policy, but they are agreed that NSA surveillance programs need to be reviewed for legality. That's a demonstration that there is a reasonably broad base of support among the American public for taking a second look at how government intelligence programs have been operating recently, and perhaps revising the legal framework for regulating those programs. The large volume of lawsuits connected to NSA surveillance pretty much guarantees that the Supreme Court will consider the issue after the various trial court and intermediate appellate court decisions in different cases have shed light on the issues. [1] http://www.wyden.senate.gov/ http://www.wyden.senate.gov/ [2] http://www.paul.senate.gov/ http://www.paul.senate.gov/
- twoodfin 13y agoThat's a demonstration that there is a reasonably broad base of support among the American public for taking a second look at how government intelligence programs have been operating recently, and perhaps revising the legal framework for regulating those programs. I don't think that's accurate. This just happens to be one of those issues where the traditional left/right spectrum breaks down. Paul comes from the libertarian wing of the GOP, and Wyden is perhaps best described as a small government liberal. Together they represent not insignificant minorities within their own parties, but nothing like a broad bipartisan base. You wouldn't say Paul Ryan's Medicare plan had a broad base of support just because Wyden was associated with it (more or less, depending on whose talking points you're reading).
- a3n 13y ago> On his website, he's urging Americans to join the lawsuit, in his words, "to stop Barack Obama's NSA from snooping on the American people." So this is mere political opportunism. Because it's not Obama's NSA, he just happened to touch down in part of the NSA's timeline. The NSA has been, would be and will be doing this regardless of administration or party.
- twoodfin 13y agoThe NSA works for the President. He can order them to stop any and all of these programs immediately, and if they don't, start firing people until they do. He won't (and I don't think he should) because he thinks it would be a bad idea from both a national security and a political standpoint.
- a3n 13y agoAnd Rand Paul works for Rand Paul, and with the Republicans that he has chosen to throw in with. The NSA would be in the exact same state of capability and behavior today if a Republican were in the Whitehouse, and Paul would not be suing. This is about Rand Paul, using any available brick to throw at Obama, the idea being that as Obama's fortunes fall Paul's rise.
- smokeyj 13y agoWhy does Paul's motivation matter? I'm just happy to see something being done.
- pcloadletter 13y agoIt does, because motivation decides what that "something" in "something being done" is. Rand Paul's party is by far the biggest supporter of NSA, TSA, and other TLAs. If he really wanted to change things, he could start by convincing his own party to stop fellating the NSA.
- 13y ago
- thrillgore 13y agoIt'll be thrown out on "National Security" concerns which says everything that needs to be said.
- javajosh 13y agoThis will be a useful lawsuit. I think that this will be a very different lawsuit from the one the ACLU is currently pursuing. First, it is being led by two US Senators from vastly different political perspectives, which gives it tremendous credibility with a wide base of people. Additionally, if the USG falls back on the national security argument yet again, then this will damage the Obama administration's credibility even more, and that will be a useful outcome as well. As an aside, it's funny how quickly Obama has gone from a novelty (first black president, exciting!) to just a very weak, unprincipled leader, and who weakens himself even more with every backroom deal with wall street, every promotion of Bush-era hawks, every prosecution of reporters under the Espionage Act, and every defense of mass surveillance of Americans. My sense is that he is under the full sway of his advisors and underlings, and he lacks the cajones to think for himself and stand up to them when they argue for practicality over principle. Clearly our political system needs to do a better job of selecting strong, intelligent, moral leaders, rather than just well-spoken ones. (An interesting problem in itself, and one which I think is only partly addressed by campaign finance reform.) But the other lesson from this is that our system of checks and balances is not working. This suit is an attempt to use the judicial to check the executive. A laudable attempt to work within the system. But as you mention, the executive is not shy about playing their trump card - keeping secrets vital to national security - rendering a judicial check impossible. Meanwhile, Congress is still in very poor shape, with Tea Party morons so fixated on taxation that they ignore everything else. (Although I must admit, that in times like these "starve the beast" does seem mighty appealing. What the hell are we doing giving Obama $1T a year to play with, given his lack of judgement and scruples? Indeed, what man or woman exists that can be trusted with that kind of power, especially given the glaring weaknesses in our system of checks and balances?) We've seen some egregious, shameless use of structural weaknesses in our system, hacks that previous generations of senators and presidents have been deeply reluctant to use - apparently well aware of the cost of using them. Executive use of "national security" to quash judicial check is one; indiscriminate and constant use of filibuster to intentionally stop congress from functioning at all, even on routine matters. Fundamentally, political systems are designed to allow people with conflicting views to live in peace together, and to cooperate for mutual benefit. Without these systems, we devolve into tribes, mainly on ethnic and racial grounds, fighting for dominance over each other. We went from democracy at the city-state level, back to absolute monarchy, and now we're trying democracy at the national level. But remember this is all new ground; the US is only 238 years old. In essence, the US is a startup, and it might fail, and it could fail catastrophically or just kind of fizzle out. (I hope doesn't, though, because I really love the idea of Star Fleet being HQ'd in San Francisco).
- f_salmon 13y agoMy question would be: How should we be able to trust them ever again? I mean, it's been shown that people like Obama an Clapper openly lie. Nobody seems to care about that. I'm still not sure that it's a good idea to accept the weak bone they'll throw us to make us forget about the real issue (Obama hinted at some limitations he might enforce).
- eloff 13y agoYou could trust them otherwise? You can't trust politicians, period. Their interests and incentives don't align with ours. Your default mode should be to distrust them, to expect them to lie when it serves their ends. Anything else is, quite frankly, a very naive world view.
- dllthomas 13y agoBut that does not mean you should accept it when they lie. You should expect them to lie when it serves their ends, but a refusal to accept it (coupled with vigilance and systems that make it hard for them to get away with it) means it more rarely serves their ends.
- jrockway 13y agoRoll eyes. If this was happening during a Republican presidency, it would be some random Democrat suing. Even though both parties got together to make this happen behind the scenes.
- 1457389 13y agoThis shortsighted brand of cynicism, writ large, is exactly what is enabling this revolving door approach to policy in this country.
- chill1 13y agoThis shortsighted brand of cynicism, writ large, is exactly what is enabling this revolving door approach to policy in this country. Yes... I repeated your comment verbatem to demonstrate that the same could be said of your attitude.
- 1457389 13y agoI was making the point that cynical eye rolling at any initiative from political competitors, despite common goals, leads to a zero sum system where policy reflects narrowminded politics rather than shared values. That is a bad thing, and I think we should try and nip it in the bud as much as possible. What about my attitude is leading to the same?
- natmaster 13y agoA few good men.
- crystaln 13y ago"Barack Obama's NSA". What a disappointment is Rand Paul. How about making this about America instead of an unfair attack on a single president? Standing above partisanship will pay dividends to a political career in the end. This is the sort of crap that tells me never to support Rand Paul. Yes, Obama could do something about the NSA, but so could Congress and so could have Bush. This is everyone's NSA. Flagged for being simple political posturing instead of a legitimate push for change.
- rayiner 13y agoIts a good strategic move. The way to build support against the NSA among Republicans is to associate it with Obama. "This isn't Reagan's NSA but Obama's NSA." It fits into the party's narrative of Obama being dictatorial. It also is a good way to sway his party, which is otherwise trusting of law enforcement. Someone might trust the NSA in the abstract, but an NSA run by someone who wants to round up gun owners and impose Sharia law (or so the narrative goes)? Associating the spying with Obama personally is the perfect way of creating doubt among conservatives that otherwise reflexively trust government when national security is implicated.
- lisper 13y agoUnfortunately, it won't last. As soon as we have a Republican in the White House again the narrative will switch again, and the NSA will once again be protecting our security rather than threatening our civil liberties. They did it with health care: Romneycare was good and Obamacare is bad, despite the fact that they are essentially identical policies.
- Apocryphon 13y agoWell, hopefully in that administration the Democrats would be galvanized enough to be the ones leading the charge against Big Surveillance. The very fact that this issue would have to be ping-ponged around between both parties (like so many other issues) shows that we need more political parties in the U.S. to represent different views.
- noarchy 13y agoThe likely outcome of this is that Rand Paul will be called out on his partisan motivations (and there will be some truth to it, I admit) in the media, and the courts will ultimately throw out the lawsuit and thus protect the surveillance state. We know that the president won't do anything about this. The legislature won't, and neither will the courts. The most we could expect is a token piece of legislation that promises oversight, but will have stealth provisions that end up making everything worse, or provide clemency for the NSA's various crimes.