20 ms·
Fired? Speak No Evil
- bertil 13y agoI’m puzzled by one thing, if risk management is the concern: why not replace that clause by a candid, confidential conversation on what is wrong with the company? Any significant issue most likely affects more than one employee, including remaining ones. It sounds typical of a culture driven by lawyers, rather than leaders.
- uptown 13y agoIn an ideal company culture, that conversation could have taken place at any time of the employee's tenure. Many companies do have exit-interviews designed to elicit this type of feedback. But with regard to severance ... companies know they have something of value, and many will seek to leverage that to their maximum advantage.
- badman_ting 13y agoNever been fired but I think of that as consulting. I have been asked for that kind of info on my way out, and said the same. I definitely would not be giving that out to to the company that just let me go.
- davedx 13y agoYou refuse exit interviews even when you are the one who's decided to leave?
- silverbax88 13y agoCompanies could save themselves a lot of pretense with exit interviews and just assume the following: If a good person leaves your company, it is because of one or more of the following: 1. You can't (or won't) pay them as much as someone else. 2. They aren't happy in the culture of your company. 3. They aren't happy with the type of work they are doing. 4. They don't see a bright future with your company - either for themselves, or for the company, or both. 5. They don't trust the company (or, possibly, the people they work with). 6. It isn't one item, or one incident, but over their time with the company, many little things that eroded their desire to work there. A person leaving today might have become fed up with the company two years ago when some botched project burned them or a manager handled something completely inappropriately. People don't usually just quit on the spot. 7. They want to work for themselves. Which means, they don't want to work for you. It really isn't you, it's them. (Wish them good luck and be sincere) 8. They can get a better deal (non-monetary) somewhere else and it outweighs the job. For young people, often the job is part of their identity. Once people get married and have kids (or just get a little older), they realize that working for someone else is not much of a reward. They may want a more flexible schedule, may want to just physically be closer to their home, any number of things that you may not be able to control. 9. You see them as a replaceable part and they know it. (Surprise!)
- dasil003 13y agoSo rather than ask the person like a grownup they should wildly speculate in order to make everyone less uncomfortable? I mean you have a list of 9 reasons off the top of your head and it's just the tip of the iceberg.
- silverbax88 13y agoName another reason that doesn't fall under those nine. I'm honestly not trying to argue, just asking. There aren't really that many reasons why people leave. People leave because they aren't happy or aren't getting paid enough or they have a personal situation that dictates it. There are really just 3 reasons but I elaborated because I expected people to start chiming in with all of the reasons I missed.
- kohanz 13y agoThose reasons are so vague, though. Alright, so "people aren't happy", how should I go about fixing that as an employer? Step 1: find out what they are unhappy about. Hence the exit interview. IMHO, this information should be gathered well before exit, e.g. through regular 1-on-1's, but that's another discussion.
- schrodinger 13y agoAn exit interview allows you to be more candid than in a regular 1-on-1. When you're still an employee you're more worried about saying something that could affect your perception.
- kohanz 13y agoGood point. This also very much depends on the manager-employee relationship between the two people in the 1-on-1.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoJust won the lottery Close relative has received a terminal diagnosis Believed their horrorscope Got pregnant Saved enough money to retire to Thailand Spouse has had an affair with a co-worker (Trust aside this is still a good reason)
- 6d0debc071 13y agoIf the company couldn't be bothered to learn what I thought in the months or years I've been working with them, I don't feel any motivation to tell them now. An exit interview is essentially saying, to me, "We didn't care until you left." There's also the fact that I find most interviews incredibly dehumanising experiences. Someone sits down and reads some set questions at you... bleh. Does anyone enjoy that? You want to know what I think, try having a conversation. If the emotional and intellectual investment on your side is you deigned to read me a list? Just... stuff that for a game of soldiers. I'm not going to put up some of my feelings and concerns in response to a list-reading machine. Ultimately, if I've got a good relationship with my manager, she or he will know why I'm leaving without needing to sit down and treat me like some stranger who they can interrogate. If we don't have a good relationship, then under those conditions all they've really done is pay my wage in return for code, and when they stopped doing so they lost the right to my time and effort in any form.
- badman_ting 13y agoOutright refusing it seems awkward and overly hostile to me, but I have done it while giving very perfunctory answers. When they dug for more I told them I was available for consulting. Quite simply there is no incentive to do any more than that.
- willvarfar 13y agoAh the notorious "exit interview"? Steer well well clear of them too! http://www.asktheheadhunter.com/haexit.htm http://www.asktheheadhunter.com/haexit.htm
- perlpimp 13y agojust say NO.
- waylandsmithers 13y agoI had one of these recently but didn't realize I could just decline it. I stuck firm with my "Nothing personal, just moving on to something new" rationale for leaving and basically answered all the questions in a "10/10 would work here again" kind of way. I figured any actual constructive criticism would be ignored anyway.
- enjo 13y agoI've used "peer-led exit interviews" to great effect. Essentially get one of their co-workers to take them out for lunch to talk about want went wrong. Folks are much more comfortable talking to their colleagues. The person conducting the interview is generally happy to pass along the criticism (usually because they agree with it) without having to since they don't have to put their name to it. I've gotten some real painful, but incredibly meaningful, feedback from these interviews.
- crusso 13y agoThe company is offering extra weeks of pay in return for not attacking them. Why is this different than getting paid to do your job or meet a contract in other respects?
- CaveTech 13y agoIt must be different in California, because here in Ontario companies are legally required to give at least 2 weeks severance in most instances. If an employer isn't required to do the same in California then there's not much to complain about. Is this the case?
- spiralpolitik 13y agoCalifornia is what is referred to as an "at will" state which means the company can let you go tomorrow without recourse or explanation beyond "we're letting you go" [1]. ([1] There is legislation that comes into play if you let enough people go at the same time that its considered a "layoff". But it doesn't come into play for an individual termination)
- _delirium 13y agoThat's indeed true in California, but "at will" employment doesn't strictly require that. At-will employment means either side can terminate the employment arrangement for any or no cause, as distinguished from jurisdictions that require a reason for termination. It's still compatible with having a short notice period, e.g. requiring that employees give 2 weeks notice before quitting, and/or that employers give 2 weeks notice before termination.
- LanceH 13y agoTwo weeks severance isn't traditionally "extra pay". It's generally a professional courtesy that they are now withholding until the no-longer-employee agrees to an everlasting requirement. The flip side: Offer two weeks notice, but only if they agree to speak of you on your terms afterward. No company signs that. They would be liable for anything anyone in the company ever said about you, forever. It's also exceptionally vague and even if it only applies to lies spoken by the employee, it can still have a chilling effect on the truth.
- 300bps 13y agoIf I don’t agree to this nondisparagement clause, I will not receive my severance — in this case, the equivalent of two weeks of pay. For two weeks pay, I would not agree to anything. For two years pay, I would consider it. I had no idea that professionals were given such ridiculous offers and expected to sign off on them. At my last job, I was guaranteed 1 year of severance in the event of losing my job. Fortunately, it never happened. At my current job I will get a relatively modest 24 weeks severance if I lose my job. If it ever comes to that, I plan on doing what some of my former co-workers did. Refuse to sign the "release of all claims" unless they give you a year severance and history has shown they'll give it to me.
- awakeasleep 13y agoWhat country, industry?
- Broken_Hippo 13y agoThat was in the US, the call center multiple family members worked at - student loan collections.
- adricnet 13y agoLet me suggest with all respect and much jealousy that your situation may not be common across employeers or jurisdictions. And that many people may not have the finances or flexibility to decline two weeks pay, unless they already have another job (or lots of work). What you are discussing as an expected normal sounds like some utopian fantasy from here in Georgia, USA, an "at-will" hiring and firing state.
- 300bps 13y agoLet me suggest with all respect and much jealousy that your situation may not be common across employeers or jurisdictions I have no college degree, work in the suburbs of a second-tier Northeastern US city but I have 20 years experience in IT. And that many people may not have the finances or flexibility to decline two weeks pay I respectfully submit that saving for an emergency fund might be their top priority while they are gainfully employed then. My goal since I was 18 years old was to have 6 months pay in the bank and it wasn't long before I had that. Since my parents didn't have two nickels to rub together though, I didn't have much of a choice and absolutely no fall back if I got into trouble so this was kind of a necessity for me. Also, I'm surprised that anyone in IT is afraid of losing their job. Currently I work 40 hours per week at the investment bank I work at full time and 20+ hours per week doing side programming. Honestly I could work 24 hours per day and get paid for every hour if I wanted to. There is nearly infinite work for programmers right now. Losing your job is scary, no doubt, but in reality if you are a decent programmer you don't have much to be scared of.
- logicallee 13y agoThe thing is, people who are let go are going to be in a sour mood. They are often going to think of negative things, even (especially?) if they had a very positive experience, and ordinarily this would not be a signal that is important. But for a company that is reducing its burn rate, obviously public signals like what someone decides to say are hugely important. So it is really a reminder: "don't bad-mouth us please." Why not just be fair, "In understanding the important relationship I had with my employer as a valued and insider employee, I will agree to be fair in any public representations made about the company, in deference to its important and precarious image at this critical stage. Nothing here should be construed as affecting my statutory rights." I'd sign that in a heart-beat, and it might even be a good reminder.
- psaintla 13y agoBecause it is easier to bully someone to do what you want.
- logicallee 13y agosure, but it doesn't work. that's why companies give out equity and options, instead of trying to blackmail their recruitment targets. and startups around here described as being run by a bully implode or close soon thereafter.
- psaintla 13y agoI wish I could say the same about NYC startups. I once worked for a place where an employee left to a competitor which infuriated the CEO. As a result he had a meeting threatening to track down anyone who left and get them fired. In addition he made everyone sign a non-compete agreement or risk being fired. This startup is still around and doing just fine. I've heard similar stories from other nyc startups.
- mathattack 13y agoMy 2 cents... The non-disparagement is a trade. You trade not saying anything bad about them publicly, and they agree not to say anything bad about you during a reference check. You get a positive (or perhaps generic "He worked here from X to Y, that's all we can say") reference, and they don't have to worry about a book coming out trashing them. The amount of cash is secondary. The real thing is, if you want to remain on good terms with them, you sign it. If not, you don't. I can't imagine a company offering severance nowadays without including this. 2 weeks may be negotiable, but this won't be.
- silverbax88 13y agoActually, legally, they cannot say anything more than "He worked here from X to Y, that's all we can say". You don't need any agreement from them.
- netfire 13y agoCan you provide a source for this? I've never heard of this before and am curious what legal restriction you are referring to.
- SamReidHughes 13y agoIt's in a secret section of the constitution on employment law, that overrides the first amendment.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoThe first amendment (and all the rest of it) has nothing to do with non-governmental, private interactions.
- gottagetmac 13y agoOf course it does, when you're talking about the government regulating non-governmental, private speech, such as this mythical law against employers saying truthfully that you were fired for cause.
- alextingle 13y agoI wouldn't sign that any more than I'd sign a contract that gave the company everything that I produce in my own time. Both are attempts by the corporation to dissolve my agency as a human being. The only right answer is no.
- tostitos1979 13y agoSuch contracts ("produced on own-time belongs to company") are common at large software companies. If you are in California, such a contract may not hold water. Any one have experience with a big co (outside Cali) where they were able to negotiate this clause away?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tostitos1979 13y agoThanks for your data point. But I presume this was a small to medium sized company? At Big Co. HR is a faceless organization and I'm curious if people have succeeded negotiating with this beast? I'm also curious: did you negotiate this after they offered you a job? It seems frustrating to get the job first and then turn it down because it never met your requirements? Is it reasonable to ask a potential employer about their own-time policy during the interview phase?
- dredmorbius 13y agoI've pushed back on contract terms with a large company that had included a non-compete clause not enforceable locally. Turns out they had an alternate contract which met local statute, and had used it in previous hires / mergers. Still makes me itchy to sign such terms. When Marissa Meyer was hired by Yahoo, I found it interesting that her employment contract included some pretty familiar language: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1011006/000119312512307595/d384719dex101.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1011006/000119312512...
- triplesec 13y agoSue them for breaching your First Amendment rights through employment termination coercion.
- beat 13y agoWhat "First Amendment rights"? You give those up when you take a job. As Bob Black said in The Abolition of Work, "There is more freedom in any moderately de-Stalinized dictatorship than there is in the ordinary American workplace".
- BlackDeath3 13y agoFirst Amendment applies to governmental interactions only.
- patatino 13y agoI quit at two jobs until today.. The only thing I ever signed was my resignation.
- danielweber 13y agoAnd I was soon informed that the president wished to assure me that there is nothing unusual about such clauses Whoop whoop whoop! This sets off giant alarm bells in my head. It might be totally normal. That doesn't mean you should sign it. It's also an older-than-dirt salesman tactic to say that something you just made up is "totally common." Of course, the company can attach whatever clauses it wants to a separation agreement. You aren't entitled to a severance payment. I'll tell other engineers that two weeks' salary is a piddly amount for the company for you to surrender such rights. You can just walk away. They are the ones who want you to sign that. (It's kind of ironic, but after you have been given notice you are fired, you have power. They want you to do certain things, and what are they going to do? Fire you? Already did that. Withhold pay? Illegal.)
- JackFr 13y agoI've been through the process twice, and in neither case was there any pressure to sign the document. In both cases I was advised to speak to a lawyer if I was unsure or uncertain about anything, to feel free to contact them with any clarifications and in one case I expressly forbidden from signing it in the HR office and told to mail it back. A lawyer would tell you that such a clause is common, is somewhat enforceable, and rarely enforced. The situation primarily being avoided is airing specific, proprietary, disparaging information.
- neohaven 13y agoDepending on where you are, "severance", or the 2-week pay after you have been told you do not have a job anymore, may or may not be a worker's right.
- poopsintub 13y agoI've never heard of severance in the U.S. being mandatory or illegal to withhold if say, they did it for every other employee that left the company prior. I think unemployment benefits takes care of this.
- chimeracoder 13y agoIANAL, but while that may be true in general, California (where the author was employed[0]) is an at-will state, and most people reading HN (in fact, most people working at startups in general) are likely to be employed at-will. AFAIK, that means that they are not entitled to any severance unless their initial contract stipulated otherwise. [0] Actually, where the company was based we don't know which employment laws applied to his contract without reading it. You can be a California resident employed by a Delaware corporation operating out of California and your contract can still be subject the the employment laws of a third state. I'm not entirely sure how this actually works in practice, but I know it is done. EDIT Some quick Googling found this website, which has some interesting information (albeit a rather terrible layout): http://www.careerprotection.com/severancepay.html http://www.careerprotection.com/severancepay.html
- imgabe 13y agoThere's already established case law concerning libel and slander, do these not apply to corporations? This clause just seems like a way to give a company the option to sue you for anything at all, regardless of whether it caused them any damages.
- rbanffy 13y ago> This clause just seems like a way to give a company the option to sue you for anything at all, regardless of whether it caused them any damages Or if it's true.
- chris_wot 13y agoTwo things wrong here: 1. Isn't this against the U.S. Constitutional right to free speech? 2. I'd say that if you had this signed then it would be under duress. Not sure how this can be enforceable!
- LargeWu 13y agoThe Constitution establishes the limits of the government's powers only. It does not apply to contractual agreements between private parties.
- ProAm 13y ago1) No, this is not against the 1st amendment. You do not have free speech at work, and before he signs this he is still employed. 2) He would not have signed it under duress because he does not have to sign it. It could be argued, but he'd probably lose. I wouldn't think either party would want to go to court over 2 weeks pay either way.
- TheBiv 13y agoThe Constitution only stipulates your right to free speech against the government.
- jrs235 13y ago1. No. The first amendment pertains to government restrictions on free speech. 2. I highly doubt a judge or jury would believe that the individual's life was in danger if they didn't sign this. Update: #1 is why having a few large conglomerate companies "in bed" with government is dangerous. The government can't hush you up but if you and most everyone else works for the few government appeasing companies then those companies could threaten to fire you... effectively diminishing [political and/or government] dissent and protest.
- alecbenzer 13y ago1. Free speech means you have a right to say what you want, but it doesn't mean you cannot voluntarily give up this right in part. 2. What part of this is duress? Nothing unlawful is going on; the author wasn't legally entitled to severance pay, even if withholding it is unprofessional.
- qwerta 13y agoWhat is "termination agreement"? You were fired with written or verbal notice. Severance and other stuff should be arranged in original contract you signed when hired.
- harryh 13y agoIt's an agreement that your company asks you to sign at the time of termination. You don't have to sign it (as the guy who wrote this article didn't). You're incentive to sign it is the severance pay they offer. I don't really get why everyone here is so offended at the concept. It's the company offering a contract. You can sign it, or not. All the folks here that are being so high and mighty about it just come off as weird tbh.
- dec0dedab0de 13y agoLets say you were to sign something like this, but then 10 years later the company completely changed direction and their new business plan was stealing candy from babies. Then you wrote something about how horrible the company is now. What kind of recourse would this contract let them take on you? Would you just have to pay the 2 weeks salary back to them?
- chiph 13y agoYour lawyer would tell you not to sign that agreement, because there wasn't a sunset clause on that portion. The ones I've seen are usually 2 years.
- MartinCron 13y agoI wondered about this after I signed a severance contract that required me not to "disclose, defame, compete, or recruit" for a set period of time. Don't judge me, it was an emotional time and the severance was non-trivial. I'm happy to say that time is over and I've gone on a disclosure, defamation, competition, and recruiting spree.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI laughed out loud at this :)
- chrisbennet 13y agoI wonder if you could head this off contractually when you start a new job? Something like adding "Severance pay will not be made conditional on limitations of free speech." to the contract that you and your employer sign when you start a new job.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoFirst you would have to get contractually guaranteed severance pay, which is a lot more than most people get.
- chrisbennet 13y agoNot necessarily. They probably wouldn't even notice the clause in the contract until you pointed it out when you refused to sign the disparagement clause. As an aside, the last time I got "severance" was in 2003 - my severance was a free lunch. It was a good company that went out of business.
- hisabness 13y agodo most companies purchase ipads for employees when they're cash flow negative?
- frozenport 13y agoOr you can sign it and nevertheless keep making disparaging remark.
- stkni 13y agoI've grudgingly signed one of these a few years ago because the owner of the company had a habit of vindictively pursuing employees she didn't like until they were poor. That trumped the crappy termination clause so I signed it! But ultimately I don't think it really matters too much so why not just take the money and have it both ways? I reasoned that it would be pretty hard to enforce if I ever did really feel like venting some serious spleen. Having said all that, most sour-grapes aren't worth publicizing IMHO. Unless they're funny of course and this one wasn't funny enough.
- rayiner 13y agoI would approach these contracts as creating an anti-competitive restraint on trade. Specifically, they seek to undermine the efficiency of the labor market by obscuring information about the working conditions at various employers. I think states would be quite justified in outlawing the practice on those grounds.
- melindajb 13y agoI love this. Yes, you want someone's silence, you're going to have to do better than two weeks of substandard pay that passes for a salary in SV startups. most employees forget that leaving is as much a negotiation as starting and EVERYTHING (in most cases, barring mass layoffs) is negotiable.
- X4 13y agoFired People need Help, Power and a Lobby. >> Real story: I hated when I found out that I got presumably 2x more than other people and weren't allowed to tell them contractually. What I found out was that it was a lie and that some pet or favorite employees later or earlier got the same amount as I did. I don't like unfair payments even when I win! There are alternatives way of payment, like self-chosen salaries and collective efficiency based correction, but I don't know how such things are solved on a social level without causing anger and hatred. For example, I have a "friend", who is such a lazy ass, he would consider him smart for doing only what's necessary to get things done without doing actual work. That means finding ways to apply pre-made solution etc. and he hustles at every single job that you may have heard about. Yes he makes themes, IT-Stuff, changes your tires, washes your car, sells stuff on local classifieds ads, sets up stuff at events, works on your mc donalds and more. What would you do about such people? That guy would choose the highest possible salary for himself, his salary would get corrected by the employees based on performance, well if he doesn't try to social engineer his way up. You see, it's hard. I don't know a solution to fair payments to be honest. Do you?
- geebee 13y agoI have serious misgivings about this sort of "hush money". In general, I'd prefer not to interfere in private contracts, but this one has such serious implications for everyone else. In particular, it can end up creating an information imbalance, enforced by the courts, that allows a certain group of people to remain "in the know", with everyone else unaware of what is going on. I read a while back about a law firm that had evidently done something very dodgy - representing an inventor and the firm purchasing the invention at the same time. The engineers were eventually paid a settlement, but part of the settlement was a gag order - nobody was allowed to talk about what had happened or the amount of money paid. This included, of course, the press. Now, what do you want to bet that well connected lawyers, upper managers, and so forth, are able to access the terms of this deal - even if they weren't involved? What are the odds that an inventor who approaches a law firm will know what transpired and why? The imbalance of information will put the inventor at an overwhelming disadvantage. My gut feeling is that there is a third party in all of this - me. Well, me, and all the little people. I understand the need to enforce contracts within reason, but I'm having a tough time seeing my own personal interest, or the general public interest, in enforcing these "stay quiet" contracts. I'd also point out that this isn't really a situation where we are prying into a private transaction and forcing people to talk. Our courts are actually enforcing the gag rule that keeps most of us in the dark about what is really going on out there. My misgivings about regulating private transactions aren't as strong when all we'd need to do is stop enforcing contracts that are clearly against the public interest [1]. [1] I am still thinking this through. I'm not absolutely sure this is against the public interest, or, even if it is, if we the courts should refuse to enforce the provision. It's how I'm leaning, but I have a sense that there may be more to this. I am generally glad that courts won't enforce certain terms of contracts, such as very long non-compete clauses and the like...
- dreamdu5t 13y agoThe article works against your point. Ultimately, he didn't take the money. We aren't in danger of living in a world where people can't talk about work. The vast majority of employers wouldn't be able to afford such a clause.
- 13y ago
- FrankenPC 13y agoMaking termination/downsizing severance payouts contingent on signing a STFU clause should be criminalized. It smacks of duress to me.
- busterarm 13y agoI was laid off in a big layoff round on Monday. Apparently the only reasons I got caught in it were because it's a public company and because I've been employed too long and my benefits cost too much. Whatever, I got several weeks of severance and signed. I feel shitty about it but I need the money. I can't believe how many people have been fired this week. My twitter feed is filled with them.
- maxmem 13y agoThat's when I'd rewrite it and then sign the rewritten version.
- _delirium 13y agoA friend summed it up like this: Modern employment. Can't speak freely before you have a job (social media vetting), can't speak freely in your own time while you have a job (clauses in your contract), can't speak freely when you no longer have a job.
- cududa 13y agoYou can speak as freely as you want - there's just a difference between public and private speech. It's your own choice to publicize your opinions on social media and the internet.
- _delirium 13y agoI wouldn't say having to confine your speech to private quarters where word can't get traced back to you is being able to "speak freely". If you can't write a newspaper letter to the editor, or post an update on Facebook, without your creepy employer stalking you and disciplining you for it, you aren't able to speak freely.
- cududa 13y agoAt any point in history, if you wrote a "Letter to the editor" disparaging your company or boss, you'd most likely get fired. How is posting on a public web service different?
- CapitalistCartr 13y agoBecause now you risk your employment by writing a letter that isn't about your employer at all. Anything your (prospective) employer doesn't like is verboten. So people deliberately circumscribe their speech.
- mccolin 13y ago> I think I get to keep last year’s Christmas gift of an iPad, and the previous year’s bottle of wine has long been drunk A way to reduce burn rate could have included slightly less lavish gifts.
- gwern 13y agoThe wine was probably like $20, and the iPad (what, $400?) may easily have paid for itself in giving employees first-hand experience with a very popular/hot tech & ecosystem.
- dwc 13y ago> Though such clauses don’t technically violate the First Amendment Not technically, not in spirit, not in any way related to the 1st amendment. Have so few people actually bothered to learn even a little about the 1st amendment? You can read the entire first amendment several times and then ponder it a little in just a few minutes, because it's very short. In fact, I'll paste the entire text: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. To boil it down even further for relevance: Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press That's it. The contract and agreement to it have nothing to do with the first amendment.
- jrockway 13y agoIf this were 100 years ago, you could make the argument that by enforcing this contract, Congress made a law abridging the freedom of the press. I think that ship has sailed and failed, however, so it's too late now. But it is interesting to think of how the Constitution can become meaningless if the government is willing to create laws to allow others to take away your Constitutional rights.
- darkarmani 13y ago> If this were 100 years ago, you could make the argument that by enforcing this contract, Congress made a law abridging the freedom of the press. That's crazy. The point of the right is that you have choice where a law takes away that choice. You can choose to sell your actions to other people for a limited set of legal actions. Why shouldn't Congress enforce contracts when BOTH parties are willing to sign? I hate the idea of this particular clause and find it very distasteful, but I don't think it should be illegal.
- gottagetmac 13y agoLearning "a little about the 1st amendment" and pondering it "a little in a few minutes" is a dangerous thing. From just looking at this text, for example, you would think that it only applied to Congress, when actually it also applies to the executive branch, the judicial branch, and states and local government (since the Fourteenth Amendment and the incorporation cases). I also think this narrow view has made you jump to a much stronger conclusion than is warranted. At least one scholar has considered whether the First Amendment could be interpreted to require that contracts of silence be unenforceable. http://www.lawschool.cornell.edu/research/cornell-law-review/upload/Garfield-final.pdf http://www.lawschool.cornell.edu/research/cornell-law-review... In this case you happen to be mostly right, but don't assume you can understand the contours of First Amendment law just by looking at the text. There is a vast apparatus that has been built around the First Amendment, little of which is deducible from the constitutional text alone.
- babesh 13y agoThese agreements come with monetary penalties such as $10000 per disparaging remark. Also agreements come into place not necessarily with a signature but with the consideration, the severance money going to you.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoIt takes money to sue someone, and, given that the company is downsizing, it doesn't sound like they have money to do that. I'd consider taking the two weeks severance and ignoring the clause. What are they going to win back, the 2 weeks of severance plus what? The amount of time and money plus potential negative publicity they're going to generate just isn't worth it. I realize this might seem unprincipled, but they're being pretty unprincipled by putting the clause in the exit agreement anyway. Regardless, it's usually best not to talk smack about previous employers. Better to damn with faint praise.
- hercynium 13y agoHeh. Almost two years ago I was fired from a fairly prominent internet services company... Ah, who am I trying to avoid? It was Akamai. I speak ill of them all the time. Not about their impressive infrastructure and engineering, or the scores of brilliant people I had the privilege to work with. No, it was more my experience with the corporate culture and the pervasive games of "power politics" that anybody who wasn't a manager was constantly subject to. Unfortunately I ended up in a position to be the patsy for a director's bad decisions, to make a long story short. Indeed, I was asked to sign an agreement in exchange for money, and because of the timing of things (newborn baby 2.5 weeks prior) I needed the money more than I needed the freedom to speak my mind about the situation. And it really wasn't very much money, just like in the linked article. However, despite sending the signed agreement certified mail, the money never showed up, their HR department claims it was never received, and the money didn't end up mattering so much as I was fielding offers within a month and began my current position in short order. Since then I've received several letters from them, asking for my signature on various things and I refuse - There's simply nothing they can do to me. But I know quite well that I'm lucky. I've got a skill set and experience that puts me in demand, and anybody who asks why I was fired can get a simple answer: "Here's my LinkedIn profile, take note of the slew of recommendations I got within a week of my termination." (I will add, my subsequent contact with their HR and legal department did have me worried about things for a while - not to mention various thinly-veiled verbal threats made by my former director before and during my termination, in case you're wondering just what kind of politics and culture made me dislike the place)
- toomuchtodo 13y agoAfter having to work with Akamai as a vendor in several positions (it being out of my control to use a different vendor), their corporate attitude doesn't surprise me at all. Apologies for your experience.
- hercynium 13y agoNo apologies needed, but thanks! I learned some valuable lessons.
- robbiea 13y agoI think the issue that Will Blythe might face now is that he has now alienated himself against future employers. Here is a guy who is willingly going to criticize a company he leaves (or maybe even currently employed at), just because he feels like it. There once was a hugely popular tech gossip newsletter in Chicago that once publicly criticized an employer for screwing over his part-time editor in some sort of business deal. On one hand it's great that the employer was called out for some wrong-doings, but most importantly who is going to hire that editor now? Not me, that's for sure. You want me to hire someone who if I have a disagreement with is now going to tell her side and her side only on this email newsletter which she has priority access too and essentially put me on blast? Will put his previous employer on blast without any quotes from them or getting their side on it. Does Will feel better about it? absolutely. Is this going to help his chances of getting a job with a new employer. Not a chance. Maybe this will help him sell his books? | Mind you, I’m not looking to disparage Byliner. This is the equivalent of saying, No offense but.. or I'm not a racist, but...
- mcherm 13y agoHe did not criticize his former employer at all, merely talked about the clause in the severance contract and his need as a journalist not to feel constrained.
- ujsfdo 13y agoSo on the money re: I'm not a racist but.. (ie I'm not going to lie to you.. Especially for someone in an editorial position, which is a pretty interchangable hire. First result, first page on Google for searches on his name will be that article in which he publicly discloses a VC/employer decision on burn rate, and this company health. I'd never hire the guy.
- jrockway 13y agoVery nicely done. Whenever someone wants you to sign something they say is "meaningless", refuse. If it's meaningless, why would they want you to sign it? At the very least, hold out for more money and a time limit. Ask them to keep you on salary for 6 months, and you'll agree not to disparage them for a year, or something like that. A 50% discount! Think of the burn rate!
- kabdib 13y agoI've been in a couple exit interviews where the terms were crappy. One I didn't have a choice with: The company was shutting down, and while I was going to get a severance check I was going to have to wait a period mandated by law (because I was a protected class, being over 40 at the time). Fortunately there was money left in the bank when I was able to collect the check (the founders had deep pockets and had committed to paying). The second was when a start-up tried to stiff me on vacation pay, which in California is yours. I just said, "This is unacceptable" and sat there. 20 minutes later, after some apologizing and attempts to justify it with "well, that was your sick pay, too..." they cut a check.
- aragot 13y agoWhat about when the forever-non-disparaging clause is in the employment contract itself? And what value does it have that the contract has a stamp "Confidential" on all pages? Would talking about it here be forbidden?
- run4_too 13y agoHere's a simple thing to say to an employer that offers such a clause: Define "disparagement". If anything ever goes to court, from case law it seems to be all based on whether or not an action is "disparaging". So, define what constitutes disparagement in advance, and if that is acceptable to you, go ahead and sign. Personally, I'd sign nothing for 2 weeks pay, and then make sure everyone knows that was the offered severance. Seems disparaging enough to me. ;)
- guelo 13y agoAs a programmer, the clause that always bothers me is the one about how they own everything that I do that's vaguely related to their business, even on my own time. I go ahead and sign it because I hear that the state of California protects me on that one. But I still make sure to hide my side projects from my employers and coworkers.
- theatrus2 13y agoIf you are operating in California, push back. Non-enforceable doesn't mean they can threaten all they want. Note that good companies clearly spell out the CA legal section which covers this. Bad ones try to hide it.
- hafichuk 13y agoDoes Will Blythe have a paypal account I can send some love to?
- staunch 13y agoI agree with this person completely. It's the principle of the thing. There's absolutely no way I'd ever sign such an agreement...for two weeks severance. For 6 months severance? I think we'd both sign with enthusiasm.
- jrs99 13y agoDo they still keep pushing irrelevant articles from the 1980s?
- fit2rule 13y agoThe thing is, why disparage things? It never works in your favour, and the catharsis is never worth the ricochet factor.
- entendre 13y agoHave you ever walked into a job that you thought would save your life and pull you out of a slew of bad breaks... your dream job? And then some miserable pissant with leverage over you and your position decides to make you a scapegoat? When you're going down in flames at least grab the pilot's parachute.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- raganwald 13y agoNo disparagement clauses are a lot like non-compete clauses. I would never sign one, but at the same time, I am reluctant to speak poorly of a former employer or to go into direct competition with former colleagues. I want the right to do those things, but I don't actually want to do them. Now of course, they always say, "Yeah, maybe not you, but somebody." To which I say, "That's why you took so long to check my references before hiring me. I'm no longer somebody. And if it mattered that much, you should have put it in the employment agreement so that I could have declined the job before taking it." The only people who should feel morally compelled to sign no-disparagement clauses before accepting severance are people who are being fired for leaking confidential information on the job.
- genwin 13y agoI'd sign a non-compete clause for enough money in return. Same with a non-disparagement clause, especially if I had nothing bad to say. "Give me 6 weeks severance, instead of 2. Then I'll gladly sign it."
- vladd 13y agoFor me it's not about the amount of money but rather the freedom of speech restriction that you must remember for the rest of your life. Human memory is a rather shady thing. How many of the university lectures do you still remember? Now imagine yourselves 10 years down the road, at a beer with other people getting asked about an event related to that company. Will you assume the rights of speech you forfeited for the rest of your life and remember them every time you will have the chance to speak differently? When you're 80 and possibly with Alzheimer -- does that count too?
- genwin 13y agoFor enough severance money I would hold them in good regard! I'd take a chance on letting something disparaging slip to someone who could get it back to them with proof; odds of that are nil as I rarely talk about my past jobs.
- 13y ago
- swamp40 13y agoIt seems to me like he would have quickly signed the agreement if it were, say, for 3 months salary. So his "I'll keep my self respect" morality argument seems a little weak. Like the joke goes, "We've already established what you are, now we're just negotiating your rates...".
- oh_sigh 13y agoPersonally, I would sign it, and then if I felt I had something negative to say and wanted to say it publicly, I would return the money. Also, could you use ASL to communicate your feelings about the company, since that is neither oral or written?
- JohnTHaller 13y agoLet's say you sign such an exit clause and get paid your 2 weeks hush money. What's to stop the company blaming some performance or missed target on a project on you afterwards, possibly even publicly. And then you're not allowed to respond. I have never signed a clause like this in a start/end employment contract nor will I ever. If a company doesn't want to be spoken ill of, don't do ill. If the only way a company can keep its employees/former employees from speaking true ills of them is to contractually obligate them not to, that's not a company worth giving the time of day to.
- snorkel 13y agoBah! The termination agreement is just a bunch boilerplate legalese cover your ass bullshit, really. So sign it and take the severance check, then go say whatever you want anyway. It's very unlikely that a company that can't afford its current staff will then spend time and money with lawyers just to smack you around for saying mean things about them.
- ExpiredLink 13y ago> “You agree,” it reads, “that you will never make any negative or disparaging statements (orally or in writing) about the Company or its stockholders, directors, officers, employees, products, services or business practices, except as required by law.” No consequences in case of violation? Sign it. It's meaningless, merely there to intimidate the judicial illiterate (i.e. most of the ordinary people).
- michaelochurch 13y agoMy general rule of thumb is that if the severance covers the expected time of the job search-- and allows you to represent yourself as employed during that time-- you should sign the non-disparagement clause and take the package. That's typically 2-3 months at lower levels, and 6+ months at higher levels. Offering nondisparagement is almost always worth it to move on with your career intact and your income undisrupted. At 2 weeks, you should tell them to shove it. If they don't take care of you, you don't take care of them. Honestly, I wish more people did tell the truth about ex-employers who treated them badly. The "never badmouth" rule makes severance payments low, reckless firings common, and bad corporate behavior a lot more prevalent than it should be.
- mrfusion 13y agoIs that common to present yourself as employed? I've never heard of it.
- keypusher 13y agoHe wasn't fired, he was laid off. There are two types of employment termination, those where the employee is deemed at fault by the employer, and those where he is not. This guy was explicitly told that he was not a fault, and he was laid off due to burn rate at the company. Then he says he was fired? No. What difference does it make? When you are laid off there is often a severance package and you are eligible for unemployment benefits, some of which come out of your former employer's pocket. Therefore, you are still at least somewhat obligated to them financially. If you are fired, you are not eligible for either of these things. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Termination_of_employment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Termination_of_employment
- rickyc091 13y agoMy case is pretty similar, but I caved and signed. For me, I wasn't fired, I quit, but I had to sign the same clause, except it was to receive my final paycheck. Oh yeah, my vacation days/pay were also stripped from me, even though I had already requested days off months before I had told them I would be leaving.
- dmourati 13y agoThis is a perfect time to apply Holmes' "bad man theory of law."[1] Sign the agreement AND disparage them all you want. Sure, you could wait the two weeks and cash the check first to be extra cautious. After that, what are they really going to do? People like to imagine being dragged into court to determine whether disparagement (whatever that means) actually took place. The author even says the disparagement has to be untrue. That doesn't sound like anything any company wants to litigate. Can they cry and scream and say you broke the agreement? Sure, but so what? Their remedies are few and far between and you are long gone. If you really want to cover your end, just get a job first, then disparage away. Happy disparaging! [1] http://www.constitution.org/lrev/owh/path_law.htm http://www.constitution.org/lrev/owh/path_law.htm
- squozzer 13y agoI would only say this -- sticking to facts, avoiding emotionally-charged or conclusive words (e.g. "dishonest", "evil"), and -- perhaps extreme cases -- not naming names makes the claim of disparagement much harder to stick. For example, consider the following: I bought a widget from an online retailer. It arrived broken. It took two emails and three calls to get an RMA. Once received, it took three weeks to receive a refund. Versus Online retailer X is evil.
- yoavyoav 13y agoamazingly written. that's a keeper right there.
- damm 13y agoIt is unfortunate that companies must resort to Termination Agreements and wave money in front of your face to buy 'brand loyalty'. (I Call it that) Additionally it is downright shameful that companies have forgotten to communicate better; some empathy and you'll find letting go of employee's does not have to be as negative. Worst part is companies expect the negativity when letting go employee's; they expect them to blow up. I think the worst part is how I've seen companies set up the firings at times to add extra 'pain' to the employee's departure. Personally I spent almost 2 years at a company who was Acquired by Twitter to only be let go less than 45 days after the merger (right before Christmas). They let a peer go right after he got back from his Honeymoon! I have seen worse but this is just the tip of the iceberg! Nothing better than Congratulations on getting married; pack your desk and GTFO. Lastly: I did not sign a non-disclosure agreement personally about my last $client and I can speak freely about how much vitriol was spewed there on a daily basis.
- Rexxar 13y agoThere should always be a time limit on this sort of clause (preferably short).
- samstave 13y agoThis happened to me in ~2009 where I worked for the worst CEO I have ever worked for. When I left the company, he offered me ~$5,000 to sign a non-disparagement agreement. I refused and said I was free to say whatever I wanted about the company. They literally held the check out to show me "Here is your carrot, take it".
- grellas 13y agoNon-disparagement clauses can be seen as a throwaway item, a suffocating burden, an essential protection, or a damned nuisance, each according to taste or context. To begin with, lawyers tend to see these clauses as essential protections and they are sometimes right. But, right or wrong, they tend to insist upon them, especially in the employment context. This explains their prevalence but, of course, does not necessarily justify their use. Just to illustrate the cases where they truly are an essential protection, you and a competitor have been fighting for years in court over ugly and untrue things that someone has said about you or your company - non-trivial things that have really hurt you. When it comes time to settle that case, a continuing non-disparagement obligation will be not only helpful but essential to the resolution. The same is true in many other legal fights. When emotions have run high, and parties have antipathy toward one another, it is good practice to help ensure the peace after their fight has been settled to require that they not speak badly of one another and to give a simple mechanism such as binding arbitration to help resolve any follow-on dispute over whether they have done so or not. In such cases, there are excellent reasons to bind parties contractually to restraints on their ability to speak where they would normally be free to do so. The employment context gets trickier because the antecedent acrimony that characterizes a legal fight may well not be present at the time of a termination and the question then arises: why am I being artificially muzzled? And there is a point to this: why be barred from speaking truthfully about a former situation even if it might be negative? why be at risk of a harassing lawsuit over what it means that something "may" reflect "negatively" about someone? why, in an age of easy communication through social media, be made to feel you cannot even speak about something that may have been a major part of your life, perhaps for many years? What may be seen as a throwaway item by some can be felt to be suffocating by others, and all the more so because it is tacked onto a token severance that gives you very little in exchange. That said, I would say that the overwhelming number of employers and employees alike see these simply as throwaway items. They figure no one will care about such clauses except the lawyers. And, in most cases, they are probably right. The question then becomes whether one should not sign as a matter of principle or whether to just sign and take the money. Most employees take the money. Of course, employees can push back if they have leverage. No one is obligated by law to sign a separation agreement. If the terms aren't right, and can be made right, then push back. Insist that the token severance be made more substantial. Or that non-disparagement, if it is to be included at all, be made mutual (it can be quite a head-ache for a large employer to keep control of its many people to ensure that none speak badly of you). Or insist that it be narrowed or clarified so as to reduce or eliminate vagueness about what may or may not be deemed disparaging. Or insist that it be coupled with other considerations that give you benefits apart from your normal final pay, etc. This sort of negotiation can make these clauses a big nuisance from the employer standpoint and may cause the employer simply to drop the clause. However, all of this assumes employee leverage, which doesn't often exist in the routine case, and so, as noted above, most employees simply take the money, accept the restriction, and don't bother to look back. And so it all depends. For the author of this piece, this was a critical issue. For many others, it is not. Context is critical. And for all but trivial cases, do check with a good lawyer to understand the implications of what you are signing. If the risks are real, there is nothing worse that a harassing lawsuit from a former employer angry with you over some statement you made out of emotion. This is what gives these clauses a bad name and it is also what can make them dangerous. In such cases, be cautious about exposing yourself to such risks in exchange for some token severance. It is probably not worth it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MyNameIsMK 13y agoEmployers are taking WAY MORE RISK than the worker. The term is called Employment-At-Will http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-will_employment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-will_employment
- mcv 13y agoHaving previous employers as guaranteed positive references can be pretty valuable. On the other hand, if it's standard, what's the value of a positive reference? If you get extra pay and the non-disparagement goes both ways, for most people individually it's probably a good idea to sign it. But for society as a whole? I'm not so sure.
- product50 13y agoI wonder if the author's stance would have been the same had he been offered 6 months severance.
- ErikRogneby 13y agoIt would be interesting to turn the tables and draw up a termination of contract when you quit, and demand 2 weeks severance in exchange for a non-disparagement clause which you agree to. I have a feeling that would raise a lot of hackles.
- jakobsen 13y agoAnybody with some law knowledge can help me get this right? He says the clause doesn't violate the First Amendment because he is freely agreeing to "forfeit his right to speak freely". Are constitutional rights not inalienable in the USA then? In my country, in case of conflict laws of "greater range" take precedence over laws of "lower range", and contracts are at the bottom of this hierarchy. That means that a clause as the one being discussed here would be void, since you can't give up your right to speak freely even if you wanted¹ Isn't there a similar concept in the USA?? ¹ That also means that if laws mandate 3 weeks of holidays, you can't take only 2 weeks in exchange for a bigger pay even if you wanted (happened to me once).
- fatca 13y agoThere is a mismatch in duration. The obligation on the side of the employer is a one-off payment. The obligation on the side of employee is ad vitam aeternam (forever). If the employer wants to keep the employee to his obligation, he will have to make additional payments for additional periods of non-disparagement.
- dangayle 13y agoWhen I and my team stood up to the executive team of a startup I was working for and quit, they offered me this exact non-disparagement gag clause in exchange for any compensation whatsoever. The reason we quit was because they were taking advantage of us, and we knew we were never going to get paid. We also knew that they would simply lie to whoever it was they were going to replace us with, so we refused to sign the gag. It was seriously one of the worst companies to work for, and I was darn sure going to make sure that everyone knew it. I value my freedom of speech
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- DavidWanjiru 13y agoI've always assumed that severance pay is not an artifact that is negotiated upon severance, but rather that it comes into effect once the necessary conditions vest, so to speak. Severance pay, and an employee's right to it, is implicitly contained in the employment agreement, and once the conditions for payment laid out in the employment and labour law regime under which you were hired are met, then your right to get paid automatically comes into effect. The idea that an employer can refuse to pay you on the basis that you have refused to sign a severance agreement seems out of whack with the spirit of the law to me, assuming that this is not explicitly stated either in law or in your employment terms (that your being paid for severance is subject to you signing a severance agreement).
- jwatte 13y agoEmployees are supposed to give two weeks of notice before leaving, and employers have traditionally (?) Given two weeks severance. If that severance is now conditional, what is the converse that employees change? Btw: whenever there is a limitation (and non-disparagement is common in employment agreements, too,) I insist it be time limited. Who knows what kinds of trolls have bought the other party ten years from now?
- ps4fanboy 13y agoAre severance payments in USA not guaranteed by law? In my country the company has to pay your severance and cant hold it hostage while you negotiate a contract.
- dimfisch 13y agoOne thing's for sure: Byliner got a lot of free advertising here...
- smhanov 13y agoIn Canada, at tech startup seminars, the lawyers remind us that the government has a "Ministry of Labour", and it is NOT called the "Ministry of Employers" for a reason. Lawyers advice employers to make the employee happy, or risk costly battles due to a complaint to the Ministry. As far as I know, you are legally entitled to either termination pay or advance notice, and holding it ransom as coercion to sign some agreement would be very risky. Apparently some companies still download employment agreements off the web that have the "at will" clause but this makes them invalid.
- dbot 13y agoA few years ago, my law school classmate turned down a lengthy severance to avoid signing one of these after a bitter termination. Instead, he took a job in the building's coffee shop. He'd see people he used to see all the time, and when they'd ask what happened, he'd tell them all about the horrible way he was treated by the firm, etc. The firm ended up giving him a bunch more money to shut up and quit the barrista job.
- JJ216 13y agowhat was that last part...except as allowed by law (approx.).....hmmmm, so by law one has the freedom of speech...so as long as there is not the contents of slander or fighting words in any utterance made by the fired employee, then it sounds like they got frazzled by some legal masturbation...the clause means nothing...
- JJ216 13y agowhat was that last part...except as allowed by law (approx.).....hmmmm, so by law one has the freedom of speech...so as long as there is not the contents of slander or fighting words in any utterance made by the fired employee, then it sounds like they got frazzled by some legal masturbation...the clause means nothing...
- JJ216 13y agowhat was that last part...except as allowed by law (approx.).....hmmmm, so by law one has the freedom of speech...so as long as there is not the contents of slander or fighting words in any utterance made by the fired employee, then it sounds like they got frazzled by some legal masturbation...the clause means nothing...
- JJ216 13y agowhat was that last part...except as allowed by law (approx.).....hmmmm, so by law one has the freedom of speech...so as long as there is not the contents of slander or fighting words in any utterance made by the fired employee, then it sounds like they got frazzled by some legal masturbation...the clause means nothing...
- JJ216 13y agowhat was that last part...except as allowed by law (approx.).....hmmmm, so by law one has the freedom of speech...so as long as there is not the contents of slander or fighting words in any utterance made by the fired employee, then it sounds like they got frazzled by some legal masturbation...the clause means nothing...