8 ms·
Searching the Internet for evidence of time travelers
- GenKali 13y agoEver so slightly disappointed at the complete lack of mention of Steins;Gate (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate) in the paper. Interesting read all the same :)
- Nursie 13y agoAnd no John Titor! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Titor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Titor
- Tarang 13y agoQuite interesting with the methods used, alas the conclusion: > Unfortunately, as of this writing, no prescient tweets or emails were received. Given the additional exposure that the public listing of this manuscript gains, we will continue to search, on occasion, for active tweets and emails involving potential time travel.
- 8ig8 13y agoPDF of paper in case it wasn't obvious: http://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.7128v1.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.7128v1.pdf
- Houshalter 13y agoWell great. Now time travelers can't make prescient tweets because if they do it will reveal them.
- justsee 13y agoI expect time travelers will agree on a responsible prescience disclosure system which uses something like http://www.proofofexistence.com/about http://www.proofofexistence.com/about.
- bachback 13y agoI thought this kind of stuff goes to http://vixra.org/ http://vixra.org/
- cs02rm0 13y agoOf course the search didn't find anything. They already know what will be (was?) looked for...
- Strilanc 13y agoLooks like an Ig Nobel prize winner to me. > Although these negative results do not disprove time travel, given the great reach of the Internet, this search is perhaps the most comprehensive to date.
- awjr 13y agoIsn't the issue here that they are describing the methods through which they are trying to determine time travel. In effect, telling anyone in the future exactly what not to do. Let's also assume that somebody had a reason to travel into the past, say to kill Hitler. Our timeline would record that an Austrian artist was murdered in the 1920s. We would not consider this historically significant. I think time travel is inherently very difficult to detect. Even if a time traveller 'dropped' tech. This tech would be recoverable by popping back in time and recovering it.
- andyjohnson0 13y ago"...say to kill Hitler." Everybody kills Hitler on their first trip. http://www.abyssapexzine.com/wikihistory/ http://www.abyssapexzine.com/wikihistory/
- bsaul 13y agoThanks for that link, i haven't laughed this hard in ages
- fhars 13y agoWell, then starting to read at http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlersTimeTravelExemptionAct http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlersTimeTravel... may be dangerous to your health.
- danielweber 13y agoIt's beautiful for how it captures the essence of all message board fights.
- arethuza 13y agoWhy just Hitler? Stalin and Mao were arguably equally as bad: http://necrometrics.com/tyrants.htm http://necrometrics.com/tyrants.htm And there are monsters like Leopold II of Belgium (possible victims in the range 2-15 million) who hardly anyone remembers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leopold_II_of_Belgium#Exploitation_and_atrocities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leopold_II_of_Belgium#Exploitat... Actually, as hardly anyone remembers Leopold II maybe he is the ideal target.... :-| [NB I eventually remembered that I'm against the death penalty - so what I am actually in favor of is apprehending the relevant individuals and bringing them back to face trial by the appropriate authorities. Although I admit there would be a distinct temptation to do a Cheradenine Zakalwe with Vasili Blokhin: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasili_Blokhin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasili_Blokhin Where was the Grey Area when we needed it!]
- Udo 13y agoThis is interesting, but these methods don't strike me as really viable. The Twitter outreach was specifically targeted at the cooperation of Twitter-using time travelers, and while Pope Francis might or might not be historically significant enough to warrant prescient mentioning, I'm sure comet ISON is not. The assumption is also (and maybe it has to be) that time travelers would blurp out important prescient information - however, I don't think that holds true if they were either well disciplined or engaged in historical research - which would mean they know little more (if anything) about our immediate future than we do. I'm obviously not advocating time travelers are present (I would think with the certain prospect of leaving your time line in order to create another one, the proposition of time travel seems akin to a one-way change in universes that doesn't sound very inviting), but it's definitely fun to speculate about. Realistically, one would also have to take into account the fact that, by mere virtue of being present, a time traveler will change the course of history in the long run. A more thorough effort could center on large-scale automated data mining for prescient terms on the internet. Of course, there would be many false positives, but as a side effect we could learn more about the epidemiology of ideas even if we don't discover time travelers. It seems to me that a disciplined time traveler would not purposefully drop historically significant hints - however, if they are from a future and culture close enough to our own, they might still reveal themselves inadvertently through idiosyncratic phrases and reference to concepts that are from the future. Hand-picked phrases are not enough to discover this, it would have to be large-scale AI-supported text mining.
- lucaspiller 13y ago> Twitter-using time travelers If I were a time traveller I probably wouldn't use any of the social networks that are popular for non-time-travellers. Firstly managing so many social network accounts to keep up with the latest fashions would be a right pain (imagine having to change your profile picture on all of them...), but also their 'timeline' view would be completely different to my relative timeline. I'd assume the network format would be distributed, running on something akin to a phone that you keep on you at all times. Whenever you make a post it records your relative 'life time', or just increments an id, so posts are always ordered in your relative timeframe. When you meet someone it would sync up with their account - I'm not quite sure how that would work though. The issue is you could post something about them publicly that hasn't happened yet in their timeframe (that could be embarrassing). Private messages are even worse... (N.b. I should probably patent this idea for when time travel is invented)
- Ensorceled 13y agoIf you are interested in time travel: I saw the movie "About Time" last night and it was both awesome and romantic. Perfect date movie for the geek/non-geek couple. And now at least this discussion thread is not completely useless :-)
- bushido 13y agoWell if you're really interested in time travel fiction, nothing beats Doctor Who.
- ChikkaChiChi 13y agoSpecifically, 'Blink' is the best time-travel conceptual episode in recent memory.
- Ensorceled 13y agoTrue, very true. But my girlfriend has a negative interest in watching Doctor Who but loved About Time.
- sathishmanohar 13y agoWhat if there is no internet in the future?
- binarymax 13y agoThis only covers time travelers from the future. If one were to use similar methods to find time travelers from the past, we'd probably find millions of candidates :)
- Udo 13y agoBillions, even. Since we're all time travelers from the past...
- raverbashing 13y agoI believe finding time travellers from the past is trivial, especially those who travelled at a speed of 1s/s (or adimensional 1)
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoHow does the measurement even work? 1s/s in what frame of reference?
- rpenguin13 13y agoIt probably doesn't really work.
- infruset 13y agoHere's a good way to spot them : http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=3001#comic http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=3001#comic
- bushido 13y agoTravel to the future is actually more probable(theoretically possible), I am basing this on a good explanation by Brian Cox(based on Einstein's theory of special relativity). The basic premise is that to travel to the future an object would need to reach near the speed of light, the closer you get to the speed the further you can travel into the future, but travelling back would not be possible. A direct quote from Brian Cox "If you go fast, your clock runs slow relative to people who are still. As you approach the speed of light, your clock runs so slow you could come back 10,000 years in the future".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 3rd3 13y agoThe NSA probably has enough data at hand for answering this question.
- XorNot 13y agoThis is actually something that's more reasonable. Presumably time travellers wouldn't advertise their presence heavily (can you say immediate and massive possible security hazard?) but one way to track them would be to look for net-traffic patterns which matched a person who was trying to localize the day and time, or who searched for things well in advance of them becoming known, general trends, or even being put up on the internet at all.
- chime 13y agoLike this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Benoit_double-murder_and_suicide#Wikipedia_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Benoit_double-murder_and_...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 13y agoPerhaps Twitter is run by a cabal of evil time travellers who have created technology to check whether tweets reveal temporal anomalies and delete them automatically to cover their tracks and protect the status of an elite class in the distant future. What if all communications technology has been built around this capability; everything routed through a network of 'security agencies' that ostensibly protect the function of the current government but really work to design a future that benefits a rarified few. That'd be cool.
- dionyziz 13y agoI work for Twitter and can confirm that.
- DanBC 13y agoThere's a relevant Mitchell and Web scetch. Someone travels back in time and meets Faraday. Faraday asks a bunch of questions, none of which can be answered because the traveller is just an everyday person who has little clue about how things work.
- bwindels 13y agoArmstrong and Miller actually: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6c2kyNJ3Omo http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6c2kyNJ3Omo
- DanBC 13y agoWhoops, thanks for the correction. I did wonder why I couldn't find the clip in YouTube.
- g_lined 13y agoYou may have been thinking of this sketch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa_hiLXLbTc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa_hiLXLbTc Where one guy proposes a modern idea but it makes no sense to people of the past. I think this is one of a 2 or 3 such sketches.
- rwmj 13y agoThere's a slightly silly-but-entertaining film in which an aircraft carrier goes back in time. The spoiler of the film is that one man who is left behind in time becomes absurdly rich by becoming a pioneering "inventor". So we should look for absurdly rich people who have made dozens of inventions. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080736/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080736/
- praptak 13y agoI'm about to go back in time. If I succeed, the silicon transistor gets invented in 1954 and Christmas goes to happen in the winter (northern hemisphere).
- lazyjones 13y agoIf time travel is possible at all, we'd eventually discover and use it. I wonder if this means that we'll destroy our civilization before becoming able to use time travel (seems more likely than time travel being impossible to achieve within thousands of years from now).
- lukifer 13y agoOne could also posit an Anthropic Principle of time travel: the fact that we still exist means that our universe is among the tiny subset of potential multiverses in which time travel is not discovered, or whose use is sufficiently constrained so as to not result in destruction or paradox.
- frankydp 13y agoOr that time travel is discovered so far into the future that change in our time would have un-calculable consequences even for that advanced society. Or that they have discovered immortality and view us as a subspecies like we would neanderthals.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoLarry Niven phrased it thusly: > If the universe of discourse permits the possibility of time travel and of changing the past, then no time machine will be invented in that universe. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niven's_laws http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niven's_laws
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alimoeeny 13y agothis is HN not reddit/r/wtf !
- andyjohnson0 13y agoI'm not sure why time travellers from the future would bother to leave prescient messages on the net. What's the motivation? Something like graffiti artists tagging difficult locations? What I can see them (hypothetically) doing is manipulating present-day financial markets by exploiting their knowledge of future events (e.g. sudden commodity shortages or unexpected mineral discoveries) to increase their wealth. Even small manipulations would produce large downstream gains due to compound interest. So perhaps market data is a place to look for abnormalities - particularly in existing systems that look for signs of insider trading, or investment accounts/trusts that are untouched over very long periods of time. Of course, such data is usually protected and inaccessible anyway.
- infruset 13y agoYes, I would probably go back to 2009 and mine bitcoins (or fill captchas for 5 BTC a piece..) with a CPU..
- andyjohnson0 13y agoGood point. All the early bitcoin miners are clearly suspect. And Satoshi Nakamoto's sudden appearance and then disappearance now makes total sense.
- arethuza 13y agoCombining time travel and computation has interesting results: http://www.frc.ri.cmu.edu/~hpm/project.archive/general.articles/1991/TempComp.html http://www.frc.ri.cmu.edu/~hpm/project.archive/general.artic...
- danielweber 13y agoTotally serious question: If I go back to 1990, can I distribute a current version of emacs? The toolchain to build the current source tree won't exist for a while.
- venomsnake 13y agoThere is no such thing as time travel. There is only teleportation. Because you have to have 4(or 10) fixed coordinates to move. Just time travel means you will be in vacuum, rock or middle of a star the moment you arrive. Since we already found the higgs I think the next line of research should be what exactly gives a particle "the where".
- graylights 13y agoDoesn't relativity say there is no such thing as fixed coordinates? That it all depends on frame of reference.
- ElongatedTowel 13y agoThat point is often brought up. But we don't really know how a time-machine could potentially work, so why is teleportation a necessity? If you want to travel to the future you would abuse time delation. While all means to do so pose certain problems none of them involve teleportation. If traveling to the past would work in a similar way the time-machine would move trough every moment until it reaches its destination. If it never has to leave earth or its orbit to do so it would always be affected by gravity and as such end up where you want it to.
- threeseed 13y agoI've never understood this logic. If say time travel is invented in year 3000. Then surely by 3050 it would be affordable for a certain segment of society. And be 3070 available for a mass market. And by 3100 available in watch form. So shouldn't we expect there to be millions/billions of people interfering with the past. A significant percentage of which would be deliberately aiming to manipulate, destroy, communicate, affect and do all the things we expect people wouldn't. Clearly it means either two things. 1: time travel is not possible. 2: going back in time forks the universe/space-time (About Time is a recent movie that proposes this).
- graylights 13y agoIt's been 60 years since nuclear power was invented, so in 10 years it'll be available for mass market? I'd also like my watch form plane. What if it's so energy intensive that a future dyson sphere can only power it once a year. It doesn't matter how cheap the machine is, if the resources are expensive.
- astrobe_ 13y agoIndeed energy conservashion and entropy equalizashion was a large problem.
- ElongatedTowel 13y agoThat poses the question whether a civilization that is advanced enough to build a dyson sphere would be able to build a second one somewhere else. The species would have enough time to collect energy and improve the machine until no reachable sun would be usable. And though we don't carry nuclear reactors in our watches (I guess smartphone would be more reasonable these days) we might carry fusion reactors in the year 38000.
- astrobe_ 13y agoInterventions in the past are possible as long as they don't change the future in significant ways. Think of it as Schrödinger's cat who is not dead as long as you don't look inside the box.
- 13y ago
- aquanext 13y agoTemporal Prime Directive
- wslh 13y agoSorry, I use a VPN to the future ;-)
- Irishsteve 13y agoCitation bait == link bait
- Vaskivo 13y agoOn a tangentially related note, the tabletop roleplaying game Continuum has, IMO, the most interesting description of time travel and a time travellers community. The premise is simple. What is the most logical thing for the first time traveller to do? He would travel to the future to get his hands on the most advanced time machine possible. In the end, the best is the human mind. They time (and space) travel with a simple thought. It has a single "timeline", i.e. changing something in the past doesn't "split the timeline" but creates a paradox, that translates to "frag" on all people related to the changed action. This makes people want to correct these paradoxes. Example, I go back in time and kill Hitler. It frags a LOT of people. The good guys want to correct the frag. They could go back in my timeline and prevent me from doing it, fragging me. If they don't want to frag me, they could switch Hitler with a Robot or something. I don't get fragged because still I shot something I though was Hitler, yet Hitler remains alive.
- precisioncoder 13y agoWouldn't we as well need a counterpart to "frag" such as "pop" for all the people saved/born due to the change? Then if the "good guys" corrected the original "frags" those "popped" people would be re-"fragged" which would cause a split group of "good guys" to attempt to "correct" the previously "corrected" history?
- Vaskivo 13y agoNot really. It's cosmology is weird. The universe is kind of a mutable thing full of "sentient force" (it's time travellers). When a paradox is formed, it's defense mechanism kicks in to eliminate the paradox. That defense mechanism is the good guys (the continuum). Frag is associated with what you KNOW. Information is usefull but very dangerous. Imagine this, I go to Auschwitz and see all that horror. I decide to kill Hitler and succeed. I just fragged myself, because I know I killed Hitler (therefore, the Holocaust never happened) yet I saw/know what happened if he were alive. Frag is like being "out of sync" with the universe. If I don't feel frag, it means the good guys intervened, and nullified my action. Of course, as punishment they would probably frag me in another way. Why do they prevent the killing of Hitler? Because they and their frieds may have/will have seen the consequences of Hitler's actions so it's in their interest to prevent the paradox. Practically, it doesn't matter what really happened, just that it happened as remembered by the coninuum, and that the consequences remain the same. Another example, by some means, JFK's father is sterile. He can't concieve JFK This is a problem as JFK is known to exist. The continuum may stealthily inseminate JFK's mother for him to be born. In the grand scheme, it may be even impossible to know if JFK's was always sterile or if some outside force made him sterile. The universe must BE as it is remembered. Higher level continuum members start realizing that, in fact, free will does not exist. You just have to do what you have to do, and have fu doing it. (This is also the main focus of disagreement with the bad guys.)
- ksk 13y agoI've always wondered about this. Now, what if, in "reality" after every unit planck-time the universe forks itself N times based on all the things that could have happened but didn't? And if you went back in time, you go back to that particular fork and so that there is no way to ever detect your time travel? I realize this a fairly naive idea..
- xradionut 13y agoI'm sorry the Rothschild's have the monopoly on time travel for the next few millennium.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoI think it's rather unlikely that we will find time travellers among us, for two reasons: We don't seem to be anywhere close to inventing time travel. If time travel is invented, say, 10000 years from now, our moment in time might not be interesting enough to travel to. All the funny paradoxes caused by time travel suggest that time travellers could fork a new branch in the multiverse, but that would not change the future they were coming from and they would never be able to return to that future. Hence, the interest in travelling back in time might not be that great, even if it were possible.
- jlgaddis 13y agoHeh, reminds me of John Titor, the time traveler from the future who was working on the Year 2038 problem: http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread61544/pg1 http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread61544/pg1
- alan_cx 13y agoI never thought I'd see ATS referenced on HN...
- gozmike 13y agoThe Doctor already made sure that efforts such as these would be doomed to failure: http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Bad_Wolf_virus http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Bad_Wolf_virus
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bbwharris 13y agoThe only famous person that I can suspect of being a time traveler is Warren Buffet. It would make so much sense.
- wslh 13y agoSatoshi is a time traveller...
- gesman 13y agoThe core assumption here is that there is only one physical reality "spread" along the timeline. Another representation of universe is that there are infinite number of parallel, simultaneous parallel realities all simultaneously existing in the present moment. There is no past and future. Dodge that!
- waqasx 13y agowhats up with cornell's favicon?
- mathattack 13y agoWith a cursory look, I couldn't figure out if this was serious. Assuming it is, I'm convinced that Time Travel doesn't exist because casinos and sports betting exist, and casinos would go broke if time travel existed. (Unless you altered time so much travelling in time that you altered everything in the future)
- delinka 13y agoIf we consider that multiple "time lines" can exist in parallel (multiverses perhaps?), and if we consider that changing an event is the equivalent of making a new decision and branching into a new multiverse, then it stands to reason that at least one universe still exists where casinos and sports betting have not gone broke. And it must be this one.
- mathattack 13y agoThis seems less likely than time travel is impossible, no?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- toddh 13y agoThey were of course found the first time the study ran but the time travelers just kept going back in time and cleaning up traces of themselves until the tests stopped finding the evidence.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoah this idea... Stein's gate anyone?
- panzi 13y agoWell, Guido van Rossum has a time machine.
- htuao 13y agoIf we had time travelers, they would have been already comeback in the past and meet us from the future. It is useless to look for them. Wait for them and do something else.
- znowi 13y agoWe could try to analyze the tremendous amount of visual data collected - photographs, video, CCTV footage. Discern abnormalities in appearance, clothes, possible gadgets used, movement, behavior. Given the abundance of recording devices today, chances are they got caught on tape or had their picture taken somewhere. Of course there's always a possibility of false positives (e.g. Lady Gaga), but I think it may worth a shot :)
- jsonmez 13y agoThis makes no sense... here is why: "Hey Bob, you idiot! Someone found you by a stupid tweet you made. Then they posted a research paper online and now everyone knows about time travelers. Go back and fix it." "Done" The very act of publishing the results of this study could have caused the results to be changed, thus showing a non-positive match...
- kitcar 13y agoThat would be a great (yet unsatisfying) twist for the end of a low budget sci-fi movie.
- dm2 13y agoWouldn't that be indicating that Nagasaki and Hiroshima were better off destroyed rather than saved? Wouldn't that also imply that the future would end up a better place if the World Trade Center was destroyed and the Iraq / Afghanistan wars did actually happen? The two things above make me think that time travelling in the past (without a pre-built exit point) is never achieved. Otherwise, someone would have came back and prevented them, unless that is too risky because then time-travel might not be invented. Maybe time-travel creates an alternate universe and the original continues, but at-least life (and the time-travelers) have a chance in this new universe copy.
- babs474 13y agoThis paper was fascinating when I read it tomorrow. Unfortunately, I had to warn my former future self about their compelling results and prevent myself from posting all those really fun tweets.
- logfromblammo 13y agoWouldn't it be more useful to examine the stock and options markets for evidence of time travel? If I had a time machine, I would almost certainly try to use it for personal profit with maximum secrecy, rather than giving myself away by blathering about the future over Twitter. Also, the study does not rule out Back to the Future style time travel, Terminator style travel, or Primer style traveler isolation protocols. Nor does it rule out multiple universe theories, such that future events become unpredictable to a past-traveler within a very short period of time due to the butterfly effect.
- michas 13y agoIt is pretty hard to find time travellers this way, because millions of lucky-guessers would cause a noise.
- sciguy77 13y agoWhen I go back in time I'll be sure to setup a Myspace page.