29 ms·
Can-Do vs. Can’t-Do Culture
- abalashov 13y agoUltimately, in 1842 English mathematician and astronomer George Biddel Airy advised the British Treasury that the Analytical Engine was “useless,” and that Babbage’s project should be abandoned. The government axed the project shortly after. It took the world until 1941 to catch up with Babbage’s original idea, after it was killed by skeptics and forgotten by all. Is it not reasonable to suppose that it was an idea before its time, and useless in the particular historical context and implementational form in which it appeared? There has always been utility for mechanical computation, but it's entirely possible that the world simply did not have an application for The Analytical Engine in the 1830s-1840s because other sectors of technology and the economy simply hadn't evolved to a level where they could effectively utilise it, especially given its physical properties--its size, scale, and energy consumption. I don't know that for a fact, and can't effectively gauge the merits of my own suggestion, as I am neither a mathematician nor a competent historian of the intellectual, scientific and commercial zeitgeist of that period. But, for the sake of argument, is it not possible that this invention fell into the "interesting, novel, but useless" category? Now, as for the telephone: 1) From the point of view of the telegraph establishment, it was a competitor; 2) Unintelligible voice really is useless. They just weren't far-sighted enough to see that the voice quality could improve, and indeed, it was a quite a long time before it did. Local loop quality improved first. Long-distance toll voice really didn't begin to sound good until digital trunking came along. Ask your grandparents or great-grandparents what coast-to-coast long distance phone calls sounded like in the era of analog lines and waveguide-type multiplexing technology; 3) In the heyday of the telegraph era, deploying lines was an extremely expensive and capital-intensive process, and it wasn't until other technological advancements that made possible various multiplexing and aggregation schemes (frequency-division, and later digital TDM) came along that the idea of running a copper line into every home really got to be realistic[1]. I agree that Western Union was a bit shortsighted in turning down this patent, but one could hardly blame them for thinking that universal telephone service wasn't economically possible. That's like selling a business idea today that relies on everyone having a 10 terabit fiber cable run to their home. Yeah, it's possible, and I have no doubt someone will make fun of me in a decade or two for naysaying it in any way, but would you invest $2bn in a related patent today? What mistake did all these very smart men make in common? They focused on what the technology could not do at the time rather than what it could do and might be able to do in the future. I don't disagree, but that needs to be fleshed out. No viable entrepreneurial venture can succeed solely on the basis of what it is logically possible for the technology to someday do, or what it could, in principle, in theory, one day. There is a need to realise a return in a usefully short period of time that is also unanimously acceptable to a coterie of investors with varying needs in terms of payoff time frame and patience. Thus, you need a practical plan for getting to point B, making the technology do X. Even the most far-fetched, high-risk, R&D-driven ventures entail a proposal to concretely deploy and commercialise technology in a period that is usefully short and politically palatable, and that means everyone involved is somewhat constrained to what can be practically envisaged in terms of today's possibilities. One can make some leaps of faith, some intelligent extrapolations and some prescient forecasts, but ultimately, it's something expressed largely in the observational language and ontology of today. Thus, I can't bring myself to fault someone for doubting, in 1995, that the consumer web is going to be what it is today, or even be what it was six or seven years later, in the early 2000s. It was possible--perhaps even reasonable--to suppose so, but would you have bet the farm on it? Your retirement savings? I'm not sure I would have (not that I have a farm or retirement savings, pero bueno). [1] http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=4511639&url=http%3A%2F%2Fieeexplore.ieee.org%2Fiel5%2F35%2F4511634%2F04511639.pdf%3Farnumber%3D4511639 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=451163...
- smacktoward 13y ago> No viable entrepreneurial venture can succeed solely on the basis of what it is logically possible for the technology to someday do, or what it could, in principle, in theory, one day. I think the real trick here is to learn how to distinguish between objections that are just examples of people not getting it, and objections that really do point up a fundamental problem you will have to overcome or find a way around in order to succeed. This can be trickier than it sounds. A common mistake advocates for new technologies make is to fall in love with their new toy and dismiss any skepticism of its prospects as examples of cluelessness -- often with glib responses like the one in the OP, "don't hate, create" (ugh). Not everyone who comes to you with a critique is a "hater." Some of them are coming to you because they have learned something through hard experience that they think will be helpful to you. Ignoring those people can lead you to walk right into the same well-hidden minefields that have blown up countless other bold explorers over the years. So there's value in learning how to spot the one guy in the crowd of people telling you to watch where you step who's sporting a peg leg.
- abalashov 13y agoIndeed. Also, about "haters": It'd be nice if the tech startup community looked like the OP imagines it, with innovative companies boldly challenging ingrained assumptions and disrupting conventional wisdom with forward-thinking solutions to hard problems worth solving. I think a lot of the "hating" is directed at the latest pump-and-dump social plugin or other VC-funded sausage party. The lack of mood emoticons on Twitter is not a problem worth solving, and failure to see its utility is not for a paucity of vision or ambition.
- hatu 13y agoIt seems to me (an outsider looking at the Bay Area culture) that people create what the VC's will invest in. In a way the VC companies are the first customers they focus on. If VC's stop funding 90% of their portfolio useless social websites and instead focus on robotics, green tech, medical tech etc. I would argue that most new startups will start working on meaningful products.
- _delirium 13y agoI kind of wish the startup community looked like the picture painted in this post. :) More audacity and innovation, less audacity-lacking "innovation" of the form, how to get users to click ads more often and exit this company for a multiple ASAP.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- fudged71 13y agoI see this all the time in the consumer 3D printing space. Sometimes high tech people act like laggards. "I can't make a metal part on my desk, so it's useless!" "okay, we're almost there, but how about you look at the progress in this industry and all the other applications that we CAN do right now!"
- iamwil 13y agoI hear this all the time as well, Tom. Most people don't understand at all how things are made, and that most of the things around us are made from plastics, not metal. Even then, 3D printing is just weird enough, outside the scope of the experience of most people, that unless you've done hand-on work in it, it's hard to see the value.
- fudged71 13y agoAbsolutely. This will be another big year for 3D printing coverage in the media so hopefully educating the public continues. And it almost seems like schools are the best place for 3D printers because there isn't the barrier of expectations and criticisms from adults.
- chiph 13y agoJames Burke (BBC presenter and historian) said in his "Connections" series that around the late 1960's, things made of plastic became their "own things". Previously, items made of plastic had to imitate some other existing thing for them to be accepted. Notebook covers had to imitate leather, complete with fake stitching. Telephones had to look like the older ones made of Phenol resin. And so on. 3D printing is at that stage right now. We're using it to imitate items made in traditional ways, and not treating it as a new process in it's own right. But given time, people will adopt it as something totally distinct from subtractive manufacturing.
- Crito 13y agoThe state of metal printing is much better than many people suspect, though of course the state of the art in metal printers are not exactly Rep-Raps: http://blog.solidconcepts.com/industry-highlights/worlds-first-3d-printed-metal-gun/ http://blog.solidconcepts.com/industry-highlights/worlds-fir...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- austenallred 13y agoI love the comment from Robert Scoble: "My friend Andy Grignon worked for Steve Jobs and was on a very small team building the original iPhone. Steve told him "sorry, you can not hire anyone who has worked on a phone before." Why not? For exactly the reasons laid out here. He didn't want his team to find out what they were attempting to do was "impossible." Andy learned that when he went to AT&T to pitch them on what became visual voice mail. Andy and his team thought it was possible. The AT&T folks thought they were nuts. It took lots of work by Steve Jobs to convince AT&T to try."
- Aloha 13y agoNot all telecom people are sticks in the mud, that said modern at&t (SBC) is not known for being progressive, forward looking or flexible.
- mathattack 13y agoThey are too big and mature to be reinventing the future. For better or worse, the modern AT&T came about by Southwestern Bell being the most disciplined of the baby bells. While other telecoms invested in pie in the sky projects that didn't work, SBC invested in operations and financial discipline. Their increased market cap relative to size allowed them to buy their less efficient competitors. They won on efficiency, not product development.
- Aloha 13y agoDisciplined, is not the words I would use - SBC was the most corrupt (IMO) of the former baby bells too. They have been slimy for a long long time. In the 70's several executives were fired for what amounted to having a political slushfund [1] to buy off state officials when needed. While they may be successful they miss the concept of "Spirit of Service" in whole. [1] http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1356&dat=19760728&id=pgYkAAAAIBAJ&sjid=jwUEAAAAIBAJ&pg=2555,5732593 http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1356&dat=19760728&id=p...
- grecy 13y agoI work at a telcom. The vast majority of people are sticks in the mud, and those that aren't are leaving, fast.
- mech4bg 13y agoThat Alexander Bell quote sounded way too good to be real, looks like I wasn't the only person to think that, some interesting sleuthing: http://blog.historyofphonephreaking.org/2011/01/the-greatest-bad-business-decision-quotation-that-never-was.html http://blog.historyofphonephreaking.org/2011/01/the-greatest...
- Joeri 13y agoThe interesting thing is that apparently the kernel is true, but the actual quote is invented. It's a shame that people in the real world rarely give us quotes ready to be made into a movie.
- elwell 13y agoWhen I'm overworked or simply lazy, and my co-founders want to add some feature, it becomes a "can't do" culture pretty fast. Yes, I'm the only technical co-founder.
- seivan 13y agoNot being snarky, but what domain knowledge do they have that you can't get?
- elwell 13y agoMy two co-founders handle the business aspects of company, though there is some overlap between our roles. Is that an answer to your question?
- lsc 13y agoeh, with business... it's not so much what skills you can't get... as what you don't want to do. I'm all for helping technical people negotiate from a strong position... but personally, were I able to send messages back in time to advise myself before going in to it? I would advise taking on a business person. It's a lot of work, and perhaps more importantly, while business people /say/ they have this "give 110%" or "can-do" attitude, in reality? if it looks like you aren't going to make money, they are gone in a flash. And frankly? that's a good thing.
- tlb 13y agoA fine editorial. Stirring. It has inspired me to not write off recode simply because 90% of what's on their front page today is crap.
- xux 13y agoThe article was written by Ben Horowitz.
- smokeyj 13y agoLooking at you Krugman.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zach 13y agoThe economist who helped Walt Disney's theme park dream become what it is today[1] said that the most important thing he learned through it all was the profound difference between a "no, because" person and a "yes, if" person. If you ask many people an audacious "Can we do X?" their response is usually along the lines of "No, because [valid reasons]". They're not wrong, but the basic attitude is to shoot down what doesn't seem to fit with one's own view of the world. These are "no, because" people, and big companies are often full of them. Much rarer and infinitely more valuable, especially for an entrepreneur, is the person who hears "Can we do X?" and responds, "Yes, if... [possible solutions]". Their response is one of problem-solving instead of confrontation, seeking to find a synthesis of the new perspective and their own. It seems like a small thing, but it is a very significant shift in mindset. Thinking like a "yes, if" person can unlock so much potential. A friend of mine, one of the most talented and knowledgeable game programmers around, could easily have shot down many of the ambitious ideas that came his way. Instead, he greeted them with enthusiasm, often saying, "It's software! We can do anything!" Wouldn't you like to set out to do amazing things with that person on your team? [1] - https://d23.com/harrison-price/ https://d23.com/harrison-price/
- shuaib 13y agoWhere then does the "learn to say 'no!'" attitude comes in if we are to say "yes, if..." to every idea coming our way? How to find the right balance between being a "can do" person, and NOT being the over-committer?
- swalsh 13y agoIf I was to pull a rubber band back a small bit, and let go, it will fly a small ways. If I pull it back too far, it might break. However if I pull it back as far as it can go right before the breaking point, then let go the rubber band will fly across the room. these "no because," people are a common resistance to new ideas. In engineers, they're almost the default. It's much easier to say no; to say yes is to deal with an increasingly larger amount of resistance. However, that resistance is also what makes the idea go far.
- joelandren 13y agoLet's also remember that there is valid criticism of startups and how they operate their business. If a startup founder is an asshole, let's not excuse the behavior because they are building something worthwhile. If a startup makes a mistake due to lack of concern about its users (i.e. Snapchat and their security hole), they should be criticized. All told, I'm all about "can do" culture, but let's not use it as an excuse for boorish behavior or bad business practices.
- temphn 13y agoLet's also make sure the person criticizing said "assholes" is not paid to be a professional asshole themselves, like Sam Biddle or Nitasha Tiku at Valleywag.
- KaoruAoiShiho 13y agoNot even sure why this needs an article. The great majority of people in the world are "can't-do" people. It's entrepreneurs who buck the trope and create the things that end up being valuable. It's risky and scary and you'll probably face opprobrium. Fuck the noise.
- XorNot 13y agoYou might also fail because you refused to consider reasonable objections (because people didn't put them in a tone you approved of), and then blow a lot of money and put yourself in debt you might never escape. So you know, it's a trade-off.
- dingaling 13y ago> The great majority of people in the world are "can't-do" people. Well I think that's a bit harsh! In my experience, most people are 'won't-do'. I haven't encountered many who aren't open to doing new things, but why would they do so without an incentive? Particularly in the workplace, where people are already over-loaded with tasks, there can be an agreed list of 'great ideas' but no-one has time or freedom to tackle them.
- gfodor 13y agoOne thing to ponder: this is a strong counterpoint to the "Lean Startup" culture, which basically states that unless you have people telling you not just that something can be done, but that they will pay you for it yesterday, it's not worth working on.
- argonaut 13y agoI don't see the two as mutually exclusive. The lean startup methodology doesn't care at all what people think about the feasibility of something. What matters in that methodology, however, is whether people will pay for something, if implemented. A side note is that people telling you they will or won't pay for something can be quite misleading. The act of talking is quite disconnected from the act of actually paying you.
- gfodor 13y ago"Why would I ever need anything other than a horse to get around? Mine gets me where I need to go just fine. And more cheaply, too." The short-sightedness of the people cited in the article doesn't just come from critics, but from the potential market as well.
- Aloha 13y agoThis goes back to the glass half full/glass half empty discussion. It's not anything really new or different. The problem is half full people, tend to turn into half empty people as they age, get more conservative and have power/established interests to protect. In short, disruption seems scary when you are part of the powers that be.
- altero 13y agoA few years ago the iPad mania just started. I worked for harware company on admin software. It was written in Java, 15 years old (1998) and never had major rewrite. All managers were like 'be like apple' and 'we must release iPad app' and 'PC is over'. Programmers on other side wanted to rewrite some critical parts, introduce automated tests and fix some very old bugs. I was speaker for programmers, soon I became 'tablet hater' (kind of funny since I had Android tablet). Latter we even bough some iPads for developers to learn, those were locked in managers office :-). I left company shortly after that. So for me 'Can-Do vs. Can’t-Do Culture' is just sort of bullshit to mask real problems. Sure Jobs made iThinks, but he pulled massive resources towards the problem. Apple actually bought factories for touch screens before iPhone was made.
- praptak 13y agoI don't buy this division into can - the good and cannot - the bad. It's just two strategies with different outcome distributions. The critic will be right more often, invest in boring tried ideas, earn less on average but with less variance. The enthusiast will often fail but when he's right against the common knowledge, he hits the jackpot. And picking those jackpots and their critics ignores the majority of crazy ideas that indeed fail - "They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown." Here's some criticism of a crazy idea that actually failed (CueCat): http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000037.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000037.html Obviously there is a lot of criticism for the sake of proving oneself smug. Unfortunately sounding smug does not automatically make one wrong.
- yalogin 13y agoHe is concerned about this because it directly impacts him and his line of work. But this is nothing new even in technology. The one glaring example is Apple. When the first iPhone came out Apple was the savior but soon the number of people hating Apple is greater and more vocal that the so called fanboys. I think its simply that success begets hate on a superficial level and in some cases makes people look into certain aspects of that success with more scrutiny which might beget dislike(or hate). Its just what it is. Point being, even the most educated, practical thinking people on the planet succumb to mob mentality, particularly online. Deal with it.
- lmm 13y agoI've found the best places to work are quite negative about their own products (I wish I could find the release announcement Facebook had for one of their open-source libraries, with endorsements like "okay, I guess" and "oh, that thing") and ideas. If you're able to shoot down bad ideas fast, and have a culture where that's ok, people are much more willing to make all sorts of crazy suggestions, and you have a better chance of finding one that will actually work.
- jasonkester 13y agoI wonder how much of this is just a visibility issue. We notice this same thing here on this site, where every new idea seems to get immediately piled on with negativity. The feeling is that it didn't used to be this way, and many of us old timers will remember a time when new ideas were mostly met with encouragement and constructive criticism. But I bet if you look at the threads today and then, you might find that the absolute number of constructive, encouraging comments hasn't changed much at all. Rather, they are simply lost in a sea of negativity spouted out by the peanut gallery that seems to have washed in from other places where people dump all over tech news. We used to be conspicuously entrepreneurial here. Now we're a lot more representative of the tech world at large. So yeah, I think that there are still plenty of people with the right entrepreneurial mindset out there. It's just getting harder to find them.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoThe visibility / selection bias issue works both ways. Only successful entrepreneurs are visible, not the many more that have failed despite their "can-do" attitude. Maybe we're just slowly reaching a more realistic equilibrium.
- daemonk 13y agoHow about just being reasonably rigorous in your assessment instead of being overly cautious or overly idealistic? This division into can-do and can't-do seems to represent two opposite extremes that might not reflect the majority. What's the real data here? From a practical standpoint, isn't it just risk vs reward? Can-do's probably get a bigger reward than can't do's, but they fail more. A can't-do gets smaller reward, but succeeds more.
- rayiner 13y agoHere's my problem with the implied attack on skeptics: sure you can point to the cases when the skeptics are wrong, but for every poo-pooing of what turns out to be a tremendous invention, there are 99 cases where skepticism averts disastrously misconceived projects. There is tremendous economic value that is preserved by people who say no. People like to use the example of Jobs launching a tablet in the face of skeptics, but this doesn't give Jobs enough credit. Apple is tremendously skeptical. A huge part of their success is the products they don't launch.
- rikacomet 13y agoMy thumb rule: As long as you are young, given the time, you can do anything that you can conceive in the mind. I firmly believe, that its a practical thing, that with time, most people who aren't way successful become pessimist, yet.. their kids always have the fresh start. It is upto the young generation, to carry the baton of HOPE! If young people won't dream, who will?
- devhinton 13y agoAny one else notice the self-justification of the comments? > Cherrypicking. A great majority of startups fail and their ideas are proven as unworkable or impractical, so it is not unreasonable to summarily dismiss most of them. Clearly read the article but is trying to justify his own negativity in the past and undoubtedly. >Would love to see a post on how you define "great" in this context, Ben. Who the fck, address someone they don't know by their first name like that?? Ending the statement with his name also seems a bit passive aggressive. Enlightening check out the comments and see how many people actually respond to the article. All too often when reading articles or listening to other people, instead of listening or understanding, the goal is: 'let me read until I think think of something I can say'. This really hurts that person and just isolates people in their own point of view (note this post could be ironic. Its not though, the article was freakin awesome! I will try to change my mindset towards a more positive one after reading and rethink what it means to innovate)
- michaelochurch 13y agoOne more quote to start this off. I do not bring a weapon. I am the weapon. -- Michael O. Church I like the overarching theme of what the OP is saying. Good companies provide multiple ways to succeed. Shitty firms provide multiple ways to fail, and only one way to succeed. That's why closed allocation is such a pile of 9/11 nukular buttfail: because it's founded on the idea that a person is only admitted one avenue for success (but there are numerous ways a person might lose face). Good institutions provide multiple ways for the people within them to succeed. This encourages creativity. Bad companies lay down multiple ways to fail, and only admit one way to succeed. It is known. I don't think this is only an artifact of company size. I've seen small companies with that negative, embarrassment-averse culture; I've also seen large companies create pockets of the positive, open-allocation type culture. Hardly a day goes by where I don’t find something in my Twitter feed crowing about how a startup that has hit a bump in the road is ”fu&%@d,” or what an “ash%le” a successful founder is, or what an utterly idiotic idea somebody’s company is. I am all for product risk and innovation. If someone tries to cure cancer and fails, I'm going to praise her to the moon for trying. On the other hand, moral failure (asshole founders) I cannot support. There is a huge difference between a scientist who tries for 20 years to cure cancer and falls short (but probably delivers a lot of useful research along the way) and an Evan Spiegel, who fails morally. "We're a startup" has been used too many times to justify reckless management and moral bankruptcy. Well I say: fuck that shit. I am all for removing the stigma against good-faith failure. The problem in the VC-funded startup world is all the bad-faith failure that is out there. When someone gets fired with no severance because his 24-year-old, inexperienced, technically incompetent manager turns out to be a wad, no one should congratulate the company for "taking a risk". Recklessness, the defining trait of the current crop of VC-funded cool kids, is not a virtue. It seems like there is a movement to replace today’s startup culture of hope and curiosity with one of smug superiority. That "culture of hope and curiosity" is long gone. Snarky people like me are working our asses off in the effort to bring it back. We do it by taking down the Evan Spiegels and Lucas Duplans of the world. We need to take out the trash so there is some fucking space for the good guys. Some people would like to turn the technology startup world into one great big company with a degenerative Can’t-Do Culture. That's VC-istan, not in some future dystopia but right now. With all of the co-funding and note-sharing and collusion, VC has degenerated into a feudal reputation economy that behaves like a large and dysfunctional company where people are too busy padding their resumes and manicuring their reputations to even consider doing anything remotely ballsy. That's exactly what has already happened.
- oznathan 13y ago"Bitcoin could never succeed as a currency. It's too unstable"
- al2o3cr 13y agoIf you bought at the beginning of December, it's certainly "succeeded" in turning 1/3rd of your money into nothing...
- oznathan 13y agosure that's a clever argument? what if you bought it at any other time during the few years it exists? anyway that was not the point. The point was people failing to see the innovation and seeing only the problems. Which was the point of this article.
- brianzelip 13y agoPleasantly surprised to find the son of David Horowitz is a rap fan. Not only does this article start with a Rick Ross (ugh) quote, but most of his blog posts all start with music lyrics too. [http://bhorowitz.com http://bhorowitz.com] Seems he's on the Board of Rap Genius.
- sopooneo 13y agoNo, [your "Soylent" food replacement will not work] because...
- crazygringo 13y agoOf course, too much of a 'can do' attitude can lead to completely unrealistic expectations, spread your resources too thin, and bankrupt a business or lead you to waste years or even decades of your life. The smart choice is obviously a happy medium. Too much of a "can do" attitude is just as harmful as too much of a "can't do" attitude. We all need reality checks. And this is why diverse teams and groups are so important -- one person says "of course we can't do", another says "of course we can do", and everyone hashes it out until they've come up with a realistic assessment that is neither clouded by overly optimistic nor overly pessimistic thinking.
- mrbrowning 13y agoHe's making a good point in the abstract, but I think Horowitz is too close to the matter to understand that a lot of the negativity he cites is a natural reaction to the totally overblown rhetoric of the start-up scene. He inadvertently proves this by referencing such epoch-defining inventions as the telephone and the internet. Many tech start-ups are creating interesting, useful, and sometimes even novel products, but it's nonetheless annoying to anyone with a sense of perspective to hear from every angle that Start-up X is going to change the world by revolutionizing, you know, shoe-resoling.
- lazyant 13y ago"Alexander Graham Bell, inventor of the telephone," obligatory to mention the other inventor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elisha_Gray http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elisha_Gray
- robgibbons 13y agoBen, your site is so Goddamn frustrating on mobile.
- aetherson 13y agoI don't believe that quote that purports to be a Western Union memo on the telephone. I don't think that 19th Century businessmen put words like "idiotic" into business communication, and I don't think that they used phrases like "the technical and economic facts of the situation," as the word "economy" at that point was much more strongly meaning "being thrifty at home" and much less about economic systems. This blog post claims that the quote is fake: http://blog.historyofphonephreaking.org/2011/01/the-greatest-bad-business-decision-quotation-that-never-was.html http://blog.historyofphonephreaking.org/2011/01/the-greatest... Slate says it "may" be fake and is awaiting verification: http://www.slate.com/blogs/business_insider/2014/01/02/why_people_thought_telephones_would_fail.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/business_insider/2014/01/02/why_p...
- MichaelMoser123 13y agoAnd venture funds also have to be picky about start-ups that they are going to fund; I understand that the author is working for a venture fund, and that he tries not to be a 'hater'. Is the Andreessen Horowitz portfolio really breathtakingly innovative, or is it more of the same? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andreessen_Horowitz#Investments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andreessen_Horowitz#Investments "In February 2011, Andreessen Horowitz invested $80 million in Twitter,[2] becoming the first venture firm that holds stock in all four of the highest-valued, privately held social media companies: Facebook, Groupon, Twitter and Zynga" http://a16z.com/ http://a16z.com/ Otherwise its a great article. The lesson that I took home: I always held that asking/questioning of assumption is also of value; but this article told me that I have to be careful here, and that style of communications is often also very important - style determines how a person is evaluated by others.
- jeffdavis 13y agoWay too general to be useful. I think it's useful to be optimistic when it comes to visions of the future and how a business can accomplish it. Electric cars for everyone? Sure, give it a try. All that can be lost is a little money, and maybe you make a huge fortune and change the world. Isolated government programs can be a similar story -- e.g. NASA, which is unlikely to lose anything but a small amount of money but can be really inspiring or create some great things. However, when it comes to government policy, the downside can be utter disaster. It pays to be a little skeptical that the "help the poor" bill (or whatever other utopian title) will actually deliver as advertised. Or skeptical that a war will be a simple in-and-out proposition. Or some things just have little upside. We see this all the time in engineering. Someone wants to use a fad technology or model of some kind, or wants to reimplement something to be a little faster, or whatever. There's huge project risk that it could derail other projects and destabilize the entire product -- which is fine if you're going to change the world with it, but not fine for a 10% speedup on some specific workload. Moral of story: optimism and "can do" attitude is good when the upside is huge and the downside is contained (like in a startup). Not exactly a profound revelation.
- stevewilhelm 13y agoI have found that there are many more ideas than time or energy to do them all. How does one foster a successful "Should-Do" culture instead of a "Can't-Do" culture?
- annnnd 13y agoI think this article missed a point. It is not a battle between "Yes, if" and "No, because" - each has its own place and each should be used with care. The first stage of innovation should use "Yes, if" approach. This is similar to brainstorming session, where negativity should be kept to minimum. This mentality lets people find ways around the obstacles. When the idea is ready for evaluation, it should be evaluated in light of resource constraints and similar. In this phase "No, because" approach should be used to identify all possible downsides. If the answer is "No", the idea can be either retired or returned to brainstorming session, until it is ready for re-evaluation. So it is not a question of Yes/No, it is a question of appropriate answer in appropriate moment.