6 ms·
Unlike Android, the iPhone can’t scale, says Google
- jemmons 17y agoClearly misleading. By this definition, Windows "scales" an order of magnitude better than OS X — a statement that, when considered in the classical sense, is, at very least, up for debate.
- plinkplonk 17y agoAnd how would one code for all these different versions of Android working on devices with varying capabilities?
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoSee my explanation above: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=699223 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=699223
- mechanical_fish 17y agoMarketers use the word "scale" the way Star Trek writers used the word "phase". Cue Inigo Montoya: "You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means." And even if you ignore the poor choice of words and the inane anti-iPhone spin (what, the iPhone OS won't run on products besides iPhones? I'm typing on the iMac that disproves that point!) what I see here is Google trying to put a positive spin on one of their platform's big problems: Android not only can run on a thousand kinds of hardware, but that appears to be the official plan. Some of that hardware will have physical keyboards. Some of it will not. Some of that hardware will have screens the size of a dinner plate. Some will not. The result is a loss of coherency: What kind of hardware is an Android app for? What is Android for? If you build an Android app, you have to decide if you'll optimize it for a physical keyboard on the long edge, or a physical keyboard on the short edge, or a software keyboard. You'll have to decide how much of the screen you can take up with your control panel. You can't optimize for everything at once. The likely outcome is that you'll have to support your Android software on a divergent set of hardware, and you'll inevitably disappoint a subset of your customers. If the customer base breaks into thirds and you can only please one-third at a time, you will routinely disappoint a majority of the customer base no matter what you do. The fact that the iPhone has one consistent hardware platform is a big advantage for Apple. The newest iPhone OS runs great on my two-year-old original-edition iPhone. The phone is getting better by the month: The interface works better, the crashes are fewer. This is presumably because Apple's engineering team can focus on refining the current platform rather than on porting their OS to a dozen different platforms.
- trezor 17y agoSome of that hardware will have physical keyboards. Some of it will not. .... If you build an Android app, you have to decide if you'll optimize it for a physical keyboard on the long edge, or a physical keyboard on the short edge, or a software keyboard. Add touch-screen capabilities to this list, and you have the mess that was software for Windows mobile. Add multi-touch if you want to make it really messy. In the end, 90% of your software's code is going to be dealing with different types of user-input, user-input capabilities and how to interface with the actual code that does stuff. I'm definitely going to agree with you on this being a problem that needs solving before Android being on thousands on devices can be considered a good thing.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoI only left the touch-screen out of my argument because I frankly can't remember what kind of touch screen the typical Android phone has. Which, of course, may also be a symptom of the problem. (Though perhaps it is just a symptom of my poor memory.)
- gaius 17y agoIt's like the old argument of games console vs PC. Why is it that the original X-box with its puny 733Mhz processor and 64M of main memory was delivering a credible gaming experience against PCs 4x faster with 16x the memory? Because from the developer's perspective it was a stationary target. Even BlackBerry, with only half a dozen current handsets (and maybe a couple of dozen in actual use in the wild) forces a lot of compromises. Android could be on hundreds of different devices, and Google can't possibly put its reputation on the line for all of them.
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoActually, the Android SDK makes it supremely easy to build applications that are built specifically for different types of devices with minimal effort. The implemented separation of XML resources, combined with the ability to further refine/subdivide resources based on phone capabilities, without having to write any code to make the choices at runtime, is incredibly useful and powerful. For a simple example, let's say I want to optimize my application's interface layout for whether the phone is in portrait or landscape mode. I simply make two copies of the layout definition and place them in specially-named resource folders, like such: res/ layout/ main.xml # basic layout layout-port/ main.xml # optimized for portrait mode layout-land/ main.xml # optimized for landscape mode Then all my application needs to do to load the layout is: setContentView.(R.layout.main); Android then takes care of loading the appropriate layout element on the fly based on the device's capabilities and state. All I have to do is include optimized versions of the layout for whatever I think in important. This capability not only covers screen orientation, but screen resolution, screen DPI, touch versus stylus input, hardware or software keyboard, and more [1]. And it all comes basically for "free" because my actual code doesn't have to know about any of it; it just asks for the base resource, and Android does all the selection for me. So yes, running on lots of devices is part of Android's plan, and they've been working from day 1 to mitigate all of the problems inherent with targeting a divergent platform, and it works. So yes, Android will "scale" to any number of devices, and it's trivial for developers to stay on top of everything if they use the SDK the way it was designed. [1] http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/resources/resources-i18n.html#AlternateResources http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/resources/resource...
- trezor 17y agoI see the hype around scaling has now reached so massive heights that even Google is willing to misattribute it to mean things that it doesn't if they think it makes them look good. That Android over time may get a higher market adaptation has nothing to do with scaling. If I were to take on Google's interpretation here, Symbian would seem to scale better than any other mobile OS, and I'm not even sure what that would mean.
- lrm242 17y agoIt seems to me that Android is really about taking share from Windows Mobile, not the IPhone. Given that, it would make sense to take the multi-platform approach that they have. This article, and the comments within it, seem to simply be "stuff that must be said" given the recent announcement re: Chrome OS.
- enomar 17y agoIt was never about taking market share from some other mobile OS. Google's main objective here is to put pressure on carriers and handset makers. They need high end phones with good web browsers to become the norm. More people using these phones mean more people using the mobile web (and therefore Google's services).
- st3fan 17y agoPersonally I would rather have one very well designed phone than a 1000 'cheap plastic' ones.
- jamesbritt 17y agoLet a hundred flowers blossom. I'm interested in seeing what devices people come up with, knowing that the OS side of things is a solved problem. Most of it might be crap, but there are sure to be some wicked ideas.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- zimbabwe 17y agoApple's ad responding to this philosophy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZRcYS88BwQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZRcYS88BwQ
- noelchurchill 17y agoThe iPhone will scale just like the iPod scaled. There are a few different models and sizes to fit different peoples needs. The world doesn't need 1000 different phones running Android, and I doubt that's even on Google's agenda. They want Android to be the fabled "operating system for any electric device". Apple hasn't even shown any interest in this business model at all, ever! You could easily flip this article around by saying "Unlike iPhone, Android Runs on Low Quality Products".
- jacobian 17y agoYeah, exactly! Just like a single distribution of Windows can't possibly compete with the thousands of branches of Linux out there. Oh, wait.
- brisance 17y agoAndy Rubin is the sort of deadwood that will spell Google's doom. What he says is no different from what already had existed on the mobile marketplace for years. It is called Windows Mobile.