7 ms·
> We need to make sure we're not being manipulated. Here the Guardian is just serving up an emotional, unsubstantiated, one sided view of this discussion (...)
by e12e 13y ago
> We need to make sure we're not being manipulated. Here the Guardian is just serving up an emotional, unsubstantiated, one sided view of this discussion (...)
> We all know war is hell.
Yes, but the drone attacks are unlawful systematic assasinations that are turning peace time living into hell. As there are no declared war zones (afaik, as I understand it the situation in Iraq is in a peculiar state of limbo, and there are presumably interventions in some of the civil wars that could be accepted as "wars", even if not decleared as such) were the US (or NATO) is involved.
So your comment is doing quite a bit of manipulation, itself -- accepting the use of leathal force against foreign civilian and paramilitary targets as equivalent with waging regular war.
I think history will show the push by the US in normalizing this type of terror to be a significant blow against the geneva conventions and agreement on the "rules of war" (which have never been followed to the letter, but have at least held the hope of bringing war criminals to justice and be used as a sound basis for refusing illegal orders).
I can't see how this stance by the US can't be used for justifying attacks on senators and lobbyists on US soil (for "their role in funding and facilitating illegal terrorist attacks against civilian targets").
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes, but the drone attacks are unlawful systematic assasinations that are turning peace time living into hell. Its not peace time living. Its a war -- on which seems to be permanent and global, which is a problem, but a different one than you describe. > As there are no declared war zones Wars -- even the most formally declared ones -- rarely have declared zones. They have declared belligerents.
- e12e 13y agoWell, there might be global conflict, but global war is a little disingious - at least when the casualities and effects are so extremely polarized. I've never felt afraid of retaliation even if Norwegian forces have shot up some kids or guided a missile down on an illegal target somewhere. Even with the few attacks on the US it would be hard to say that it would be rational to live in fear of attack orchestrated by foreign nations when on US soil? As for declared war zones (vs declared wars), that was an unfortunate slip in editing on my part (text fields and smart phones don't mix well imo).